iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Joan K. Smith

GET UPDATES FROM Joan K. Smith
 

One Last Plea to the City of Belfast: Save Lennox and Save Face

Posted: 07/08/2012 3:15 pm

The saga of Lennox, the non-aggressive Belfast family pet sentenced to death under the U.K.'s "Dangerous Dogs Act" based not on any misdeed but simply on his appearance as a "Pit Bull Type," has riveted the world, generating over 174,000 signatures on the "Save Lennox" petition, over 20,000 on a more recently-created "Boycott Belfast" petition, as well as an intense social media outcry. (For background, see my first post on this case.)

2012-07-07-lennoxcupsm.jpgAs reported here last month, his family's final plea to lodge an appeal was denied by Northern Ireland's highest court on June 12; at the time of that last post, hope remained that further legal options might be available. However, this sad case is now inching perilously closer to tragedy, as the Barnes family, owners of Lennox, released a statement on July 3 that all legal options have been exhausted, and that

"the fight to spare Lennox's life may well be over. It has been almost impossible for us to accept that we have to admit defeat. We always believed that there was some hope and that justice would prevail. We were wrong. "

At this point, the family's only remote hope to spare Lennox's life is for the city of Belfast to agree to allow him to leave Northern Ireland for adoption in a country where his existence is not banned by breed specific laws, and this is their last-ditch plea. Without this intervention, his death sentence could now be carried out on Monday, July 9.

It should be noted that since he was removed from the family in March of 2010, a number of viable re-homing offers have been put on the table as a potential solution, and the Barnes family have always remained open to this; as heartbreaking as this might be for Craig, Caroline, and especially young Brooke Barnes, who would be losing her dear soulmate and companion, it would be obviously preferable to a death sentence. Yet Belfast has, so far, turned a deaf ear to such a solution, insisting instead that Lennox must be put to death.

Other compelling offers have opened the door for the Northern Ireland government to gracefully demonstrate evenhanded goodwill in the case and thus save face in the eyes of the world: Jim Crosby, an impeccably credentialed dog aggression expert cited in my earlier articles, has presented official proposals to Northern Ireland First Minister Peter Robinson (who has informally stated his disagreement with Lennox's death sentence on Twitter) and Northern Ireland Secretary of State Owen Paterson, whereby Crosby would visit Belfast -- on a completely pro bono basis -- to conduct an independent evaluation of Lennox from the basis of his particular area of expertise.

Although Crosby is an opponent of breed specific legislation and has spoken out on behalf of Lennox for some time, his offer emphasized that he would not criticize any preceding actions or opinions in the case; instead, he presents

"a mediated remedy that would allow the Belfast City Council and the Government of Northern Ireland to extricate themselves without loss of public respect, yet with compassion for the individuals... a possible solution that would both protect the citizens of Northern Ireland and allow the dog Lennox to live out his life in peace."

Perhaps the most feasible offer currently at hand comes from Victoria Stilwell, the highly regarded celebrity dog trainer and author (best known in the U.S. as the star of the program It's Me or the Dog) who has been a longtime staunch supporter of Barnes family and Lennox, and who has offered to personally cover all costs related to Lennox's rehoming with her in the United States.

2012-07-07-lennoxgrass.jpgStilwell has been conferring closely with Lennox's legal team, and is in Belfast at this very moment, ready and willing to take Lennox out of Northern Ireland to prevent his euthanization. As Stilwell, the Barnes family, and the Lennox legal team anxiously await a response from Belfast on this offer, Stilwell has posted an eloquent plea on her official website. This plea, in short, presents an elegant "out" for the city of Belfast, which has faced a public relations debacle over the Lennox case, as well as an olive branch to spare the city further negative backlash:

"... to the Belfast court system and the BCC [Belfast City Council], I now publicly give you my word that if you remand custody of Lennox to me and allow me to take him to a safe place in the U.S., I will not disparage the BCC, the Belfast court system, or those involved with this case in any way moving forward. Indeed, I will publicly recognize the courage that it will take to rise above the divisive voices clamoring on both sides of this issue, follow the law, and yet also show some humanity and allow this dog to live out his final years in peace in the US... All I'm asking is that you recognize the special nature of this case and allow him to leave the country -- a result which still allows you to uphold the spirit of the law while avoiding the death of what I and many others consider to be an innocent dog and averting an even more damaging end to what has undoubtedly become a public relations nightmare."

Barring the acceptance of these offers to save Lennox by removing him from Northern Ireland, which would in turn save face for the city of Belfast, the Barnes family has one final, heartbreaking request: "If the offer is turned down we will fight for our right to say goodbye. We cannot bear the thought that Lennox will die without being reminded of the hearts and hands that love him."

NOTE: Supporters worldwide are still rallying frantically to save Lennox. Group actions include an email campaign to veterinary surgeons to refuse to administer the lethal injection, and appeals to Michelle O'Neill, Northern Ireland's minister of agriculture, for a pardon. A peaceful protest took place at Belfast City Hall at Saturday, June 7; and another one is scheduled for New York City on Monday, July 9 beginning at 10 a.m. at the British Consulate, 845 Third Avenue.

 

Follow Joan K. Smith on Twitter: www.twitter.com/wassilyk

FOLLOW IMPACT
 
 
  • Comments
  • 117
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4  Next ›  Last »  (4 total)
11:09 PM on 07/18/2012
If this decision is only based on looks then this is a travesty. But Im tired to "Pit Bulls" being portrayed by some as a non violent breed and say things like "Its not the breed its the owner"...I have 2 Labs...They are retrievers...They were bred to be retrievers!!! Pit Bulls were bred to fight!!! Could I train my dogs to stop retrieving? Sure!! Could I train the instinct out of them??? Not a chance!!! So with that being said, could you train a Pit Bull not to fight or be aggressive??? Absolutely!!! But can you train that instinct out of them??? No way in hell!!! Just ask Sigfried and Roy if you can train those instincts out of an animal!!!! And your right.....It is peoples fault when those type of dogs attack!! Because no one should own them in the first place!!!
02:03 PM on 07/11/2012
What an appalling mess the Belfast politicians got themselves in to. Their staunchly entrenched and unreasonable position exposes their stubbornness by way of refusal to accept a common sense solution. Joan - don't let this story die. If possible, worldwide pressure should be maintained on these people until the citizens of Belfast vote them out of their elected offices.
01:27 PM on 07/11/2012
This is just completely heart breaking. After years of fighting prejudice and discrimination, this has shown that all that work was for NOTHING! What's sad is the fact that there were people out there willing to pay for his way out of Ireland with no cost at all to the city. This was not about doing the right thing. This was a demonstration of "who holds the power and who is in control."
It makes me sick in my heart and my soul to know that human beings care so little about a life.
This is a perfect example as to why I have zero faith in humanity. For all those who came together to save him, a handful had the power to destroy and shatter hope and a life.
I hope they burn in hell.
I have no sympathy for the wrath that is about to fall upon them.
I will not pray for your souls, I will not shed a tear for what happens to you BELFAST.
A life was taken out of spite and hate.
I guess now when your children ask you people about monsters, you can stand in front of the mirror and point at your reflection.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Joan K Smith
Philadelphia-based artist and cultural critic
11:14 AM on 07/11/2012
Lennox is gone. Belfast CC released a notice that "the dog Lennox, an illegal pit-bull terrier type, has been humanely put to sleep." Par for their PR spin strategy, their statement includes allusions to a "sustained campaign of abuse" against Council, as if that subject is appropriate for this type announcement; again, they imply this alleged "abuse" gives them some justification for their actions. Shame on Belfast, a crime was committed today, a crime that the world will not forget.
01:51 PM on 07/11/2012
BTW, Thank you Joan for your excellent reporting of this story over recent weeks. It is a shame that the world community could not save this (apparently) wonderful dog.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Joan K Smith
Philadelphia-based artist and cultural critic
02:36 PM on 07/11/2012
I so appreciate your note of thanks, I've done my best. Huffington Post has been amazing in both providing the outlet for telling this story and in promoting the pieces. But it is personally heartbreaking that these stories -- mine and others -- brought wide attention to the case but were unable to ultimately sway opinion enough to save Lennox. I only wish that major broadcast media could have also picked up this story sooner than the very last minute... when it was simply too late to make a difference.
12:21 AM on 07/11/2012
I urge everyone to boycott anything with BBC on it. I don't care if you love this show, or that show... they have behaved DEPLORABLY in this matter... there is NO defending their lies and actions. I will never watch anything they air. Sorry. I don't support liars and dog murders.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Joan K Smith
Philadelphia-based artist and cultural critic
10:03 PM on 07/10/2012
According to the utterly heartbroken Barnes family, their dear boy Lennox is set to be murdered -- yes, I'm using that word -- at 7 a.m. Wednesday Belfast time. Belfast City Council has just over 4 hours to gracefully redeem their reputation and political future. A real miracle is needed to prevent this, as it seems clear that Belfast City Council has no intention of bowing to worldwide pressure -- not to mention the urging of their country's own First Minister.
06:29 PM on 07/10/2012
I truly hope something can be done but I am deeply suspicious about this. To not allow the family a final visit or to allow them his body makes me believe that he put to sleep sometime ago or is not in good shape. Shame on the council and the courts for covering this up.
01:49 PM on 07/11/2012
Same on the Belfast City council for sure. They are apparently stubbornly entrenched in an appallingly stupid decision. One can only hope that the good citizens of Belfast see through this nonsense and will vote these people out of office at the next opportunity. That will be little satisfaction, however, now that Lennox has been destroyed.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Joan K Smith
Philadelphia-based artist and cultural critic
04:28 PM on 07/10/2012
LATEST UPDATE: There is still intense last-minute rallying from around the world to save Lennox, who may just have hours now. The public outcry has intensified in the last day, and among current efforts being pursued by supporters are appeals for intervention from the Church of Ireland, and an email campaign to MPs to put pressure on Belfast as well as DARD Minister Michelle O'Neill to at the very least offer a reprieve for review of the case. There are also a flood of requests asking for proof of Lennox's current condition and that he is in fact still alive via access from a DARD or USPCA inspector, due to concern about the conditions under which he has been held.

Belfast CC has still not responded to Victoria Stilwell's offer nor, apparently, have they been moved by the direct appeal from First Minister Peter Robinson to Belfast's Lord Mayor.

The Barnes family did release a statement about an hour ago, saying "...at the present time Belfast city council seem to be intent on killing our boy. Despite previous assurances otherwise, we have been denied the opportunity to say goodbye. We have also been told that we cannot collect his body and bring Len home. We have been informed however that we will receive 'some' ashes in the mail." It seems inexplicable that Belfast CC would deny the family Lennox's body, unless there is some issue to be covered up about his "care" while in their custody.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rubiconski
On Crisis Standby Mode
01:38 PM on 07/10/2012
Let Victoria Stilwell bring Lennox to the US or get boycotted into bankruptcy!!!

Don't be scared Lennox....the whole world loves you!
03:51 PM on 07/11/2012
Please, for this animal's sake, do not let this be forgotten, ever. I just read about this for the first time, today, and I feel so sick about it.
01:24 PM on 07/10/2012
It's time to riot in the streets. Justice for Lennox!!!!!!!!!!!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
olitenup
12:10 PM on 07/10/2012
Something really stinks with this.

Just as with Occupy, the BCC is claiming threats. We all know how trolls are planted to discredit the movement, and the BBC has bitten this one hook, line and sinker. Who knew the BBC was moving to entertainment news, like CNN and faux.
05:24 AM on 07/10/2012
iam horrified and appauled that people can play god with a defenceless animals life .
10:11 PM on 07/09/2012
BSL is one of the most ignorant things I have ever come across. If they were to kill this dog it will be a travesty- but, only one in a long line of travesties that have happen all across the globe due to misguided thinking. If a dog is vicious it most certainly needs to be removed from society- but, to label those as vicious based upon the "look" of an animal is beyond reprehensible. I have met many "illegal" dogs at the Miami shelter that later where killed- simply because of their look... those same dogs had begged me through the chainlink to take them home-- they kissed me -- they licked my camera lens and cried.. and they did not have a mean bone in their body.. yet, they were killed because they were illegal. It would be wonderful for the world to wake up and to start logical thinking and stop this madness. I will never be against putting down dogs that are vicious - but, I will always be against labeling them as such not based upon their action- but, by their look. It would be wonderful to see Belfast do the right thing.. but, the ignorance and hatred run deep.
09:08 PM on 07/09/2012
Why would a loving pet owner bring that pet to a location where it was sure to be destroyed? That makes no sense to me. I pray this dog is somehow saved, but I pray more that all pet owners or prospective pet owners will learn from this and follow the law to keep their beloved pets safe.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Joan K Smith
Philadelphia-based artist and cultural critic
09:58 PM on 07/09/2012
The Barnes had no reason to believe Lennox was in danger -- please see earlier stories which give background -- he had been licensed by city for 5 yrs, neutered, DNA tested, insured... in short, all was within law. He is an American Bulldog / Labrador mix, they could not have predicted when he was a puppy that someday his physical measurements would deem him a "Pitbull Type."
11:31 PM on 07/09/2012
belfast has even deemed his LITTERMATES to be legal and they are liscensed and legal.
04:17 AM on 07/10/2012
The dog warden came to their house about the license allegedly,to begin with .Apparently the license was out of date .That is how the whole thing began .The wardens then onsight said "Tere is a Pitbull in the yard",however as the Dangerous Dogs Act paragraphs which include banned breeds has been in force sine1991 there ARE NO LIVING PITBULLS IN THE UK that is unless some one secretly has a dog which is now 22years plus (LOL).I have seen and lived beside a pure bred Pitbull ,many years ago ,and he never bit anyone either. I have to say quite adamently that Lennox looks nothing like that dog.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
karen lyons kalmenson
i poem/paint, sometimes, i ain't
06:43 PM on 07/09/2012
what is fair,
what is just,
what is boom,
what is bust.
lennox and his
story,
neither fair
nor nice,
has brought
a troubled world
together,
without thinking twice.
yes we all know
that the scales
forever tip
to one side.
but that does not mean
we have to let it slide.
we have taken a stand,
chosen to live humane,
in the larger picture,
anything else
is inane