End the Torture: Let Susan Boyle Go Home

"If I had an enemy and I was trying to conquer him, I would give him money, fame and power. They are three things that are extremely difficult to deal with."
Curtis Martin/Former Star NFL Running Back

It may seem strange to apply the words of an ex-football player to a newly-minted singing sensation. But that comment by Curtis Martin, an eventual Hall of Fame running back who starred for the New England Patriots and the New York Jets, applies perfectly to what we're now seeing with Susan Boyle. The middle-aged Scottish plain Jane who became a overnight worldwide sensation with her performances on Britain's Got Talent, the English version of American Idol, seems to be moving closer by the day to a complete emotional meltdown.

The latest chapter came this week when Boyle had to miss two more performances on the 24-date Britain's Got Talent concert tour, after already skipping several other appearances. Today, organizers decided she shouldn't perform at a show in Cardiff after she reportedly had a "screaming fit." In Liverpool yesterday, witnesses said she was crying from her hotel balcony, begging for her cat to be brought to her. All this comes weeks after she checked into a private clinic for what was described as a breakdown.

It's time for someone to say "enough." Ms. Boyle's rags-to-riches story is taking a turn toward tragedy, even faster than what we've seen from others traveling the arc of sudden fame. She is said to have mild learning difficulties, and may simply be incapable of processing the immense amount of attention she now receives. Or maybe she just doesn't like it, and wants her old life back. When someone is crying out from a balcony, "I want my cat, I need my cat," as other hotel guests saw her doing in Liverpool, it doesn't take Sigmund Freud to see that it's a cry to return to the environment and things she's familiar with.

But without someone interceding on her behalf, it might not happen:

"Her mentor Simon Cowell is close friends with the owner of the Planet Hollywood casino and hotel, Robert Earl, and has been trying to broker a deal which would see her singing on The Strip. A source said: 'Simon is confident that Susan will achieve a huge amount of success in America.

'She is already a household name despite coming second on the show, and she is now being lined up to play a number of dates in Las Vegas."

Right. She can't handle a show in Liverpool, but she's going to be the toast of Vegas. It's time for someone with her best interests at heart to step up and, at least temporarily, pull her away from all this.

Comments

[tammylynch]

I don't agree. First, we have absolutely no idea what's happening behind closed doors or in Susan's head. Clearly, she's emotionaly-fragile. But, does that mean she doesn't have a right to try to fight through her difficulties and reach for the dream of her life - to be a professional singer? Absolutely not. To suggest such a thing based on tabloid reports of supposed "breakdowns" or near breakdowns is horribly unfair. Particularly if these reports are based on anonymous sources.

Let's remember that ever move Susan Boyle makes is chronicled worldwide - even more than some of our biggest celebrities. She's called frumpy, ugly, fat, hairy and a hobbit. Her intelligence is regularly insulted in Britain's media and she's taunted by Britain's worst-in-the-world paparazzi. She is in more of a fishbowl than almost anyone in the world - and she's never been elected, and never experienced anything like this.

Give her some time. SEVEN of the acts on the tour have taken days off to rest, but that's not discussed. More than one act has cried or crumbled, but again, never discussed. They're amateurs being pushed into the professional world; it's a big adjustment.

She has clearly stated her firm desire to continue and "give it a go.". The producers always said she may only be able to do "a handful" of shows, so I'm not sure why everyone is shocked. I'm looking forward to her CD, and would definitely see her in Vegas if she comes.

[philistine]

I agree. Susan Boyle is a hot-house flower. It is time to put her back in the greenhouse.