More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
James Moore

GET UPDATES FROM James Moore
 

Mitt Still Can't Beat Rick

Posted: 09/23/11 08:54 AM ET

Mitt Romney is emerging as the grown-up in the GOP primary process, which is too bad. He will not win the nomination. He would make the strongest candidate for the Republicans in 2012 but he cannot win the primaries. The primary process does not require sanity and moderation in the GOP race. The candidate must appeal to the Tea Party, evangelicals, fundamentalists, and right wing conservatives who vote on social issues.

And they rarely vote for Mormons.

Romney's problems with the radical right go a bit beyond his religion. He has refused to sign an abortion pledge because the way it was worded meant that too many federally funded hospitals would be forced to close. He decided that everyone in his state ought to have health care and passed a bill his own party derisively calls Romneycare. He thinks that global warming is a real issue but he is not sure about human contribution to the problem. And he doesn't seem afire with desire to stop gay people from getting married.

Romney makes too much sense to win this GOP nominating process.

And lucky Ricky Perry is the guy in the perfect position to win by default. The Texas governor is neither as smart or as poised as the former Massachusetts governor but he's close enough to be the first choice of the primary voters who will take their anger against Obama into the polls this winter and into next spring. Romney's repeated squishiness on social issues will give them pause and then his religion will help them make their decision to vote for Perry. He is consistently conservative on the social issues that matter to primary voters.

And he is not a Mormon.

Religion is the biggest issue in the GOP primary and it is being completely ignored in the debates and public discourse. The only way a Republican can win back the White House in 2012 is with a southern strategy that turns out huge numbers of conservative Christian voters. And conservative Christian voters do not view the Mormon faith as being a part of Christendom. If Romney is the nominee, they will stay home and President Obama will be easily reelected. Romney's campaign keeps trying to suggest that a tiny percentage of evangelical voters will ignore him because of his faith, which is unfounded optimism.

James Gimpel, a GOP political scientist and consultant, argued in the Boston Globe that Romney is failing to recognize what could be an "insurmountable" problem with fundamentalist Christians. "The question is whether a church-going Christian is willing to set those differences aside as irrelevant to holding the office of president, or take them quite seriously as heretical and cultish. There are a great many evangelical Christians who would have a hard time justifying a vote for Romney under any circumstances."

But they are enthusiastic about the wildly conservative Christian Rick Perry.

Republicans must carry the south, including Florida and Texas, to win the presidency because they will split the plains states and the Intermountain West. The president will win New York and California and the Northeast and the election will come down to the Midwest. Ohio, Indiana, Michigan, Illinois, and Pennsylvania are the electoral votes that will pick the president. Romney can do well in that part of the country; his father was a popular governor of Michigan. But it is irrelevant unless he wins the south and that is impossible. A Mormon cannot win Texas, Oklahoma, Tennessee, Virginia, Florida, Alabama, Mississippi, the Carolinas, and, consequently, the White House.

A 2007 Pew poll reported that 43% of Christians do not believe Mormonism is a Christian religion and among Christian evangelicals that number jumps to 57%. The unanswered question until Election Day is how many of those evangelicals will cast a ballot for a Mormon, who has also been vague or contrarian on social issues that matter to religious conservatives. A significant number of these people view Mormonism as a cult. They will not vote for Mitt Romney.

Rick Perry will have to make a huge mistake to lose this GOP election. Christian conservatives in Iowa will make him a big winner. If he loses in New Hampshire, where Romney has a home and has been campaigning for four years, Perry will win handily in South Carolina as well as Florida. On Super Tuesday, which includes (under current GOP scheduling rules) states like Oklahoma, Texas, Tennessee, and Virginia, Perry will win handily. Romney has the resources to stay at least through that March 6th multi-state contest but the race will not last any longer and he will be forced to concede.

Romney and Jon Huntsman, both Mormons, are the best candidates for the GOP to have a chance against President Obama. But neither of them will survive the primaries because of their faith. Rick Perry will win.

And the GOP will lose.

Also at: http://www.moorethink.com

 
 
 

Follow James Moore on Twitter: www.twitter.com/moorethink

 
 
  • Comments
  • 470
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (11 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
GoDems2012
I've got the POTUS' back!
01:59 PM on 09/26/2011
I find it interesting that the only reason conservatives think their nominee will "crush" the President is because people do not like him or his policies, NOT because the GOP has something to offer voters. I suspect that deep down they know this is not how elections work but they are trying to repeat it enough so they will believe it. After all, GWB was not well liked in 2004 but he won re-election anyway.
photo
VivaldiPickpocket
"Bringing news to its sneeze."
07:39 PM on 09/23/2011
Watch Romney identify his running mate by as early as next spring, a selection that will reflect the calculated wishes of power brokers (Karl Rove, anyone?) operating stealthily within the deepest chambers of the GOP election machine. They will not allow Perry to get the nomination, not just because they do not like the man, but because they know he cannot win in the general election.

Stay tuned . . .
06:56 PM on 09/23/2011
I disagree, Romney is beating Perry in Florida and New Hampshire, he has a high chance of winning the Repub nomination, but beating Obama, that's another thing, it will not be easy!!.
09:04 PM on 09/23/2011
Yes, Obama's incredible record of achievement will be very difficult for Romney to run against.
11:56 PM on 09/23/2011
In fact, Obama has a good record so far. Other than employment figures, he's been a pretty successful president. Good news for him is that the unemployment rate we enjoy today is not his doing. No policies he's enacted have prevented it from going down. It's the structural issues our economy faces that is the problem, and we all know any attempt to remedy those comes with obligatory obstruction by Republicans.

Here's an idea, companies selling goods here made in China must pay payroll taxes for each employee used in the manufacture of those goods. This will somewhat level the playing field.
06:50 PM on 09/23/2011
I agree. Mitt's arrogance and overconfidence along with the establishment's over hype of him being able to beat President Obama will be his downfall. Remember, Hillary though she was unbeatable, and candidates like Giuliani thought they had the nod in their back pocket just like Mitt does.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dr Scott
All I ask is that you make sense
06:47 PM on 09/23/2011
Thank God! I hope Moore is right. As long as Huntsman or Johnson don't rise in popularity, Democrats have this one in the bag because Perry can't beat anybody.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Steve-G
Forget party loyalty: follow the money!
06:46 PM on 09/23/2011
With all due respect Mr. Moore, you underestimate how much the tea-vangelicals hate Obama. It doesn't matter to them that he is actually more of a centrist democrat than a fire breathing liberal because he represent progress that undermines their view of the natural order of things. Obama's policies represent an existential threat to their reverence for the myth of self-reliance. Why? Because to allow for health care to be regulated, you have to first admit that the deck is actually stacked against the little guy in the first place. Similarly, with regards to regulation of the banks, you have to admit that Wall Street is actually more like a rigged casino that has been sucking the life out of the little guy courtesy of 410k's that subsidizing those crooks. It would require a recognition of how rigged the system is against certain groups actually being able to achieve self-reliance. The integrity of their belief system is what is threatened by such policies. That's what's really at stake here and why the evangelicals in particular are so incensed and willing to let the country go down the tubes rather than allow government to successfully do anything.

Thus, while I certainly agree that their enthusiasm will not be the same if Romney is the nominee because of the points you have made, I think you are seriously underestimating the opposition.

Everyone needs to turn out in the droves in 2012!
01:21 AM on 09/24/2011
Except for this point, "With all due respect Mr. Moore, you underestim­ate how much the tea-vangel­icals hate Obama.", I think that you hit the mark on all counts. It isn't that I think that you are wrong on this point. It's quite the contrary. I think that you overvalue the tea-vangelicals' numbers. While they hate Obama I don't think they have the numbers to influence the general election all alone.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Steve-G
Forget party loyalty: follow the money!
02:40 AM on 09/24/2011
I actually wanted to add more, but was limited in the number of words for a single post. What you are saying about the evangelical's numbers is true, of course. But part of what is going in addition, is the influx of libertarians into the republican party. That adds to their numbers. And these are all folks that are way motivated to defeat Obama for the reasons I mentioned in my last post since the self-reliance myth is central to libertarian philosophy. On top of that, we have an economy in the tank, which is certainly not going to be turning around by the election. And, whether or not its fair, people tend to vote their pocket books and kick incumbents out in bad economic times. Last, when you consider how unenthusiastic progressives are about Obama, the election is certainly not going to be a slam dunk as long the Republican's elect a moderate. If they go hard right, then, Obama's chances improve--though there is a danger of the election getting stolen via republican state legislatures gerrymandering the electoral split in favor of their party. So, my point is its really, really important to get out there in 2012.
photo
wolfdancer
Republicans -this is why we can't have nice things
06:44 PM on 09/23/2011
Not only Mormons but also Catholics. Who was the last Republican presidential nominee that was a Catholic.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
redscarecrow
Friend of Mr Milo
06:36 PM on 09/23/2011
Obama-Perry-Romney, no Democrats in the race.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tracy Kline
06:34 PM on 09/23/2011
I agree that Perry still has the most momentum and buzz. And I agree that Perry would be less of a challenge to Obama then Romney would.

But I don't like either of them anyway. The only candidate from the GOP I support is Ron Paul.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
stillbarbi
Keep Reading
06:28 PM on 09/23/2011
"But they are enthusiastic about the wildly conservative Christian Rick Perry. "

He can call himself a Christian all he wants, but he's not a Christian.

"Matthew 25:34-40 34"Then the King will say to those on his right, 'Come, you who are blessed by my Father; take your inheritance, the kingdom prepared for you since the creation of the world. 35For I was hungry and you gave me something to eat, I was thirsty and you gave me something to drink, I was a stranger and you invited me in, 36I needed clothes and you clothed me, I was sick and you looked after me, I was in prison and you came to visit me.'

37"Then the righteous will answer him, 'Lord, when did we see you hungry and feed you, or thirsty and give you something to drink? 38When did we see you a stranger and invite you in, or needing clothes and clothe you? 39When did we see you sick or in prison and go to visit you?'

40"The King will reply, 'I tell you the truth, whatever you did for one of the least of these brothers of mine, you did for me.'
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rda1911a1
God Bless John Browning
06:41 PM on 09/23/2011
where does michelle obama's 48k dollar diamond bracelet fit into a christian life?
06:59 PM on 09/23/2011
Irrelevant.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
stillbarbi
Keep Reading
07:01 PM on 09/23/2011
The quote I posted from the article is about Rick Perry being a Christian. He's not, other than in name only.

The article is not about Michelle Obama. At least wait until she is relevant to the story to bash her. What you're referring to is a watch, which was a gift. She didn't buy it.

"The first lady of Ghana, Mrs. Ernestina Naadu Mills has given America’s first lady Michelle Obama a gold watch valued at $48,000, according to a US Federal Register report released in the US Tuesday."

http://www.ghanabusinessnews.com/2011/01/20/naadu-mills-gives-michelle-obama-48000-gold-watch/
Ready to Vote
Jan 2013 End of Error- HURRY
06:26 PM on 09/23/2011
The author can't come to grips with the fact that either will CLOBBER Obama.

The GOP will rally around their nominee regardless of who they are.

Anybody But Obama!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rda1911a1
God Bless John Browning
06:41 PM on 09/23/2011
This republican will stay home if romney is the nominee
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
2012 POTUS 45
44's defeat will be SWEET
06:53 PM on 09/23/2011
Home | Headline
Tags: Barack Obama | Mitt Romney | 2012 President Race | 2012 GOP Primary | Rick Perry | Christie | president
Chris Christie Reconsidering 2012 Run, Will Decide in Days

Read more on Newsmax.com: Chris Christie Reconsidering 2012 Run, Will Decide in Days
Important: Do You Support Pres. Obama's Re-Election? Vote Here Now!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
srheard
Life is full of a number of things.
06:41 PM on 09/23/2011
If the Republican Party believed that, they would not be changing the rules for casting electoral votes before the 2012 election. They think it will be close, and splitting electoral votes in PA could make the difference. Theocratic Plutocracy, here we come!
06:25 PM on 09/23/2011
Wrong. Mitt will win the nomination and the election.
Ready to Vote
Jan 2013 End of Error- HURRY
06:30 PM on 09/23/2011
As long as Obama is DEFEATED!
07:00 PM on 09/23/2011
Wishful thinking based on no logic.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
vesaversa1
Politics is made up largely of irrelevancies.
06:18 PM on 09/23/2011
If Perry win the GOP'ers primary Obama beat him by a landslide. If Romney win President Obama beat him by 4% points.
Ready to Vote
Jan 2013 End of Error- HURRY
06:27 PM on 09/23/2011
Obama is already "one & done."
12:05 AM on 09/24/2011
Biy, will you be depressed Nov 2012...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
FactsvsFear
06:53 PM on 09/23/2011
Yep.
06:11 PM on 09/23/2011
"Rick Perry will win.

And the GOP will lose. "

Yes, and the corporatist oligarchy will win, because Obama will sign anything they put in front of him.

The operating principle will be "hey, at least Rick Perry isn't President, so stomach Obama's signature on bills cutting Medicare, Medicaid and Social Security and extending (again) the Bush tax cuts, because things (Rick Perry) could be (Rick Perry) a lot worse (Rick Perry)."

They're setting you up, people. They LIVE to set you up. They have focus groups, think tanks, research institutes, and they craft a detailed strategy to SET YOU UP.

Only Nixon could go to China, and only Obama can gut Social Security.
06:06 PM on 09/23/2011
If Perry wins, that will make Obama a more obvious choice for anyone who is even slightly reasonable. Let's just hope there is still a reasonable majority left in the states.