iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Joan E. Dowlin

Joan E. Dowlin

Posted: March 30, 2010 06:21 PM

The GOP Is "Shooting the Messenger"

What's Your Reaction:

I disagree with House Minority Whip Eric Cantor (R-VA) that the media and Democrats are "fanning the flames" by reporting harassment, death threats, vandalism, and brick throwing directed at ten Democratic Representatives who recently voted "yes" on the Health Care Reform bill that recently passed in Congress. Isn't this, pardon the metaphor, like "shooting the messenger"?

Are we supposed to ignore this intimidation? Act as though it is not happening? How foolish is that? Also isn't it a little hypocritical to state a bullet was shot through your office window while declaring we shouldn't report these matters? Turns out the bullet didn't go through Cantor's office but landed nearby and was a stray shot as a result of random gunfire, but let's not be picky. What the Representative was trying to say was "we Republicans get targeted too", which I am sure is true.

So doesn't it make sense for Congress to be bi-partisanship on the issue? Neither side should condone bullying, death threats, and acts of violence. Why did it take the Republican leadership in the House four days to come out against it?

As far as "fanning the flames", could it not be argued that yelling out "you lie" to the President of the United States while he makes a speech to Congress and screeching "baby killer" to one of the most pro-life members of the House while debating the health care bill could set a bad example for the followers of these GOP leaders? Is this not more "inciting the rioters" than the reporting of it?

I am all for freedom of speech, but I thought there was an unwritten decorum that was supposed to be practiced in the halls of Washington when debating issues. I have never seen such animosity in DC in my lifetime.

It also seems the Republicans can't stop making military references when campaigning against the Democrats. Sarah Palin is constantly talking about reloading (well, she is an NRA member) and on her Facebook page she has a map with crosshairs on the Districts where some incumbent Democrats are running in 2010. Michael Steele has a web site with a "Fire Nancy Pelosi" headline that has a picture of her in front of a blazing background. "Fanning the flames" indeed. He also made reference to putting her in front of a firing line in a recent interview.

House Minority Leader John Boehner (R-OH) was recently quoted as saying Congressman Driehaus (D-OH) was a "dead man" after voting for health care.

There do not seem to be calls for civility. When Congressmen and women stand on the balconies of the House with signs reading "Kill the Bill" while whipping up the crowd of Tea Party activists right after some of these protesters shouted nasty epithets to black and gay members of the House, it is distasteful at best, reckless at worst.

The GOP talking point is that it is a separate incident and only a small minority of fringe tea partiers created this havoc and the movement on the whole should not be blamed. OK then, but how many "separate incidents" does it take to make a disturbing pattern? And why not condemn the actions of the few when it occurs, instead of defending the whole Tea Party?

We all know times are tough right now. People are worried about jobs, wars, education, health care, their retirement, debt, foreclosures, natural disasters, greedy banks and corporations, and any number of things. There is much to be angry and skeptical about. But we would all agree, I hope, that violence and intimidation is not the answer from either side of the political spectrum. Cool heads and civil hearts must prevail. Let's tone down the rhetoric and work together to find solutions to our nation's problems. Anything less than that is truly "fanning the flames."


 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 8
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
08:10 AM on 04/01/2010
I just have to say this; with my 45 plus years of following politics, I have never seen a new Administration get handed SO MUCH!!, and get SO LITTLE "Cooperation" I this is totally Disgusting!!
and the Republican party should be Ashamed of themselves.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
FlamingLibrul
08:42 AM on 03/31/2010
Did anyone see Mika on Morning Joe this very morning, trot out the tired, lame 'Code Pink' justification for why both sides are equally at fault for the vitriol? The righties aren't even trying anymore- they know there are enough stooges out there who willingly buy whatever they're selling- no matter what reality indicates is actually happening.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Joan E. Dowlin
Love will find a way.
12:35 PM on 03/31/2010
I saw O'Reilly last night and he did a piece saying the left is more dangerous than the right showing the University protests in CA, Code Pink etc. What good is making one side worse than the other? It's childish. It all should be condemned!
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
FlamingLibrul
03:14 PM on 03/31/2010
Do you see a large contingent of right wingers denouncing the Taxed Enough Already crowd? I certainly don't. I saw way more bed-wetting liberal types denounce a Democratic state senator who made a really bad reference to Japanese Anime and nuclear bombing.

I also don't see how any annoying, rude and disruptive PETA or Code Pink lefties can be compared to radical, rock-throwing, weapons-carrying seditionists who want to overthrow the government. I know you and I are on the same side here, I just want to be clear about my perspective.
12:16 AM on 03/31/2010
"Oh what a tangled web they weave...." Sooner or later, all regimes built on lies and deception come crashing down of their own accord. You'd think that someone would have anticipated that and tried to build the GOP on actual ideas rather than on spin and hype.
09:12 PM on 03/30/2010
The tragedy is not that such behavior happens, it's that the GOP encourages it, which can only eventually swallow them.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jalowe1957
Poisonous epitaphs dished out periodically.
07:12 PM on 03/30/2010
They're not just shooting the messenger, they're stalking and assassinating their prey.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
tmf945
07:06 PM on 03/30/2010
Taking metaphors have always been in existence, so don't read more into them than what's really there. However...It is irresponsible of the GOP leadership not to step up and condemn any and all threats, real or perceived. It is time for the hypocrisy that is the GOP to end and for one person to set forward and become a leader and say "Enough!" I have been thru the 60's during the social upheaval, Vietnam protests and Free Speech Movement along with Civil Rights and any other damn thing you care to name. Yes, we had differences and at times fought in the streets, until cooler heads prevailed. We had leaders, not screamers or talking head pundits who are self proclaimed experts on everything from Astrology to Zoology. The flames of those days became embers until just recently when they were fanned by those of us that prefer a stasis government and way of life rather than moving forward and exploring new frontiers.
It saddens me that so many have given their blood and lives, so that this may be the end result of a 235 year experiment with Democracy