iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Gov. Jennifer M. Granholm

GET UPDATES FROM Gov. Jennifer M. Granholm
 

Mr. Romney, Have You Seen the 47 Percent?

Posted: 09/18/2012 11:55 pm

Just as Mitt Romney was scrambling to get his message back on track yesterday, yet another shoe dropped. Mother Jones released this video which was secretly recorded at a Romney closed-door event. In the video, Romney tells donors, "... and so my job is not to worry about those people. I'm not going to convince them."

Really? You don't worry about "those people," almost half of America?

That would be a shocking sentiment, if it weren't so disappointingly predictable coming from Mitt Romney.

We've all seen this before:


$10,000 bets. Corporations are people. Let the housing market hit rock bottom. Yada, yada. Now, I don't want to play armchair psychologist, but it seems to me -- taking him at his word -- that Mitt Romney isn't concerned about the 47 percent because he doesn't even see them. That's because he came into the world in a protective bubble and he's basically stayed there for his first 65 years.

Now, lots of people are born wealthy and stay that way. That's not the point. The point is what have you done to pierce the bubble? To see and feel how the other half lives?

There's a Zulu greeting that says: "Sawubona." It means "I see you." The response, "Ngikhona" means "I am here." It's an acknowledgement that you exist now that you've been seen.

I just don't think Mitt Romney has really tried to see those who struggle. But don't take it from me. Mitt himself said, "My job is not to worry about those people."

No, Mitt, your job as president, should you be lucky enough to buy it, is, in fact, exactly to worry about all of the people in this country. Every single one. From a secretary in the company to the CEO. From the hairdresser to the hedge fund manager. From the crack addict who lives in the streets to those who have streets named after them.

A leader makes hundreds of decisions each day. And while Mitt Romney may never consciously consider the 47 percent during a specific decision, his attitude towards them -- who he sees when he sees America -- those things are present in each and every decision that a leader makes. That is what character is all about.

That is why it matters. If a president is guided to favor 53 percent of his people and disregard 47 percent, slowly, but surely, over hundreds and thousands of decisions, his policies and the arc of opportunity will bend away from them.

"My job is not to worry about those people." Well, Mr. Romney, it is our job to worry about you.

Originally aired on The War Room with Jennifer Granholm. The War Room airs weeknights at 10 p.m. EST on Current TV. Follow Jennifer Granholm on Facebook and Twitter, and The War Room on Facebook and Twitter.

 
 
 

Follow Gov. Jennifer M. Granholm on Twitter: www.twitter.com/JenGranholm

FOLLOW POLITICS
Just as Mitt Romney was scrambling to get his message back on track yesterday, yet another shoe dropped. Mother Jones released this video which was secretly recorded at a Romney closed-door event. In...
Just as Mitt Romney was scrambling to get his message back on track yesterday, yet another shoe dropped. Mother Jones released this video which was secretly recorded at a Romney closed-door event. In...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 1,013
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (17 total)
10:20 PM on 09/30/2012
Wow she took this so out of context to serve her own royal hiney. He's pushing for voters. He's saying if he labels his campaign with grandois anouncements that make his $50K per plate pig Repub greasers happy, it will do nothing to raise the love of the 47% who aren't paying taxes. To that 47%, even WITHOUT paying taxes, they are barely making ends meet. Mitt is DEAD ON STRAIGHT, and opponents will continue to manipulate the heart of his message for their own benefit. Better walk the talk though Mitt. If you're smart enough and brave enough to know you already have the Repub vote, and only need to focus on strengthening America for the hard working middle and lower classes, you're on your way to gaining votes from non-partisan, and possibly even Dems.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
maoticamison
09:24 AM on 09/24/2012
Maybe he'll garner votes from those eager to prove they're not among the 47%...
every little bit helps and there are peoplewho may decide that the only way to suggest that they are not "freeloaders' is to vote for someone who will then, somehow "recognize" their independence...there's one born every minute.
photo
scythus
*sigh* because they don't let it trickle down.....
09:43 PM on 09/23/2012
You want the "47%" to pay taxes maybe we should get them jobs and pay them a living wage. Minimum wage is about half what it takes to live as lower middle class last I'd checked....
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
se72748
09:40 PM on 09/23/2012
Mitt try's not to see the forty seven percent.We are unwashed heathens in his mind.Did you notice he did not offer to shake the hand of any of those coal miners ,who were compelled to go to his rally?.He hardly even looked at them.Disdain was written all over Romney's face ,to even share the same stage with them.
09:03 PM on 09/23/2012
Seen em? Why Jennifer, I've not only seen em up close and personal, I've taken their pensions and fired em on first sight!
08:21 PM on 09/23/2012
And let's not forget his remark about not wanting to put Ann forward too much because people might "tire" of her.

When my husband heard that he was stunned - a man worrying about his wife "tiring" people??? Another example of Mitt's being out of touch - even with his own wife!
02:18 AM on 09/30/2012
where is that? I would like the link!~ What crazy times we live in when you realize this shell of a
man is even in consideration to be leader of this country.
02:08 PM on 10/01/2012
If you watch the whole video it's there. I think it was Colbert who did a segment on it. Seriously, Romney said it!!
08:09 PM on 09/23/2012
And this is the problem with electing someone on the basis of their success in business - in a business, you can get rid of those you don't want to deal with or who you feel aren't pulling their weight. You can't do that when you run a country, What's he going to do if he gets to be President - fire anyone he doesn't feel is up to his standards (whatever they are)? Doesn't work that way. Can't send nearly half the population to another country, unlike when you take over a company (ethics aside).
07:33 PM on 09/23/2012
The government started the housing bubble. In fact, Obama's lawsuit against the banks was one of the original causes. If you really cared about poor people, you would support Romney. Obama is creating more and more poverty every day. He is a complete disaster. I guess you are too partisan to actually care.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
maoticamison
09:40 AM on 09/24/2012
Technically he was on a team of 8 lawyers which filed the suit, not for poor people to get loans but to limit CitiBanks' rather prevalent practice of discriminating against minority borrowers who were in similar financial circumstance to non minority borrowers who did get the loans.

CitiBank paid up...but the "sub prime" loans, and the student loans, and the auto loans and a few other interest producing instruments began to look good enough to the banks, as marketable entities in themselves that a couple of new words or three entered the finance realm...securitization, and CDO...and derivatives...leveraging of course was already there but kinda got on steroids.And then there was that little bit of legedermaine practiced by a few ratings experts whose expertise became at one point...just "opinions...".It's complicated, but several factors, of necessity contributed to the bubble's bust...mostly greed and arrogance
photo
open a book sometime
in every war the first casualty is the truth
06:48 PM on 09/23/2012
Mitt is probably the only person who when traveling abroad his horizons become smaller rather than broader
photo
georgemorris61
Life is a journey,not a trip
06:10 PM on 09/23/2012
Jennifer Granholme I can never say thank-you enough for reminding America of who we are and what we represent. May God continue to bless and guide the women of our nation who lead the charge for all those who are marginalized and taken for granted..........................You make me proud.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
chlai88
Change is the only constant
05:55 PM on 09/23/2012
It reflects a larger GOP mindset. They see people only as votes. To be wooed during the elections & then discarded. Their real plan is just to see their ideology of top-down, rich-poor economics get implemented. It's not about the economy, it's all about the division, stu-pid. Their election strategy is to convince the 53% to think that they are unfairly subsidizing the 47%. We've seen that division get Scott Walker elected. They're using the same game plan here.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
maoticamison
09:43 AM on 09/24/2012
It's not only that people are just votes...each one of them is a possible source of cheap labor.And if you get enough of them, they're disposable.
05:07 PM on 09/23/2012
watch and weep https://vimeo.com/49466232
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
John Dillingerr
revolt against tyranny
09:14 PM on 09/23/2012
i watched that video and have a question

wtf are homeless people doing with dogs?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
maoticamison
09:46 AM on 09/24/2012
Well...they're cheaper than cattle and slower than rats.So when push comes to shove...hahahahaha...just kidding, lots of people enjoy some kind of companionship.Even those you wouldn't think of.And dogs are sometimes wild, too.
photo
TKI
sage from a distant star world
03:15 PM on 09/23/2012
the guy is stiff and aloof...has to wait every time for the wife to turn his head so that he can look in your direction; still, does he even see you then
02:37 PM on 09/24/2012
Are you kidding. If Romney gets elected, it will actually be Anne who is running this country.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
huhwatjusay
02:34 PM on 09/23/2012
If this video of Romney and his 47% statements was the the only example of Romney's attitude towards "you people" it would be different- but it's simply not. Both he and his wife have presented to America a picture of two people who give the impression they are better than "you people". This video merely put on record what people have perceived him to be for many, many years. Here is a guy who will say or do anything...buy out or knock out anyone who will get in his way because the end justifies the means. The statements made -while in HIS comfort zone in this private fundraiser video shows the character of a man unfit to lead this nation. Don't even get me started on his so-called "bus-tour"...the driver took the bus while Romney jetted to the next location. He knows the 47% only by those little specks he sees from 35,000 feet.
09:43 PM on 09/23/2012
LOL. And when Mr Obama thinks the mic is off he insults PM Netanyahu to French Pres Sarcosi , and tells the Russia ambassador to let Rusian Pres Putin know that he can be more flexible with negotiations after the election. What character. BTW, Obamas $1.1 million tour bus was made in Canada.
How about that unemployment rate?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
huhwatjusay
10:33 PM on 09/23/2012
It's rather clear that your primary source of misguided "information" emanates directly from FOX- first we'll deal with the bus- purchased in Tenn...not one, but two. Certain specifications were outfitted in Canada. BOTH Presidential candidates will be using them. Only Romney's will not be fitted with  codes to the country's nuclear arsenal. Thank goodness, he will never have charge of these. Also, in case your selective memory disposes of additional facts that do not comply with your complaints, in 2004, GW Bush also had a bus manufactured by the same Quebec company. The statement to the new "leader" of Russia was entirely understandable given the putrid environment in DC with the obstruction of the GOP so that nothing can be done.  As far as Bibi is concerned- his intrusion into the political season here is offensive and wrong. We will not have our President or our foreign policy dictated by any country...any.  Bibi is running for re-election. His posturing is evident. 
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
maoticamison
09:49 AM on 09/24/2012
Jeez, dude..."I can't make any definitive decisions at present...I don't even have the job yet.But once I get settled in I'll have more "flexibility" to consider different ideas.

Sometimes words are important...so some are careful how they use them.
02:13 PM on 09/23/2012
I'm really tired of Ayn Randian fantasies where everything would be just perfect if only all "those people" would die off.

What so many of them forget is that it's "those people" who actually work crazy hours in factories making their products, who clean their houses and businesses, who staff the restaurants and bring them their foie gras and quail, drive them around, build the buildings and pick the food? I'd love to see those guys who whine about paying people so little money that they don't get taxed on it have to deal with having to either deal with a world where they either went without the fruits of "those people's" labor and/or had to do some of that crap themselves. Can you imagine Adelson and the like having to cook, clean and wash their own clothes?
07:35 PM on 09/23/2012
Great post! Every job should be seen as integral to our society and everyone should earn enough to be secure food, shelter, and health care. Romney's suggestion that these are the unreasonable demands of slackers is deplorable.
08:24 PM on 09/23/2012
Bravo for you. Totally agree. None of us would have so much as a loaf of bread on our tables without the labor of 1,000's of our fellow citizens. The ingratitude of these takers is stunning.

But then, the Romneys do not really see the "little people." Which is what makes it even more amusing that this video was pretty obviously shot by one of the staff at Daddy Warbuck's mansion. Poetic justice.