iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
J.D. Rothman

GET UPDATES FROM J.D. Rothman
 

Passionistas

Posted: 03/ 7/2012 1:50 pm

The Neurotic Parent is a humor writer who satirizes the insanity of the modern college admissions process.

Yesterday, when I picked up my younger son, Good Conversationalist, he had just come from a meeting with his dean. He is starting high school next year and had to select his ninth-grade electives. He showed me the catalog and said that for a sport, he wanted to try cross country.

I was horrified. He has always been a baseball player. Why was he suddenly thinking of trying something new?

Then he let the other shoe drop. "Mom," he said. "There is so much I want to try. I might want to stop doing graphic arts and take a semester of photography. Then maybe I'll do a year of speech and debate, and a summer program in creative writing. I'm going to run for Student Council and start a ping pong club. And I want to take music composition, kayak lessons, and maybe even two languages: French and ancient Greek."

At that point I was too agitated to drive and had to pull over. How dare he become enthusiastic about so many different pursuits! What kind of kid had we raised?

"Stop right there," I said. "You cannot study all those things. How would that look to the admissions committees at the colleges where you're applying to four years from now? They want to see that you have just one passion, two at the most. Top candidates choose something they love in third grade and stick with it."

"But how am I supposed to have a passion now?" he asked. "I'm only 14!"

"Most 14-year-olds bound for selective schools already have won awards in their field of choice," I explained. "They know it's a terrible idea to have more than a few interests. So give it up."

He looked down. "But how am I going to know if I like something if I don't try it? Can't I be passionate about learning itself?"

Here it was: my worst parenting nightmare coming true. I shook my head and told myself it was all hormones, and he soon would return to baseball. But in my heart I knew he might be on the road to giving into his temptations. Any day, I imagined, I would be getting a call from the Dean of Students, letting me know that he was experimenting with both photography and Greek.
This was something that needed to be nipped in the bud. I dropped him off at Little League practice went home to look into intervention programs.

Excerpted from "The Neurotic Parent's Guide to College Admissions" by J.D. Rothman. Published by Prospect Park Books.

 
 
 
The Neurotic Parent is a humor writer who satirizes the insanity of the modern college admissions process. Yesterday, when I picked up my younger son, Good Conversationalist, he had just come from a ...
The Neurotic Parent is a humor writer who satirizes the insanity of the modern college admissions process. Yesterday, when I picked up my younger son, Good Conversationalist, he had just come from a ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 22
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
JBS
Part time misanthrope & full time curmudgeon
08:33 PM on 03/09/2012
Well, FWIW, a semester of photography could be a strong complement to graphic arts.
-swift
Can you put your country before your party?
09:21 AM on 03/08/2012
Be careful. That kid might grow up someday to be a ... (shudder)... artist.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
environmentalista
Nature is divine. Worship it!
09:17 AM on 03/08/2012
I love this article! Good thing it is in the comedy section as the reality of the situation is rather sad.
My middle son Over Scheduled (he named himself) said to his brother a college freshman, "I think the best thing about college must be not having to worry about doing things to get into college."
He is so overburdened trying to do it all. I keep pushing him to cut back but between the things he needs and the things he enjoys, he can't let go.
He is so looking forward to learning for the sake of learning. I am sad that he has to wait 3 more years to get there and can not wait to see all the wonderful and varied choices he will make when he does!
barbara jay
my kid says hi
08:24 AM on 03/08/2012
A friend from Eastern Europe, research doctor, told me she thought it was a waste of time that (full-time) college students in the U.S. take courses in a variety of subjects for two years before they concentrate on their major. Nice for her that she was precocious enough to have planned out her whole course of study at an earlier age than most of the rest of us.
08:49 AM on 03/08/2012
This is what all college students in Europe do (or rather, how BA-curricula in general are designed). Students spend 4 years studying only their major, with _maybe_ one or two courses in a related field. General education courses such as Freshman Writing and Basic science courses will have been covered in high school. It is assumed that if you have not mastered basic academic skills you will not be getting a university degree to begin with.
barbara jay
my kid says hi
06:33 AM on 03/09/2012
Actually, I'm aware of this because I'm in the thick of it; my 11-year-old daughter attends a German Gymnasium, and German university may be all I can afford for her. Reforms over the last eight years have put her on a very different timeline than I would have expected on the day she (at age 3) entered kindergarten. Three things have changed: children enter grade 1 at a younger age, the thirteenth grade has been cut out, and the Diplom, which took university students a minimum of four years to complete, has been replaced by the three-year Bachelors'. If she never repeats a grade or takes a break,she'll have to commit to a major at 17 and have her B.A. at twenty. What used to take too long is now rushed through too fast, and something will have been sacrificed. I was one of the students who needed to take exploration time to pin down my interests, and in a U.S. college I was able to do that.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JD Salinger
My micro-bio is invisible to the naked eye.
07:51 AM on 03/08/2012
Trying a wide variety of activities is how many people discover where their talents and passions lie.
For example, the author might find it useful to try other genres of writing.
02:14 AM on 03/08/2012
Reinassence was all about how men and women discovered passion for all aspects of knowledge. It was common lo learn music as well as astronomy... What is wrong with that? By specializing in niches of knowledge we are kind of reducing our humanity.
07:30 PM on 03/07/2012
Sad but true. Corporations don't want graduates with a range of knowledge. They want people with tightly-honed areas of expertise, even at 22. This allows the employer to skip on time and money spent on training, no matter how effective.

Perhaps corporations should just assign people to work specialties upon entering a university, as they did in the Soviet Union. Corporate America is calling the tune, but doesn't seem well-rehearsed with the dance steps.
11:30 PM on 03/07/2012
Corporate amerikka is cheap. I think the gop candidates at least need a "certificate" to run for President.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:32 PM on 03/08/2012
Really? I'm betting Apple and Google and FaceBook and a thousand other corporations I can think of would take issue with that notion. They can make machines. What corporations need -- and are looking for -- is people who can think, who can create, who can solve problems.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Welshish
The sadder but wiser girl for me.
05:57 PM on 03/07/2012
There's a clip in that documentary on Woody Allen's jazz tour of Europe, "Wildman Blues" that is so hilariously terrible. Woody's elderly parents are asked about him as a child and they launch into a whole diatribe saying "He never stuck with anything! He should have been a dentist! But, he never stayed with sports. If only he would have stuck to one thing!" etc, etc. OMG!!!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ray Butt
My micro-bio is empty.
04:00 PM on 03/07/2012
I get that this is supposed to be satire, but it is closer to horror than comedy.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Paros
12:01 AM on 03/08/2012
I agree completely.
I just kept getting "horrific mother."
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
orcinous
Close Guantanamo, pass a jobs bill, end the drones
03:37 PM on 03/07/2012
There are people who have great talents and as I heard someone else say, cannot remember who, the real talent is sticking to one thing for years to become talented. That;s what it takes to be one of the best at anything. It is still ok to be passionate about learning, it is just that you will not be the best until you put years of devotion into it. Nothing wrong with going either way.
UVA1983
Left of left
01:59 PM on 03/07/2012
Neurotic Parent should be modified to read Dumb Parent. You have a wonderful child who is interested in trying lots of things; and I imagine, is/will be successful in most of them. This is the time for him to try things out and experiment and find his groove. All successful children who go to selective schools have won awards by the time they are 14? Are you high? I realize this is supposed to be funny, I guess. Sounds like you need to support your child's interests more. What's wrong with cross country anyway?
02:14 PM on 03/07/2012
UVA1983, have you heard of satire?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Paros
12:04 AM on 03/08/2012
Clearly she is writing satire but the problem with her writing is that the irony simply is underwhelming and the satire not only falls flat but is reflective of a very common current philosophy.
02:28 PM on 03/07/2012
Are YOU high? This is clearly satire. Lighten up.