More

Jane Smiley

Jane Smiley

Posted: September 4, 2008 11:06 AM

Nothing to Offer


Last night, Sarah Palin got her once in a lifetime moment, the moment where she introduced herself to the nation at large. She had a choice about how to reveal herself. We all know she could easily become president, so we were looking to see what kind of person she is, and we saw it. She's mean and shallow and aggressive. She thinks being a leader is about tearing down your rivals. She lies about her own actions and she demeans the more generous actions of others. She goes for the easy laugh, but doesn't even make up her own jokes. If there's a low road, she will take it. If she can pander, she will do it. Her performance recapitulated her actions as mayor and governor in Alaska -- holding office, for her, is about keeping as much power as possible and using it for her own selfish ends. This woman is small small small. She demonstrated that with every word she spoke.

But she inspired the base of the Republican party, all those white folks visible in the audience in St. Paul, so they must have seen themselves in her. I often wonder how, after the Bush years, anyone could be a Republican. It's an ongoing mystery, but Sarah Palin demonstrates who they are. They are small small small. They are obsessed with power. Whatever they have, they want to be sure that they keep it. They don't mind if the pie is shrinking through their own actions -- they will just employ the police state to keep their portion and get more. All other factions of the Republican party -- all the ones who once had and still have any vestiges of kindness and morality and (God forbid) altruism -- have drifted away and only the narrowest are left -- the out and out racists, the sexual opportunists, like McCain, the operatives who do it for the money, and the knee-jerk haters, the folks who leave destruction all around themselves and never even say they're sorry. It's not that they don't believe in, say, global warming. It's that they don't care about any larger issues at all as long as they get theirs.

It's obvious to everyone that Sarah Palin's life is chaos. Her record as mayor and governor is chaotic and her personal life is chaotic. Could she have orchestrated and survived two years of campaigning for the presidency with the panache, the energy, the organization, and the personal growth that the Obamas have shown? Of course not. How the campaign goes is how the administration goes. Palin is showing stress, desperation, and vindictiveness already. And speaking of that -- Obama extended respect to her and she returned contempt. Is she a mean girl? Not as harmless as that. She's more a Lady MacBeth. She IS the Republican party. She shows as clearly as anyone ever that if we as voters embrace something small, we get what we deserve.

 
 
  • Comments
  • 213
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (10 total)
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Einstein44
12:41 AM on 09/07/2008
Hooray for the messenger...Jane Smiley ,you are on target each time.Thank you!
08:34 AM on 09/05/2008
I am personally OUTRAGED that Senator John McCain is standing in the way of Governor Palin's Presidential ambitions.
01:57 AM on 09/05/2008
I love to read the panic stricken left. It's over! Once again you far left morons have put up someone who is unelectable in the eyes of the general population. Again if the ticket was Clinton/Obama it would have been a cakewalk. How pathetic that you are about to lose this campaign. How is that possible? You will never gain high office when you let the fringe element in your party select your candidate.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
proveit2me
Snarky Cold Medina
03:33 PM on 09/06/2008
For over a year the same right wing nut jobs who savaged hillary for a decade have been cheerleading for her to be on the ticket, preferably at the top, because you knew that would be one of the only things to galvanize your base. So what do you do? Put an extremist novice on your ticket that succeeds in further galvanizing the democratic base against her.

THAT, my friend, in strategery.
01:26 AM on 09/05/2008
Being "mean and shallow and aggressive" keeps folks from getting too close and finding out the truth behind the facade (chaos.) After a weekend of public exposure, the McCain campaign circled the wagons and informed the press that Palin's vetting was complete and there would be no more discussion of the matter. That was a major mistake on their part; the press is tearing through her records now wherever they can find them. 60 days to uncover all the dirt the vet missed. From her attitude during the speech, I bet there's a lot out there yet to see the light of day. Viva la Freedom of the Press!
11:23 PM on 09/04/2008
What a pathetic appeal by a woman who suffers from white guilt. Somebody should tell her the Confederacy didn't win. What's small, small, small, is the argument of Obama's experience versus Palin's. But what does that matter? Obama's black and that'll help with the indoctrinated "guilty." Vote away, liberal sheep!
libbygirl
I'm still thinking about it
09:19 PM on 09/04/2008
One of the reasons I was drawn to Obama was his decency and respect for everyone....even his opponents. It's a shame that McCain's campaign can't share these traits.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BurtR
08:15 PM on 09/04/2008
The Repugs disparaged community organizing. Their idea of community organizing is to put a fence round their community and have a thug with a shotgun at the gate
Let's start helicopter hunting on mooseback
08:08 PM on 09/04/2008
Bravo!
07:58 PM on 09/04/2008
"Small" is the mot juste, all right. I couldn't agree with you more.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jeanrenoir
07:53 PM on 09/04/2008
Of course this is all on target, but the American mob is itself "small, small, small," just like the mob in every society, because the mob is always so bitter, so filled with Nietzsche's resentment. Great mob leaders--like Huey Long, George Wallace, Reagan, Palin, and HItler--understand in their "small, small, small" resentment filled gut just how the mob feels, and they channel their rage and spit it out at those the mob wants crucifiied to give them a crazed moment of vindictive superiority. But we all should KNOW this by heart after forty years of this poisoning our politics. What we need is James Carville and Bill Clinton's determination to channel the resentment OURSELVES, if we Dems ever hope to win again. We've got to "feel" the mob's pain, but mainly we've got to become their fighter ourselves, the way Hillary did, completely reversing decades of mob hatred of her simply by getting angry and "fighting" for them on the economy. This is the ONLY way to beat McCain-Palin. Carville needs to give an instant seminar to Obama on how this is done. And stand at his ear, like Lieberman at McCain's. If Obama doesn't build on his convention speech's attack mode, he's going the way of Adlai and giving years more humor to Rush and O'Reilly.
07:53 PM on 09/04/2008
Excellent blog. I was thinking the same during her speech. Where does she stand on healthcare, the economy, civil rights, immigration? I found out none of those things.
07:49 PM on 09/04/2008
What about Hillary? Will she speak up?
07:48 PM on 09/04/2008
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

I haven't been able to articulate why ever since Palin was announced I have been sick with rage. It is the same feeling I've gotten with every Bush blunder - Iraq , Abu Graib, Katrina, Scotter Libby, Rove, Harriet Meir, on and on. That sinking sensation that the country is going down the tubes and we as a people are powerless to stop it. But Palin is beyond the Pale and the fact that people LIKE her and are BUYING this crap just means four more years I'm afraid. It is becoming increasing obvious , my friends to the left, that we might be the minority. It's not red state/blue state it's something much bigger. It's about soul, character, street savvy, education, life experience, work experience, who you love, how you love, your spiritual beliefs, and on and on. When one lives in the world as in some acceptance of what is or as the buddhists say "awake.," the things the Republicans stand for these days are repugnant. It's painfully clear that many, many in the country are not awake, and there may be more of them then there are of us....and for that I am deeply sad. The team with the slogan "COUNTRY FIRST" (does that say it all or what!) might just pull this out of their......
07:46 PM on 09/04/2008
You can't deny that Governor Palin has very strong presentation skills. I appreciate the imagery of her speech. But why would she think that her life as a pit bull would be a selling point? An urge to sniff out a threat in every passing butt, too much inbreeding, enjoying a kill just to show dominance: this is the experience she touts? Of course, those are Dick Cheney's selling points, so perhaps that's what the successful VP candidate needs to show.

We none of us want to admit - at least in public - that all too many in these here United States feel exactly that way. Or, at least, that is what we'll find out.
07:46 PM on 09/04/2008
Thanks for the article. My sentiments exactly - in fact I really couldn't watch it - though we've been bombarded by clips of it ever since. Never thought I'd see the day - but I actually think this might (?) be worse than Bush?? Could it be? All this hoopla over someone who obviously isn't "qualified" to step into the job. What kind of judgment do these people who are cheering see here? A presidential candidate who will pander to anyone as long as he gets the votes - and a vice-presidential candidate who says she puts "country first" - well, she certainly doesn't put her family first since she doesn't mind putting her daughter through this - though it seems the daughter must have been rebellious at one point!

Question is - what do we do now? I've sent money - as I see others have. But I really question this country to know what's in its own best interests. Do we need to become the laughing stock of the Western world again??