More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Janet Murguía

Janet Murguía

Posted: April 7, 2010 10:16 AM

Higher Expectations: If We Believe Our Students Can Succeed, They Will

What's Your Reaction:

We know the statistics. We've read the headlines. The narrative of Black and Latino students faring worse than their White peers in school has become all too familiar. The achievement gap has become a self-fulfilling prophecy in our classrooms; educators have come to accept the disparity as a given, handing down their bleak outlook to their students. From this pessimistic view, two educational systems have emerged in America: one for White students, and another for students of color. But what would happen if we expected more from our youth?

The late Jaime Escalante demonstrated that when students are expected to reach higher standards, they will work to achieve them. Escalante, the renowned math teacher who inspired the 1988 film Stand and Deliver, urged his James A. Garfield High School students in East Los Angeles to defy the statistics and pass a national calculus exam. No one expected the students to pass--except Escalante. When they passed, officials accused the students of cheating and forced them to retake the test because "those kids" were not supposed to make "those scores." They were later exonerated by passing the test a second time.

Escalante and his students proved that dedicated teachers who invest time in developing the potential of motivated students--with the support of a highly involved community--can achieve remarkable results. Underestimating our students leads to underachievement. If we challenge our students, they will rise to the occasion and succeed.

There may never be another Jaime Escalante, but we all have the responsibility to make sure that our children are not short-changed. Policymakers, teachers, students, and parents all play a role in the success of our schools. Congress and the administration must work together to enforce the high standards put in place by the recent reauthorization of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act (ESEA), formerly known as No Child Left Behind (NCLB). All students should be taught to the highest standards by effective teachers. This legislation is an important first step toward closing the achievement gap by taking targeted approaches to educating students based on their school, rather than through a blanket strategy that attempts to encompass all students.

While continuing to strengthen education legislation is a critical element in improving our schools, parents must also be actively involved in the process. With so many outside factors telling minority students that they are unable to reach their goals, a strong and informed parental unit motivating them to ignore the naysayers is vital.

The strength of our nation's future depends on our students. Let's make sure we give them the tools they need to succeed and the preparation they need to confront the unique challenges they face.

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 9
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
04:26 AM on 04/09/2010
While continuing to strengthen education legislation is a critical element in improving our schools, parents must also be actively involved in the process. [HS: As I said above, parents who care make sure their kids don’t go to ghetto schools in the first place] With so many outside factors telling minority students that they are unable to reach their goals, [HS: Yes, every day I read in the NY Times that minority students aren’t capable of learning anything. Sarcasm.] a strong and informed parental unit [HS: Notice the use of the singular; apparently she accepts that it’s impossible to get poor women to stop having children out of wedlock.] motivating them to ignore the naysayers is vital.

The strength of our nation's future depends on our students. [HS: Unfortunately true. Which is why we are doomed.] Let's make sure we give them the tools they need to succeed and the preparation they need to confront the unique challenges they face.
04:26 AM on 04/09/2010
There may never be another Jaime Escalante, but we all have the responsibility to make sure that our children are not short-changed. [HS: That’s why liberal white parents make sure they’re kids go to white schools.] Policymakers, teachers, students, and parents all play a role in the success of our schools. Congress and the administration must work together to enforce the high standards put in place by the recent reauthorization of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act (ESEA), formerly known as No Child Left Behind (NCLB). All students should be taught to the highest standards by effective teachers. [HS: As I wrote before, no one cares about higher standards and effective teachers for gifted white students.] This legislation is an important first step toward closing the achievement gap by taking targeted approaches to educating students based on their school, rather than through a blanket strategy that attempts to encompass all students. [HS: Better teaching will make the gap worse by helping those with higher IQs pull even more ahead of those with lower IQs]
04:25 AM on 04/09/2010
Escalante and his students proved that dedicated teachers who invest time in developing the potential of motivated students--with the support of a highly involved community--can achieve remarkable results. [HS: In the ghetto, few students are motivated, and their parents aren’t involved.] Underestimating our students leads to underachievement. If we challenge our students, they will rise to the occasion and succeed. [HS: Too bad no one cares about challenging smart white students, are who allowed to languish because people only care about closing the “achievement gap.”]
04:25 AM on 04/09/2010
The late Jaime Escalante demonstrated that when students are expected to reach higher standards, they will work to achieve them. [HS: Not true, he only taught the top students at the school. At most, less than 5% of seniors took his AP calculus class.] Escalante, the renowned math teacher who inspired the 1988 film Stand and Deliver, urged his James A. Garfield High School students in East Los Angeles to defy the statistics and pass a national calculus exam. No one expected the students to pass--except Escalante. When they passed, officials accused the students of cheating and forced them to retake the test because "those kids" were not supposed to make "those scores." [HS: They may have actually cheated, even though they could have passed without cheating.] They were later exonerated by passing the test a second time.
04:25 AM on 04/09/2010
We know the statistics. We've read the headlines. The narrative of Black and Latino students faring worse than their White peers in school has become all too familiar. The achievement gap has become a self-fulfilling prophecy in our classrooms; educators have come to accept the disparity as a given, handing down their bleak outlook to their students. [HS: Just the opposite, the establishment refuses to accept HBD, as evidenced by this very editorial. How many editorials say that we should just accept the disparity?] From this pessimistic view, two educational systems have emerged in America: one for White students, and another for students of color. [HS: There are no racially segregated educational systems in the United States. Liberals are constantly on the alert to stomp out any “disparate impact” they see.] But what would happen if we expected more from our youth? [HS: What would happen is that we would get No Child Left Behind which expected that every child would be competent by 2014.]
05:15 PM on 04/07/2010
Jaime Escalante only taught the top students at his school. Fewer than 10% of the students at his school actually took the calculus test. Of course, mentioning that would disrupt the feel-good narrative that all underperforming minority students are latent geniuses just waiting for some enlightened teacher to bring out their potential.

Interestingly, inter-racially adopted students raised by middle class white parents tend to do as well scholastically as other members of their race/ethnic group: Asian adoptees tend to outperform their white siblings, and black adoptees tend to underperform relative to their white siblings. See http://www.gnxp.com/MT2/archives/004064.html

There really is no scientific reason to think that tens of thousands of years of divergent evolution left different population groups with the exact same mean cognitive abilities. Yes, saying group A might, on average, be more intelligent than group B because of genetic differences is taboo, and quite possibly racist, but the fact that something is taboo and/or racist does not make it false.
04:37 PM on 04/07/2010
***The late Jaime Escalante demonstrated that when students are expected to reach higher standards, they will work to achieve them.***

Not true, he only taught the top students at the school. At most, less than 5% of seniors took his AP calculus class.
04:32 PM on 04/07/2010
***The narrative of Black and Latino students faring worse than their White peers in school has become all too familiar.***

What about white students faring worse than their Asian peers?
04:31 PM on 04/07/2010
***The achievement gap has become a self-fulfilling prophecy in our classrooms; educators have come to accept the disparity as a given, handing down their bleak outlook to their students.***

Just the opposite, the establishment refuses to accept HBD (human biodiversity), as evidenced by this very editorial.