iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Janine Boldrin

GET UPDATES FROM Janine Boldrin
 

The Reality Military Shows Will Never Air

Posted: 08/17/2012 8:30 am

Army Wives: Alaska. Coming Home. Stars Earn Stripes. There's a lot of interest in the reality of military life. But even with all of these shows, I'm left wondering about what story they are telling because, for the past decade, most of the military families I know have been living a reality that I don't see on primetime.

Episode one of any show I've watched doesn't feature deployment number five which is a coming attraction over in my friends' living room next month. Where's the show called "Leaving Home," documenting the crying on the front end of a year apart? Note the crying kids in unmatched shirts in the background. Oh, and those beautiful homecomings. Those big, flag draped hangars filled with soldiers. I wish every real life reunion installment ended that way.
Maybe I could write an episode for a new series. I'll pull from one day last week:

Military spouse friends gather with their kids to play on a day off from school. That morning, news flickered across their Facebook newsfeeds that a friend had been killed in Afghanistan leaving behind a wife and young children. Camera pans to their tight circle of chairs, hushed voices, and finally to the women whose talk is interrupted by a text message. It's from another military spouse. She has received news that her husband who is deployed survived an attack. She was in the middle of Kindergarten orientation when the call came. The guy next to her husband was blown up. His legs may be gone. One mom pulls a granola bar out of her purse. Their discussion turns to the upcoming nine month deployment their husbands leave for on Monday. Most sit up straighter and say everything will be fine. Camera pans away. They leave the falling apart for the middle of the night when they find themselves alone in bed with their own thoughts hoping the kids don't wake up with fevers.

Beloved. Supported. Championed. The military family has become the darling of reality television along with a sanitized version of our service members' lives. The love we're supposed to feel from the networks quantified by the interest in showing our existence. But not by showing our reality.

Because if the entire truth was shown, instead of just pictures of daddy kissing baby for the first time, you'd get to see the young man who is failing in school because he couldn't come to grips with a father who is struggling with PTSD. Or the wife who is struggling with depression and is considering suicide. Veterans without homes. Soldiers who return to broken families. And the spouses, girlfriends, and parents who work to keep a semi-normal life in a very unpredictable existence.

Military families are resilient. We are proud and strong. We don't like to let the cracks show. Maybe that's why many military families appreciate being remembered with the shows that make the eight o'clock slot instead of showcasing the drama we have become so used to in our own world; shouldering the burden is kind of our thing.

So I'll speak for myself when I say that, while the networks sell our daily lives, I hope the public will not be duped by celebrities jumping out of a helicopter with no real bullets coming or wives in high heels cheering on their husbands' training. We don't air our struggles and ask for pity regarding our troubles but the public should be exposed to the true, unglamorous sacrifices our service members and their families' make. Not the staged glory.

Viewers may be drawn to visions of grand homecomings, breathtaking training, or wives in cute dresses and big smiles, but Americans also need to know the gritty reality our military service members and families face. And start tuning into a forgotten program:
The war in Afghanistan.

Even if you hear it may be cancelled, I understand there are a few spin-offs being planned starring our service members and their families for many years to come. I hope you'll check this old favorite out because, unlike the reality shows that are on now, as fewer viewers click into the show, the longer the program will be on the air.

This is our reality:

 
 
 

Follow Janine Boldrin on Twitter: www.twitter.com/janineboldrin

FOLLOW IMPACT
Army Wives: Alaska. Coming Home. Stars Earn Stripes. There's a lot of interest in the reality of military life. But even with all of these shows, I'm left wondering about what story they are telling b...
Army Wives: Alaska. Coming Home. Stars Earn Stripes. There's a lot of interest in the reality of military life. But even with all of these shows, I'm left wondering about what story they are telling b...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 57
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
05:00 PM on 08/22/2012
The troops, and their families, need more than just your tax dollars for support. We realize many don't agree with the mission. Don't be persuaded into believing that the military does either. Our warriors need to know that, even while you question the leadership of this nation, you appreciate the fact that they're still making the sacrifice. It takes a special person to sign up knowing the ultimate sacrifice may be asked. It takes doubly special people to love them. Because while we get perks like medical care, a DODEA education for our kids and travel to sometimes exotic locals, our lives are tumultuous, gritty, terrifying, stressful and sometimes incredibly ugly. Intermittently interrupted by joyous reunions, first time meeting of new babies and quick surprise phone calls. There is very often more sadness than joy and more time apart than together. We're not all here because finances demanded it. Some of us are here because we come from a family that serves. Some are here because their wife convinced them that they are, in fact, smart enough to do it (guilty). Some are here because they love this country and choose to defend it and her citizens. Whatever our reasons, we all sacrifice, we all hurt and are saddened and it is, at some point, tough as hell. But we pull ourselves up, dust ourselves off and do it again today. Because that's who were are.
08:38 AM on 08/19/2012
Thank you. Thank you for saying it all! That's exactly what we've been talking about over this way.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
SvrWx
Eileen, toora tooluri Eh..
06:58 AM on 08/19/2012
Janine,
I am coming to the end of a year long deployment and truly believe that the wife is the warrior of the family. My wife works 8-10 hours a day, drives our 2 year old daughter 25 miles to her mothers so she can watch her during the day and then drives back out at night. She doesn't have much time to herself and is stressed out all the time. She has even told me that she fears that she is going to feel resentment toward me when I get home because she doesn't feel that I have earned the right to spend time with our daughter...that she is the one that has done all the work. And she has. My job has been a non-combat job but I still spend that time without her or my daughter.

And as much as I can't wait to get home, I am also scared...I don't know what to expect...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
eljefefx
12:34 PM on 08/19/2012
I faced this when I came home from there as well. What I learned to do after the second one was to just find ways to spend time with the family and help out. You already have an idea as to what your wife has done while you were away so don't ask her what you need to do. Little things like getting up and making breakfast for the family is a good way to start (not to mention it made me feel somewhat human again). Walk around the house and do laundry, clean up - little things. Over time your wife will realize that you're home, you're back in the family and can help.
06:57 PM on 08/18/2012
It's the mission of our soldiers that many of us question. Also there is the fact that many returning soldiers do not get the necessary medical/mental care that is warranted upon their arrival home. We all support the troops, with our Federal Tax dollars, however, we are often left questioning the leadership that requires our military to be engaged in these conflicts.
photo
Unca Wiggilie
I am but a meager bookworm...
04:03 PM on 08/18/2012
The de facto draft...
With No JOBS and No MONEY, more and more young Americans are being forced into the military.
Yet there is a huge gap between our American service personnel and the middle and wealthy upper classes of our civilians... A gap that a silly, piffling so-called "reality show" cannot begin to fill!
The least privileged and most disenfranchised of our young people are being forced to fight
and possibly die in senseless, incessant and illegal 'wars of aggression'.
Bring ALL of Our Valiant Young Boys and Girls Home NOW! - SAFE and SOUND!
THEN we can make many 'really' fine, happy HOME movies! __ "Smash Yankee Imperialism!"
12:50 PM on 08/18/2012
The fact is, more people are getting louder about PTSD and other issues that are going on with or active military and veteran's. Which is great! These issues need to be resolved... But I find it quite interesting that all these shows pop up... Showing only the good or glamorous side of it... Oooohhh look at the sexy celebrity doing some push ups in camo
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
see-ellen2001
12:28 PM on 08/18/2012
I don't want to see these these people and their families used as props in some sappy show that gives what people can see in some schlock movie of the week: tearful goodbyes, crying kids, sorrowful dogs, then happy reunions and bucking up and getting on with it! What about the dads so scarred they smack their wives in PTSD rage, the vet living on the streets, the kid's growing up without their parent. Makes me sick.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
fineartgalaxy
Speaking from the heart, always.
08:15 AM on 08/18/2012
War propaganda. Another cheap parody of human tragedy.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
eljefefx
09:22 AM on 08/18/2012
War propaganda? Hardly. It's a horrible reality show, nothing more.
06:29 AM on 08/18/2012
Currently in the army do not care one bit about these shows, neither should anyone else do not watch them if you have a problem
pillgirl
Obama/Biden 2012
03:31 AM on 08/18/2012
well written. points taken.

thanks for your family's sacrifice. thanks certainly doesn't seem like enough, though...
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
realitytrumpsbull
Two 'alves of coconut!
03:21 AM on 08/18/2012
Why do the people in the picture look like they're attacking the camera? How about just getting the uniforms OFF the TV screen, for good? Being in the military is serious business, it's not a game show. Maybe it's part of the New Army's recruiting campaign, but I think they should have a 'reality show' featuring people at the rehab centers, like that one segment in Starship Troopers: Mobile infantry made me the man I am today.(guy with no legs) War sucks, don't glorify it, and never send a man where you can send a bullet/artillery shell/1,000lb. bomb. Bigger IS better when it comes to winning wars, and even large, well-toned, muscular, highly trained alpha-fighties need food, medicine, transportation. All that aerial bomb needs, is a set of grid coordinates, and a release order. Maybe not as glamorous, but, deciderdly more effective.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
tiredofpc
retired: RN,Adult NP,USAR
02:49 AM on 08/18/2012
Ms. Boldrin, thank you for an enormously moving and informative article. Most of the HP readers, in fact, any US Media readers won't understand what that picture means. They won't know that the picture represents 4 soldiers who've been killed or died. They won't understand the meaning of the upside down weapon with Kevlar on top, the boots, the dog tags, the unit patches, the coins. They won't have a clue that as anyone who has ever attended a funeral or memorial service while in uniform must remain standing at attention while the roll call is called, calling each of the dead soldier's names 3 times, always without answer and all of us, many with tears running down our faces, chin/lips quivering and hands clenched so hard that we can hardly feel our fingers.....they won't get it, and they never will unless they serve.
I wish you and your family a safe return of your loved one; may you and your fellow spouses stay strong and support one another. God Bless.
02:46 AM on 08/18/2012
Janine - well said - the military is not a "reality show" - it is real and most of it is incredibly difficult with sad thrown in. Would really like to hear your feedback on the work done by FLOTUS and the V FLOTUS to help military families. It seems to me to be much more the real thing than any reality show - but I'm not close enough to know what the benefits to military families may be/are.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
clearthinker16
reads, investigates and thinks before making stupi
09:58 PM on 08/17/2012
As a combat veteran, this show makes me ill. They are never in danger, the go through training, BFD. Training is one thing, but getting into the real thing where people are shooting at you because of your uniform is entirely different. You cannot yell cut, or I quit. I also got upset when recently in that tragedy in Colorado, some morons said if everyone was armed, it would not have been as bad. None of the people who said that were ever in a firefight, in the dark. If everyone was armed, and they all started shooting the death toll would have been much higher, friendly fire casualties by people firing at anything that moved
06:27 PM on 08/17/2012
My reply to 'glowtodor' and his irresponsible comment below about the Commander in Chief 'not feeding the troops' was moderated.
If a veteran can't even post a comment against less truthful accusations, then heaven help us all!