iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Jeff Biggers

GET UPDATES FROM Jeff Biggers
 

AZ Gov. Brewer's Latest Finger Wag Media Stunt for Obama: Denial of Driver's License to Deferred Dreamers

Posted: 08/15/2012 9:50 pm

President Obama may have been too far away on the campaign trail in Iowa today, but that didn't stop Arizona Gov. Jan Brewer from her latest finger-wagging media stunt of state's rights defiance.

Once again placing Arizona at the forefront of political posturing at the expense of immigrants, right-wing "superhero" Brewer issued a fairly inconsequential but incendiary executive order reminding state agencies that today's beginning of the federal Deferred Action program for undocumented youth "does not provide for any additional public benefit to unlawfully present aliens."

Especially if those aliens want driver's licenses. Arizona laws already prohibit undocumented residents from accessing driver's licenses or public benefits.

In a total disregard for the documented economic and social benefits from Obama's Deferred Action for undocumented immigrants brought to the U.S. as children, Brewer's order railed about 80,000 potential recipients in the state, including some "unlawfully present aliens inappropriately gaining access to public benefits contrary to the intent of Arizona voters."

Two months ago, Brewer drew statewide condemnation for her hastily called press conference on the president's deferred action announcement, which she framed as an "amnesty."

In a released statement, the Phoenix-based Puente human rights group blasted Brewer for her timing and actions:

Once again, [Brewer] has stood on the wrong side of history by implementing anti-immigrant policies and directly contradicting federal mandates related to immigration. By taking public action against President Obama's policy that will potentially grant work permits to over one million undocumented young people, Brewer has once again put Arizona's name on the map as the epicenter of anti-immigrant racism and hate.

Strangely enough, Brewer and Arizona's right-wing politicos have their own issues with driver's licenses and following the law; in 1988, Brewer failed sobriety tests after a car accident in Phoenix.

Then a state senator, Brewer received immunity from arrest and prosecution.

 
 
 
FOLLOW POLITICS
President Obama may have been too far away on the campaign trail in Iowa today, but that didn't stop Arizona Gov. Jan Brewer from her latest finger-wagging media stunt of state's rights defiance. O...
President Obama may have been too far away on the campaign trail in Iowa today, but that didn't stop Arizona Gov. Jan Brewer from her latest finger-wagging media stunt of state's rights defiance. O...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 45
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
realitytrumpsbull
Two 'alves of coconut!
10:54 PM on 08/17/2012
How about you just start actually enforcing US immigration law, and sending people home, period? Illegal has been double-speaked down to 'undocumented'. Lying, 2-faced, mealymouthed social engineers...and they wonder why no one trusts politicians in this country.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Viper1st
multi quasi faceted
09:38 AM on 08/17/2012
The State of Arizona passed state law denying illegals state public benefits since 2004 ~ called the, "
Arizona Taxpayer and Citizen Protection Act of 2004

http://www.naswaz.com/displaycommon.cfm?an=1&subarticlenbr=202

12 States have similar state laws denying state public benefits to illegals ~

Arizona ~ 2004
Colorado ~ 2006
Idaho ~ 2007
Utah ~ 2008
Nebraska ~ 2009
Oklahoma ~ 2007
Missouri ~ 2007
Indiana ~ 2011
Alabama ~ 2011
Virginia ~ 2005
South Carolina ~ 2008
Georgia ~ 2006

http://www.nilc.org/states-wrapup-2011.html
10:19 AM on 08/20/2012
Last year California property and taxpayers got stuck for $12 billion for welfare for illegals. Uck.
08:08 AM on 08/17/2012
What will be the consequences? People without licenses, will continue to drive. If they do not have licenses, they will not have insurance. If the police pull them over, many will attempt to out run the police, which will put innocent citizens at risk.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Viper1st
multi quasi faceted
05:42 PM on 08/17/2012
Very Good Reason to forceably deport ALL illegals that choose not to self-deport ~ before the illegals make their problems into U.S. Citizens' problems
04:53 AM on 08/17/2012
This is disgusting, a new low - even by Arizona standards. A mean spirited act no doubt fueled by hatred from the Governor of a state where over 70% of her constituents support the DREAM Act. What's next ? Is she going to round the DREAMers up and put them in concentration camps run by Joe Arpaio ?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Viper1st
multi quasi faceted
08:33 AM on 08/17/2012
If ~ 70% of Arizonans support the flawed DREAM Act ~ why has it not passed out of the U.S. Congress on 12 different occasions in the past 11 years?

Appears ~ the one-sided benefits for illegals, only ~ is not resonating with the U.S. Taxpayers
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lavender menace
I calls it like I see it.
10:44 PM on 08/16/2012
If these folks get access to driver's licenses, who is to say that they are not going to try to register to vote and falsly claim to be US citizens when they are not.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Viper1st
multi quasi faceted
08:38 AM on 08/17/2012
Exactly!

The USA is having the exact same voter fraud problem with the 500,000+ illegals, whom have been issued valid/legal Driver's Licenses, since 2003 by the States of Utah, New Mexico & Washington

Remember ~ voter registration is automatic when obtaining a Driver's License, via the Motor Voter Registration Act of 1993
08:45 AM on 08/18/2012
First of all, the popular vote doesn't actually count. It's to give the electorial college an idea of what the public wants, but if you check your history, the popular choice doesn't always match the winner in an election. Also, being a green card holder but not a citizen, I know I can't vote, but you're right technically if you have a driver's license and you try to vote they will let you. Being that I live in MA, NH and surrounding states are always in the news. In NH, the last time there was a voting, a reporter went undercover with a hidden camera and used documents of people who were deceased and got to vote in all the venues he visited. Some didn't even ask to see his ID, when he offered, the old lady attendant said something along the lines of "This is New Hampshire, you're free, we don't need proof." So will it really matter if some people try to beat the system and vote? No, considering even caucasian deceased people can vote....
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jenny Kraige
11:24 PM on 08/18/2012
Maybe the fact that voter fraud would not be worth the only opportunity people have to drive and work legally. I think rational people, with currently zero possibilities of doing that legally would do just about anything to qualify, as in staying on the straightest and narrowest.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ugly american
"I drank what?"- Last words of Socrates
07:13 PM on 08/16/2012
There are prices to pay for playing by the rules.
Young illegal foreigners protested and marched demanding that they just be given a chance to stay and go to school or work.
So a law was set aside for them. Nobody declared them innocent, only allowed to stay and work.
It says in the memo "This memorandum confers no substantive right, immigration status or pathway to citizenship. Only the Congress, acting through its legislative authority, can confer these rights."
But now there are cries that it is "racist" and "hateful" to deny them all the benefits of having followed the law or being a citizen.
Most states deny licences to unregistered foreign nationals. This work permit doesn't change that status. And as Obama said, changing that is outside his power. If he tries he would stand for impeachment.
Social benefits are denied to foreigners, legal or illegal. For that to change, Justice will need to sue Agriculture.
It will be some time yet before Latin nations are ready to sue our Federal government for having laws at all, but it's coming. It takes time short of war to erode another nation's sovereignty. Now that illegal foreigners have one thing they said they wanted, they demand it all, right now. That attitude should be telling of what they are really after.
rafaelkafka
"Dubito, ergo cogito, ergo sum!"
05:19 PM on 08/16/2012
She is amazing! Obama coup will not work in Arizona!
photo
Snake1994
Snakebite!
04:01 PM on 08/16/2012
Jeff, it is against the law in Arizona for illegal aliens to obtain driver's licenses or any other state benefits. Since deferred action does not grant them a path to citizenship, they are not entitled to any public benefits. They are called laws for a reason you know, or should we just throw all laws out the window when it comes to illegal aliens.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
RiverWalker
Listen to the "Before World"
01:31 PM on 08/16/2012
"Strangely enough, Brewer and Arizona's right-wing politicos have their own issues with driver's licenses and following the law; in 1988, Brewer failed sobriety tests after a car accident in Phoenix."

She was a state senator at the time and "immune from prosecution." I bet her insurance company wasn't immune from paying for her gross negligence.

The self-righteous right is most guilty of one hypocrisy after another!
photo
edw1
A seasoned observer
07:02 AM on 08/16/2012
If you want respect then you must give respect. This is a lesson that Gov Brewer has failed to learn. She is not smart or tough, she is not standing up for the rights of her citizens, she comes off as mean and uncaring as well as ego driven without regard for the consequences to the image of the state of Arizona around the rest of the country.

She has done more to hurt tourism and business growth in this state than any other state leader in history. Something needs to change either her or our desire to reelect her to represent all of the people of the state of Arizona.
photo
emigholzjr
There is love and there is a cry for love
12:50 PM on 08/16/2012
Arizona is under attack by Mexico, under attack by criminals wanting to rob US citizens their right to earn a decent wage. This is nothing more than blatant Keynesian economicis by the US and by Mexico.
photo
edw1
A seasoned observer
08:10 PM on 08/16/2012
The illegal population has decreased signifinately in the last two years. This is because the construction industry was not active and the illegeals went home since they only came to make money. They basically were laborers doing work for basic minimum wage the work they did is not work that the workforce in AZ seek since it is hard work for medium pay.

This is proven by the fact that since they left it is very difficult to find anyone to do these jobs and if the industry picks up it will not be able to keep up no matter how much they were paying since it is not the kind of work amercians like to do.

I get it that Brewer et al would like us to beleive they are protecting us from some sort of invasion however if any right thinking person check he will find that the truth is much different than the lies we are being told .
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:03 PM on 08/16/2012
"If you want respect then you must give respect."

Sort of like the respect shown by immigrating to this country illegally?
photo
edw1
A seasoned observer
08:30 PM on 08/16/2012
Our conversation was directed toward our elected officals respecting one another. We do not advocate anyone breaking the law but if the people in authority lawfully set policy that modifies how it is administrated then like it or not we should comply until it can be set aside. Otherwise we have our leaders creating chaos. Thanks for your discussion of these matters we are all after the same thing we just have different points of view on how it should be handled.
02:05 AM on 08/16/2012
In other words, we will collect their tax money but not give them the benefits of being an upstanding citizen. Hmmm. Does not sound very American.
photo
emigholzjr
There is love and there is a cry for love
12:54 PM on 08/16/2012
They want IDs so they can forge more IDs. This type of activity has created a state of lawlessness in the US and in Mexico; Lost generation after generation to lawlessness.
02:37 PM on 08/16/2012
"DOESN'T SOUND VERY AMERICAN"? TAKE A PEEK AT THE FACTS, THEY ARE NOT AMERICANS THEY ARE ILLEGALS, NOT, I REPEAT, NOT AMERICANS. THE STATE OF AZ HAS THE RIGHT TO REFUSE AID TO WHOM THEY CHOOSE, THEY VOTED TO NOT GIVE DRIVERS LICENSES NOR ANY STATE OR LOCAL AID TO ANY NON-CITIXEN. . OBAMA DOES NOT CONTROL THE STATE OF AZ NO MATTER ILLEGALS HE GAVE BACKDOOR AMNESTY.
photo
voyager48
Illegitimi Non Carborundum
02:04 AM on 08/16/2012
Jeff - your twisted agenda is showing again. Just as Napolitano issued a memo to give guidelines to her cohorts, why is it any less valid for Brewer to issue a statement clarifying things for hers?

The law remains the law and this is in no way new or a surprise since DOJ clarified this all months ago in the case of Sergio Garcia who was trying to get a license to practice law in California. This is just another typical puerile ad hominem attack on someone with whom you do not agree.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
spytheweb
Black Democrat
01:41 AM on 08/16/2012
Good for her. No licenses for illegal aliens. Watch California issue licenses and watch the fraud began and spread across the country.
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
realitytrumpsbull
Two 'alves of coconut!
10:40 PM on 08/15/2012
The general impression here is that at this late date, the federal govt. STILL doesn't have its stuff in one sock on immigration. C'mon. We need a 50-state policy, do's, don't's, who to call, what to do, resources for local and state level. This country spends three and a half TRILLION dollars on government, and we're still not there. Why? Wherefore? Does it all go to interest payments on 16 trillion dollars' worth of debt? Is there a race to see who can stuff it down their pants the fastest? What support, assistance, and professional guidance is the federal government either able or willing to provide to the states, here? HelLOOOOO!!!! Time to fire some people and open up some job positions? Illegal means illegal, define it, illustrate it, so we can all commonly understand this issue, and make the bad thing go away. People busy squirting out their units overseas by the millions annually, expect more external pressure on the immigration system, not less...