iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
James Zogby

James Zogby

Posted: July 24, 2010 10:30 AM

I Understand Shirley Sherrod

What's Your Reaction:

As an Arab American, I can empathize with Shirley Sherrod, In the midst of this crisis, I wrote a number of short pieces on a few websites charging that she had been "lynched" and was a victim of a hysterical mob spurred on by lies and cowards in authority who, out of fear or political calculation, had sacrificed her to a mob refusing her right to a fair hearing.

I understood her plight because I, and many other Arab Americans and American Muslims, had endured similar treatment. Over the years a veritable industry has developed of anti-Arab groups and individuals whose job it has been to track our progress and to challenge our every advance with smear campaigns. Taking our quotes out of context, making patently false and sometimes bizarre claims that fabricate connections with terror groups and extremists, these characters and the websites and right-wing publications who use their work have directed their attacks against many prominent Arab and Muslim Americans and those in government or business who work with us.

This is what happened to my son more than a decade ago, when he worked for a time at the Department of State. The same types of attacks have followed my every move for decades. When in 1993, Vice President Al Gore asked me to head up a project he was launching to support economic development in the West Bank and Gaza, one of the professional Arab bashers wrote a piece suggesting I had been supportive of terrorists. Using this material, a prominent liberal magazine editorialized that Gore should remove me from the post. To his credit, Gore defended me and arranged a meeting with the magazine's editor. When the editor produced the quote I was alleged to have made and I shared with him the full text of what I had said, he recognized his error and apologized. But the attacks never stopped. When I was invited last year to deliver the closing remarks at a Department of Justice conference, a right wing researcher published an article describing me as "[Attorney General Eric] Holder's Hizbollah Buddy" and when I addressed last year's Pentagon Iftar dinner, another of these anti-Arab hatchet men wrote a piece in a conservative magazine noting that a "well known Wahhabi supporter" spoke at the Pentagon.

Much the same has been experienced by others in my community. An Arab American state legislator in Michigan, and even the newly crowned Miss USA were falsely accused of Hizbollah ties. Young attorney Mazin Asbahi was forced to resign from the Obama campaign over similar fabricated charges.

And even now a new storm is brewing. A new mosque is being planned in an area near Ground Zero, the site of the terrorist attack that killed 3,000 innocents on September 11, 2001. Some local groups have objected and have been supported by the likes of 2012 presidential aspirants Sarah Palin, who called the mosque a "stab to the heart," and Newt Gingrich, who saw the mosque as part of a larger challenge arguing that "America is experiencing an Islamist cultural-political offensive designed to undermine and destroy our civilization."

A conservative magazine accelerated the assault with a personal attack on the mosque project's leader, Imam Faisal Abdul Raouf -- a truly honorable man with a long record of promoting peace and reconciliation. Using the now familiar tools of half quotes, fabricated connections (described by another writer as: "his wife has an uncle who used to be "a leader" of a mosque that now has a Web site that links to the Web site of an allegedly radical organization"), and innuendo, the article attempts to portray Imam Faisal as a suspicious and even dangerous threat. And now Congressman Peter King, the Republican ranking member of House Homeland Security Committee has called for an investigation into Faisal Abdul Raouf.

And so I understand Shirley Sherrod. I know what she has endured and while I celebrate her vindication, I know we, as Americans, are not yet out of the woods. Something is fundamentally rotten in our political culture -- where groups seeking political advantage can so easily make victims of innocents and cowards will let good people pay a price rather than defend their rights to a fair hearing.

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 84
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Mark Olmsted
essayist, blogger, activist
12:07 PM on 07/26/2010
Sherrod's experience is an excellent vehicle for examining ourselves on the issue of race, an opportunity I had in prison: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/mark-olmsted/how-i-confronted-my-inner_b_657584.html
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
oregon bird
09:41 AM on 07/26/2010
No, she wasn't thrown to a mob. The mob never so much as managed to pick up a pebble to throw. She was thrown under the bus by government minions. By our civil service. Because they were afraid the rabble, and too chicken-s**t to stand up. And, she was black, they were white. All the white people who were proved in court to have been racist are still working there -- she got thrown out without a trial. And it was the white leader of the agency that made that decision. NOT the mob.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:52 AM on 07/26/2010
who was it that started this whole mess by releasing ANOTHER video of someone that was deliberately misleading?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
oregon bird
07:46 PM on 07/26/2010
Breibart and Fox baited the Administration. No doubt about that. And when they got such a gratifying response, they did a quick 180 and pretended to sympathize with her. So, they punked Obama et al. twice. It was horrifying. But the facts remain. In a department that has legally been judged and fined for acting in a racist manner, the only person who lost their position for racism -- without so much as a hearing, which is STANDARD procedure -- was a black woman. Facts suck.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
pjwrites
09:14 AM on 07/26/2010
I'm sorry you've experienced discrimination in this country. It's only because of a lack of trust, caused by the corruption of those we once trusted at the top of the heap.

But we're working on cleaning house. And senate.
photo
MyAhaMoment
Mississippi Liberal: a rare breed, indeed!
08:16 AM on 07/26/2010
Unfortunatley the rot doesn't stop at the 'political' border but is permeating the very fabric of our entire culture. for some reason the majority of Americans have to have someone to hate...it leads back to an article i read about the inability of most 'adults' (and i use the term loosely) to reach a maturity level in their conscience that allows for everyone, regardless or race, color, or creed, to be an accepted, beneficial member of society. It's sad really, and that is what 'stabs at the heart' of those of us who believe America can be a better place for all.
09:50 AM on 07/26/2010
"it leads back to an article i read about the inability of most 'adults' (and i use the term loosely) to reach a maturity level in their conscience that allows for everyone, regardless or race, color, or creed, to be an accepted, beneficial member of society."

So true MyAhaMoment. That's exactly what it is, and I've said the same thing for years. And the same thing is true unfortunately for people across all levels of intelligence.
photo
Charles Grimmett
Former Stock Broker, Retired Teacher. Disabled Vet
05:42 AM on 07/26/2010
We are in the midst of a new incarnation of McCarthyism. In today's version "Red" has been replaced by Muslim, and un-American has become to mean other than white or Christian. As the nation's demographics move toward a majority that is not white, there is a natural apprehension of the change and what it will mean.
While the election of a black man as President served to increase the uneasiness of many whites about the future, it galvanize bigots and fear mongers into action. Political opportunist of the right, sensing possible advantage have resurrected and old approach; label, demonize, criminalize, and convict without fair hearing.
"They" are taking over the country. "They" are not truly American. "They" hate us and want to rule us. "They" are violent, unscrupulous, and hate us. "They" would end "Our" American way of life. But most of all they can't be American! Multiculturalism is a lie! Political correctness is unrealistic. The Constitution is not a suicide pact. Fear those who are different.
Its an old tune. Are you now or have you ever been a progressive?
01:13 AM on 07/26/2010
At a family gathering a couple of weeks ago, a relative I was talking to got to talking about how there are Muslim fundamentalists in America trying to build mosques all across the country and that they're all acting in concert with a grand plan to take over the country.
She was dead serious about it, and convinced that this Muslim takeover of the country is going on right now - apparently right under our noses, and no one is noticing.
It turned out from what she said that she'd heard all this online.
The root of the story - the only fact in it all - was the mosque that may or may not be built near ground zero.
Everything else she was ranting about was total right-wing BS scaremongering.
THAT is the kind of thing that's poisoning the minds of a significant portion of the country - aka Republicans.
They're using racist fearmongering to try to motivate white Republicans to vote in large numbers the same way they used homophobic fearmongering to motivate anti-gay Republicans to vote in 2004 with all those anti-gay-marriage ballot measures in swing states.
Does it NEVER occur to Republicans to try to get themselves reelected by just doing their job well?
Why do they always feel they have to stoop to slimy dirty tricks and divisive wedge issue fear and smear tactics?
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
druidlady42
12:33 AM on 07/26/2010
It's our OWN religious extremist elements, FOX "News", and (as Hillary so accurately said)---- that "vast Rightwing conspiracy", all of which have poisoned and divided this country!

How can so many people be so hateful now in this country, still not accepting that we are ALL made of the same elements, the same God-given spirit,---fellow travelers on the same troubled, yet beautiful, earth? What a waste of our time here to spend it in hate!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Mujtaba S
01:42 PM on 07/25/2010
Politics in America is seriously just like high school drama. He-said she-said. We focus so much on what a person says, or should say, or doesn't say or shouldn't have said. But when it comes to policy, and the actual business of governance, the conversation just goes static.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:26 PM on 07/25/2010
Great point. Fanned & faved.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Dr. Jonathan David Farley
mathematician
10:50 AM on 07/25/2010
I am Shirley Sherrod. And one of the people who attacked me and who defended the Confederacy was Arab-American, Muslim Samar Ali, now a White House Fellow.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/dr-jonathan-david-farley/the-national-association_b_657056.html
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SaraSH
Athi*est Scientist Independent Old Fashioned
01:56 AM on 07/25/2010
This article is SO true.Before 911, you always felt racism here and there if you were from the Middle East,religious or not. But after 911, I can honestly write a book about what myself and ALL my friends experienced.In fact, those who think Black Americans have had it bad they are underestimating the situation of Middle Easterners to a HUGE extent.Affirmative action and diversity has NO usage for us & we get discriminated left and right without ANY power to do anything about it.I am not even mentioning the NASTY treatment we all get in airports all over the world,that is just NO BIG deal these days, we have all evolved thick skins on that one.I am talking about facing ignorant questions and comments for our ethnicity,serious dumb generalizations, etc.There was NO shock for me to see the Miss USA get treated that way.My friends and I,ALL secular, mostly Agnostic/Atheist Persians and Turks were cornered in bathrooms of our universities,were mistreated big time by our counselors and professors, etc right after 911.The cases of racism we all have experienced are just over the roof. And NONE of us looked like or acted like the stereotypical Muslims.Americans need to REVIEW their actions,all of them,& realize MANY of us are here DUE TO those radical terrorists.We HATE THEM TOO.We are NOT like them. I for one would not be outside Iran for ONE second if its regime was a secular one
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
musewrites
Writer in search of the next great story to tell
01:41 PM on 07/25/2010
Thank you for pointing this out. When I was in New York for grad school one of my friends who is half Syrian and half Hispanic was told by her career counselor to remove from her resume that she speaks Arabic fluently.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SaraSH
Athi*est Scientist Independent Old Fashioned
01:00 AM on 07/26/2010
someone should make a documentary about this....I myself have several movie worthy stories.
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
bklynsparrow
creating reality from unreal things
11:06 AM on 07/26/2010
When I worked at Ground Zero we often wound up doing 2 shifts and someotimes I would have to take a cab home. One night it was an Arab driver who picked me up, and he was very nervous. So we started talking- wound up sitting outside my house for about 20 minutes just talking and crying about how we both just wanted peace. In NYC we have so much opportuity to talk with so many different people- talking with each other is so important. YOu see how we are all just people- more alike than not.

Extremism is the most self destructive thing we can engage it- you can see how crazy it is on some of the GZ Mosque threads. It's a huge controversy among those of us who are connected to the WTC and my feeling is that the Cordoba center would be a wonderful asset to have. Anything that promotes understanding and peace must be built and those who take offense at it, have issues no common sense or appeal to fairness will fix.

I hope we wil see better times - for all of us.
06:52 PM on 07/26/2010
If it's not too personally probing - how did you come to be working at Ground Zero?

I can still walk every hallway in my mind, having worked at 7WTC for six years. I used to do a power-walk during lunch across the bridge to 5WTC, then over to the WFC, through that complex, circling back across the bridge to 7WTC. In all 1/2 mile. Air-conditioned and dry all the way, except for the first little bit across the bridge from #7 to #5.
photo
lightist
light as a photon, heavy as tungsten.
12:48 AM on 07/25/2010
So many cowards I cry.
So few courageous to testify.
We're changing that minute by minute.
Tears of rage turn towards infinite.

Strength grows where pain overwhelmed.
Each hit taken surges adrenaline through core.
Heart takes on courage, brain-body unifies.
Whole being senses all will exemplify.

Each follow lead birds - holding formation
Each glides - not fall this long voyage.
Conscience compass guided through pineal
True bearings we feel.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
politicky
just follow the $$$
11:51 PM on 07/24/2010
Thank you Mr. Zogby. I'm still floored that anyone takes Breitbart or Fox news seriously anyway.
Sergeant
Dress Right
09:40 PM on 07/24/2010
The only defense to bigotry is having courageous leaders who demand accountability and listen to those who are falsely accused.
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
ron071
07:35 PM on 07/24/2010
Shirley Sharrod will emerge from the FAUX SMEAR by the extreme right wing-nuts better than before. She is now in the clear plus she has her full dignity in tact. That is far more than the agents of deceit on the radical right like Brightbart and his aides in smear at Faux " News ". Anyone who knows the rudiments of this smear story will acknowledge that it is another nail in the coffin of these low-lifes on the right wing.
Sergeant
Dress Right
09:41 PM on 07/24/2010
So, the liberals who fired her get their information from right wing media outlets? Is that what you are saying? That, once again, the Obama administration is not responsible?
08:56 AM on 07/26/2010
Are you denying the bottom line responsibility of the people that creatd and then manipulated this sham of an issue and presented it as news? You lose credibility to denounce the Obama Admin. until you denounce the people that painted her and the Admin. as bigots in the first place with a false portrayal.
06:57 PM on 07/24/2010
It is indeed the case that there is something "fundamentally rotten in our political culture." And it is indeed cowardly to cave to accusations before the accused has been given a fair hearing - something which can only take place after the emotional reactions that many accusers fully intend to trigger have began to subside. Thank you, Mr. Zogby, for this thoughtful essay.