More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Joan E. Dowlin

Joan E. Dowlin

Posted: February 14, 2010 04:31 PM

Pettiness Over Crib Notes and Teleprompters

What's Your Reaction:

It was a breaking point for me. I finally reached my limit. The recent media and political lunacy over crib notes and teleprompters did it for me. Everyone -- politicians, pundits, media, and the electorate -- are responsible for what we have become: a petty nation.

To reiterate: former Governor Sarah Palin accused the President of being "a charismatic guy with a teleprompter" in her speech to Tea Party Nation last Saturday night. Later in a Q&A session at the convention she was seen reading crib notes written on her palm.

This sparked a media frenzy. Even Press Secretary Robert Gibbs got into the act by mocking Palin when he showed a grocery list written on his hand.

Jon Stewart and Stephen Colbert had a field day, which is fine because they are political comics. But watching Keith Olbermann

The left justify their petty reactions by saying (like a two-year old), "Well, she started it by mocking President Obama's use of teleprompters." Yes she did, but do two wrongs make a right?

The right have never stopped criticizing Obama's gaffes and their perceived teleprompter crutch. Did they not hear or see his Q&A with the GOP representatives in January? His engaging conversation should have put to rest the myth that he can't speak or communicate without his teleprompter.

So both sides are acting childish and petty. No wonder the American public is so angry at Washington! We have a high unemployment rate, a mortgage crisis, two wars, Wall Street greed, a broken health care system, blizzards and natural disasters due to climate change, and an energy crisis. Why can't our politicians do what they were elected to do: work together to solve these problems? Why can't the media hold them to the fire to do that and stop reporting these petty issues about crib notes and teleprompters? I just have two words for you all: grow up!

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 17
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
10:07 PM on 02/15/2010
I'm thinking the author of this blog doesn't understand that the pursuit of ethics is never petty.
Palin cheated.

Palin secretly got the Q&A questions beforehand, did not disclose that she had the questions in advance, wrote the answers on her palm, and did this all after reading from the text of her prepared speech where she was paid $100,000 to attack the President for reading from a Teleprompter. Palin got caught, blackhanded, cheating like a bad high school student.

Cheating? Dishonesty? Hypocrisy? I don't know where the blogger comes from, but where I come from dishonesty is a big deal.
09:17 PM on 02/15/2010
Palin is a hypocrite for mocking Obama's teleprompters while using her own hand version of the teleprompter.

But there is NOTHING WRONG with either practice.

It's is Palin's hypocrisy that is wrong.
03:49 PM on 02/15/2010
I think the author over-simplifies the pettiness argument. I agree that "gotcha" moments concerning teleprompters and crib notes are petty, but those moments don't occur with as great a frequency as is implied in this article.

The bulk of gotcha-moments in the media today (at least on the shows I'm watching) usually involve politicians who say or do something "today" that totally contradicts something they said or did "yesterday". Does "she was for the Bridge to Nowhere before she was against it" sounds familiar? I want the hypocrites publicly outed. I don't care what party they're affiliated with, I want the media, and other politicians for that matter, to red-flag these frauds so that I can make an informed decision on who's word I should be trusting. Politicians have been getting away with waffling on what's popular "at the moment" for too long.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
shryock
It never is what it is anymore
02:31 PM on 02/15/2010
perhaps real reporters feel that if you have to write your answers on your hands you could not possibly answer a real question or even understand it, so they give up in horror on the idea of substantive debate.

the president does quite well answering questions without a teleprompter, but the media would seemingly rather report on sarah palin disparaging the president. for what reason, i do not know.
she is the queen of false equivalences, blatant hypocrisy, and circular logic.

and here is the flaw in your cry for rational discourse. sarah palin is not a politician. she is not elected to do anything, but the media seem to feel she must have her time to have her say. for some reason, the media feels compelled to report on every nonsensical utterance from her rather than to report on the rational members of our true political class. they do indeed need to stop quoting sarah palin. stop quoting ex-vice cheney. stop quoting each other!
01:06 PM on 02/15/2010
Teleprompters are OK as long as you are sporting a flag lapel pin. As for palm notes - it depends on the legs displayed.
12:33 PM on 02/15/2010
I thought this was article was right on point. And to prove how right you are, please note the 5 examples below. Don't you love it when others prove points for you? Everything against the other side will always be justified, no matter how juvenile they may sound. Sad, isn't it?
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Json
Cynical dreamer, sarcastic idealist...
01:40 PM on 02/15/2010
Despite being a "HuffPost Pick", it looks like you have missed the point.
There is a temptation to buy into the false equivalence of "both sides do it, both sides are being childish/petty". That is just intellectual laziness.
There is an organized campaign underway to discredit Obama. Everything he does is criticized and offered as proof of his incompetence/socialism/fascism.
This teleprompter thing is just the latest example of the glaring hypocrisy. While the backlash that Palin is getting over her notes might be a little over the top, calling her and other out is very important.
Look back at the swiftboaters. Kerry didn't fight back because the charge was both silly and inaccurate and he thought no one would buy it. That probably cost him the election.
The lesson is that you must fight back against these type of smears. Even if you think it is a bit silly. Even if you think it is beneath you to do so. Only them can the right possibly be shamed into acting like a responsible political entity.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Joan E. Dowlin
02:39 AM on 02/16/2010
Do I need to remind you there was "an organized campaign underway" during the election to discredit Palin? Remember all the lawyers sent to Alaska to dig up dirt? How about the attacks on her family? How about the sexist assault on her about her wardrobe? Remember the false rumors about book burnings? I saw all of this and I am an Obama supporter.
This is how politics work in this country, on both sides of the aisle. That is what people are sick of. The Swiftboating, the personal attacks, the racism, the sexism, the smears. You can't shame people into being responsible. You set an example by being above the muck.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
booker52
avid reader
11:50 AM on 02/15/2010
The main difference between Sarah Palin reading crib notes on her hand while complaining about President Obama using a teleprompter is just that hypocrite, and while Sarah and the rest at Cluster Fox would like to make a big deal out of this, all they really are trying to do is deflect from real issues, say insurance reform, banking reform, two wars, etc. Get the picture now. That is the real point of all this crap.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Json
Cynical dreamer, sarcastic idealist...
11:47 AM on 02/15/2010
If Palin had been caught with writing on her hand, but had not been mocking Obama for last year for using a teleprompter, it would have been a five minute joke.
The reason it has gotten more play is because of the flagrant hypocrisy.

Every president in modern times has used a teleprompter. Nobody cared about it, until Obama used one. If you are going to be one of those who are loudly mocking him for it, expect to get called out if you need to write your core beliefs on your hand.
09:43 PM on 02/15/2010
Totally agree.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
NotStarvingArtist
"Art is the signature of civilizations."
10:46 AM on 02/15/2010
I have to disagree with you about the crib notes being a petty issue. This goes straight to the character of Sarah Palin. Anyone who criticizes someone else for using a teleprompter while at the same time using notes written on their own hand is a hypocrite pure and simple. It also speaks to her inadequacy as a candidate for high office in America. We need leaders who have intelligence and a deep understanding of the tenets of our democracy and of the issues of the day. We don't need leaders who cannot remember simple talking points without writing them on their own hand. Far from thinking the media made too much of it, I would also have liked to see the media explore whether Palin was also using a teleprompter built into the podium where she was speaking when she criticized the President for using one. Her hypocrisy and disengenuousness should not go unchallenged.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Joan E. Dowlin
12:49 PM on 02/15/2010
I agree there is hypocrisy, but it exists on both sides. It seems as a nation we are more obsessed with how our leaders communicate rather than what they communicate. In this "gotcha" media culture it's style over substance and it may have been what's contributed to getting us into the mess we're in.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
PRONESE
Somewhat Opinionated Curmudgeon
07:44 AM on 02/15/2010
Now that Dianne Feinstein was found with notes on hand.
*
*
The hand wringing begins.
*
Posish!
*
R/ PRONESE
photo
LMPE
I connect the most dissimilar things
07:00 PM on 02/14/2010
If in fact we seek to grow up, then maybe we should start by getting rid of organized religion, so that we don't squirm every time that someone mentions a body part.