More

Jillian York

Jillian York

Posted: July 26, 2008 01:16 PM

The Iranian-Jewish-American Constituency Weighs In


Immigrant communities in the US, whether able to vote or not, have so far played a public role in this year's elections. Many, fed up with US foreign policy, are looking to the incoming president, whomever it may be, for change. One such community is the large Iranian-American Jewish community, the majority of whom live in California. A recent article and podcast, in the The Jewish Journal, focuses on the opinions of that community and their concerns with foreign policy.

The podcast, which can be found here, focuses on political participation from the community and their views on the two main candidates. An excerpt:

If you would've asked me this about 10 or 15 years ago, I would've said the involvement would be low to minimal to zero. Now, the community has brought itself out on all different levels, be it on the federal level with the national election, be it on the city level with our next mayoral election, be it on the city council level both here in Beverly Hills and the City of Los Angeles. On a national level, I see it going both ways - the Persian Jewish community likes McCain because of his obvious stance on national security, which is something that's very important to us. Some are very turned off by that and the fact that he says we might stay in Iraq for 100 years...there's definitely a cost and a loss of life component of that. But uh...some are also turned on by the fact that he wants to go invade Iran - there are a lot of people who still live here who have a lot of sentiment toward Iran, you know, I don't blame people....The younger generation, they go with Obama and the democratic party. It's not just about change but it's about something new. And uh, that Barack Obama brings to the table. I really see a divide among the generations.

Those interviewed in the podcast also discussed economics as it relates to political preference, as well as a bit of history surrounding Persian Jewish participation in politics.

The accompanying article makes further note of the generation gap in the Persian Jewish community, as well as why Persian Jews are unlikely to support Obama:

Iran is indeed an issue during the election this year and it is particularly important for local Iranian Jews because the majority of them have suffered at the hands of Iran's regime during or after the 1979 revolution. Obama's calls to negotiate with Iran's current regime does not sit well with older Iranian American Jews because many had their assets confiscated by the regime or were terrorized by the regime. So they do not want to see the Iranian Ayatollahs rewarded by any American administration's welcoming gestures that will legitimize their rule in Iran. Some of Obama's foreign policy advisers are also former Carter administration advisers who older Iranian Jews and other Iranian Americans blame for helping to bring the current Islamic fundamentalist regime to power in Iran nearly 30 years ago.

Any errors in transcription are the author's own

Follow Jillian York on Twitter: www.twitter.com/jilliancyork

 
 
  • Comments
  • 5
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
09:17 PM on 07/30/2008
There is no "THE Jewish-Iranian constituency" -- Iranian Jews and nonJews, just like Hispanics, Catholics, Blondes, left-handed people, do not have a hive mind. In fact Iranian Jews are very, very Iranian and have deep cultural roots in that nation and don't want to see it attacked. Most Iranians will tell you that sanctions and threats only strengthen the regime, while engagement would undermine it.
07:49 PM on 07/28/2008
The Iranian-Jewish-American, the Asian-Americans, the African-Americans, the Cuban-Americans, the Italian-Americans and the lisrt goes on................ WHERE WILL THIS END?

IT'S NO WONDER THE COUNTRY IS DIVIDED ................. AREN'T WE ALL JUST AMERICAN?
03:09 PM on 07/28/2008
Iranian-American community is as diverse as any group in the United States. The majority of this group is very educated, progressive and support issues that are often expressed by Senator McCain.

Iranian-American of Jewish faith (Persian Jews) is not any different than any other Iranian-Americans in their attitudes and support for democratic principles.
01:27 PM on 07/29/2008
I disagree. It's understandable but Jewish Iranians are divided in their loyalties towards Iran and Israel. Muslim Iranians are less aligned with keeping Israel as the first priority. And the words progressive and McCain in one sentence canceled each other out. There is nothing progressive about that candidate. And yes, there are conservative Republican Iranian-Muslim Americans who want the Islamic Republic to become a bad memory but they are less inclined to Iraq Iran than their Jewish counterparts. I live in the Iranian community. I'm Iranian. I think the use of the word Persian, however, is pretentious. The American leaders convinced the Shah to take on the word Iran/Iranian and that's what it's called...
12:49 PM on 07/28/2008
It's very interesting because like many Iranian-Muslim Americans, my family lost everything after the revolution but most of us support Obama because we don't want to see our homeland and heritage destroyed, especially when the people who will die don't support their president. Also, we do not want the country of Iran to be occupied and see our past mistakes. Diplomacy will open the channels of regime-change. Right now, the populations of the enslaved Muslim nations (lead by our allies) look to Iran. If Iran is attacked, it will be like striking a hornet's nest in the region--less so in Iran-proper. And what's not said by the Jewish-Iranian communities is what's problematic. They were not persecuted so much for being Jewish but for supporting the Shah and Israel (again, the white-washing is of anti-semitism versus anti-zionism). Many Muslims too (many more than Jews; compare thousands versus a handful) were persecuted, murdered. We must remember that just as if an Iranian were to do illicit business in propping up Iran's current regime right now, it was then frowned upon for an Iranian (Jewish or otherwise) to do business with Israel. This past fall, we had a slew of novels (categorized under Jewish history, not Iranian history) exaggerating the truth for political ends. Many Jewish Iranians in California travel to and from Iran on business protected by their Jewish status. Send a Muslim from the old guard and he will be instantly executed.