iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Jeff B. Cohen, Esq.

GET UPDATES FROM Jeff B. Cohen, Esq.
 

Paul Ryan's Moment of Truth: Why the VP Debate Matters More

Posted: 10/05/2012 9:40 am

Ladies and Gentlemen...

In the Red State Corner, hailing from Janesville, Wis., the Gen X, fresh-faced, fearless, ferocious "intellectual leader of the Republican Party," the undisputed Grand New Superstar of the Grand Old Party... Paul "The P90X Kid" Ryan!

And, In the Blue State Corner, hailing from the mean streets of Scranton, Pa., number two in the country, but number one in our hearts, he's not afraid to say exactly what's on his mind (even if everyone else in the White House is terrified of him saying exactly what's on his mind!)... Joe "The Gaffe-Inator" Biden!

Excited for the VP Debates? I am! Excited for the presidential debates? Not so much. Here's why.

The Mitt Who Cried 47 Percent

In light of Romney's "47 Percent" Tape, the presidential debates are irrelevant. It was a fatal error for the already struggling campaign. I disagree with the popular narrative that what we learn from the tape is that Mitt Romney has genuine contempt for 47 percent of American citizens. The true takeaway is that Mitt Romney has no genuine political convictions whatsoever.

Mitt is ambition and a mirror. He will tell anyone, anything at any given time to achieve his current objective.

He told very rich people what he felt they wanted to hear: 'You are rich. You are extraordinary. You deserve to be rich. People who are not rich suffer the indignity of not being rich because they are weak.'

Of course, this is not the first time Mitt has told people what he thought they wanted to hear.

Mitt v. Mitt

On health care:

  • "I'm proud of what we've done. If Massachusetts succeeds in implementing [Romneycare], then that will be a model for the nation." Speech in Baltimore, 2007


On abortion rights:


On gay rights:


On conservatism:


Even if he clobbered Obama in all three debates, he no longer has any credibility. Lincoln's adage holds up: "You can fool some of the people all of the time, and all of the people some of the time, but you can not fool all of the people all of the time."

Put a fork in Willard. He's done.


Representative Ryan, Pharmaceutical Grade

With Mitt out of the way, Ryan's moment is now. A national forum. An opponent considered by many to be a gaffe prone loose cannon ("put y'all back in chains," etc... ).

Ryan is the youthful heir to the throne of Republican power, a beltway darling considered by many to be the best spokesman for and "intellectual leader of the Republican Party." The GOP's Ringer v. The Democrat's "Gaffe Machine."

And let me be clear, I don't want a Mitt-Romnified, flip-flopping Paul Ryan. At The Oct. 11 VP debate, I want to see the real deal, unfiltered, unmitigated, 100 percent pure pharmaceutical-grade Paul Ryan. The one who said: "The reason I got involved in public service, by and large, if I had to credit one thinker, one person, it would be Ayn Rand." The one who drafted the 2010 "Roadmap For America's Future," the intellectual blueprint of the current Republican Congress.

This is Ryan's big moment to argue to the American people why the intellectual leader of the Republican Party's "Roadmap For America's Future" includes the following:

-- Social Security becoming privatized

-- Medicare becoming a voucher system

-- Converting Medicaid into block grants for states

-- Giving massive new tax cuts for the Wealthiest Americans

And for good measure, Ryan should tell the American people why in 2011 he co-sponsored the personhood amendment/Sanctity of Human Life Act, which outlaws in vitro fertilization and some forms of contraception.

And perhaps, most of all, Ryan should explain how someone who relied on Social Security Survivor Benefits, went to public high school, went to public university, worked for the government since graduation and inherited a fortune from a family business that built roads for the government is in any position to argue that government should have almost no role in the lives of American citizens.

This is your moment of truth, Representative Ryan. Your bright, hot spotlight. Time to lead. You will never have another chance like this. Persuade the American people of your vision or forever hold your peace.

 

Follow Jeff B. Cohen, Esq. on Twitter: www.twitter.com/Jeff_B_Cohen

FOLLOW POLITICS
Ladies and Gentlemen... In the Red State Corner, hailing from Janesville, Wis., the Gen X, fresh-faced, fearless, ferocious "intellectual leader of the Republican Party," the undisputed Grand New Sup...
Ladies and Gentlemen... In the Red State Corner, hailing from Janesville, Wis., the Gen X, fresh-faced, fearless, ferocious "intellectual leader of the Republican Party," the undisputed Grand New Sup...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 219
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (6 total)
11:52 PM on 10/15/2012
Ok, that didn't work
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ladyrosedeky
03:05 PM on 10/10/2012
There is a big reason Biden should win this debate -- foreign policy. It's Biden's area which he knows it well. Not only has Biden served in the military himself and been a long time senator which Ryan has not, but both of Biden's sons have served as well. One is still serving. So Biden has a much more indepth understanding of these issues which impact our military and military families that Ryan will never know because Biden has been there on the front lines. This is why Obama picked him as V.P. Biden knew foreign affairs and military which was Obama's weakness. It gave Obama the balance he needed.

Then there is how to talk to people, including the blue collar. That's who Biden grew up as and is deeply entrenched. It's in his blood. He served as a Marine in Viet Nam. This is his turf. Not Ryan's even though Ryan didn't grow up with his father, Biden grew up blue collar in Pennsylvania's hard streets. He also knows what it is like to have to raise kids on his own since he lost his first wife. He knows it's not easy.

So I give this one to Joe who knows the common man well and knows how to communicate with them. Including knowing how to talk the religious walk because he is a devout Catholic himself.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
drkazmd65
Mom Taught me - Question Everything - Thanks Mom!
12:37 PM on 10/09/2012
"Even if he clobbered Obama in all three debates, he no longer has any credibility. Lincoln's adage holds up: "You can fool some of the people all of the time, and all of the people some of the time, but you can not fool all of the people all of the time."

Put a fork in Willard. He's done."

Make no mistake,... Mittens is far from done. To discount him (or Ryan) is to court failure before the game is played.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ladyrosedeky
03:16 PM on 10/10/2012
If we had a populace that still thought things through, I'd agree. Unfortunately we don't. They haven't even been paying attention for the most part until recently.

A portion of the people who are voting for Romney are doing so because their pastors are telling them he is the candidate to vote for. They don't even read any news or listen to any so they don't even know he's flipped on the abortion and birth control issues. If many of them knew Romney's flip on abortion, they might not even go to the polls and vote on November 6. I have three neighbors that are totally pro-life. One won't even consider the idea of an abortion if it were to save the mother's life. So if she were to hear Romney say to keep abortion legal, she'd probably stay home on November 6.

God save us from those who won't listen to or read any news, please?

It's not like religions haven't had evil motives for controlling what people think in the past.
photo
A is A
This is this. It's not something else.
08:41 PM on 10/08/2012
Hey Jeff, I guess HuffPo put your column in the Comedy section for a reason. It's a big joke and I laughed pretty hard at some of your expectations for the debate.

For starters, when Mitt says that what he did in Massachusetts should be a model for the nation, he meant that this is what each state across the nation should implement. Do it at the state level nationally and not at the federal level.

I am looking forward to this debate and will return here to read what kind of spin you guys put on how many times Biden will stick his foot in his mouth.
mrrgl
Brevity is the soul of wit.
10:13 AM on 10/07/2012
Mitt is always molting...quite a skill.
09:06 AM on 10/07/2012
During the Biden/Ryan debate Ryan should be asked as to whom he believes is the greater sophist, Romney or himself?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
crazyalice
still traveling hopefully
12:40 AM on 10/07/2012
i agree with the writer however i never underestimate the naivete of the masses. many of those who aren't true political junkies often choose their candidates for all the wrong reasons. - looks, "seems like a nice guy/gal," and so on. if they are paying attention then i'd be less worried about the outcome on nov. 6.
photo
Unca Wiggilie
I am but a meager bookworm...
08:15 AM on 10/07/2012
Low information voters (LIV) are easily influenced and swayed, then elections
are won by the lying propaganda that is bought and paid for by the mega-bucks
of the Koch bros., the war criminal Karl Rove, Sheldon Adelson and other
moneyed interests.
So sez the 'Golden Rule' (and the US "Supreme" Court): "He who has the gold,rules!

"http://www.csmonitor.com/USA/DC-Decoder/2012/1004/Election-2012-top-seven-super-PACs/Restore-our-Future
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
zackeryrichards
NO Party - just an American
11:17 AM on 10/07/2012
Unca Wiggilit: You are 100% correct. And therein lies the problem with
America. If the American people do not wake up and get involved in what
is going on in Washington very, very soon . . . . we will lose our democracy
[if we have not already!].
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ladyrosedeky
02:48 PM on 10/10/2012
I do love reading the Christian Science Monitor. It is one of the best news sources out there.

However, I do wish more Americans would start listening to or reading some foreign press as well. They'd be a lot better informed if they did. For one, they'd know how frightened a number of our allies are of Romney winning the election. Secondly, they'd know how well respected Obama is in the world, including by Israel's defense minister, Ehud Barak who praises Obama for being the best American president Israel has ever had towards them and insuring their security.

What's funny is all of a sudden since Netanyahu is running for re-election, he's starting to make nice with Obama so he doesn't look like he's alienated Israel's best ally -- America.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
hipocampelofantocame
retired pediatrician
10:52 PM on 10/06/2012
I'm frankly surprised that Paul Ryan would ever have "a moment of truth". It's
so contrary to his modus operandi.
photo
demisfine
Often correct, NEVER right.
04:43 PM on 10/06/2012
I cannot wait until Paul Ryan tries to be disrespectful of or insubordinate to Joe Biden.
Paul Ryan is a pischa of a Congressman.
Biden is a veteran Senator and VP.
If Paul Ryan tries to act as a peer to Joe, it's curtains.
He will get a smackdown on national TV.
Just let Paul Ryan try to pull an "It's too complicated" reply.
Joe will counter with "No, please Paul, take your time and educate us to the details of your plan".
01:08 AM on 10/07/2012
Don't forget, Ryan fathered that bill to get that library's name changed. See, he is ready to become 2nd in line.
photo
demisfine
Often correct, NEVER right.
10:10 AM on 10/07/2012
Post Office, not library.
No books or learnin' in his portfolio
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tuxter
The only thing we have to fear is, fear itself!
04:36 PM on 10/06/2012
Biden may be a bit gaffe prone but I think that he will,or should, win the VP debate. He is a passionate individual that is highly intelligent and compassionate. Say what you will of Senator Biden,( and yes i do have a beef to pick with him on some of the votes he took on financial deregulation) he truly seems to care for the regular guy or at least it comes across that way. Sharp guy too. Gounded in the real world and not the half baked world of a second rate science fiction hack. Yes that would be the screwed up world of Ayan Rand. Ryan says he's Catholic. Yet he adhears to the philosophy of an Athiest that declared herself the enemy of all religions? There is some sort of disconnect there at least to me anyway. ( PS. I definitely have my problems with organized religion but spirituality I can most definitely believe in and do. )
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
alumcreek
sorry to see humanity repeating errors ad nauseam
11:36 AM on 10/06/2012
I do not watch TV but I may waste time on Lying Ryan trying to ignore Biden in his effort to make a dishonest first step in his campaign for the presidency in 2016.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rosalee Harris
11:33 AM on 10/06/2012
Obama wasnt debating a person. He was debating JELLO. Maybe Joe will be lucky and get to debate an actual person who sticks by his convictions and dont change them in second.
11:50 AM on 10/06/2012
In the next debate, the President now has to prove that. If he doesn't, he just might lose.

Look, I am on your side, but I am not going to sugarcoat things. The President has to be Muhammad Ali in the next debate. He has to float like a butterfly and sting like a bee. Otherwise, he might end up like most of Ali's opponents.

Sorry, but this is truly how I feel.
11:57 AM on 10/06/2012
The President has my vote. I don't care how he does against that slimy car salesman. He is the best man for the job. And he gets the job done. Intelligently and respectfully.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rosalee Harris
12:00 PM on 10/06/2012
I dont think you need to worry about the President on that score in fact he does better when he is down than when he is on top.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ladyrosedeky
02:56 PM on 10/10/2012
Obama was standing across from a used car salesman who was pitching a lemons.

As Newt Gingrich stated in one of the Republican debates, he actually stepped forward from the podium when he said it, "How do you debates someone who lies?'

But Obama needs to bring his AAA game with him next time. I did notice he was taking a lot of notes the last time. So I do expect him to come back swinging and swinging hard.

Although I did notice him biting his lip through out the debate. Therefore, I agree with a couple of assertions that were made. That he didn't want to respond in an angry manner because he doesn't like Romney and loose his favorablity rating with the American people who like him as a nice man. He didn't have a problem debating McCain because he likes McCain and respects McCain. But evidently he doesn't like Romney.

Even though I've never met Romney, I can understand why.

Reading some of Paul Ryan's legislation and listening to him, I'm not fond of Ryan without meeting him either.

As they say, you can tell a leopard by his spots. And these two have plenty of spots.
10:48 AM on 10/06/2012
That version of the VP debate will never happen, unfortunately. Ryan sees a path to the Presidency for himself, and that path is only there if Romney wins. Ryan will back up Mitt's "new" positions on everything. Ryan will treat Biden like an extra on a movie set and spend the entire debate attacking Obama. He will pretend that he is on the House floor, where he can say whatever he wants, sometimes to a mostly empty chamber but "for the Congressional record," and face no consequences. And, yes, he will lie. Or, to put it more kindly, he will disavow any highly controversial positions. He has no other choice. He's not just the VP candidate; he needs to hold on to his House seat in Wisconsin just in case Romney loses.
05:18 PM on 10/06/2012
I saw Nora O'Donnell on Face the Nation mop the floor with Ryan. I'm sure Biden can do the same!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
LindaJC
And the sheep think themselves wolves
07:49 PM on 10/06/2012
Hopefully plain-speaking, feet-to-the-fire Joe Biden will force Ryan into the center of the ring.

By that I mean, when Ryan abandons a former position, Joe simply plunges forward debating that former position, followed by, "But, oh, that's not what you've been advocating ... so it's a waste of America's time to discuss this. I'd ask to make a decision between what you said previously and what you're saying tonight, but we still wouldn't know what position you'll hold tomorrow or next week or election day." Not sure how Ryan would respond to that. But I can picture the grin and chuckle from Joe, Godspeed to him!
photo
littlebrowngirl
Brevity is the soul of wit - Shakespeare
10:05 AM on 10/06/2012
This is the debate that I most want to see. Joe has to go for broke on Ryan.
09:57 AM on 10/06/2012
Newsweek magazine gave that same test to 1,000 Americans - and only 62 percent of them passed.

Read the Newsweek story

33 percent of them didn't know the vice-president's name (Joe Biden) and 73 percent had no idea what the U.S. was fighting against during the Cold War.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
alumcreek
sorry to see humanity repeating errors ad nauseam
11:27 AM on 10/06/2012
The fruit of Amercian education is rarely sweet if taken in toto. Somehow the bulk of Americans manage to spend 12 years in various schools and come out unscathed by basic knowledge. Even most of those who undertake 16 years of education, manage to avoid being tained by simple facts.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Stanley Bonk
"mad, bad, and dangerous to know"
01:40 AM on 10/07/2012
That's why there are Republicans: a lack of education.
11:51 AM on 10/06/2012
OMG. I weep for America. This is what the Republicans have done to our education system.

I would bet $10,000 that over 90% of the people in the U.S. could have answered those questions over 30 years ago.
01:08 AM on 10/07/2012
Just keep fighting for the right of crappy teachers to hold their jobs forever so that they can pay union dues that can support the political campaigns of Democrats and we'll keep seeing our education standards drop.