iOS app Android app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Jeff Jarvis

Jeff Jarvis

Posted: October 14, 2010 01:03 PM

Love Ya, NPR, But You're Wrong

What's Your Reaction:

NPR has told its staff they may not attend the Stewart/Colbert rallies in Washington at the end of the month. I think they're terribly wrong here, following the journalistic worldview Jay Rosen calls the view-from-nowhere to its extreme and forbidding employees to be curious.

Or as I tweeted: So I guess NPR reporters aren't allowed to be *citizen* journalists.

Oh, I understand the argument: NPR reporters are supposed to be objective and express no political opinion and do nothing political. I went to J-school, too. And we could argue the point as if in a freshman seminar. I say this is merely a lie of omission, telling reporters to *conceal* their viewpoints and making listeners guess where they're coming from (the audience knows that can't be nowhere). Objectivity is just a secret.

Of course, it's amusing that NPR had to backpedal and explain why a similar memo didn't go out about Glenn Beck's rally. That, the network explained, is because Beck's was overtly political. Oh, come on, we're not that dumb. It's because NPR people are not Beck people. NPR people are Stewart people. They have a sense of humor. Oh, and they're liberal. No guessing needed.

And that's OK. It's time for reporters to be open and honest.

But my real problem here is, again, that NPR is forbidding its employees to be curious. There's a big event going on in Washington. It could -- just could -- be the beginning of a movement mobilizing the middle. But NPR people are not allowed to even witness it, to go and try to figure it out, to understand what's being said and why people are there. No, they can do that only if they are *assigned* to do that. Otherwise, it might seem as if by merely showing up they might have a forbidden opinion.

Gasp.

In its effort to be hyperjournalistic NPR is being unjournalistic. Journalists, properly empowered, are curious. They want to know things. NPR is telling them not to ask questions.

And there's something more. A few years ago in Washington at the Online News Association confab -- which this year, it so happens, is being held the same time as the Stewart rally [coincidence? or liberal journalistic conspiracy?] -- I was on a panel back in the good ol' days when we all still yammered on about "citizen journalists" and a newspaper person came the mic in tears -- I swear -- saying, "I'm a citizen, too." Right, I said. So act like one. Citizens are involved in their communities, part of their communities, so they can understand and serve those communities. Journalists tried to separate themselves from their communities (and opinions) and that is much of the reason why journalists lost touch with how to serve them. It is time to get off the pedestal and return to the streets. And the Washington Mall.

I suggest that NPR journalists should protest this order from above. Use social media, folks, and have an opinion about opinions ... or at least about curiosity. Start a Facebook page. Start a Twitter meme. Use all those new tools your bosses are teaching you to tell your bosses about this new world you should be part of.

More: Michael Calderone reprints a Washington Post memo that says employees are allowed to watch the rally from the sidelines. Does that mean they're not allowed to talk to people there? And the New York Times advises staff to avoid such events. Ridiculous. It's as if the people they serve and cover have cooties.

 
 
 

Follow Jeff Jarvis on Twitter: www.twitter.com/jeffjarvis