More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Jeff Cohen

Jeff Cohen

Posted: August 5, 2010 11:54 AM

Colbert 1, U.S. State Department 0

What's Your Reaction:

On last night's Colbert Report, an amazing moment occurred when Stephen Colbert raised a major social issue that U.S. mainstream media assiduously ignore: the huge U.S. prison population. The issue quickly disappeared due to the apparent ignorance of Colbert's guest: Assistant Secretary of State Michael Posner, in charge of "Democracy, Human Rights and Labor."

In a sometimes jokey interview with Posner discussing China's various human rights abuses (including prisoners), Colbert tried to steer the conversation to human rights problems in our own country.

COLBERT: We've actually got more people in prison than China does.

POSNER: Well I'm not sure that's true.

Colbert's assertion is indisputably true. Posner's denial is false. Does the State Department's man in charge of human rights not know the facts?

According to statistics gathered by the authoritative International Centre for Prison Studies in London, the United States has by far the largest prison population in the world: almost 2.3 million people behind bars. China's prison population is second in the world: roughly 1.6 million.

The United States is also number one in the world in its "prison population rate": 748 inmates per 100,000 citizens. Russia is third. China is tied for 114th.

This is a U.S. human rights problem of enormous proportions. Our bloated prison population has many causes including the "drug war," mandatory minimum sentencing, poverty, and racism. And there are corporate profits to be made from "The Prison-Industrial Complex" -- as independent journalists like Eric Schlosser began documenting a dozen years ago.

Wouldn't it be great to see this issue tackled by some mainstream TV voices . . . other than Stephen Colbert?


Jeff Cohen heads the Park Center for Independent Media at Ithaca College.

 
 
 

Follow Jeff Cohen on Twitter: www.twitter.com/jeffcot

 
 
  • Comments
  • 58
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
09:41 PM on 08/06/2010
I understood SCILF. But what does TBD mean?
03:38 PM on 08/06/2010
Sadly, only Colbert and Stewart are voices on reason in a sea of misinformation and distractions known as "news"
09:41 PM on 08/06/2010
I also dig Democracy Now on www.democracynow.org Check it out.....
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
krone5
river walker
09:28 PM on 08/05/2010
It goes to show you how Mr. Colbert is pro american.
We are NUMBER 1 in prisoners. The State Dept. should add better USA=1
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
OleProfessor
"Ours is not a system based upon trust"
08:19 PM on 08/05/2010
Our own County is bankrupt due to to Jail and Prison building Jeff..?

We Build prisons and stadiums and close hospitals and schools...
07:24 PM on 08/05/2010
And where did Colbert get his data? If it was from the "offical" Chinese government records then those numbers by themsleves are highly suspect.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Turukano
Obama 2012
08:06 PM on 08/05/2010
You cannot be serious. Do you really think that China is hiding a couple million inmates?
05:39 PM on 08/05/2010
Look how we treat each other. look how we treat human beings. i think they people who are prifiting from locking up human beings should suffer the same fate. i cant wait to be there when this happens. so they can see my face and know itwas me who put them in a facility that they profitted from locking up fellow human beings
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Takebackourmoney
05:16 PM on 08/05/2010
Prison is big money, ask Arizona. By the way, have they caught the two criminals yet. The MSM has Attention Deficit Disorder.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Brian Koller
Admin for filmsgraded.com
04:42 PM on 08/05/2010
One reason that China has fewer prisoners is that they execute more of them.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
PurpleTomato
Dean of Tomatoes
04:54 PM on 08/05/2010
Do you have a link for that statement?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Brian Koller
Admin for filmsgraded.com
10:38 PM on 08/05/2010
"China executes more people each year than the rest of the world combined."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_rights_in_the_People%27s_Republic_of_China#Capital_punishment
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nosybear
Liar, damned liar and statistician
04:58 PM on 08/05/2010
Facts, please?
04:00 PM on 08/05/2010
It's a sad commentary when John Stewart and Steven Colbert are more trustworthy than the media or government officials.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Daniel R Cobb
05:55 PM on 08/05/2010
It is sad. And I can't help but wonder, how long will they be able to speak? To entertain? At some point, will their networks decide that their satire is too contrary to the interests of the corporation and they'll be taken off the air? I suspect that ten years from now, voices like Stewart and Colbert will be silent. Corporations run America, economically and politically.
03:11 PM on 08/05/2010
Just a thought how many does China execute a year. Might be something in that thought. The death penalty in China has a much lower threshold.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
javajava
Pastafarian Liberal Progressive Socialist Hippie
03:43 PM on 08/05/2010
Europe abolished the death penalty years ago. Other countries Mexico, some in southern Africa, a few in South America have since joined the civilized. Your contention that China executes more means little in light that for some one innocent is too many.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
rlugbill
03:11 PM on 08/05/2010
Thank you for raising this issue. Our criminal justice system is in bad need of reform, yet there is not even any talk of it, much less any political will to change things.

Rather than following public policy research on effective ways to reduce recidivism, we are still using outmoded practices that have been proven not to work. While we have made progress in many other systems, our criminal justice system is largely stuck in the 1800s.

American society is based on two twin pillars of state violence- wars and incarceration. We use violence against other countries and against the poor in this country. None of this violence is productive or helps people.

The criminal justice system needs to be radically reformed and taken out of the hands of the people who think state violence and evil is the solution to all problems.

By the way, I have no criminal record. I am actually an attorney who makes money off our corrupt system. If incarceration were actually decreased, I could lose my job. So, I have a vested interest in the current system, yet realize how corrupt and ineffective it is.

The system is broke. Someone needs to say it, even if it's a TV comedian. Thanks Mr. Colbert.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Imo Verit
03:00 PM on 08/05/2010
“The prisons and court system generates for all of its players as of 2007 a conservative 1.8 trillion dollars a year.”

http://margotbnews.wordpress.com/2010/07/23/modern-political-prisoners-in-america/

Big prisons, big money, it’s the American way.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Daniel R Cobb
02:51 PM on 08/05/2010
This article and Colbert's revelation to the general public about the size of America's prison population are astounding, but then maybe not so much. American is a giant corporation, not a democracy. Because prison corporations can lobby and influence legislation, even serve as a tax base for local communities, and now have the same speech rights as persons (thanks to Justice Roberts and our right-wing Supreme Court), the system is completely rigged to cater to corporations, the people be damned. Combine that with utterly neurotic sentencing requirements and we have the result, the largest per capita prison population in the world. Congratulations! Another embarrassing first for America: The land of the "free". Home of the neurotic. What and who do I blame? Greed. And the corporations who run this country.
02:50 PM on 08/05/2010
yeah. but would you rather be in a Chinese prison or an easy does it, American jail house?

Life in a Chinese prison is much much harsher.. most do not have any heating or AC, no entertainment, and sever penalties for any infractions.. life is hell.
02:58 PM on 08/05/2010
What has that got to do with the fact we have the highest rate of imprisonment, or are you planning to spend a few years in a prison to prove it's the easy life? Granted, our prisoners do get free medical care.
03:02 PM on 08/05/2010
Wasn't there a story about an elderly man robbing a bank to get back into jail for medical care. I bet that's why we have so many in prison, dang librul free-loaders! LOL
09:44 PM on 08/05/2010
In Guangdong province (China) Lack of heating and A/C is not uncommon. I think frugality is the main reason. I understand it is similar in other parts of the country.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
GandenT
02:32 PM on 08/05/2010
In 1970 there were 300,000 people in prison -- a similar number to previous decades -- but then the conservative era started along with their "war on drugs" and crackdown on liberals, women, and minorities who wanted "special treatment" like equal rights... Bringing us right up to the present where we're "not sure" torture, arrest without charges, trials, or evidence, illegal wiretapping, and unprovoked wars of aggression are perfectly legal or not...