iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Ingrid Newkirk

GET UPDATES FROM Ingrid Newkirk
 

Elle, Elle, What the Hell?

Posted: 07/06/2010 12:02 pm

Elle Macpherson has confessed to a reporter for the Times online, that she uses an illegal substance. No, it's not heroin or crack cocaine: It's rhino horn.

Like shark's fin, which is hacked off the shark, who is then thrown back into the water to spin helplessly to the bottom of the sea, rhino horn is hacked off, too, and the rhino is left to die with a machete hole in the face. It is not a quick death, as photographs and video footage attest.

Rhinos are interesting animals, not that it would matter if they were boring as hell. It isn't too long ago that human beings discovered what this species knew all along: that its members communicate by means of complex breathing noises. In my book The PETA Practical Guide to Animal Rights, I recount how Anna Mertz, the founder of a rhino sanctuary in Kenya, came to realize that these animals live in a completely different sphere from ours. They are the Mr. Magoos of the animal kingdom, barely able to see a thing, which unfortunately makes it convenient to poach them, and their world is dominated by their senses of smell and hearing.

To communicate, rhinos use a highly complicated method of regulating their breathing, a sort of Morse code, to talk to one another. Mertz says that rhinos are absolutely terrified of humans because people chase them, separate them from their calves, and slaughter them for their horns, which are cut off for use as aphrodisiacs and in cosmetics.

Mertz raised and released an orphaned bull she named Makara who had never witnessed an attack by hunters and had never learned to fear people. Over time, he came to regard Mertz as a friend.

On one occasion, Mertz was out with a tracker when the two of them saw a rhino moving very slowly toward them, looking very odd. When he got close, they saw that it was Makara and that he was completely entangled in barbed wire. Barbed wire is terrifying to animals, and most panic when they encounter it, but Makara had recognized the sound of his friend's Jeep engine and come for help. Although trembling all over, he gave the pair the greeting breathing. Mertz managed to get a handkerchief between Makara's eye and the jagged wire that was cutting into it, then took off her jacket and worked it under the wire that was cutting into his thigh. Without wire cutters, the tracker used a cutlass and a flat stone to cut the wire while Mertz, talking gently to the bull, disentangled him. The whole affair took about 40 minutes, and the whole time Makara stood stock-still except for the tremors that shook his body.

When the last of the wire fell away, he breathed goodbye and moved slowly back into the bush. Mertz says she knew that they had witnessed an act of outstanding intelligence, trust, and courage. That this bull had come to them for help and had exercised such control over his state of panic, standing still and allowing himself to be freed of the frightening barbed wire, must have been very difficult and painful to him―even more so, given the fact that although Makara knew Mertz's voice well, she had never before attempted to touch him.

I wrote in the book that perhaps if we could sit rhino hunters down and let them see that a rhino is not an inconsequential gray lump, not a trophy or a heap of body parts, but a living, thinking, feeling being―a son, a mother, a friend to others, a vulnerable individual―perhaps they would not blow these magnificent animals to kingdom come or cut off their horns via machete. Perhaps Elle Macpherson might also sit down and look at the photos of the rhinos who are ground up for human vanity and complete quackery.

Another star, Jackie Chan, who works hard to combat the devastation to wildlife caused by Chinese medicine, from tiger penises to bear bile and claws, is appalled by what is done to wildlife in the name of Chinese medicine. He says, if you know anyone who is buying the stuff, "Ask them to think first. Do they really want to be responsible for the cruel killing of an individual animal and to contribute to the extinction of the species? Don't they know that there are herbal alternatives to endangered animals in traditional Chinese medicine? And do they really need that endangered species product? There is no excuse."

I will take his advice this morning and jot a letter to Elle. If you'd like to stick up for rhinos and all wildlife caught up in this illicit trade, please join me.


 
FOLLOW STYLE
 
 
  • Comments
  • 25
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dapperd72
03:52 PM on 07/07/2010
Thank you, Ingrid, for your touching and moving portrayal of the intimate lives of rhinos, a much misunderstood & maligned species who deserve far more respect than humans are inclined to give them. I'm appalled that Elle MacPherson stoops this low, but it warms my heart that Jackie Chan takes the opposite approach, much like Steven Seagal and Pierce Brosnan, who've long gone out on a limb to protect endangered marine mammals and other animals endangered by human greed and bloodlust. I credit you deeply for continually fighting these battles, though I still reject your organization-wide welfarist tactics, which are the overriding reason I didn't renew my membership in March 1998. Anyhow, I will always give credit where it's due. I only hope this issue, which probably pertains to celebrities and other public figures far beyond Elle, will acquire more media exposure on CNN, MSNBC & C-SPAN, to wake up the nation from its perpetual moral slumber.
photo
Ethan Ciment
Podiatric Surgeon, Chelsea Foot & Ankle, PC
03:41 PM on 07/07/2010
So we're supposed to be upset about her ingesting powdered rhino horn but the other animals she eats and wears is okay? This kind of moral schizophrenia is called SPECIESISM. It's madness and it's the reason PETA under Ingrid Newkirk is heading down the wrong path- the Animal Welfare path. Let's stop singling out one form of animal use/abuse versus others. The issue isn't animal welfare. Animal welfare just serves the purpose of assuaging the guilt of human users. The core issue is animal use. Not exotic animals. Not "intelligent" animals. Not cute animals. ALL ANIMALS. If a creature is sentient, it should be left alone. Until PETA advocates a cessation from ALL animal use and promotes a vegan (note: NOT vegetarian) diet as the minimum moral baseline of an ethical society, they are part of the problem not the solution.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dapperd72
04:15 PM on 07/07/2010
As Karen Davis, President & Founder of United Poultry Concerns, told me during the White House Easter Egg Roll protest in April 1998, "Why should there be 2 words?" Vegan & vegetarian mean the same thing, as Karen asserted. If you eat eggs or consume bovine mammary secretions or honey (a.k.a. "bee barf"), then you're not a true vegetarian since these substances don't come from plants. Indeed the core issue is nonhuman animal exploitation and the right to be left alone, as the Libertarian Party always advocates. As Thomas Jefferson reputedly said when he helped to write the Constitution, one person's rights end where another's begin. Personhood applies to nonhumans as much as our own species. The animal "welfare" path obviously reinforces the status quo and reassures humans that exploiting other species is perfectly acceptable if we believe we're treating them humanely, so long as this isn't legally defined. Notwithstanding all of this intellectually honest critique of PeTA, all well-deserved, I can't dispute Ingrid's premise on this particular problem.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
06:38 PM on 07/11/2010
Rhinos are closer to extinction than most of the animals we have been eating for many thousands of years, and eating rhino horn has no medicinal benefit other than the placebo effect.
03:15 PM on 07/07/2010
That was one of the most beautiful articles I have ever read.

I am a natural health person. I like naturopathy, homeopathy, herbal medicine and yes, even Chinese Medicine.

However, I draw the line at remedies that come from killing animals. I always say "no".

I say "no" because we can be very healthy without killing animals in any way. There are tons of natural ways to heal, enhance our lives without taking from innocent beings who simply want to live.

I am appalled at Elles' selfishness. Here she is, a really wealthy woman, who has tons of options yet, she cannot muster enough compassion to choose something else. It's all about her and her well being, be damned the poor animals who have to suffer because of it.

There are millions of us who have so much less yet we still have compassion and basic ethics for living beings. We would never choose to kill for such superficiality.

Selfish selfish selfish. Just barbaric and gross.
11:03 AM on 07/07/2010
Do your dollars fund animal cruelty like Elle's ? Make informed choices. In this age of internet information everyone who can use the internet has access to answers, come on Elle, stop financially rewarding animal abusers.
Thanks to Ingrid Newkirk and Peta for providing us with the easy tools to actively stop cruelty at Peta.org.

2 minute video about humane education http://www.humaneeducatorsreachingout.com/video.htm

Humane education is long term life insurance for the animals and the planet.- Susan Hargreaves
06:20 AM on 07/07/2010
I am disgusted and flabbergasted. With so few of these magnificent animals left on planet Earth, consuming them for some ridiculous reason is outrageous. Elle should hang her head in shame. The few who are left are doomed when nonsense like this comes out.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Anjushri
Veganism = Ahimsa
06:01 AM on 07/07/2010
Ms Newkirk, Elle McPherson uses all kinds of animal products and each of those products involves a great amount of suffering and the murder of sentient beings. 53 billion animals are tortured and murdered each year, so why focus on a celebrity's use of a specific animal? Why doesn't PeTA stop giving awards to animal exploiters and creating "conscientious omnivores" and promote veganism as a moral baseline.

All animals deserves at least one right --- the right not to be used as property and veganism is the step to taking that right seriously. It is the minimum standard of decency. Veganism is the recognition of the moral personhood of nonhuman animals
I would suggest to any readers of this article to view Prof Gary L Francione's blog : Animal Rights: The Abolitionist Approach http://www.abolitionistapproach.com
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
nameunused
02:10 AM on 07/07/2010
I eat cows.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:25 PM on 07/06/2010
I was so sickened to read about someone using rhino horn in such a blase way...great article1!
07:51 PM on 07/06/2010
Powerful anecdote about the rhino bull. I believe in the power of good writing.
06:18 PM on 07/06/2010
Anytime a human being exploits another living being for gain, it actually damages the ability that human being has to love and care for others. It is an actual damnation of emotional and spiritual progression and greatly compromises his/her capacity for full joy and happiness. How can we say that we care about the well-being of one individual, but not the well-being of another because he's of a "lower" species, his flesh tastes too good, he's fun to watch in a circus, or his horn brings a lot of money on the open market. The human heart does not compartmentalize that way. There is great tragedy in the suffering we impose on animals for money, taste, science and fleeting entertainment, but the greatest tragedy of all is the damage that is done to the human heart.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
nameunused
02:13 AM on 07/07/2010
So farmers can't really love? Wow, the things you learn here.
03:20 PM on 07/07/2010
Yes...if a farmer is routinely sending animals to slaughter, they are desensitizing themselves and harming themselves. Yes, it is degrading to the human spirit.

Why do I say this? Because there are many would never be able to do that. Ever.

I can't blame them entirely. They are a part of a culture that says it's ok to kill for some things. They are told this their whole lives and trained to do the job and to ignore their spirit. I actually feel compassion for them and blame all of society...especially those who eat meat, have other kill for them without thinking of the damage they are doing. Not only to animals but to the people who are forced to kill for them. Very harmful for the spirit.
03:18 PM on 07/07/2010
Janene....I totally agree with this!

When we harm other living beings for our own selfish needs...not only is the animal harmed but we are harmed. OUr spirit is harmed. It closes our hearts and makes us less sensitive and less willing to be compassionate. It clouds the beauty we could have and show.

You are totally right. Killing, harming degrades us totally. And makes us less human.
06:15 PM on 07/06/2010
Well, so do I, but who really cares what I eat??? Nobody (and let's keep it that way!)
04:45 PM on 07/06/2010
Shame on Elle. No animal deserves to be killed just to satisfy some human's greed and vanity.
03:25 PM on 07/06/2010
What was Elle thinking? There's nothing funny about animal abuse. We are just killing our way through the animal kingdom. When will people learn that animals are not medicines, food, clothes, or tools for us to use as we see fit? Thanks for exposing this hideous cruelty, Ingrid.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:27 PM on 07/06/2010
good post
03:04 PM on 07/06/2010
I don't know what makes me more nauseous: the thought of eating rhino horn or about how the poor rhinos are killed and poached for one part of their bodies. Please stop, Elle!
01:49 PM on 07/06/2010
I'd heard that animals were abused and killed to prepare some Chinese "therapies," but I could not - in my most macabre nightmares - have imagined the horror of it. The photo to which the article links is so painful. It's unclear to me why McPherson and others use powdered rhino horn -- whether it's to look younger or as an aphrodisiac. The reality of rhino poaching is positively ugly and anything but sexy. That is the image I will see when I think of McPherson.