iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Jamie Henn

GET UPDATES FROM Jamie Henn

Sen. McCain Should Blame Climate Change, Not Immigrants, for Arizona Wildfires

Posted: 06/22/11 12:34 PM ET

Rather than blame undocumented immigrants for the fires ravaging his home state, Sen. John McCain should be educating the public about something he used to profess to know something about: the climate crisis.

At a press conference last Saturday, McCain said, “There is substantial evidence that some of these fires have been caused by people who have crossed our border illegally.”

This isn’t the first time McCain has talked about seeing the “substantial evidence.” In a 2008 speech at a wind turbine facility in Portland, McCain said of climate change, “No longer do we need to rely on guesswork and computer modeling, because satellite images reveal a dramatic disappearance of glaciers, Antarctic ice shelves and polar ice sheets. And I've seen some of this evidence up close.”

John McCain’s transformation from climate Dr. Jeckyll to anti-immigrant Mr. Hyde is a challenge for climate and a immigrant rights activists to find common ground.

Climate scientists have studied not only how increased global warming exacerbates fires across the western United States, but also how the drought caused by climate disruption drives more and more people in Mexico and across Central America to leave their parched homes and risk their lives to find work in el norte. A 2010 study in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, concluded that climate change's impacts on crop yields may force as many as seven million Mexicans to emigrate to the U.S. over the next 70 years. 

Now, the very immigrants that were driven from their homes by the climate crisis are being blamed for its impacts.

As climate disruption continues, it will exacerbate social conflict around the world. As Christian Parenti writes in his new book on climate conflict, Tropic of Chaos, “The United Nations has estimated that all but one of its emergency appeals for humanitarian aid in 2007 were climate related.”

The US border is not the only place where the conflict is coming to a head. India is already building a militarized fence along its 2,500 mile border with Bangladesh, a country that could see 22 million people forced from their homes by 2050 because of climate change.

Weathering the storm of the coming century will require immigrant rights, social justice, and environmental advocates to come together to offer a new vision of how society must deal with the multiple crises we face. Instead of building walls to stop the flow of climate refugees, we need to be building fair and sustainable economies that allow people to stay in their homes. And when refugees are forced to flee extreme weather, we need to show solidarity with one another, rather than cast blame on the most vulnerable.

In a different world, one could imagine Sen. McCain being a voice of reason on these issues. Instead, he’s decided to fan the flames of conflict. Let’s hope that by working together, we can begin to put out the fires.

 

Follow Jamie Henn on Twitter: www.twitter.com/agent350

 
 
  • Comments
  • 23
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Idaho dachnik
meliorist goat lady
12:40 PM on 06/30/2011
I would have Christian Parenti as President as he has more understanding of what is really going on than the rest put together!
photo
bad spelling grammar
Help save Big Cats from extinction!
04:44 PM on 06/27/2011
Don’t expect the not so great state of Arizona to believe any of this when people like @OPRockwell a HP user posts comments like

11:46 PM on 6/24/2011
“CO2 is good for the planet. I run a green house. we pump in about 2% Co2 and it doubles our food production. we sjopuld think seriously about making ity mandantory¬, to drive your car twice as much to get our CO2 levels up!”

here is the link to see what else this guy posted

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/06/23/arizona-wildfire-endangered-species-animals_n_883567.html

Just scroll down to see what else the people of Arizona had to say about the fire and on an article about the loss of endangered species due to the fire. The comments are disgusting and will show you the type of mentality that is promoted in that state. It is honestly worse than any ware else in America. This is why Arizona is last in science in the country; because people like this guy promote this insane ideology of resisting anything that hints at climate change or the possibility of changing their way of life. Such a lack of intelligence is very dangerous for our country especially because it is being encouraged in Arizona. Anyone who thinks they should drive their car twice a day to increase the CO2 levels on the planet for the sake of plants is INSANE!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
FLECKENSTEIN44
Pointing out the hypocrisy of the Left and Right
04:31 PM on 06/27/2011
i have a hard time believing Mccain blamed illegals for the fires in his state.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Royal Payne
09:08 AM on 06/27/2011
"Sen. McCain Should Blame Climate Change, Not Immigrants, for Arizona Wildfires" This has to be in the top 5 of all time stupid conclusions. Is it climate change that burns California every year or poor land mgt. Prairie fires have been an annual event since lightening. Fires start in one of two ways … caused by nature or carelessness.

The ILLEGAN IMMIGRANTS, drug smugglers, gang-bangers, and terrorist affiliates that cross our southern border should remain forever blameless. Let's blame T. E. Lawrence instead for setting the desert on fire.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
OldHick
12:49 AM on 06/27/2011
We should give the Mexicans jobs as firemen, and they can put out their own flames.
photo
bad spelling grammar
Help save Big Cats from extinction!
04:53 PM on 06/27/2011
I thought they determined that the cause of the fire was from two unattended camp fires within the national park caused by tourists and that it spread due to wind. Read this article, there are hundreds more just like it that provide real evidence other than blaming Mexicans.

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/06/12/us/12wildfire.html
12:38 AM on 06/27/2011
totally a chicken an egg argument.. is the grass dry? yes. did someone sneaking over the border start a fire? yes. my goodness.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Gottlieb
hated by left since 1973 and right since 1982
11:39 PM on 06/26/2011
Scapegoating is easier. McCain likes to demagogue since this is also easier. He had to shift to the far right to get re-elected this last time so he has to have simple solutions to complex problems,
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Counterintuitive
We'll steer by the beacon of our 100 year forecast
09:31 PM on 06/26/2011
The Blame for Climate Change needs to fall directly into the laps of Conservatives and the Oil Business. The moment they realize they will be held to account, they will stop sponsoring the disinformation campaign.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Gottlieb
hated by left since 1973 and right since 1982
11:48 PM on 06/26/2011
We are all to blame. Each air conditioner, low mileage car, garbage can full of recyclables and compost-ables, each thermostat set too high or low for conservation, each unnecessary car or plane trip or frivolous consumer purchase points the finger of blame at each of us. Carbon emission intensive industries are to blame for selling America what it demands. I blame politicians for lacking the political courage to pass legislation to limit greenhouse gases, promoting the transition to the next generation of relatively green power generation. I dislike scapegoating as a simplistic and divisive tool of the demagogue.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Counterintuitive
We'll steer by the beacon of our 100 year forecast
12:37 AM on 06/27/2011
To some extent everyone bears some responsibility. But lets not pretend the blame is shared equally. The politicians and businesses who promote/fund the Denier bandwagon have slowed down progress. They need to be held accountable. The easiest way is to force them to fund the clean up efforts for these disasters. Once they start paying bills, I suspect they'll stop funding Science Denial.
photo
bad spelling grammar
Help save Big Cats from extinction!
04:46 PM on 06/27/2011
AGREED!!!!!!!!!
FreeHat
Really?
06:39 PM on 06/26/2011
There is no evidence that 'climate change' caused the fires in Arizona.In what other arm of science are you allowed to make arbitrary statements because people feel good about it?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Gottlieb
hated by left since 1973 and right since 1982
11:54 PM on 06/26/2011
I would like you to state which scientists are making arbitrary statements. Climate Change did not cause the fires in Arizona. You have many ideologues making arbitrary statements to support their "truth." Scapegoating scientists is an old tradition of the ideologues who need to attack inconvenient truths.
FreeHat
Really?
11:21 AM on 06/27/2011
The people making these alarmist statements are not usually scientists, they are paid activists with a separate agenda. So counter to your insinuation, I am not attacking scientists.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
silverfoxylassy
06:02 PM on 06/26/2011
As I recall, didn't they find that people in the area did not put out the fire correctly, and that is how the fire actually started? Blaming the fires on climate change? Please.
And who can trust the media to be unbiased any more?
02:05 AM on 06/26/2011
Blaming climate change for wildfires puts effective and timely action out of reach. It is actually truer to say that our unprecedented megafires (with excess heat, particulate matter, and carbon emission consequences) are exacerbating global warming than the other way around. Unless we deal with it effectively, we will see wildfires escalate.

There is a way to lessen wildfires effectively through thinning our over-dense forests http://bit.ly/iZzy95. Most forest professional ascribe the blame of wildfires to poor forest health and decades of fire suppression policies which have left our forests dangerously overburdened with fuel wood to fuel fires. These same conditions contribute to the pine beetle outbreaks in BC, Colorado, and even New Jersey. wildfires. Thinning not only saves communities but also provides wood feedstock for biomass power, biofuels, and green chemical industries to take root - further industries to help mitigate greenhouse gas emissions. http://bit.ly/cRCe6t
01:59 PM on 06/27/2011
Although I agree with your general premise about thinning trees, I'd also want to see evidence that such thinning does not harm the biodiversity that has adapted to denser forests.

Also, I'm not sure that we should play down the fact that climate change has played a significant role in these and other natural disasters. Humans are typical more consequence-motivated than theory-motivated. Unfortunately, many people can have the world's top scientific organizations clearly telling them that climate change is real and human caused, and still not pay any attention if they feel the results do not directly affect them. Look at past oil price spikes. We come up with wonderful technologies during the price hikes, and then jump right back into SUVs when the prices drop again. It's just human nature. We need to make it very clearly that climate change and its disastrous effects are happening right now.
02:41 PM on 06/27/2011
I appreciate your concerns. I have attended UC/Berkeley USDA Forest Service workshops in the Sierras that show picture evidence of the consequences of wildfires as they pass from fire-suppressed dense forests to thinned ones. The fires snuff out within 30 yards when the forest has been treated to a healthy density. Wildfires do not discriminate - they destroy habitats and can forever shift the evolution of an ecosystem. It is folly to bolster a habitat and then not protect it with appropriate forest thinning.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
eaarth2
“An era ends when its illusions are exhausted
06:10 AM on 06/24/2011
The Senator has decided to ignore the growing climate related disasters by aligning himself to science denial head in the sand- that the GOP T Party represents- along with its anti immigrant raving.

What a way to go Senator!
photo
pmag88
water and carbon and a bunch of other stuff
12:55 AM on 06/24/2011
Sheriff Joe basically said these new laws don't mean jack because the existing laws were already in effect and being enforced.

In other words, 1070 is all about keeping the wages low and cowing people into keeping their mouths shut and staying out of the political arena. A shameful example of bad governance by weak people who have no scruples and will do anything to win elections.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rkmerriman
07:54 AM on 06/23/2011
I am not a fan of Senator McCain, however he does deserve accurate reporting on his actions instead of outright lies. Senator McCain is not anti-immigrant he is anti-illegal alien, as anyone with a double digit (or higher) IQ is. This writer of course uses the Liberal/Democrat politically correct word for people that are illegally invading the United States "undocumented immigrants" instead of the correct term "felons". After tiring of lying about what Senator McCain said (McCain later admitted he was likely wrong) he then goes into a global warming/climate change rant stating "facts" that have long been proven incorrect or outright lies.