iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Jay Tavare

GET UPDATES FROM Jay Tavare

Life or Death: Teen Suicide on American Indian Reservations

Posted: 02/12/11 01:41 PM ET

Teen suicide is beyond what most of us can fathom. No parent should have to bury their children. I have done it in my films and even that much was emotionally uncomfortable and draining.

2011-02-11-MountainGodsMescaleroApachereservationsmall.jpg

American Indian teens take their own lives at more than two times the rate of any other teen demographic in the USA, according to statistics from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Of course, these numbers are just averages, so on certain reservations the suicide rate is exponentially higher. But calculating the numbers is easy. It's the reasons that are harder to fathom.

Most are kids who do not have drugs or alcohol problems. Many come from financially comfortable families, by Native American standards. And most don't leave a suicide note, so their loved ones suffer the pain of regrets and self blame without the relief of being able to know the true reasons. 

Imagine a 14-year-old girl coming home from school and after putting her books away, hanging herself. Shocking, I know, but this is what had become commonplace on the Mescalero Apache reservation in New Mexico (map). In 2009, they faced a true state of emergency when four teens committed suicide and one attempted suicide in the space of just two months.

  • Fifteen-year-old Coloradas Mangas shares his stunning firsthand experience in this AP story.
  • Also read Coloradas' moving testimony before the Senate Hearing for the Committee on Indian Affairs.
  • For some reason the truth about this crisis is seldom publicized by the mainstream media. Maybe we find it comfortable to believe that problems on the reservation are the same as ours in the mainstream. But the situation is more complicated than that.

    The American Indian nations are proud and independent people. They're not helpless and they're not seeking outside assistance. In fact -- and this is something we must take to heart in order to truly understand -- historical evidence strongly suggests that it's outside "help," in the form of European colonialism and religious missionary movements, that created this problem in the first place.

    For centuries, American Indian culture has been attacked and exploited by our new dominant culture. Traditions, language and spiritual beliefs of so many of the American Indian nations are almost completely extinguished. Is it any wonder that the youth find themselves in an identity crisis?

    Hearing all this, it's natural we want to help. But real healing has to come from within the Indian community. What we can do is become educated and empathetic. We can help by learning about and respectfully supporting programs founded by and for Indians on the reservations.

    The Mescalero Apache reservation has created their own suicide prevention youth program, Honor Your Life, headed by coordinator Jeremiah Simmons. And the recent news are encouraging: In 2010 there were no teen suicides on the Mescalero Apache reservation. Although kids still talked about taking their own lives, they didn't go through with it.

    Janice Merino -- who happens to be a direct descendant of Cochise and a beautiful generous soul whom I cherish dearly -- is a suicide prevention specialist for the Honor Your Life program. Janice says:

    "Its interesting because now we are mainly seeing suicide ideation, thoughts but no plans."

    This is a huge step in the right direction. I'm incredibly proud of Janice and everyone she works with. The things they accomplished in defiance of all odds and adversity are miraculous. Kudos to Janice, Jeremiah and all the precious people at Honor Your Life!

    Janice goes on to say:

    "Also the teen pregnancy rate has risen very high and parents are not talking to kids about sex. There have been more bullying issues in middle school. And of course drugs and alcohol issues seem to remain the same."

    These are things I'll talk about more in upcoming posts.

    Obviously, the greater crisis still looms, not just on the Mescalero Apache reservation, but over all of Indian country. Pine Ridge Oglala Lakota Sioux reservation of South Dakota is another tragic example, with a suicide rate more than three times the average for the rest of the nation.

    There are too many stories like these. But by learning the facts, remembering them and sharing them with others, you're a vital part of what happens next. The shift is coming!

    As the Apache say: G'u Z'u D'alsh ("Let all good things happen!")

    (Photo by Jay Tavare. "The Apache reservation is surrounded by four mountains that are sacred to them. White Mountain is the one seen here.")

     

    Follow Jay Tavare on Twitter: www.twitter.com/JayTavare

Teen suicide is beyond what most of us can fathom. No parent should have to bury their children. I have done it in my films and even that much was emotionally uncomfortable and draining. American I...
Teen suicide is beyond what most of us can fathom. No parent should have to bury their children. I have done it in my films and even that much was emotionally uncomfortable and draining. American I...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 0
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
05:58 PM on 04/22/2011
I couldn't agree with you more when you wrote "real healing has to come from within the American Indian community". Any influence from the outside could irritate the strong structure of traditions and cultures of the American Indian Nations, which could lead to more of an identity crisis amongst the teens. And wow... Coloradas Mangas is such a survivor and is so wise beyond his years. When he wrote "I come from people whose pride runs deep, but I also understand that sometimes, pride can keep us from asking for help"... it brought tears to my eyes knowing that these teens didn't want to "lose face" or bring shame to themselves and family... and so have decided to take their own lives instead. Great blog Jay, very graciously written.
05:49 PM on 04/22/2011
I feel very sad when I read this, the stress on the familys is to hard to handle for many, I understand the problems that was created by the religious colonalists. It's still going on.

I do how ever not understand why parent's stopped talking to there kids about sex, that's also a way of talking about life, with responsobility.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:23 PM on 04/22/2011
So true, Marsgoi. Kudos. Additionally, I think it is important to acknowledge that as we go forward, the term "white" will not necessarily accurately describe the dominant culture that is responsible for seeing that we correct past wrongs as much as we can. And it is imperative we understand that as the dominant culture changes hue, this change does not necessarily guarantee humanitarian progress.

If we mentally assign the past bad behavior to a race, instead of realizing it belonged to a culture that arbitrarily happened to be white, then we miss the vital lesson that every human being is potentially vulnerable to the same insidiously destructive ideas. In other words, we should be careful not to promote the idea that people of any one particular color are innately more inclined than other colors to unfair thinking on the subject of indigenous populations and their rights.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
06:48 PM on 04/11/2011
Consider the reports which recount the crime of whites giving Smallpox infected blankets to American Indians in the 1760's. Consider also the 1932-1972 Tuskegee experiments conducted on 399 syphilis infected black men. In these two cases the two non-white groups were supposedly being helped by whites. The fact that they were actually being lied to and harmed makes it highly understandable to encourage caution when it comes to accepting outside "help." In regards to the teenage Indian suicides, who is conducting the autopsies on the victims and who do they answer to? What of damage to American Indian’s physical and mental health caused by toxic dumping? How have these toxins affected their air, water and crops? Are Indians being regularly tested to track the possible side effects resulting from toxic and other contaminates? How many non-Indians reside on the reservations and who do they work for...? Unfortunately, racism (along with greed and political corruption) continues to weigh in prevalently on legal and quality-of-life disparities between whites and non-whites. It cannot be ignored. Especially so, when one considers that American Indians remain as a constant reminder that whites did not acquire this country honestly but, as history shows more and more truthfully, through acts of trickery, death by disease, and arrogant "manifest destiny" supported murder. Of course, many whites today would never engage in such evil behavior, but there are still too many misguided whites who would – and misguided non-whites as well.
09:37 PM on 04/01/2011
Awareness and Action...We all know someone in our lifetime who has taken their life...and for many times we have no idea why. I remember as a teenager this same thing among my friends was happening....and always left wondering...If we bring awareness, many more kids will be willing to talk to someone about whats going on in their head....take a teenager under your wing and guide them....thats all they want is for someone to know that they care...I guess....Great post Jay...always a pleasure to read what you have to say because it inspires us to be a more conscious soul...
09:16 PM on 03/31/2011
jay thanks for being the voice of all that young boys and girls suffering that much!!!!!go ahead,you will have all of our support and help.The world must know what those children are suffering.Stay strong!!!!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:45 AM on 03/31/2011
Glad to read in Jay's article that different measures are tried to end suicide amongst Native
Youths.
02:21 PM on 02/26/2011
Kudos to the author, Jay Tavare for a very insightful article on the problem of teen suicide within the Native American community. America has chosen to forget its own history of genocide and violence against the Indigenous peoples of this continent. These actions are not merely "in the past." These actions ripple into the present time, and are just as real today as they were in the chronological "past." "Then" is still "now." There can be no healing until there is justice. Justice begins by admitting the truth and establishing restitution. "From the 1490s when Christopher Columbus set foot on the Americas to the 1890 massacre of Sioux at Wounded Knee by the United States militia, the Indigenous population of the Western Hemisphere may have declined, the direct cause mostly from disease, to 1.8 from as many as 100 million (Stannard)." David Cesarani has argued that the government and policies of the United States of America against the Indigenous peoples of America in the name of 'Manifest Destiny' constituted a genuine genocide. In terms of the sheer numbers killed, the Native American genocide exceeds that of the Holocaust (Cesarini)." Sources: American Holocaust: The Conquest of the New World (by David Stannard), on the website of Oxford University Press. David Cesarani, Holocaust: Critical Concepts in Historical Studies, Routledge, 2004. Perhaps we can begin by changing the way we teach history in our schools. Dean Leh, M.A., M.S.Ed.
09:48 PM on 03/02/2011
Dean, I agree with you. I am seeing more recognition, more communication, more people writing about these truths than I ever have before, which is very encouraging. I grew up in Minnesota, right in the heart of where the US-Dakota war broke out in 1862. The end result was the genocide of the Mdewakanton Dakota and oppression that continues to this day. I have walked the same land, fished the same rivers and lakes, been to all the historic sites many times. The land still cries out for healing for the Dakota, and it is palpable. You are right - "then" is still "now". The causes of the war were never resolved. I pray for healing and restoration to come.
11:44 AM on 02/21/2011
Please keep writing articles like this! I am listening
photo
Indigo1941
Time traveler.
05:00 PM on 02/13/2011
Chief Tecumseh understood how tribal identity was dwindling away at the beginning of the 1800s and attempted to establish a united Amerindian nation where Ohio and Indiana are now situated. It didn't work out and many of the People died or were finally displaced to the west. Others remained behind, some of my ancestors among them, assimilated and finally intermarried to the point that no one national identity or ethnic claim really applies. They're North Americans and that's where it stands now. I'm not arguing that assimilation is the answer but I am saying that Tecumseh showed an resolve and understanding that are empowering, even today. "This is where the Maker put us, this is where we stay!" Honor your life, indeed, and never give up!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:23 PM on 02/13/2011
After nearly 200 years of segregating Native Americans in rural ghettos notorious for poverty, poor education and cultural isolation, isn't it getting to be a good time to start treating them decently?
Not to be fussy, but pretty much every iota of research says we tried to exterminate them, then tried to exile them internally and have for at least a century kept these folks in dire poverty with very little hope of finding good jobs.
I figure five hundred years of unmitigated savagery inflicted on North and South American native peoples is probably enough. Maybe we could divert the trillions we spend on foreign wars and spend maybe .05% of that incomprehensible public treasure on improving the lives of our neighbors.
Just a thought.
01:58 PM on 02/13/2011
I hear you loud and clear Jay. Thanks for shedding light on this issue.
01:56 PM on 02/13/2011
Hi Jay,congrats again......you really have an incredible gift..to express yourself in a way that reaches straight to others heart,eventhouhg,at least in my case,we are totally outside of reservations way of life....happy to know that there are people taking care of this terrible problem....kisses from Ururguay.
01:25 PM on 02/13/2011
End of my previous comment:

We need a peaceful revolution of government and laws which favor the greedy in this country, and for this Apacheland.
01:22 PM on 02/13/2011
Teen years are a threat for suicides, even among whites in America. Parents too dispirited (whites call it depressed) are unable to find interests and opportunities for them and their children. They are too burdened to watch for signs that their children are suicidal.

I applaud Coloradas Mangas for his courage in speaking up and searching for the roots and cures of the tragic suicides on his reservation. The rundown buildings say "hopeless" and even the name - "Reservation" - says where his people were forced to live. Why not call it Apacheland or whatever name has meaning to its residents, for starters?

He understands that the first and most important deterents are family, friends, and the community being on guard for problems in each teen. He understands the need for professional help as well. The best medicine is preventive - start a mutual support group for 12 year olds and including training sessions with their families. This could be called an issues and answers group of about 10 students, served by a teacher trained in couseling teens - but a trained parent with access to a professional counselor (a job for Apacheland) could also work.

The roots of suicide are universal. Suicide is up among all young people in America though much more among Native American teens. Children are so aghast by the greedy exploitation of our polluted Blue Ball and a reward system that pushes rich and poor ever further apart, that they logically opt out. We need
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:16 PM on 04/11/2011
It is true that parents (around the world) have to find the time to communicate with their children regularly - even while dealing with the constant burdens of work and just plain surviving. A child will forgive having less "things" in life if they receive the regular love and communication that is like the bread of life for them - especially in their teenage years.

I agree that names can have great meaning, so I guess I do not wholly agree with Shakespeare's Juliet who states "What's in a name? That which we call a rose by any other name would smell as sweet." Words or names can render a perception of places, people, and situations - good or bad - and that is not a little thing.