iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Jodie Levin-Epstein

Jodie Levin-Epstein

Posted: January 4, 2010 02:38 PM

Peaceful Revolution: Paid Leave Makes Horse Sense

What's Your Reaction:

Vacations are good for your health. And, you don't need to get away to any fancy Caribbean retreat to get the benefit of time-off from work. But it helps if you are a horse. In New York City, that is.

The City's Health Department has proposed new rules for those horses hitched to carriages that carry tourists around parts of town. If implemented, the horses would get 5 weeks of job-protected vacation. During their time off, the horses would continue to enjoy their standard payment -- room and board, along with grooming. It is a reasonable business decision to invest in these workers since the vacation time will likely prolong their work-life and enhance their productivity. Added to the economics are the ethics of humane treatment of animals. The Health Department apparently considers the 5 weeks to be akin to a minimum labor standard. An advisory committee had urged that the horses get 8 weeks based upon 'best practices'; in defending a shorter vacation, Daniel Kass, a department official noted, "Operators are invited to give them more."

It's time for Congress and the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services to pony-up to the value of vacation for two-legged workers. Workers outside the federal government, that is. Federal workers are entitled to 13 vacation days starting in year one. No wonder the federal government is often viewed as a desirable employer-of-choice. For the rest of the nation's workforce, however, no federal law provides any paid time off -- and that includes vacation, holidays, and sick time. As the Department of Labor explains it, "These benefits are a matter of agreement between an employer and an employee." One result of that 'agreement' is that among working parent households, fully 41 percent of those with incomes below twice the federal poverty level have no paid time off of any kind. While higher income workers tend to have paid leave, they, too, can miss out; for example 17 percent of white collar private workers have no paid vacation. And, even before the recession, what employers gave, they sometimes took away. Access to paid vacation, sick days, and holidays was less likely in 2006 compared to prior peak years.

Legislation has been introduced that would begin to give the U.S. human workforce parity with the standards proposed for the Big Apple's equine workers. A bill that would provide for paid vacations was introduced in Congress in 2009 (while all carriage horses in New York are expected to get 5 weeks, the bill in the U.S. House of Representatives for human employees would enable them to access one or two weeks, depending on the size of their employers). Other pending legislation would provide paid sick days and allow most workers to take up to 7 days in a year to treat or prevent illness, or to take care of a loved one. Numerous national organizations including MomsRising, Take Back Your Time, The National Partnership for Women and Families, and the Center for Law and Social Policy are trying to move these and related paid leave bills.

Other nations provide paid time off
. Nearly 160 have accepted a UN covenant which declares that all countries should "recognize the right of everyone to the enjoyment of just and favorable conditions of work which ensure, in particular, reasonable limitation of working hours and periodic holidays with pay, as well as remuneration for public holidays." Indeed, among the world's 15 most competitive countries, 14 provide paid sick leave, 14 provide paid annual leave, 13 guarantee a weekly day of rest, 13 provide paid leave for new mothers and 12 for new fathers according to Raising the Global Floor.

Giving U.S. workers some paid time off just makes horse sense. If horses can get it, why can't their bosses?

A Peaceful Revolution is a blog about innovative ideas to strengthen America's families through public policies, business practices, and cultural change. Done in collaboration with MomsRising.org, read a new post here each week.

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 9
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
10:44 AM on 01/06/2010
That settles it. When I die, I hope to be reincarnated as a New York City horse—unless of course we can get conditions improved for our species.
12:15 PM on 01/05/2010
This piece is brilliant--very funny and points out the absurdity of our situation in the US. Of course, I believe the carriage horses deserve vacation too, but how about our workers. The median American workers gets only one week of paid leave. There is no law guaranteeing any leave, contrary to Europe or Australia where people get four weeks by law, at least. Please support Congressman Alan Grayson's Paid Vacation Act of 2009 (HR 2564) and check out the Web site: www.right2vacation.org to join the campaign. Also check out the most recent Economist magazine debate at http://www.economist.com/debate/archive It is about holiday time and the side favoring more vacation time won 79-21%. C'mon, United States, let's get on board the train. Progressives especially should support Ms. Levin-Epstein on these issues!
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Deborah Weinstein
10:04 AM on 01/05/2010
So if one of the four in ten parents with no paid leave is told she "works like a horse," the right answer is "I only wish!"
07:55 AM on 01/05/2010
While I was aware that you were only alowed 2 weeks vacation time I had no idea that your holidays were unpaid.

Following from asdusty's comments below we enjoy (in Australia) 4 weeks annual leave, 10 days sick / family leave and universal health care.

Your employers must really have no regard for your workers no wonder everyone carries a gun and is so pissed off.
05:33 AM on 01/05/2010
This is silly writing. The situation in New York City in regard to the carriage horses can not be compared to American employees. The horses are legal property. They are entirely at the mercy of their owners and the indifferent oversight of their welfare by the New York City Health Department. The carriage horse industry in New York City should be banned. But, the hard-working American employee needs sound legislation from Washington for a chance to live a decent life with some time off from the daily grind.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
asdusty
Remember Milne Bay!
01:28 AM on 01/05/2010
As an Australian it amazes me that this is the situation that Americans face. We enjoy legislated paid holidays as part of our employment conditions. We also enjoy universal healthcare. The societal benefits of both holiday pay and universal halthcare has been well documented and should be part of the rights of citizenship. It appears that the only rights associated with US citizenship is the right to have to pay for everything and to support your corporate masters through your taxes.
Australia's economy is one of the healthiest in the world so any suggestion that a country with the sort of economic power of the USA cannot afford such programs is laughable and is merely a line used to protect corporate vested interests. Employment without a social contract is just slavery and a minimum wage of less than ten dollars an hour, no holiday pay and no universal healthcare demonstrates that life is cheap in the US.
03:33 PM on 01/04/2010
The government should force all companies to provide at least 20 annual vacation days for their employees. A happy and well-rested worker will most likely work more and produce at a higher quality. A worker who gets no rest will simply do the bare minimum not to get fired.
05:08 PM on 01/04/2010
The government should force you to do things you can't afford
05:59 PM on 01/04/2010
Nonsense. When the CEO at a company gets paid millions per year with lavish vacation time, I don't think it is too much to ask for 2 weeks vacation plus 5 days of sick leave. This is why people like me support the return of unions. Not only have I given up salary since 1980, I have lost significant benefits as well. The gap between the haves and have nots needs to close.