iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Jacob Heilbrunn

Jacob Heilbrunn

Posted: March 12, 2010 10:21 PM

Hillary Clinton and Israel

What's Your Reaction:

Not since George H.W. Bush tried to stop Israeli settlement activity has an American president openly confronted Israel. Now Barack Obama, first through vice-president Joe Biden, then Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, is admonishing Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu about expanding settlements. Just as he has begun to make the case publicly for health care, so Obama is now starting to demand progress in the Middle East.

Obama, in other words,is going for broke. He has not given up on his insistence upon an Israeli-Palestinian peace. Instead, he's doubling down, much as he did in Afghanistan. Anyone who thinks that Obama lacks boldness should think twice.

The blunt fact is that this is no sudden outburst of anger, but a simmering fury on Obama's part. Obama's calls for negotiations have gone nowhere over the past year. Biden's humiliation was apparently the last straw. By flaunting its contempt for the administration, the Israeli government may have miscalculated.

Obama clearly believes that he has the political capital to lecture Israel, which is what makes the current standoff so fascinating. Obama is apparently calculating that the surge in Afghanistan, among other things, buys him enough political cover to push Israel to treat with the Palestinian leadership. Obama also appears to have a united foreign policy team. Biden, who is staunchly pro-Israel, was blindsided by the announcement of expanded settlements almost as soon as he touched down in Israel this week. The result has been an opening for Clinton, who lectured Netanyahu today. The message is clear: Israel is jeopardizing its special relationship with America.

Whether Obama's efforts will actually lead to a comprehensive peace is another matter. Obama could end up simply alienating the Democratic Party's traditional constituency of mostly liberal Jewish voters, who bridle at overt criticisms of Israel. But after a year of passivity, Obama is, to use a Clinton term from the 2008 campaign, finding his voice. America's allies and foes have been put on notice.

 
 
 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 410
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (8 total)
photo
BartRoberts
Vita canis, tum mors.
09:10 AM on 03/22/2010
I, too, support Israel, but that doesn't mean Obama should let the thuggish Bibi Netanyahu and his fascist ally Avigdor Lieberman continue to pursue uncriticized policies that jeopardize the peace process between Israel and Palestine and American interests including her military in the ME.
04:47 PM on 03/18/2010
I really get that Obama is furious about those apartments that are going to be built 5 minutes from the prime ministers office. He can keep cool about the killing of people protesting an election in Iran, about the foreigners being beheaded in Saudi Arabia, the enormous human rights violations in China, but we can't expect even Obama to keep his cool about this, the greatest travesty going on in the world.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
05:06 PM on 03/16/2010
Ah, more stern talk! Wow!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Cosatjockomo
02:09 PM on 03/16/2010
Obama set the stage for this last summer when he secretly agreed to allow Israel to build. Remember - One week headline read - Net. reports progress with US on settlements - then a week later they announced more construction. Obviously the progress Israel made was getting Obama to cave on the issue. Obama is the wet paper towel of international leaders.
09:21 AM on 03/16/2010
Actually, it IS news when an administration does what it says on certain issues while campaigning, and Israel is one of them. Count me an Israel supporter, but not "Israel right or wrong," and delighted that the Obama administration decided to call their bluff. It's about time. American tax dollars are spent liberally in Israel, especially on the military, but Israelis made it the "first world" country it is. Netanyahu needs to recognize that the time for reckoning has come and his financial support is in jeopardy if he doesn't reconsider. Some of my friends and cousins who live there would be unhappy with me if they read this, others would agree and just push harder for détente with the Palestinians.

Show time.
09:20 AM on 03/16/2010
Oh Please, any threats to Israel are hollow and empty. If we really meant to get Israel to do what we want then CUT OFF THE BILLIONS WE SEND THEM EVERY YEAR. We need the $$$$ here and they are never going to offer peace to the Palestinians anyway!!!!!
03:39 PM on 03/17/2010
You should also know that we give billions of dollars in aid to Egypt, which has one of the worst human rights records on the planet, and we don't say one word about it. If Palestinians and their supporters really wanted peace they would advocate removing from the Arab League charter advocating destruction of Israel.
08:44 AM on 03/16/2010
It isn't news when the administration does what it promised during the campaign. They made it very clear that they were anti-Israel during the campaign. The president wouldn't even look Netanyahu in the eye when they met in Washington. This is not a surprise it is what we expected when we voted for this administration. Bring down Israel and make the entire middle east a muslim mecca. Praise Allah.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
StCuthbert
Anytime the mods are ready...
09:32 AM on 03/16/2010
Another day, another poster calling for Israel's destruction.
07:38 AM on 03/16/2010
The U.S. needs to demand that Israel do a credible investigation into Rachel Corrie's death, Shaden Abu Hijleh's death, and Tristan Anderson's death. U.S. money paid for these atrocities. The U.S. Congress approved giving the money to Israel and at least in the Caterpillar bulldozer case have stated that U.S. security is tied to the sales (see Corrie vs. Caterpillar, U.S. intervention in the case). If Israel cannot even accomplish decent criminal investigations the U.S. needs to intercede.....after all, our money supplying the tools and per Nurenberg....if you supplied the tool, knowing how it was to be used .....then.....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
deluk
disgusted.
03:25 AM on 03/16/2010
Does this make Hilary Clinton "anti-semitic?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Brian D Smith
05:13 AM on 03/16/2010
any one that criticizes Israel is anti semitic.
however, Palestinians are Semites too. How Ironic!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
zbowling
software engineer, geek
03:18 AM on 03/16/2010
Our government has been exposed for it's duplicitous policies. Thats all that has happened and it's about time someone pointed out this vapid exercise in futility.
Let Lula DeSilva handle the problem, and have the US Admit to the world that it's too compromised to deal with the situation fairly, and agree to any DeSivla or UN recommendations including funding cutoff and boycott.
02:27 AM on 03/16/2010
President Obama does not miscalculate. Finally, when the irresponsible GOP did not cooperate, he decided go against them full force in health care. I hope and pray that he wins a clear vote. he has indeed worked hard. People have seen it all. How much he tried to work with the republicans and how they always rebuffed him! Mr. Obama is sharp like an American Eagle. His point of view has a long as well a wide perspective. With respect to Israel he has asserted that they can be dispensed with, if they don't play fair under US supervision.

In fact, Mr. Obama's foreign policy strength comes from being completely fair. He knows that he can finally broker a peace treaty involving Israel with clear vision and determination that helps both the warring parties.

Israel has always been an asset for previous administrations for pusuit of war. By taming Israel, Mr. Obama can even win Iran's trust .

Truly this man is smart in domestic and foreign policy, both. The GOP will be 'Going On Protest' on this issue because he is taking an assertive action against the naughty state of Israel.

By golly, a good leader is known by his fairness and exemplary action.
08:48 AM on 03/16/2010
"If they don't play fair under US supervision" - WHAT? The US doesn't have any business 'supervising' a sovereign nation. We are not an imperialistic nation.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:44 AM on 03/16/2010
Zionist terrorists slaughtered many Palestinians starting in the 1920s. Zionism is a creation of the Jewish European elite with it's first elected leader,Theodor Herzl, in the 1890s. It's MO has been for the re-creation of greater Israel using whatever it takes. The Irgun and the Stern gang are well known for their reign of terror in the Palestine community for well over a decade before Israel was a state, to the point of destroying the King David Hotel in Jerusalem on 22 July 1946 and blaming it on the Palestinians. This date is celebrated by Zionists as the date the British were driven from what would become Israel! By way of deception shall Israel wage war (Mossad motto).
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Brian D Smith
05:22 AM on 03/16/2010
"By way of deception shall Israel wage war (Mossad motto)."
I wish more Americans would understand this phrase.
Israel cares not about the USA but in its own self preservation. at any cost. they have even attacked us in the past {see 1967 USS Libetry}
http://www.nytimes.com/2001/04/23/world/book-says-israel-intended-1967-attack-on-us-ship.html?scp=2&sq=1967%20war%20israel/us%20ship&st=cse

CUT OFF ISREALS FUNDING
then we could put that money into health care.
09:23 AM on 03/16/2010
Don't worry, this is all part of the plan. We must distract Israel long enough for Iran to fully develop their nuclear weapons capability. Once we succeed in making Iran a nuclear power, Israel will be defanged and powerless. Then, it will only be a matter of time before Israel ceases to be a problem in the world and will become a Muslim nation and this will hasten the return of the 12th Imam. Praise Alah.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:16 AM on 03/16/2010
New FBI Files Alleging AIPAC Theft of Government Property and Israeli Espionage Released

http://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/new-fbi-files-alleging-aipac-theft-of-government-property-and-israeli-espionage-released-87230727.html
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mountainweb
Conservative Commonsense
11:41 PM on 03/15/2010
Total stupidity for obama to be doing this, he is alienating not only the liberal Jews but many Americans that feel that the Palestinians will never settle for peace and that trying to force the give away of land is badly flawed politics. We need to be focusing on JOBS and obama is running in every direction except that one.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
12:46 AM on 03/16/2010
Rubbish!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
zbowling
software engineer, geek
03:13 AM on 03/16/2010
You can't give away what you don't own. It's stolen land from the palestinians. The problem is not correcting the truth and letting Israel believe it's own propaganda and feed it to it's citizens.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
FearlessFreep
A radical leftist with a JS Woodsworth avatar.
11:36 PM on 03/15/2010
Remember when Hilary Clinton was running for the Senate and took the Israeli position on Jerusalem? (This at the time when her husband was trying to broker a peace agreement between Israelis and Palestinians.)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Brian D Smith
05:26 AM on 03/16/2010
Maybe she finally realized how BAD Israel is for the USA
we need distance.
not "NO SEPARATION" like little Joe stated.