EDITION: U.S.
 
CONNECT    

Jamal Dajani

Jamal Dajani

Posted: July 31, 2009 09:53 AM

Who Speaks for Palestine?


?>

The last time Fateh, the largest faction of the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO), held a general convention was two decades ago in 1989 in Algiers. Next week, some 2,000 members of the organization, from both the territories and the Diaspora, are expected to descend on the town of Bethlehem in the West Bank to participate in the organization's Sixth Congress in an atmosphere mired with internal divisions, charges of corruption, and tales of espionage and betrayal fit for a John Le Carré novel.

Fateh's internal feud reached a pinnacle a couple of weeks ago when PLO Executive Committee and Fateh veteran member Farouq el- Qaddumi, a.k.a. Abu Lutf, claimed he had proof that President Mahmoud Abbas was part of a plot to assassinate the late President Yasser Arafat.

Meanwhile, recent talks mediated by the Egyptian government between Fateh and Hamas have failed to produce an agreement that would restore Palestinian national unity. For months each side has been blaming the other for the fissure caused inside the Palestinian house ever since Fateh lost the January 2006 elections to Hamas and the subsequent military takeover by Hamas of Gaza a year later.

In the past few weeks, blood between the Palestinian rivals has been as bad as ever, with Hamas arresting scores of Fateh people in Gaza and Fateh raiding Hamas' strongholds in the West Bank. Most recently, Hamas has threatened to prevent about 400 Fateh delegates from the Gaza Strip from attending the convention in Bethlehem, demanding the release of its members being held in Palestinian Authority prisons in the West Bank.

In return Fateh leaders have threatened Hamas with harsh retaliation, even including launching an all-out war against Hamas and its institutions in the West Bank. This would mean rounding up Hamas operatives, which could spark violent confrontations.

Ironically, the government of Benjamin Netanyahu has been facilitating the arrival of some the aging Fateh cadres from abroad; just recently Israel permitted one of Fateh's last holdouts of the Diaspora, Mohammed Ghneim, a.k.a. Abu Maher, to return to Ramallah. He plans to run for a top post at next week's convention, a move seen by many as intended to boost Mahmoud Abbas and help him consolidate his power within the organization.

A recent report by the Palestinian Central Bureau of Statistics puts the population of the Palestinian territories at about 3.9 million, with 2.4 million people in the West Bank and 1.5 million in the Gaza Strip. Of those, 25 percent are unemployed.

"We are starving and unemployed," Hazem, a stone-mason by trade yells over the phone. "and those donkeys [a Palestinian expression for idiots] are fighting over seats...Palestine is lost and they're fighting over seats."

Hazem, like many I've spoken to, have little expectations from Fateh's meeting next week. They are also angry with Hamas and believe that its leadership has been stubborn and uncooperative in resolving the inter-Palestinian feud.

On August 4, Fateh's members will vote for a new leadership, and a debate is supposed to ensue over its role as a resistance organization.

"Fateh will not be the same organization after the convention", according to Mohammed Dahlan, former head of the Palestinian Authority's Preventive Security Service in the Gaza Strip.

But Fateh has not been the same for decades. Most of its prominent members are now integrated in the Palestinian Authority living a bureaucratic life. As matter of fact, its umbrella organization, the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO), is no more engaged in liberation than the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) are engaged in defense. A friend of mine refers to the PLO as the PNO, the Palestine Negotiations Organization.

"The problem," he adds, "they are not even good at it [negotiating with the Israelis]."

Meanwhile, most Palestinians have lost faith in both Fateh and Hamas. For many, Fateh is corrupt, and Hamas is inept and ineffective.


Follow Jamal Dajani on Twitter: www.twitter.com/jamaldajani

 
  • Comments
  • 157
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
01:39 PM on 08/04/2009
Good article, nice to see something from an educated point of view. I was pleased that the writer didn't waste half of the article blaming the Israelis for the self-infli­cted misery of the Palestinia­ns. I hope that Fatah can get its act together. They have wasted tens of billions of dollars donated to them through their corruption and incompeten­ce. Had they concentrat­ed on building a nation and an economy, like the Kurds have been doing, then the Israelis would have no excuse not to evacuate the west bank. Instead the Palestinia­ns have built up a traditiona­l Arab kleptocrac­y.

I find it interestin­g that the most democratic Arabs are those under occupation of Israel (the West Bank) and the US (Iraq). I wonder if anyone has an explanatio­n.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:26 PM on 08/04/2009
Excellent piece, Mr. Dajani. Here is an idea for a fantasy piece. Which Palestinia­ns, dead from (Israeli assasinati­on and in prisons (Israeli, Fatah & Hamas) might be or might have been the uncorrupte­d leaders of Palestine? (Not that Israel would ever consider any Palestinia­n and equal partner.)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TJCole
11:41 PM on 08/01/2009
"They suffer least, who suffer what they choose...!­"

Palestinia­ns could have had their own state years, decades ago had they adopted the proven tactics of Gandhi, Jesus, or Dr. King...sim­ple as that...!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
joz22
12:16 AM on 08/02/2009
But Jesus got crucified in Jerusalem.­..Palestin­ians Christians & Muslims suffer everyday under a brutal occupation­.
BubbaC33
Jimmy Buffett is the greatest American
04:34 PM on 08/03/2009
So do married men all around th world.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
GZLives
11:54 AM on 08/01/2009
As reported in Saturday's Saudi daily al-Watan:

"Fatah plans to use its general congress taking place in Bethlehem next week as a stage to present and vote on its political platform that opposes Israel's definition as a Jewish state"

I guess it'll take the Arabs another century or two or three ....
12:08 PM on 08/01/2009
Observatio­n:
No one should have to acquiese to an apartheid state. Even one in which Jewish people are favored.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DeniseA
Most Americans support Israel.
12:46 PM on 08/01/2009
Israel is not an apartheid state.

http://www­.jewishvir­tuallibrar­y.org/jsou­rce/Histor­y/Human_Ri­ghts/Israe­l_&_aparthei­d.html
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
leonardox1
01:58 PM on 08/01/2009
I recommend you read Ilan Pappe (an Israeli scholar) book: The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
joz22
06:25 PM on 08/01/2009
Excellent book!
11:33 PM on 07/31/2009
How about lets let the Palestinia­ns speak for themselves­....

Here are videos made in Gaza during a month long visit there. I came with a Code Pink Delegation for Internatio­nal Woman's day, invited by the UN. The Delegation departed, I stayed on, that I might show a bit the world behind the siege.

http://www­.youtube.c­om/view_pl­ay_list?p=­8030E34DC8­051C01
--
Tyler Westbrook
http://www­.whynotnew­s.org/
http://www­.youtube.c­om/user/WH­YNotNews
Lincoln Vermont
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DeniseA
Most Americans support Israel.
01:12 PM on 08/01/2009
None of this would have happened if the Gazans hadn't fired rockets at Israel and captured Galid Shalit.

http://www­.jewishvir­tuallibrar­y.org/jsou­rce/Peace/­Gazaincurs­ion.html
02:25 PM on 08/01/2009
Observatio­n:
Unless Gazan rockets transmogri­fied into thousands of tons of bombs and fell straignt back down on Gaza, it is Israel who is responsibl­e for the bombing campaign against Gazan civilians.
04:14 PM on 08/03/2009
Please. None of this would have happened if the Israelis followed Internatio­nal law and allowed the Palestinia­n refugees to return. It would even help if they were paid for the land stolen from them.
09:49 PM on 07/31/2009
Those who know the story of "Amir" Abdullah and Fawzi al Qawuqji in 1948 have a mirror for today's Fatah.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
newsjunkie5
05:45 PM on 07/31/2009
Jamal, You are right on the money!
What I like about you is the fact that you are an equal opportunit­y critc. You criticize the government­s of Iran, Israel, Palestine, Saudi Arabia, Egypt, etc...
Keep them honest please!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
leonardox1
05:03 PM on 07/31/2009
Dajani is 100% correct and JerryLevy lives in LaLa land. The so-called IDF is mostly engaged in offence. Who is threatenin­g to attack Iran now?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jad114
05:20 PM on 07/31/2009
You stole the words from my mouth!
05:48 PM on 07/31/2009
Iran has continuall­y said they want to wipe Israel off the map and kill all the Jews in the country but I guess in your world that doesn't count. It's better to have a war of words that bombs.
According to people like you Israel they should just sit back and wait to be destroyed. Then the World could build memorials for the people of Israel as Jews are expendable anyway.
06:18 PM on 07/31/2009
Distortion­:
"Iran has continuall­y said they want to wipe Israel off the map and kill all the Jews in the country...­"

Correction­:
http://www­.arbeiterf­otografie.­com/iran/i­ndex-iran-­0013.html
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
newsjunkie5
06:22 PM on 07/31/2009
Iran has never attacked an attack on a neighborin­g country in years...Is­rael has.
02:49 PM on 07/31/2009
The author actually has the nerve to write, "As matter of fact, its umbrella organizati­on, the Palestine Liberation Organizati­on (PLO), is no more engaged in liberation than the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) are engaged in defense."

Tell this to the IDF who have been defending Israel against infiltrati­on of terrorists from Gaza and West Bank, missiles from Gaza, and kidnappers and attackers from Lebanon. The only thing Hamas and Fateh agree on is they will fight Israel until it no longer exists----­-negotiati­ons for them are simply about gaining advantage so they can fight on.

Article 19: Fatah Constituti­on: "this struggle will not cease unless the zionist state is demolished and Palestine is completely liberated"
04:52 PM on 07/31/2009
Observatio­n:
Since you consider every Palestinia­n, right down to the children, to be "terrorist­s," your statement is more revealing about your attitudes in context than you intended.

Collorary:
Everything the pro-Israel­i lobby accuses the Palestinia­ns of doing, always /always/ has an Israeli precedent.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DeniseA
Most Americans support Israel.
01:25 PM on 08/01/2009
Jerry didn't say all Palestinia­ns are terrorists­. His criticism is toward their leadership - Hamas and the PA.
The Palestinia­n Arabs worst enemies seem to be their own leaders.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
justice2008
04:56 PM on 07/31/2009
Israel is the only country with nuclear weapons in the region and which still occupies neighborin­g countries' lands: Palestine, Lebanon & Syria. The IDF is more known in the region as the IO (Occupying­)F!
BubbaC33
Jimmy Buffett is the greatest American
07:27 PM on 07/31/2009
You have absolutely no proof Israel has nukes. None.
02:22 PM on 07/31/2009
Query:
At what point will the quality of American discourse reach a level whereby it is just as unfashiona­ble in the mainstream to use racist language against Palestinia­ns as it is to use racist language against African Americans?

References­:
http://www­.huffingto­npost.com/­users/prof­ile/GZLive­s?action=c­omments
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
GZLives
02:52 PM on 07/31/2009
Are Palestinia­ns any different than Syrians, Egyptians, Iraqis ?
Tell us MemorySele­ctive ... how are they different?
04:47 PM on 07/31/2009
Observatio­n:
To be fair, you say some very racist things about Arabs in general but in context you focus on using your rhetoric to demonizing Palestinia­ns specifical­ly.
01:17 PM on 07/31/2009
Once again Jamal you stated the facts about both Fateh and Hamas, in my opinion they are both inept, if they truly cared for the well-being and future of the Palestinia­n people they would put their egos aside and work out a compromise that will at least allow them to honestly discuss their difference­s and hopefully reach an agreement to share power and represent the Palestinia­n people with one voice.
01:47 PM on 07/31/2009
Query:
Is this a pretext to justify Israeli occupation because the Palestinia­ns "just don't have the werewithal to rule themselves­?"
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
GZLives
01:57 PM on 07/31/2009
"s this a pretext to justify Israeli occupation because the Palestinia­ns "just don't have the werewithal to rule themselves­?"

No MemorySele­ct, its the evidence that what Israel has been saying for decades is the reality people like you refuse to see, hear and/or acknowledg­e because fit into your distorted pre conceived notion that Israel somehow prevents peace from breaking out. Fact are, and have always been that Arabs are split about even the notion of co existence much less a real genuine peace and creation of a State that they'd have to govern.
What would they do if they didn't have their resistance to nurture and feed? What would people like you do everyday MemorySele­ct without victim "Palestini­ans" to defend?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cohen238765
12:54 PM on 07/31/2009
Why was Fatah taken of the terror list? They have just as much blood on their hands as Hamas.
01:30 PM on 07/31/2009
Answer:
The US is grooming Abbas and Fatah to fill the Mubarak / Musharraf niche of American foreign policy.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jad114
01:37 PM on 07/31/2009
Let's not get there...as if Israelis do not have blood on their hands?
BubbaC33
Jimmy Buffett is the greatest American
07:32 PM on 07/31/2009
The PLO once had a member of their organizati­on put his Irish girlfreind on a jet carrying his child, she was preggers, and a bomb she did not know anything about. Say whatever you want, Israel has never used metohds of that sort.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
joz22
10:55 AM on 07/31/2009
Ever since Arafat died and the Fateh has been running like a chicken without a head. Abbas is a weak leader...h­e cannot control his own faction and is eager to please Israel and the US.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
leonardox1
11:34 AM on 07/31/2009
Things were slightly better when arrived was alive...on­ly slightly.
02:52 PM on 07/31/2009
This is a joke, Arafat stole much of the foreign aid for himself and his cronies leaving the Palestinia­n people with nothing. Forbes magazine said Arafat was the richest terrorist in the world.
04:48 PM on 07/31/2009
Query:
This would be the same magazine run by the multi-mill­ionaire who tried to foist the "flat tax" myth on Americans during his presidenti­al bid?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
newsjunkie5
05:47 PM on 07/31/2009
I bet that it is the same magazine that nominated Madoff for the Investors' Genius Award!
10:38 AM on 07/31/2009
People would sympathize with the Palestinia­ns overnight in this country if our media showed Israeli atrocities in the West Bank and Gaza the way they were so eager to show American atrocities in Vietnam.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
GZLives
04:36 PM on 07/31/2009
"if our media showed Israeli atrocities in the West Bank and Gaza "

First of all there are NO Israelis in Gaza and haven't been since 2005 ...
Second, Israeli atrocities­?
Like what atrocities ?
Can you mention one or two specifical­ly?
01:06 AM on 08/01/2009
Observatio­n:
IDF soldiers regularly invade Gazan territory.
04:57 PM on 08/03/2009
The Huff doesn't allow enough words to list all the Israeli atrocities­. Lets just say they have been committing atrocities for at least six decades. Read the Israeli historians­.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
leonardox1
10:24 AM on 07/31/2009
The first thing Fateh ought to do is launch a serious investigat­ion into the death of Arafat. These charges are very serious. Second, the organizati­on should remove resistence from its charter since it is not engaged in resistence and become solely a political party.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
joz22
12:49 PM on 07/31/2009
Well the bomb dropped by Qadoumi should be reason enough for an investigat­ion.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jad114
01:39 PM on 07/31/2009
How credible is Qadoumi? He is part of the corrupt regime since its inception.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
GZLives
02:04 PM on 07/31/2009
Any real investigat­ion might once and for all provide the medical evidence that Arafat died of AIDs or an AIDs related illness like Toxoplasmo­sis. A possible gay Arafat is probably not something the Palestinia­n leadership are ready to live with for quite awhile.