More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Jacoba Urist

GET UPDATES FROM Jacoba Urist
 

Please, Don't Save for College

Posted: 01/24/2012 11:25 am

For so many of the parents I get to know in my line of work, January is all about those financial New Year's resolutions -- and all month I've been hearing how couples have pledged to make 2012 the year they really start saving more in their kid's college fund.

If you've got children, setting aside money for college sounds like a no-brainer, right?

I mean, how many times have we all heard that stashing a few hundred dollars here and there will pack a nice punch in say, ten or fifteen years when that tuition bill comes 'round and we have to pony up for all those pricey textbooks. And who hasn't been warned about how much college will cost by the time their little bundle of joy turns eighteen? I know that $400,000 estimate for a private university made me shudder. It's no wonder parents get locked into a kind of tunnel vision.

But here's what a lot of people miss: saving for college isn't for everyone. Yes, you might have to do a double take here. I really did just ask every parent to question whether saving for college is the right strategy at this point in their life. Because sometimes, it's actually better to pass on those nifty tax advantaged plans and focus on other, more important personal finance objectives -- that will get your family closer to paying for school down the road.

Without further ado, here are the four financial goals I believe every family should reach before they think about putting cash in their kiddo's college fund:

Buy Life Insurance
Whether your kid is thirteen or three-months-old, the most important purchase you can make to protect his or her long-term financial well-being is a life insurance policy. Sure, the chances of something happening to you (and/or the primary breadwinner) are, thankfully, super slim, but good parents just don't roll the dice on their child's future -- plain and simple.

The upshot: life insurance replaces the lost income of your primary earner if something happens to him or her, and you can also cover the cost of higher education if your policy is large enough. I tell every parent that putting money towards your life insurance premiums each month should take precedent over money in a college fund. After all, there are plenty of ways to help finance an advanced degree: public and private loans, part-time jobs, scholarships and financial aid packages. But if something happens to your main source of income, and you can't provide for your family's daily needs and make ends meet, there just aren't those kinds of funding options.

Pay Off Those Cards
Some basic math behind saving and borrowing: if you're paying double-digit interest on your VISA or MasterCard, but only getting single-digit returns on your college fund, you aren't helping anybody. I tell every family to start saving for college by paying down high-interest debt today.

The best strategy: kiddie costs come flying at parents left and right (my toddler literally seems to outgrow his shoes every time I turn around), but at least make a commitment to keep all of your discretionary items off of the plastic, and shoot to send in a little something extra for your payment every month. That $25 or $50 dollars plus any foregone adult charges will add up over 2012 and help chip away at that balance -- putting you in a stronger position to save for college next year.

Have A Solid Emergency Fund
Turns out, according to the most recent data, the majority of Americans can't cover an unexpected $1000 expense if they needed to. Can your family?

Before you open up that 529 account, make sure you have a solid cash cushion in case of a rainy day (or leaky roof). Given today's jittery job market, putting aside three to six months of living costs is bare minimum; I tell parents with young kids to shoot for six to nine if they possibly can. Without an emergency reserve, guess where those surprise expenses will end up? Yep, right back on those credit cards (see above).

Build A Real Budget
Nobody likes it, but the best way to save for college is to spend less. The lower your family's overhead, the more you can put towards your child's higher education in the long run.

I've found so many of the parents I work with don't have a real sense of where their money goes every year, and nobody can stick to a budget that doesn't reflect reality. With that in mind, the best thing you can do for your child's college fund this year is to print out your bank and credit card statements from 2011, and take a good, hard look at where your hard-earned cash is going every month. Bet there will be some surprises. But just think: you have eleven months to get in shape to start putting money in that college account for 2013.

 

Follow Jacoba Urist on Twitter: www.twitter.com/TheHappiestPare

 
 
  • Comments
  • 27
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
07:23 PM on 01/25/2012
One should indeed save, but not for college. Why would I pay somebody to attempt to turn my brain into mush?
02:12 PM on 01/25/2012
We did manage to finance college for two children without saving in advance mostly through current cash flow. The key was in living a lifestyle where essential expenses were covered by one salary. We chose modest home in outstanding public school district and drove reliable inexpensive automobiles. My smaller salary covered extracurricular activities, home furnishings, unplanned medical, dental, auto maintenance and repair, home repairs, vacations and my automobile expenses. When the kids started college, we were able to shift my earnings to college expenses for those years. Retirement savings were sacred, we never touched them.
12:36 PM on 01/25/2012
Confusing article. Don't save for college, but then at the end, save for college? Funny, I thought life insurance, paying down (or eliminating) credit card debt, an emergency fund and living on a budget were just standard things every family does. If not, i'm shocked and more than a little concerned. And as the parent of a current college student, which another closely following, may I offer this: SAVE FOR COLLEGE, EARLY AND OFTEN! It's crazy expensive, even at a state school. Yes you can get student loans if you haven't saved, but that just drives one deeper into debt with the interest and all. And I think it's not very nice to saddle a college student with a mountain of debt upon graduation, unless there is no other choice.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Jac Urist
04:38 PM on 01/25/2012
Hi Freedom Mama,
To clarify: you absolutely should save for college AFTER you've tackled these other financial goals. The article is saying please don't save for college if you haven't met these other crucial milestones. Also, unfortunately, given the economy, the job market, people's life styles (and a million other reasons), these financial goals are not "just standard things every family does." Sometimes, because they are trying desperately to make ends meet and sometimes because they are living above their means. Either way, this article applies to them.
thank you for commenting,
Jacoba Urist
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ejljr
When all else fails, read the damn instructions!
11:35 AM on 01/25/2012
What to do before saving for college? Give the kid an IQ test to make sure he/she can graduate from high school first!
12:37 PM on 01/25/2012
If you breathe, you can graduation from high school, at least a public one. College, however, is a different story.
12:38 PM on 01/25/2012
Graduate! Not graduation. More coffee needed...
09:53 AM on 01/25/2012
Not only is it important to have life insurance for the adults in the family make sure the kids are all insured too. Make sure your older children continue it once they are to old to be on your policy.
09:11 AM on 01/25/2012
Instead of having lavish birthdays for children such as princess parties that can cost around 400 dollars give them the gift of education and have a regular party at home or at a pizza parlor that may only cost about 150. Put aside 200 each year until it is time for college into a high yield account and watch that money grow. The princess party is so wasteful and so are diva parties.
07:42 PM on 01/24/2012
Good advice. I would add that life insurance IS necessary. Sadly, I just lost a friend the other week. 47, married, two small children. They have life insurance so while the loss is awful, the wife and kids are financially fine. It happens folks.

As for 529s - they mostly suck. 529s were crafted by Wall Street and made into law by their buddies in Congress for their benefit, not your kids. If you have a LOT of money to save, put it in a 529 but in a guaranteed/FDIC insured option - not the bogus, ponzi stock market. If you're a normal person and can't sock away $300k for Jr, stick to I Bonds and good, dividend paying stocks in a regular brokerage account. Tax savings are great, but not if your stock funds tread water for 15 years, or worse, lose 40-50%.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Jac Urist
04:40 PM on 01/25/2012
Dear Asult Jain,
I am so sorry for the loss of your friend. But I agree, IT does happen and thankfully your friend's family is fine financially.
With sympathies,
Jacoba Urist
gmikejake
resist evil
07:02 PM on 01/24/2012
As a now retired college professor/administrator for nearly four decades, please do not presume that your child will go to college directly after graduation from high school. Also, please consider having your child "earn" at least some of monies required for a college education. And, if your child is an "average" academic performer, please consider enrolling your child in one of our many excellent junior/community colleges before enrollment in a 4 year instituction. And, finally, what exactly is wrong with a career as an electrian, plumber, welder, etc.? Increasingly, during my last years, I saw more and more first year students that were simply not prepared, or even really motivated, for a 4 year college right out of high school. Too many of them, additionally, had earned decent grades in high school but were almost functionally illiterate with very poor reading abilities. At times, some "underperforming" students took my, usually unpopular advice, and "dropped out" for a term or two only to experience "real life," "find themselves," or at least learn what poverty is really like, and return motivated and much eager to participate in actual learning. I increasingly experienced young adults who were essentially "wasting" their parents monies, partying, taking the "easy majors," enrolling in the "easy courses," with social skills perhaps their greatest area for growth.
10:17 AM on 01/25/2012
Thank you. Directly out of high school, the only thing I was ready for was a break. I scored very well in every class but one (second language), performing a bit above average, but going immdiately to college felt like walking straight back into Hell. I dropped out to, as you say, "experience real life", and that time spent working showed me what I *really* wanted to do with my life (which was *not* my previous major). It also taught me that I didn't need to start towards my dream job right away; I can go to a technical school and get hands-on knowledge on a specific subject that I don't absolutely hate, then go back to college for my dream job a few years down the line. Luckily, I attended only community college for cost reasons and knew by the beginning of the second semester that I needed out (*immediately*); I feel very sorry for the parents of teens who dropped out after a year at Brown or Cornell or Northeastern.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cruisedoc
Physician, centrist, independent (x-dem)
05:23 PM on 01/24/2012
Whatever investment vehicle you use, DO save for college. You can never rely on current programs to be there tomorrow, and many govt. programs I suspect will go. Next, pursue a marketable degree, especially if you're borrowing to get it. Pursuing an 'interest' degree is nice if your parents can afford it, you won't go into debt to get it, and you're realistic about the return on educ. investment. One school offers a degree in 'The Beatles' (no kidding). Before going into debt on that one, make sure McCartney's hiring.
Always consider state schools. I have a son paying $12k a yr. at our state univ. - and that includes tuition, fees, private dorm room, meal plan, and health insurance.
So, use your head - don't pay $40k a yr. for a degree in Art History - you may find yourself carrying a sign in a cold park in NYC.

Also, realize that a 4 yr. degree has been devalued BIG TIME. I'd estimate that half the kids in college today don't belong there, were pushed through high schools, and simply aren't college material. So, it may take a higher degree to have something meaningful.

Finally, while prospects are good statistically - the unemp rate among college grads is only about 4% - realize it takes more than a degree in hand, and a degree is no guarantee. If a person comes to my office with tatoos and using bad English, their application immediately goes in the trash, even if
08:20 PM on 01/25/2012
Saving for college under a child's name is very UNWISE. Apply for FAFSA and all the funds(100%) available in the child's name will be counted against any aid that the child be granted. Instead, save under the parents name and the child will receive much more aid, plus your money.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cruisedoc
Physician, centrist, independent (x-dem)
02:06 AM on 01/26/2012
Did I say save in the child's name? No, I said save for college by whatever investment vehicle you choose and deem best. That said, you do realize that what you propose is gaming the system so a person may receive aid that is not truely needed ...aid intended to help those who truely need help. Frankly, what you propose exemplifies everything that 's wrong with our system. I pay for my son's education. I ask no other hard working American to pay for my family.
04:25 PM on 01/24/2012
This is good advice independent of the college-saving question.

It will be interesting to see how Gen Y fairs with the education and work market in the near future, let alone how future generations fair.

It used to be all about graduating high school and getting married. Then it was about going to college and getting a Bachelor's degree. Now-a-days it seems like having a Master's degree isn't enough--that it's best to have a degree and to know a trade. And in the future...?

Fail to plan and you're planning to fail. But no matter how much planning and preparing you do, there's no telling what life will bring.

Interesting times, interesting times...
04:02 PM on 01/24/2012
I'm not sure I agree with the life insurance piece and would be interested to hear what other people have to say. Do most people really think this is de rigeur?
05:54 PM on 01/24/2012
We have enough life insurance so we won't lose the house if one of us dies.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JustinP213
I dislike all political parties.
08:55 AM on 01/25/2012
My parents got a lot of life insurance for me and my sister when we were young. When my dad dies (he's 68), I get 2 million dollars tax free and so does my sister (since it passes through irrevocable trusts). We're sure glad that our parents set up life insurance policies for us.
03:57 PM on 01/24/2012
Number 5: DO NOT put money into a 401K except up to the employer's matching amount.
If the employer doesn't match, do not invest a penny in the plan.
noahmarder
Exposing the regressive lies, one by one
04:09 PM on 01/24/2012
And if you don't get vested until after a certain period of employment, forget it. That just gives the employer another reason to fire you.
04:51 PM on 01/24/2012
Why, please elaborate. What about IRAs?
06:12 PM on 01/24/2012
You do not have complete control of your money. The best way to invest is to, first, invest; don't trade. Investing makes you money; trading makes a broker money.

Look for steady DIVIDEND payments. A dividend is paid out of hard cash earnings; it means the company is making what it says. You can't fake a dividend.

Reinvest the dividend through the company plan and don't worry about the stock price.

Invest in companies you know something about. Would you invest in Sears today? Of course not.

What about Altria or ExxonMobil? Of course.

There is too little growth in 401ks and you make back your same investment over and over.

If you put away, say, 10K in a 401k per year and are in a 30% bracket, that reduces your taxable income roughly $3,000.

But when the 401K loses 10K that year what good is your 3K deduction?
02:40 PM on 01/24/2012
Boring and commonplace. But only because it's good, common sense!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Under Fed yet Fed Up
Always great distaste for both political parties
02:32 PM on 01/24/2012
Some pragmatic, solid advice.