More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
HuffPost Social Reading
James P. Hoffa

GET UPDATES FROM James P. Hoffa
 

Carnage and Crime In Mexico Offer More Reasons to Keep Unsafe Trucks Off U.S. Roads

Posted: 02/21/2012 3:35 pm

The State Department recently warned Americans against taking unnecessary trips to vast, dangerous sections of Mexico. Nearly all the states along the border are awash in violence, and there is no safe road to Mexico City.

Mexico's 5-year-old narco-war is only getting worse. More than 12,000 people were killed in drug-related violence last year, a 6 percent increase over the previous year. Reports of torture, beheadings and killing of women are up as well.

Just two weeks ago, Mexican troops announced that they seized 15 tons of methamphetamine near Guadalajara -- an amount equal to half the meth seized in 2009 in the entire world.

That's why U.S. truck drivers don't haul freight south of the border.

NAFTA was supposed to eliminate trade barriers among Canada, Mexico and the U.S. But Mexico has clearly failed to do what the deal requires it to -- provide the same fair access to its markets that the U.S. offers to Mexico.

If a violent drug war isn't an impediment to trade, I don't know what is.

Mexico's failure is especially egregious in the case of cross-border trucking. U.S. trucks and truckers have to meet much more rigorous safety standards than their Mexican counterparts. Carnage and crime prevent them from using Mexican highways. But Mexican trucks that don't meet U.S. safety standards are allowed to drive on violence-free U.S. highways as part of the U.S. Transportation Department's latest pilot program.

That isn't fair and it isn't right.

The Teamsters have long warned against opening the border to dangerous trucks. Last summer, the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration allowed itself to be intimidated by Mexico into starting a pilot program to allow certain trucks to freely travel our highways.

We predicted the program would fail, based on our experience with FMCSA's previous pilot program. Six months after the program started, we believe we are right.

FMCSA allowed a company with a terrible safety record, Grupo Behr, to be the first participant in the pilot program. We were incredulous that FMCSA could be so sloppy about something that's been in the limelight for years -- something the public strongly opposes and Congress has voted against.

The Teamsters objected to Grupo Behr because it has a poor safety record -- according to FMCSA's own statistics. So FMCSA investigated and found the company had broken U.S. law by leasing trucks to companies allowed beyond the border zone. But rather than banning Grupo Behr from the pilot program, as the law says it must, FMCSA will reconsider Grupo Behr's application in six months.

Further proof that FMCSA is indifferent to highway safety came with the second company allowed into the pilot program. Transportes Olympic has one truck with a 33 percent out-of-service rate.

There's one other trucking company, Moises Alvarez Perez, that's been allowed into the pilot program. It also has one truck.

So after six months, the cross-border trucking pilot program has two trucks and three drivers who've made a total of nine trips beyond the border zone.

Now the law requires FMCSA to include enough trucks and enough trips in its pilot program to draw statistically valid conclusions about the safety of Mexican trucks. But FMCSA has consistently turned a blind eye to safety issues. The Teamsters, however, have not. We challenged the legality of the pilot program in court. Our arguments are due in three weeks.

We're confident we'll prevail. But it will take big changes at FMCSA to restore the American public's faith in its ability to safeguard our highways.

 

Follow James P. Hoffa on Twitter: www.twitter.com/TeamsterPower

The State Department recently warned Americans against taking unnecessary trips to vast, dangerous sections of Mexico. Nearly all the states along the border are awash in violence, and there is no saf...
The State Department recently warned Americans against taking unnecessary trips to vast, dangerous sections of Mexico. Nearly all the states along the border are awash in violence, and there is no saf...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 10
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Julie99
09:55 PM on 03/30/2012
http://www.teamster.org/sites/teamster.org/files/3812PetitionersReplyBrief.pdf

Filed law suit against Mexican drivers. Low standards and not commplying to American standards.
08:31 AM on 02/27/2012
More of James Hoffa's debunked BS..... Ultra low sulphur diesel? They got it in and around the major metropolitan areas. Mexican trucks have been running in this country legally for more than 4 decades, safely and professionally. Their drivers are held to a higher standard of professionalism than ours, and it shows.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ennis438
09:12 AM on 02/22/2012
Mexican trucks are time bombs and should not be allowed in the US unless their standards improve enough to match American safety rules.
09:26 PM on 02/21/2012
There is a limited amount of ultra low sulfer diesel available in Mexico.Be cause of EPA mandated engines american trucks can;t run on more polluting diesel fuel available in Mexico.Their trucks on the other hand have trucks entering our country full of their lower priced fuel,fouling our air and giving them another competitive advantage over american truckers
03:58 PM on 02/21/2012
Your article annoyed me in a few ways. The existence of an American funded drug war isn't fair.... to American teamster operations? Really??! I don't understand the purpose of this article other than to highlight your trivial cause. Maybe you just seek to start a xenophobic discussion on shutting down the border. Is that the solution you're hinting at to restore "fairness"? NAFTA is old news, deal with it.
04:51 PM on 02/21/2012
Hopefully your family wont be wiped out by some unsafe mexican truck because the owner bribed the safety inspector to turn a blind eye just like everything else south of the borderI Ithink a trade freeze on Mexico based on the chaotic and unsafe atmosephere might get them to double down the countries efforts to get control of thier situation.
09:32 PM on 02/21/2012
Free trade agreements were sold on the fact that they would build up the economies of other nations.Instead they have allowed big multi national corps do avoid living wage and environmental standards, and have led to the decline of the lifestyles for the 99%.I suspect this was the original intention.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
08:41 AM on 02/22/2012
Which political party controlled Congress when NAFTA passed? Which political party signed this into law? Which political party does the author have power to persuade?