iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Jim Worth

GET UPDATES FROM Jim Worth
 

It's Not Envy, My Friend

Posted: 02/12/2012 6:05 pm

The Republican candidate believes we're all envious of him.

Romney feels that envy of his financial success, the envy of income inequality, is the driver of the current uprising against wealth -- the driver of 'class warfare.' He also believes that envy is the reason for the anti-Romney movement of those opposing his candidacy. But the class warfare he alludes to is not generated by envy.

It's only a talking point emanating from Romney himself to deflect from his obvious deficiencies and to fire up the Republican base.

True, some individuals are probably envious, but, is it envy that causes so many to dislike him?

Watching Mr. Romney stumble through the primaries is excruciating. It's obvious he's desperate to become president despite a lack of understanding of what the position requires.

The position he's aspiring to requires connecting with 'the people' -- understanding their situations and their needs, feeling their pain, and addressing their issues.

But Romney has difficulty connecting with the average person and even more difficulty convincing middle-class America that he really cares about them.

His recent campaign statement regarding the poor, even taken in context, came off as insincere and out of touch. He has no concept of the plight of the poor. Combined with a cold insensitivity toward working-class people his qualifications diminish.

His discomfort in interviews and on the stump is palpable and is marked by his many gaffes. At various times he appears wooden, shallow, unnatural, abrasive, even phony, but rarely sincere, caring, or humble. He tries hard to appear humane yet still comes off dispassionate.

Everything Romney does and everything he says stirs up controversy.

He, at the same time, brags and apologizes for his wealth to appease whichever group he's addressing

His assertion of being unemployed or fearing getting a pink slip and his insistence that he did not inherit his wealth -- partially true but missing the point -- is disingenuous and phony.

The presumptive GOP nominee had problems releasing his tax returns and when challenged reluctantly released his 2010 return. The 2010 return showed a few disturbing things. Aside from the offshore accounts in Swiss and Cayman banks it was discovered that he paid a smaller percentage of taxes than most middle-class Americans -- 13.9 percent.

He, cavalierly, dismissed income he received from speaking engagements as a small amount. It was $374,000, which is more than 10 years of income to the average American family.

Full release of multiple years would likely jeopardize his attempt at being Everyman. The potential exists that earlier returns will show even lower tax rates. This is not a good thing for someone trying to convince the struggling, hard-working American voter, that he's just like them and feels their pain.

His inability to properly address these financial ambiguities is amplified by a hidden feeling of guilt -- guilt about how he's earned his money and the unpatriotic appearance of the low tax rates he's paid.

Though many would like to live in the confines of wealth he's enjoyed, I do not envy him. With all he's been given and all the doors that have been opened for him with his family name, he struggles with being 'real.'

Despite his tithing to the Mormon Church he appears selfish. Despite his repeated insistence that he wants to help the poor he appears pious. Despite his promise of change he has no 'real' solutions. And, with his unfactual attacks on Obama's presidency and policies, the improving employment and economy, he appears to be a liar.

The inability to connect with 'the people' becomes more evident with each primary or caucus. Even within his own party Romney is receiving fewer votes than he received in 2008 -- proof that the party is not overly enchanted with him as their nominee, or, quite frankly, with any of the others.

The 'class warfare' Romney refers to is not the product of envy, but a product of what the wealthy in this country have done to the economy and because of what they've taken from hard-working Americans to line their own selfish pockets. Romney is the epitome of the inequality they've created and one of the reasons his numbers have declined.

No, it's not envy, my friend, it's pity: pity of your desperation, of your personal purgatory over the issues, your lack of true understanding, of your feckless attempts at convincing the American people you're the answer to their struggles. But it's also pity that he must invoke 'class warfare' to avoid his complicity in the disparity in the classes.

Most of all, I pity that the Republican party is left with you as their choice for the presidency.

Believe me when I say, without liberal platitude -- you're not the answer.

Maybe for the Republican Party, but, not for America.

 
 
 

Follow Jim Worth on Twitter: www.twitter.com/authorofmystery

FOLLOW POLITICS
The Republican candidate believes we're all envious of him. Romney feels that envy of his financial success, the envy of income inequality, is the driver of the current uprising against wealth -- the...
The Republican candidate believes we're all envious of him. Romney feels that envy of his financial success, the envy of income inequality, is the driver of the current uprising against wealth -- the...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 152
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
06:40 PM on 02/13/2012
It's been stated that what the poor in this country need is a functioning economy that would help lift them out of poverty. I couldn't agree more. Unfortunately the economy that Mitt Romney and too many other very wealthy U.S. citizens believe we should have is one that reduces taxes for them and their corporations and overturns government regulations under the pretext that these policies will create jobs for those unfortunate, invisible souls wallowing in the gutters of our society. We've tried those policies for the past thirty years. Haven't worked.

"I'm not concerned about the very poor. There's a safety net there." That statement, my friend, told me all I need to know about you and your outlook: Let the poor continue to wallow.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TEDDY LJ
01:15 PM on 02/13/2012
My friend is the words of a schoolyard bully. Someone need to tell him to stop using this work my friend.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Duerksen
...but on the other side, it didn't say nothing.
04:44 PM on 02/13/2012
..."my friend", followed by a challenge to a $10,000 bet. That's how a silk-pantied Fauntleroy throw's his daddies weight around
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
PublicCitizen21044
The truth will set you free!
11:24 AM on 02/13/2012
I am so glad someone wrote an article about that ridiculous and inane line of defense Willard has been using about people "envying him for his success" for it sounds pedantic and makes him seem shallow in light of the current economic atmosphere. The GOP in Congress wants to implement draconian financial cutbacks on the taxpayers who bailed out Wall Street while the rich keep their tax breaks and they have not seen a rise in their real earnings in years and they have seen their investment income fluctuate so wildly they are not sure anymore if they are losing or gaining! etc. Thanks Jim Worth for acknowledging that Willard is just not fit to represent all/the majority of American's who are just hanging in there somewhere in the middle and just trying to make ends meet w/o asking for a handout just a hand up by having the trustees of their monies give them a fair chance at making a better life for themselves and their loved ones.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
"Jim Worth"
04:43 PM on 02/13/2012
PublicCitizen#1,

The things I indicated will be Willard's downfall, especially if he makes it through the primaries and becomes the GOP nominee.

There is much more, including wanting to return to the Bush GOP policies that got middle American into the mess which systematically eroded the middle-class. We cannot affor Mitt as president.

Jim
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
PublicCitizen21044
The truth will set you free!
09:10 AM on 02/14/2012
Well said. I concur. Thank you for replying. Peace.
photo
phal4875
The world is run by cats; we just feed them.
10:57 AM on 02/13/2012
There seem to be so many circumstances against Romney that it is hard to believe that he is leading the Republican race. Republicans appear to like him even less than they did in 2008, when he lost to John McCain. How can this be good in the general election?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
David McElveen
01:36 PM on 02/13/2012
Its not good, its great...for the President.
photo
Wmof2011
Repbs prance around the fed $trillns-& ruins USofA
10:26 AM on 02/13/2012
If he wanted to connect with 'the people,' (assuming he took a people skill class in college, lol) he would not say things like
- corporations are people my friend (it was not appropriate at the time, and he could not explain it like a lawyer; & corporations are not exactly like people)
- he's not worried about the poor, they have their safety nets (translation the poor just want a hand out). They also need education, healthcare, jobs, fairness, and representation (unions, collective bargaining). In the land of opportunity, those things are important.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cclawnj
11:09 AM on 02/13/2012
Romney wasn't talking aboout the legal fiction that treats a corporation as a "person" under the law. He was pointing out that corporations are made up of people, both investors and employees. I think it was a point well worth making, and long overdue. But of course it was not reported fairly by the "mainstream" leftist press. While Romney's remark about the poor having a safety net -- likewise truncated by the leftist reporter for maximum damage -- was unfortunate, your twisted extrapolation is way off the mark. In your list of what the poor need you left out what the poor need most, and what a Romney presidency would give them -- a functioning economy that wold empower the underclass to climb out of poverty.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lalena48
Not Necessarily Stoned...but Beautiful
11:38 AM on 02/13/2012
I believe his fellow R's twisted That same remark to their advantage.
12:07 PM on 02/13/2012
People are individuals. Corporations are business groups. They only care about quarterly profits. I am amazed that you have been sold this BS. how do you think Unions came into being? It was because they take all the profits and treat workers like dirt.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Duerksen
...but on the other side, it didn't say nothing.
10:03 AM on 02/13/2012
Society creates "money" by a general consensus that it exists; consumers are the ONLY drivers of the economy; the wealthy are wealthy because a stable society exists, and for no other reason; Individual citizens are the source of the political power in our system, and have the power to levee taxes through their elected representatives.

Therefore, there is no moral, legal, constitutional, or religious obstacle to us taxing the oligarchs into the upper middle class, where they won't have the ablity to threaten our democracy. We simply can;t afford to keep filty rich people around.
DRouss3977
Consider the source and rise above it!
09:59 AM on 02/13/2012
Mittens and the GOP/TP have no idea what is happening today in politics. All of them have their heads in the sand. They don't realize that the days of 1% power are waning. The American electorate has had enough with 1% whining!
photo
Inkosi
The gods themselves rage against stupidity
10:55 AM on 02/13/2012
What I find absolutely dispicible is that none of these have ever served in the military. Newt went ot Normandy and admired the heros; Mitt went to the treches of France to convert folks to Mormonism, Dr. Paul did serve his country- but sonny did not;,. Ricky and Obama were too young. However, Obama is not a war monger. The others throw War around like it was a video game. They have and never had any "skin" in the game - nor will they ever have skin in the game. None of Mitt's ablebodied sons have enlisted, Ron Paul's son had not enlisted. It is disgraceful. Don't send our kids, husbands, wives off to war unless you have made the same sacrified. I just want to sream when they speak about war. They have no idea what war is.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:22 AM on 02/13/2012
Good rant Mr. Worth.

Romney sees struggling Americans as just being "envious" of "his wealth"
so they are guilty of waging "class warfare" on him and the wealthiest Americans.

A perfect example of how removed Mitt is from the real hardships so many of HIS everyday fellow Americans are struggling to survive. Actual "SURVIVAL"

People all across America are not spoiled children, complaining because Mitt gets cookies for desert and they don't.

These people not only do not get any cookies, many of them do not get any dinner either, while they are listening to Conservatives preach the Government subsidized free school lunches for their "children" and FOOD STAMPS for "their" families, should be stopped, because:

Government must stop "spending" tax $ on "social programs" so the Mitt Romneys, who HIDE MILLIONS of $ off shore to AVOID PAYING their fair share of taxes, can get MORE tax cuts.

In Mitts mind, families are complaining because they are just "envious" of HIS wealth.
Their "complaints are JUST political "class warfare" being waged on "wealthy people like him"

The poor dears. VICTIMS of "envious" people who want to "steal" THEIR cookie stashes.

Maybe Mitt, they are just complaining because their families are HUNGRY, maybe HOMELESS, in AMERICA, the country that "crowns thy good with BROTHERHOOD, MITT!

Hello? MITT?

It's NOT about YOU or YOUR stash of cookies you are hiding and hoarding off shore Mitt, it's It's about THEM and THEIR actually "hungry" families.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
pmoschetta
Where are the Jobs, Speaker Boehner?
10:53 AM on 02/13/2012
http://www.greenconduct.com/articles/2012/02/10/how-mitt-romney-accidentally-jeopardized-free-market-capitalism/

Hey Mitt, how about you explaining to the middle class how Bain Capital used their lobbying efforts to reduce the capital gains tax that you currently enjoy to make you even more wealthy?
photo
Inkosi
The gods themselves rage against stupidity
10:58 AM on 02/13/2012
Maintaining "off shore" accounts for President, Congress folks should be an act of treason and they should be thorwn out of office, arrested, stripped of all pensions and health plans and thrown in jail - along with their banker buddies
09:20 AM on 02/13/2012
America needs a leader that will support this logical plan to fix the economy: The "One - Year Mortgage Holiday" 9 Point Economic Recovery & Jobs Plan, as fully detailed at www.saveoureconomy.com is the only legitimate economic stimulus plan designed to actually solve the current housing, credit, banking, financial crises, that will jump start our economy, create millions of new jobs, stimulate growth and generate long term economic prosperity.

The #1 key element of the plan, the "silver bullet", is an ingenious "One - Year Mortgage Holiday" for every home owner & business in America, so that for 12 months, you do not have to make a monthly mortgage payment. All Renters of apartments, retail & office space will also get a 38% rebate on their rent. Consequently Main Street, that has already spent & wasted Trillions bailing out Wall Street and received nothing in return, since credit markets are still frozen, foreclosures, unemployment and bankruptcies are still rising, would then be able to have a well deserved one year "Time Out", from having to make a mortgage payment. So a 25 year mortgage simply becomes a 26 year mortgage. All mortgage bank lenders, would still be paid a monthly average interest rate of 6% on all mortgage debt in the country. This would allow consumers, all home owners, renters and businesses to decide for themselves how best to spend, save & invest their own money each month, that would inject approximately $80 billion monthly back into the economy.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Terri Skau
Se... sotto una splendida luna piena...
09:12 AM on 02/13/2012
Why would any of us envy Mitt. Disgusted yes...;-) T.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
shortguy54
Short, balding, brilliant... (well, maybe not so)
08:55 AM on 02/13/2012
Wierd thing, capitalism: Making people homeless is just good business. Being homeless, on the other hand, is often almost a crime! (Nod to Terry Pratchett)
08:44 AM on 02/13/2012
Not envy and not pity either. Disgust is the word. I admire successful people who through their hard work, ingenuity and creativity build something of worth and value. I have disgust for people that get rich by gaming the system, people who enrich themselves at the expense of the greater good through their devious financial gimmicks and schemes. Perhaps the war profiteers are the only ones I hold in even less in regard.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:20 AM on 02/13/2012
Well said!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lalena48
Not Necessarily Stoned...but Beautiful
11:28 AM on 02/13/2012
Great post! Wish I could F & F
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
David McElveen
08:18 AM on 02/13/2012
How does Mitt, or any Republican who whines about "class envy", explain those Americans who are wealthy, and not part of the class of people he's "not worried about", supporting Obama? Rich people who are envious of rich people? How do they explain the wealthy Americans who openly admit they are not taxed equally and fairly?

What amazes me is the complete disconnect from reality these "conservatives" have. They always have an excuse for why someone is "hating" them. "Its because we are rich." "They want to attack our (religion, freedom, guns, unborn children, etc...)"

Its never their fault...ever.

They play that victim card so often, its hard not to feel sorry for them. It makes perfect sense, as long as you don't think about it. Fortunately for them, their voter base is not big on thinking...about anything. Reality, logic, and reason are poisons to these people.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:19 AM on 02/13/2012
Well said.

Remember the old movie about orphans (my mind is blanking on the name of the movie) with the hungry little boy holding his empty bowl up to the "fat" heartless mean person who runs the orphanage, and he says "Please Sir, may I have some more?"

I guess that little boy was just "envious" I guess his request was because he wanted to STEAL the food from the orphanage administrator who had "earned" his food and was not obligated to share it with anyone.
That little boys brazen request in front of the other hungry children was nothing more then instigating a "class warfare" attack on THE administrator authority figure "who feeds him" How ungrateful.

The nerve of that little boy.
11:29 AM on 02/13/2012
Oliver Twist - you should read the book in honor of Dicken's recent 200th birthday.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cclawnj
11:17 AM on 02/13/2012
The victim card is played daily by Obama, who after three years of disasterously failed fiscal policy still says it's his predecessor's fault, the fault of the rich, the Republican minority's fault, etc., etc., ad nauseum. The only thing he takes responsibility for was accomplished by Navy Seal Team 6.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
David McElveen
02:07 PM on 02/29/2012
Its not the "victim card". Its called reality, which you clearly are disconnected from.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Havnagudtim
There Will Be Dancing!
07:58 AM on 02/13/2012
Mitt can't possibly understand the common people, those not fortunate enough not to have been born corporations.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:30 AM on 02/13/2012
Severed conservative Romney holds the seminal secrets to sequentially seek, seize, sever and sell separable serfdoms, while setting up his own seriously and severely sequined severence settlements. Now, severed conservative Romney serially and seductively seeks to use several of his secrets to sever the government sector from the sedulity of serving and securing the severed serfs. To all serfs from severed serfdoms: See through the seething see-throughs!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lalena48
Not Necessarily Stoned...but Beautiful
11:31 AM on 02/13/2012
What a tongue twister lol