Ever since photos of Madonna's halftime show stage leaked on Tuesday, showing a Vogue'd out set, there was speculation about whether or not the 53 -year old Queen of Pop would return to her exhibitionist roots. (Though we all knew it would be hard to top Janet Jackson's 2004 halftime show performance on the scandal scale).
Madonna did get down on her knees, but this time it was in a sequined gospel robe alongside Cee Lo Green and flanked by a choir. There was no stage-humping, though there was voguing. Sometimes it was hard to know what to think: Were those cartwheels a demonstration of Madonna's athletic prowess, or awkward and a little too ambitious? Was there any reason for Nicki Minaj and M.I.A. to be involved, given how little they contributed to "Give Me All Your Lovin'?" (aside from M.I.A. flipping off the viewers at home). Did Madonna really need to straddle that tall guy from L.M.F.A.O., post-(admittedly excellent) co-shuffle?
And if you weren't a fan, what do you wish Madonna had done differently? Let us know what would have made Madonna's Super Bowl halftime performance perfect you by tweeting @HuffPost Women with hashtag #MadonnaRemix.
SLIDESHOW: What You Thought of Madonna's Performance
Follow Jessica Pearce Rotondi on Twitter: www.twitter.com/jessicarotondi