More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
HuffPost TV

HuffPost TV

Posted: November 19, 2010 09:54 AM

HuffPost's Sam Stein appeared on MSNBC's "Morning Joe" Friday to talk about Congress's recent failure to pass an extension of unemployment benefits.

"They did it in a way where they needed a two-thirds majority and there's gonna be quibbling over that, but you're right, the optics are terrible," Stein said. "We're talking about 12.5 billion dollars to help two million unemployed people, and in three weeks we're going to, most likely, be passing the extension of the Bush tax cuts which will cost much more than that."

On Thursday, a measure to extend unemployment insurance through the holidays fell in the House by a 258 to 154 vote, with mostly Democratic support. Twenty-one Republicans voted in favor of that bill, while 11 Democrats voted nay.

Stein later countered a claim by host Joe Scarborough that the unemployed were being encouraged not to seek jobs by the potential perpetual offering of benefits.

"I think we're operating under the assumption that these people don't want to find work, and I know there's anecdotal evidence to the contrary," Stein continued. "Another phenomenon that's really troubling is that people who are unemployed find that their unemployment is a real resume buster. I mean people don't want to hire people who have been out of work, they don't think they're skilled, they don't think they have the set."

Stein continued:

"I think it's just wrong and erroneous to suggest that these people would rather sit back and enjoy the minimum amount of money that they're getting from unemployment benefits and not do the work. These people really want to work, these people have been out of work for over a hundred weeks."

WATCH:

 
HuffPost's Sam Stein appeared on MSNBC's "Morning Joe" Friday to talk about Congress's recent failure to pass an extension of unemployment benefits. "They did it in a way where they needed a two-thir...
HuffPost's Sam Stein appeared on MSNBC's "Morning Joe" Friday to talk about Congress's recent failure to pass an extension of unemployment benefits. "They did it in a way where they needed a two-thir...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 31
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
03:37 AM on 11/20/2010
NO UNEMPLOYMENT EXTENTIONS THERE WON'T BE ANY REPUBLICANS IN CHARGE NEXT VOTING CYCLE!
07:19 PM on 11/19/2010
No Extensions, then no shopping on black friday.

If your unemployed you can still make a good amount of money online; here's how:

http://www.extraincome101.net

After becoming unemployed myself, I looked for other ways to make money;
that is how I found this information, so check it out.
05:20 PM on 11/19/2010
So, in order to save a few passengers, we should allow the ship to sink. How can we expect to survive if the financial sector, the farmers, the welfare folks, the government workers, the automakers, are all depndent on the gobernment. I think we may have to start back at square one.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mjtaylor22
05:10 PM on 11/19/2010
The conservatgives want the White House Back in 2012, and they are willing to sacrifice every single middle class family to get there......Believe it....
04:55 PM on 11/19/2010
The grapevine tells me that they want to use our unemployment money, which so many of us have paid for, for many years to pay for the unpaid wars we were forced into, by a lie. Now the unemployed are telling the truth that they cannot find work and they are being labeled as liars. The money is there they just want to use it for something else. They are full of $$$$. Where are the jobs? Everyone wants to work like they want to work, but of course, they don't. When are we going to stop them from controlling the purse strings. Demand the unemployment now by signing petitions. Just because the phony tea partiers got their way doesn't mean they are going to keep it. This money belongs to the people who have paid into it. UI has been paid for 50 times over and they used it for other things. They are guilty not the unemployed. 99 weeks is a very short time to collect when the UI rate is at over 10 per cent. They are lying and deceiving the American public.
DO NOT LET THEM.
04:13 PM on 11/19/2010
Quick personal comment:

I belong to the unemployed whose benefits are going to expire at the end of November.
I have been looking for a job very actively. I have cold called recruiters, collected their e-mail address and added a "sales pitch" to my e-mail along with my attached resume. Only now, about 10 minutes ago, I received an e-mail indicating I have an interview on NOVEMBER 30, 2010. This is my FIRST in person interview.
I am very thankful.
I truly doubt people just simply don't want to go back to work.
Needless to say, I am VERY MUCH in favor of keeping the unemployment insurance going.
photo
Jahli
Sanity has a well known liberal bias
05:45 PM on 11/19/2010
Being unemployed is a bit@h. Hang in there. I was unemployed twice in the last 8 years. 1st in 2003 due to HP's/Carly F's company cost saving layoffs (right after I had received a $6,000 a year raise) and the 2nd in 2006 when a small tech company went into bankruptcy. Each time it took me 50 weeks to find a new job and the unemployment rate was no where near 10%. You have my sincere best wishes as you struggle through this awful time.
photo
Jahli
Sanity has a well known liberal bias
05:48 PM on 11/19/2010
Being unemployed is a awful. Hang in there. I was unemployed twice in the last 8 years. 1st in 2003 due to HP's/Carly F's company cost saving layoffs (right after I had received a $6,000 a year raise) and the 2nd in 2006 when a small tech company went into bankruptcy. Each time it took me 50 weeks to find a new job and the unemployment rate was no where near 10%. You have my sincere best wishes as you struggle through this awful time.
03:48 PM on 11/19/2010
The frustrating thing about watching these kind of shows is that nobody every talks about the facts. They're debating the wrong question. WHY DID THEY FAST TRACK THE BILL? Fast tracking it required the 2/3 majority. It DID NOT need to be fast tracked. It could have easily gone through the normal channels in time for the expiration date.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ammsunday
03:03 PM on 11/19/2010
I call bologna on Pat Buchanan when he says small business owners cannot find people to work for $17 dollars an hour. Where are they? Please do tell? Give us phone numbers and info to inquire. Don't just say it and claim that it's true. And why would I want to be demoralized, humiliated and collect a penance from unemployment insurance after working for my entire life? Does that really make sense or is it just convenient to say that all of a sudden in life, I have no pride or sense of purpose. The unemployment checks come and make life so fantastic that I don't want to keep the heat on or stay current on my mortgage. Who needs groceries or electricity? Yea, that's it. Sure. There are no jobs out there. So, yeah, I'm just sitting here having a great time with being broke, demoralized and being looked upon now as a lazy, drug taking person who should just go get on welfare. Pat Buchanon is a horses bottom and is completely wrong. He just says stuff that makes his stance on things more comfortable for himself. Forget the facts. My husband's unemployment will end just 4 months longer than he would have gotten during normal times and these are not normal times. He's 61 and received 10 months of unemployment. (6 thru state and 4 thru fed) They make it sound as though everyone got 99 weeks. It's just not true.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MeinNH
Ooooo Silly Me
03:56 PM on 11/19/2010
You are 100% correct. They try to say that people are living high on benefits when the truth is that you can barely survive on them. Where are these so called jobs? Will they hire long term unemployed? NO IT DOES NOT PAY MORE TO STAY AT HOME!!! These are the same kind of lies that brought us the Welfare Queens with Cadillacs. We are becoming a heartless country!
06:10 PM on 11/19/2010
Buchanan and his ilk don't want to see that this is a stagnant economy, that the uncertainty is not in what the government will or will not do but when the money will start moving again. The real problem is in the private sector with the uncertainty about the solvency of the big banks, corporations sitting on cash or investing it overseas, venture capital drying up due to short-term goals. We have a demand problem, and we can't wait for foreigners to bail us out by buying our products. We have to create internal demand but the Republicans are doing everything they can to make sure that we don't and calling it fiscal responsibility.
Gutts
If I were a Transformer, I would be Ultra Magnus
01:03 PM on 11/19/2010
This is what America wanted.
photo
Jahli
Sanity has a well known liberal bias
05:46 PM on 11/19/2010
I hope the Repugs cause a huge economic disaster that they appear to want.
beachgirlchix
We Will Not Be Silent!
12:55 PM on 11/19/2010
I just want to comment as a recently laid off teacher who has already taken a new part-time job with no benefits or job security to make ends meet. I still get some unemployment to make up the difference between what the part-time job (which is the only kind you can find these days) and the full-time job that had benefits and job security (I did not have to worry about losing my job every semester like part-timers do) paid. So, just so you know, there are plenty of people out there willing to take lower-paying jobs so they don't just depend on the "nanny state." It is offensive to say that people on unemployment will just sit back and not work. What we should be debating is why folks have to take crappy part-time jobs with no benefits or security instead of real jobs. Why are the crap jobs the only ones available? I think that big business (not all but most) are economic terrorists who basically use jobs as a bargaining tool to get politicians to succumb to their demands like tax cuts for the rich and corporate tax breaks (even though most don't even pay corporate taxes, like Exxon-Mobile, which got a refund for last year), even though they are basically playing with people's lives! Corporations see workers as something to exploit or worse, as evidenced by the killings in Colombia at the Coca-Cola plant there.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mjtaylor22
03:15 PM on 11/19/2010
why are there only crap jobs avail, esp when wall street is paying out 135 billion in bonuses this year alone.......
would 35 billion of that created some nice middle class jobs in New York, or where ever......
b
06:16 PM on 11/19/2010
You answer your own question: Wall Street is paying $135B in bonuses. Effectively, that's $135B that is taken out of the economy to sit (and occasionally squander) when it could be more efficiently used elsewhere. Then there's the gambling that generates the $135B to be paid in bonuses.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MeinNH
Ooooo Silly Me
03:57 PM on 11/19/2010
"big business (not all but most) are economic terrorists who basically use jobs as a bargaining tool to get politicians to succumb to their demands like tax cuts for the rich and corporate tax breaks (even though most don't even pay corporate taxes, like Exxon-Mobile, which got a refund for last year), even though they are basically playing with people's lives"

You are 100% correct.
12:33 PM on 11/19/2010
What about people who only had 26 weeks of benefits? They won't even get tier 1 extended benefits.
photo
graffitijoe
snowballs chance n SoCal
12:30 PM on 11/19/2010
Did you know that 11 Democrats voted "no" to extend unemployment benefits and 7 Democrats did not vote - the mesure failed by 17 votes.

By the way 21 Republicans voted "yes".
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
notillegal2
01:40 PM on 11/19/2010
Thanks.
I've trying to find the info on the # of dems who stopped this.
03:50 PM on 11/19/2010
The Dems fast tracked it which requires 2/3 majority. They tried to play politics and they failed. Blame the Dems and them only. The GOP is only doing what's expected of them.
06:20 PM on 11/19/2010
Just because they are doing what's expected of them doesn't mean that they are to be given a pass. Indeed, if they weren't playing their game "fast track" would not have been deployed. GOP deflections of responsibility is why we are in so much trouble on so many fronts. Too often they are working against the country. We need to hold them accountable for it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
maximus5757
11:57 AM on 11/19/2010
Make all unemployment permanent and just pay people who aren't working a salary for the rest of their life-what a stimulus!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
notillegal2
01:40 PM on 11/19/2010
Where do you think we are, Europe?
sarabono
Oldie but Goody
03:23 PM on 11/19/2010
FRANCE -- Specifically
10:53 AM on 11/19/2010
It is time to give us the names and addresses of these small business owners who have jobs that they can not fill. Or is is just a fluffy little lie?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MeinNH
Ooooo Silly Me
03:58 PM on 11/19/2010
Fluffy little lie is the right answer.