More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Janet Carlson

GET UPDATES FROM Janet Carlson
 

Buying Gifts For Your Ex: Is That The Spirit?

Posted: 12/21/11 03:55 AM ET

Last year during the holiday shopping madness I always fail to avoid, I found myself at Chef Central with my daughters, whipping out my charge card to pay for $150 worth of gifts they'd selected for their father, his longtime girlfriend, and her two children. A wine carafe, some stemware, cookie-cutters, a root-beer float maker, a few of those "reindeer poop" candy packages. It added up.

"Ouch," crossed my mind as I signed for the charge. How insane is this? I asked myself, thinking about the child-support my ex and I had negotiated a few years earlier (not without some argument) and about the extra expenses -- medical and educational -- that I keep close track of to make sure he pays his share. We get along fine now, but we do have residual issues surrounding finances, to put it politely. If he buys clothes for our girls on "his" weekend, I'd subtract my share from what he owed me for camp payments, etc. And now, what do I do with this expense? What category in my psyche do I file this under? Am I nuts? I even went on to finish that thought, I'm ashamed to admit: ...nuts to spend my hard-earned money on my ex and the woman he replaced me with? And her children? This at a time when I'm working hard as heck to try to keep a roof over the heads of my own children?

The thing is, I knew it wouldn't occur to my ex to plan ahead and take our daughters shopping for a gift for me; so even-steven was not going to be at play here. I felt myself sinking into a moment of awful pettiness. I imagined my girlfriends chastising me for spending on gifts for my ex and his new family while I'm a single working mother who'd suddenly found herself unemployed six months earlier.

Of course, I didn't express any of this or even allow any ungenerous feelings to show on my face at the register with our children. It's important to me that they learn that giving is -- maybe not better than receiving, come on -- but at least a rewarding experience they ought to have, especially this time of year, to balance all the "I want this; I want that" our society encourages. I found myself shrugging inwardly -- her kids are nice. I like them.

I enjoyed watching the girls wrap these gifts later at home and head out to their Hanukkah celebration with what I refer to as my new extended family. We are one big, happy, divided family after all. And we get along; she and I in particular. We sometimes sit and share a cup of tea or a glass of wine and catch up on new books or movies while kids are being dropped off or picked up. She's given me birthday gifts, and I her. If this were forced, or faux friendliness then I could maybe justify my petty feelings about springing for the holiday gifts. Maybe.

But this amicability is real to me -- to us -- and it benefits the children. So I corrected my course and didn't indulge further in that knee-jerk pettiness that tried to creep in last year and spoil my Christmas spirit. Last week, I took my younger daughter shopping and told her we're on a tighter budget, like everyone else in the country, but -- hey, look, would your dad like this sweater? I think it's his size.... No, Mom; that's dumb. Let's keep looking.

 
 
 

Follow Janet Carlson on Twitter: www.twitter.com/JanetRCarlson

Last year during the holiday shopping madness I always fail to avoid, I found myself at Chef Central with my daughters, whipping out my charge card to pay for $150 worth of gifts they'd selected for t...
Last year during the holiday shopping madness I always fail to avoid, I found myself at Chef Central with my daughters, whipping out my charge card to pay for $150 worth of gifts they'd selected for t...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 179
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (7 total)
12:31 AM on 12/23/2011
I think it sets a great example for the kids. I'm adopted, so I've never defined family by "blood" as many do. I'm also divorced with two kids from my first marriage, remarried with a child from my second marriage...my exhusband is remarried, no kids. I buy him, his wife, and occassionally his wife's parents gifts depending on the holiday. His new wife treats my kids as her own, and both her and my exhusband go above and beyond for not only *our* kids but also my youngest son. My ex and his wife are my second greatest allies (after my husband of course) when it comes to the kids, the four of us (myself, husband, exhusband, and his wife) make it work for the good of the kids.
You do what feels right as a parent, not as an ex. If you're thinking of the example you want to set for your kids, instead of thinking of your occassional dislike of your ex, then you're doing it right.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dws51564
History doesn't repeat itself ignorance does
08:12 PM on 12/22/2011
Every year I made sure my kids had nice gifts for their mother for Christmas and in return I got much of what I got during the marriage. Nothing. Moreover, the kids lived with me full time.
07:39 PM on 12/22/2011
Absolutely - My X-wife and I were married 25+ years and have 2 wonderful kids - Although I was 100% faithful - she had many affairs for most of our life together - she was even sleeping (?) with a local cop who was also married - this one lasted for over 2 years - I had no idea !! I drive a grey dodge - if you are ever in my area and see a guy trying to out run a local cop - pay it no mind - It's just me, afraid it's him wanting to bring her back !!!!!! Due to her life style she is a person who has "Everything" and was so hard to pick a gift for - but because she is the mother of my kids - I always give her a gift for every occasion - and have come up with the "Perfect" gift for a woman who has "Everything" A gift certificate for a "Mega-Dose" of "Penicillin"
05:11 PM on 12/22/2011
If it vibrates is that inappropriate?
04:30 PM on 12/22/2011
If you have children with your ex, then yes I believe it is acceptable for you to carry your children to buy him / her something for Christmas.
However, I do feel that carrying your children to buy your ex's new lover something [and his / her kids might I add] is a bit much.

And it would be especially overboard if you had not had children together, because that's borderline awkward / desperate.
12:36 AM on 12/23/2011
I take my children to buy gifts for their stepmother. She is a part of their family, even if she's not a part of mine (although I personally count her as a part of my family). Ex's can break up and realize that while it wasn't meant to be any more, there was a time when they were an important part of your life, you can appreciate and respect them even if you are no longer together (not you personally, i mean 'you' in general). My ex and his wife have bought me a gift just because I was having a bad day, and as the mother of their children (our children) my wellbeing matters. I've done the same for them.
Each situation is different, people do what works for them, and when the lifestyle becomes what is best for the kids, it's much easier to view the ex as still part of the family even if not legally...because the ex, and all their relations, are part of the kids' family, and thus my family.
03:46 PM on 12/22/2011
In my opinion you are making many mistakes: if you truly are on a budget, stop giving gifts to everyone! Live BELOW your means! Have your children make greeting cards for everyone; from my experience raising four children on a budget, they don't learn how to manage money with anyone's money BUT THEIR OWN EARNED FUNDS! Giving children an allowance to manage doesn't do it! Your kids are learning bad habits from your mismanagement and poor decisions. Living beyond your means doesn't make you a better person, just a foolish one! When your kids are old enough to work, let them buy gifts for whomever with their wages. Then watch the decisions on the "sweater for Dad".....
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
angry mom
02:48 PM on 12/22/2011
This isn't buying gifts for your ex. This helping your children buy gifts for a parent and this is what I did when my children were young. I wouldn't have spent that much if you can't afford it. If you are out of work, it is a good time to teach them to budget their money or make some presents. Some craft stores offer classes on how to make gifts.
02:09 PM on 12/22/2011
When my son was little, I let him pick out something for his dad, and he did the same for me. However, we both drew the line at buying for our new 'significant others,' I paid for a gift for my new boyfriend (and kids) from my son, and my ex did the same for the new GF and kids.
12:21 PM on 12/22/2011
No...But I need to buy the guy she cheated on me with a ton of gifts! I was looking for a way out for a long time, but stayed for the kids' sake.
12:50 PM on 12/22/2011
I am sorry for your pain. I am 56 and been going through a divorce now over 2 years. I have seen you on this site much as I. My husband cheated on me (apparently for many years) he traveled
M-F. I didn't want out of my marriage, thought it was the bes!! I would get her a gift though if it could blow her up. I hope some day down the road, I can just put her out of my thoughts. I work very hard on this with God. It is a constant battle for me. She is a flight Attendent with Mas_ba. That is where she caught my husband. Anyway, He can have her. She just divorced her husband of 33 years because mine makes more money! Now theres a winner for you ! The really sad part, My husband wanted to still be a father to our grown sons(now with first grand child) They have not spoken to him for the 2 years. Dad under pressure said he was picking the Adultress over them.......He has not seen his grandchild either.

North Carolina correct? We lived in Greenville SC for 10 years. Hope you have a wonderful Holiday.
01:52 PM on 12/22/2011
Oh trust me, there was no pain. I had been out of love with her for a long time. Glad to see her go. And yes, NC is correct.
02:22 PM on 12/22/2011
Small world becrafty01, same story for me and I also live in SC and I'm also 56, lol. Time does help but the sting never goes away does it? Makes me very leary of new relationships.
11:56 AM on 12/22/2011
Yea if you don't want to buy presents for your ex it's understandable, I know I wouldn't, But if you did want to get him presents in the interest of a congenial relationship, they don't have to be $150 just have the kids make him something, it's the thought that counts right? or if the girls really wanted to buy him something let them earn the money with some chores. I would just bake them a loaf of banana nut bread; it's present for the whole family for under $5. Also I you shouldn't feel obligated to get he and his family presents if they don't feel the need to do the same for you; that's one-sided and unfair.
ae12wrangell
Everybody is entitled to my opinion
11:51 AM on 12/22/2011
I have 2 aunt's that are divorced, and kept in touch with the exes until both men died. That included Christmas Card's and gift's to each, and birthday card's to both ex-husband's. Neither aunt got a damn thing. But, they did respect the other, despite that.
psandysdad
The older you get, the more excuses you have.
11:48 AM on 12/22/2011
The former spouse doesn't need anything from me. She abandoned the family, leaving me to finish raising three kids. They are all adults now and don't want anything to do with her. She removed herself from our lives and thereby gets silence every Xmas from her own children.
10:13 PM on 12/22/2011
Similar to my story. He abandoned the kids and me 2 years ago to be with the other woman. Hasn't looked back.
11:47 AM on 12/22/2011
YES YES YES! I buy her nice gifts... and I Thank GOD and GreyHound she's gone.. that load on my mine got lighter when she got on! Thant shiney ole bus was a beautiful sight....with the black smoke a pouring from out the tailpipe..It may sound kinda cruel but I've been silent to long.....THANK GOD AND GREYHOUND SHE'S GONE.
05:14 PM on 12/22/2011
That sounds like the title of a country music song.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:43 AM on 12/22/2011
First of all, I wouldn't be charging 150.00 for my ex or his GF. I am married and if we split, perhaps I would let them pick out a little something for HIM, but my ex would not be on a big ticket gift list for sure and the GF doesn't rate anything, that would be the ex's responsibility if he wanted the kids to get her something. Personally, unless the GF or BF is going to be a fiance really soon, I don't think they should be brought into the relationship with the children. Leave that part separate.
11:30 AM on 12/22/2011
ABSOULTLY .... with her running off i've saved hundreds mabey thousands of bucks in the last three years alone! I'm not only sending her a present, but her new man I will send TWO presents.