More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Jennifer Schwab

Jennifer Schwab

Posted: August 20, 2009 10:04 PM

Air and Water: A Right or Privilege for all Citizens?

What's Your Reaction:

While it may shorten your life, you can still live and breathe with poor air quality. Such is the case for many citizens of industrial megacities like Bangkok, Jakarta, Kuala Lumpur, Shanghai, New Delhi, Mumbai and Beijing, among others. When it comes to water, however, cleanliness and freshness is essential to support life. In a growing number of nations, fresh water for drinking and hygiene is either not readily available, or, available only to those who can pay for it. Every human being is entitled to free air to breathe, but what about water to drink?

The shrinking supply of clean drinking water worldwide is on a collision course with its relentlessly growing population. And in a number of developing world countries such as Bolivia, Honduras, Nicaragua, Angola, and others, private for-profit corporations are taking over the water supply and charging high prices for this previously free commodity. In many cases, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and World Bank are behind this strategy.

The world's three leading for-profit water firms -- Vivendi, Suez and Thames -- would counter that they are installing an infrastructure to support a supply of clean fresh water that otherwise would not be built by the governments of these under-financed nations. They also provide jobs and inject significant sums into otherwise struggling local economies.

So who is right? Nobody can charge citizens for the air we breathe. Should water be for sale or is it a basic human right? Is it possible for sustainable social policies and multinational, public companies to coexist? I think the answer is no. If Vivendi, Suez or Thames invest the capital to install the clean drinking water infrastructure and their business model is to sell drinking water, how can they be required to give it away to local citizens? This is the quandary we face especially in the developing world. Company CEOs and Board Members will argue they have a responsibility to their shareholders to maximize profits, while local governments have a responsibility to their citizens. These poor countries, most often targeted for privatized water systems, need infrastructure and money to provide clean drinking water. Private companies feel that by providing these essentials, they have the right to charge for water consumption, regardless of the consumer's socioeconomic status.

This presents a classic zero sum game. There are many who say the green movement will lead us out of the worldwide recession. However, it remains to be seem who will support the upfront costs to do so. As I see it, meeting half way offers the best solution. The water companies that have been making billions off developing world water systems are going to have to sacrifice maximizing profits for basic human kindness. The developing world is going to have to transition into paying for water, but hopefully, at a reduced price that is achievable. For social equity and economy to coexist, we all must sacrifice something. Right now, as the economy is trying to recover, we need to get comfortable with this paradigm shift -- profit maximizing is out for the very rich corporations and constant hand-outs are not sustainable for the very poor nations.

I'd love to read your comments, as of course, there is no right answer to these complex issues. Here's hoping that somehow, collectively, we will find a way to clean up our air and water, and make it free for all citizens of the world.

 

Follow Jennifer Schwab on Twitter: www.twitter.com/SCGreen_Home

 
 
  • Comments
  • 36
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
05:05 PM on 09/03/2009
Water should be a basic human right. It should be free, and everyone should have access to it. But as long as stupid, lazy people continue to pay $2.99 or whatever for it because it comes it a pretty plastic bottle, companies will continue to charge for it.
04:50 PM on 09/03/2009
I just recently read an article that because of the economy, bottled-water sales are plummeting. Obviously the companies selling bottled water are hopeful that when the market improves, people will begin to purchase again. I, on the other hand, am hopeful that people realize how unnecessary and wasteful bottled water is. It wastes money and precious resources.
02:49 PM on 08/27/2009
It's nice to read all of these comments! I just wanted to add what I do at home in order to conserve and reuse my water. When I shower I have a little suction cup timer on a tile that I set for no more than 5 mins! This really allows me to regulate my use of water... and if you're interested you can even calculate how many gallons you use per shower, per bath, per dish load. Also, I use only organic and natural bath additives. I bathe in oats, wash my hair with henna, and make my own chamomile scrub. So.. when I bathe then I can allow all the organics to sink to the bottom than use the tub water. Filter it through a strainer and maybe even a Brita filter... then I water all my plants! It's a great cycle. I have a lot of plants... so I reuse the water and put it to work again. They love the extra nutrients and I rarely use fertilizer or pesticides! Let me know if you guys want more advice or info. Thanks!
04:47 PM on 09/03/2009
That's a really great idea. It sounds like a lot of work but good for you for really caring about your impact on the environment!http://www.huffingtonpost.com/jennifer-schwab/air-and-water-a-right-or_b_264733.html?show_comment_id=29715332#
07:16 PM on 08/26/2009
This is really upsetting to read for me because my house was built in 2006. I don’t seem to have any problems, but if I would have known this then, I definitely would have done more research about the house before I bought it. Very informative, thank you for such a great article.
04:29 PM on 08/25/2009
Clean water is certainly something people in developed countries take for granted. Many people complain when they don't have their bottle of Figi (which is probably no cleaner than tap-water), when there are people whose only water supply is literally littered with toxins and too poisonous to drink. I think it would be beneficial to this issue to also look at the poisons that are causing water supplies to be undrinkable...like the unbelievable amount of e-waste and toxins that pollute water supplies in developing countries. Addressing these issues is important to help keep the clean water we do have stay that way.
06:50 PM on 08/24/2009
"There are many who say the green movement will lead us out of the worldwide recession."

I believe in this statement for so many reasons. First off, the green movement will provide thousands upon thousands of new green jobs. Secondly, conservation is the key to removing oneself from a recession. A key element to the green movement is conserving. Thank you for the article!
05:51 PM on 09/03/2009
The green movement has the possibility of leading us out of the worldwide recession, but for some reason I think it scares a lot of people. Perhaps people hear "environmentally friendly" and automatically think that it will cost more money...and isn't that often the truth?
06:34 PM on 08/24/2009
Check this out.....
http://www.sierraclubgreenhome.com/go-green/water-fixtures-and-plumbing/water-conservation-advice/

Water conservation education!
05:19 PM on 08/24/2009
"So who is right? Nobody can charge citizens for the air we breathe. Should water be for sale or is it a basic human right? Is it possible for sustainable social policies and multinational, public companies to coexist?"

These are great questions that unfortunately, we have to answer. I think essentials like water should be free, but the powers that be don't think so.
06:28 PM on 09/03/2009
Actually you can charge for air. Ever been to an oxygen bar? ;)
11:48 AM on 08/24/2009
I love Marc's comments on the subject here, and we definitely need to do more as it pertains to water conservation. 30 min. showers are absolutely ridiculous given some of the conditions Jennifer's speaking about!
01:36 PM on 09/03/2009
Yah, I wish people would be more aware of the amount of water they use. Maybe if water was more expensive, people would think twice.
05:59 PM on 08/21/2009
The UN is involved in this water issue. They've been warning for years that water shortages are gonna be one of the most important concerns in the world over the next decade or so. They also said that by 2050, about 4 billion people will have to face this water crisis.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Abi Wright
Professional Hippie Rockstar
02:08 AM on 08/24/2009
Great info-- you must go to the website:
http://www.un.org/waterforlifedecade/
It has a ton of info on the UN's stand on water issues and sanitation.
05:58 PM on 08/21/2009
Hello Fellow Readers,

I need a little advice. I hope someone can help! I'm looking to improve the air and water quality in my house, but I don't really know where to start. I know plants and filters can improve air quality, along with leaving your shoes at the entry. But, what about water quality? Should I invest in a filter? Please help.

I would appreciate any replies and/or recommended websites.

Thanks,
Laura
07:02 PM on 08/21/2009
You know Jennifer Schwab, the writer of this blog, is the Director of Sustainability for Sierra Club Green Home, so I checked out her site. It's pretty cool. Lots of helpful articles and stuff. They have an article dedicated to water filters.
Here it is http://www.sierraclubgreenhome.com/go-green/water-fixtures-and-plumbing/water-filters/. Hope it helps.
Also, the National Resources Defense Council has an article on water filters. http://www.nrdc.org/water/drinking/gfilters.asp. Check it out- it's pretty good.
05:51 PM on 08/21/2009
How can we take 30 min showers in the United States when some peeps in countries like Africa have to travel miles just for fresh water? America needs to do a better job educating the people about this water crisis. Here's an article that I read about a family in India paying the hefty price for a drop of water. http://www.thenational.ae/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20090808/MAGAZINE/708079996/-1/OPINION
05:47 PM on 08/21/2009
Does anyone have any information on how I can learn more about air and water human rights? Couldn't this be an issue for the United Nations?
05:43 PM on 08/21/2009
I'm sure we've all seen the pics of da kidz that are bare-footin it next to the polluted ponds and streams and it's a shame. These people all under extreme livin conditions and no wonder they dyin of all kinds of diseases. The more fortunate ones like America, needs to help those in need because it's the right thing to do. The better water, the better da living conditions and then the better economy for that country is what I think.
05:42 PM on 08/21/2009
Unfortunately, I have to agree with the Huffington Post Pimp. We do need to focus on us right now, then go back to help others. I'm sorry Abi, but your dig at Mr. Pimp is wrong. This has nothing to do with his ego or thinking about himself. He seems to be focused on Americans. And even if he were, it's still his civil right to voice his opinion w/o the likes of you getting in the way of that opinion. Yes I believe it's wrong that other countries don't have fresh, clean water, but we do have to fix what's going on in this country first before anything else. Great write nonetheless Jennifer!