iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Joe Robinson

GET UPDATES FROM Joe Robinson
 

Is Social Networking Destroying Our Social Lives?

Posted: 02/01/11 08:48 AM ET

It's a little ironic that, as social media pushes the virtual friend count to new heights, the culture as a whole is getting ever more isolated. Researchers say that Americans have fewer close confidants outside family than ever before. One in four have no confidants at all. A study at the University of Michigan reported that 75 percent of college students have lower empathy than their peers did 30 years ago, which isn't going to boost the social cause; neither will a spike in students' narcissism over that same period, documented in research at San Diego State University.

Exploding social media hasn't dented the social isolation trend of the last couple of decades. It's a reminder that there's no substitute for the real social deal -- folks you've actually met in person, with whom you've shared experiences and built intimacy that goes beyond the surface chatter. There's no doubt you meet some great folks online, as I have, but the social animal needs to connect more than superficially with others of the tribe. Our core psychological need for "relatedness," say researchers, mandates that we have close relationships with others.

It gets harder in the adult and career worlds to take care of that social mandate. Time is the fastener of friendship, and we have less of that... or so we think. There's always time, if you make the time and lose the stranglehold of time urgency -- the false emergency that would have you believe you're too busy to live.

One of the best ways to improve real social life is through a forgotten option that's been shoved aside by overwork, the flat screen TV and the time sink that social media can be: participant recreation. Play is the real-life social network. It's a social catalyst that creates immediate common ground between strangers and makes it easy to forge friendships that can last a lifetime. The basis for the relating is the fun and the activity, not what anyone does for a living. You get behind the masks of the workaday world. It's similar to travel in that way -- you accept folks at face value and the resume doesn't matter. The unconditional realm of play keeps the inauthentic yardsticks away, which is why it creates the kind of bonds that satisfy your deepest relational needs.

I saw the power of play close at hand in the course of researching my new book, "Don't Miss Your Life." I met kayakers, climbers, dancers and a host of other life enthusiasts who had found camaraderie and real friendships through pursuing their passions and hobbies. Case in point: Kim Travis, an actress and small theater owner who had to leave New York City and her beloved softball team to take care of her ill mother in Austin, Texas. Travis' connection with her team was so important that she commuted from Austin to New York and back every Thursday to coach her Actor's Equity team in Central Park. Travis loves softball, but the flights every Thursday were about one thing: the people. "Most of us have been playing together for years," she says. "There's not one person on that team who doesn't love the others. We're a family."

Over and over, in dozens of different activities, people had found not just good friends but family. It was the support of fellow band members, choir singers or orienteering friends that helped people get through bouts of cancer or the death of a spouse. Several told me they don't know what they would have done without the support of their activity comrades when life's biggest challenges came calling.

Our real-life social networks are hugely important, and vanishing. Many suburban streets these days look like ghost towns -- there's not a soul to be seen. Humans emerge only to go to and from work. Even the kids are inside, buried in video games. Neighbors who might be burning up the social media pages inside their homes barely know each other outside.

Over the last three decades, Americans have become less and less participant-oriented and more and more audience members. We are less likely to join groups, from sports teams to civic groups, than we used to be. We are more likely to live alone. More social isolation feeds less empathy and fewer social skills. We get so used to dealing with people via e-mail or online that we forget how to function around live humans. To break out of isolation row, we have to develop a skill-set -- tools of "life intelligence" that allow us to self-determine a participant and prosocial path.

Play offers a highly targeted option to build real relationships that can satisfy your critical social need. Social connection is a well-vetted predictor of well-being. People who are content with their social lives are happier and healthier. Studies show that participating in enjoyable social activities is a strong predictor for increased daily well-being. The more active your leisure life, the higher your life satisfaction.

There are no agendas in the non-judgmental act of play, so it creates a level playing field that cuts across the usual social and income barriers. The Broadway Show League that Travis' team plays in has featured stars from Al Pacino to Kevin Spacey, but teams also include stagehands and crew members.

Salespeople the world over know that the art of the deal happens on the golf course or over lunch. You cut to the core in play, making the usual boundaries drop away. The scripted self gets replaced by the real thing, at ease and no longer on guard. We're a lot more inclined to connect when our real selves are doing the connecting -- instead of the business card or presentation face. Playing puts you in the frame of mind to be open to others. Negative feelings close off receptivity.

Marty Herman, an accountant in Southern California, put himself on a whole new social trajectory when he took up salsa dancing. He marvels how stepping out into an activity that was nerve-racking at first has brought a host of real-life friends that he wouldn't have had otherwise. "Dancing has totally changed my social life," he says. "It's been a huge plus." Playing in an adult kickball league introduced marketing coordinator Ariana Mayman to dozens of friends, including three roommates and a boyfriend. "In a big city, it's easy to feel very small and alone," she told me. "Kickball gives you the confidence to walk up to anyone, anywhere, and feel comfortable having a conversation."

You don't have to be a social butterfly to unleash the social sparks because the activity itself brings everyone together. You do have expend some effort, though. You have to get out of the house, away from the computer and impound the phone. Clicking is so much easier, but it's the participation that satisfies your core self-determination needs. Friends, optimal moments, elation, exhilaration -- it's all there for us when we step out of the sedentary box and into the center of life fully lived.

***

Joe Robinson is the author of "Don't Miss Your Life," on the science, skills and spirit of full-tilt living. He is the founder of Work to Live and is a work-life balance and stress management trainer and coach.

 
 
 

Follow Joe Robinson on Twitter: www.twitter.com/WorkLifeSkills

It's a little ironic that, as social media pushes the virtual friend count to new heights, the culture as a whole is getting ever more isolated. Researchers say that Americans have fewer close confida...
It's a little ironic that, as social media pushes the virtual friend count to new heights, the culture as a whole is getting ever more isolated. Researchers say that Americans have fewer close confida...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 37
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
06:25 PM on 02/03/2011
right on point Joe. You have nailed the dis-ease in social networks. Getting out is a challenge but very rewarding. Yesterday, I was invited to a group of people discussing Tantra and immediately had 'real' connections. For older persons it is tempting to think 'been there, done that.' I find that scheduling activities gets me off the couch and out. Even if I don't 'join' the group, I can plan to get out and then be surprised.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tracey Ginn Guidi
i have found peace
05:40 PM on 02/03/2011
Thanks to this article I know exactly who "you" are!!! I knew it!!!
06:36 PM on 02/03/2011
If you're using your real name on this site than I can say unequivocally that I do not know you in any way other than in the capacity of being a fellow poster here on HP. If you'll notice we are often on the opposite side of issues so I assure you you're confusing me with someone else. I hope that doesn't disappoint you.

Cheers
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tracey Ginn Guidi
i have found peace
09:47 PM on 02/03/2011
Oh my...why would you think i'm speaking about you? This only confirms my suspicion.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
05:20 PM on 02/03/2011
Social networks are a tool to be used or abused. I hate these articles that lump everyone who uses something together in the negative. Sites like meetup.com have put so many people with the same interests together to form real social families as stated. They have made these real social bonds accesable to so many more people then before they exsisted. No, lets just talk up some negative that is most likely a small minority. Glad I don't need a coach or Life balancer.
04:04 PM on 02/04/2011
I agree with you. There are hundreds of thousands of individuals who for the first time in their lives are now being social. I was just talking with another poster about the way it does cause unnecessary paranoia and people seem to be less trusting than ever before. For me, that's a disappointment but I've always been a "cup is half full" kinda girl and I'm able to find the silver lining in everything, even in the most dire circumstance. So, I join you in pushing back against the negative comments and the sense of paranoia it seems to instill in our very human beings.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tracey Ginn Guidi
i have found peace
01:53 PM on 02/03/2011
I have a dear friend who is being stalked via facebook. She apparently does this constantly and has no other life. She contacts his friends, has fake profiles, etc.....so annoying, life is too short. And all the while facebook does nothing!!
04:58 PM on 02/03/2011
That is unfortunate. I have a dear friend who has had just the opposite experience. Her on and off again boyfriend of over a year was two timing her and when she cornered him in the midst of the lie (just as he was living this woman's home), he set about to destroy her reputation by calling her a "stalker". He told the new girlfriend that she was stalking him and to watch out for her. It was a real mess but she finally contacted an attorney and is in the process of having him sued. And sadly the new girlfriend and his close "friends" all fell for his story. A real shame that individuals can trash one another this way. I think FB does intervene when they see an authentic issue but if FB is not helping your friend maybe it's time to reevaluate what your friend is telling you and dig in to learn the real facts on your own. There are two sides to every story and some people spin the truth better than others.
05:09 PM on 02/03/2011
I have a friend on the opposite end. She had a boyfriend who was seeing someone else at the same time and when he was caught red handed he began to spin the truth and nearly ruined my friends reputation. Luckily the truth prevailed. If FB isn't doing anything you may want to double check your friend's story. Sorry to say but you friend may be exposing you to some mistruths. Good luck to you.
01:24 PM on 02/02/2011
Not that this wasn't a well-written article, but, to us needing to get out more and stop Facebooking so much............DUH!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Stacey Jones
In the gutter but looking at the stars.
12:14 AM on 02/02/2011
Well some of us never had a social life to begin with! I just logged off all of my social networking sites like Facebook, Twitter,etc. They are so boring! I love my tumblr blog because I post my artwork but I'm going to try to get out of the house more this year. I've always had social problems at school, at home,etc. you name it!
10:40 PM on 02/01/2011
I don't see the problem here. Socializing ... ya, is that where you get together with other people and get drunk and/or gossip? Hmmm I'll stick to my big screen TV.
08:36 PM on 02/02/2011
it's where people get together to play sports or dance or read books or cook meals......
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
thebearschick
09:16 PM on 02/01/2011
Everything in moderation. Facebook is a tool that I use to keep tabs on updates from my broader circle of friends and family. It's useful because a lot of people post pictures from weddings, births...etc. I definitely can see how there would be a problem if you never attended any social functions and only went online to find "community". It's very important to get involved in some sort of face-to-face community group. Whether it's a church, a neighborhood gym, a library book group, or a cooking class---sign up for something!
08:37 PM on 02/02/2011
yeah, it has a lot of very good uses. I just find that when I'm on it too much, it makes me scattered and depressed!
photo
lovely09
I don't comment much, but when I do...
08:56 PM on 02/01/2011
I had a friend on Facebook who had a status update every hour for 14-20 hours...no joking.

She was an old high school friend and I eventually had to defriend her. I later dumped Facebook altogether myself.
08:24 PM on 02/01/2011
While this may be the case for some, it is only one point-of-view. Please take a look at my thoughts on how social networking enhances our real life connections: http://hirvimaki.blogspot.com/2010/06/internet-friends.html
10:53 PM on 02/01/2011
Here here, my internet friend. :)

While I can't disagree with much of Joe's article -- adults *should* play more, I think -- the post's title raised my ire. Social media has metamorphosed my social life in a strongly positive way. Five years ago, I had one spouse with whom I spent 99% of my social time; and a very small number of geographically close friends and family. After my divorce, I became active in social media in part to connect with new people. I'm down a husband, but in place of that one relationship I am part of a large web of loving, in real life friendships -- many of them with people I happened to connect with initially through social media.

I don't trust the internet with dating relationships -- those are best originated, as far as I'm concerned, in concert with Joe's commandment to play more in real life. But aside from dating, people I've first connected with through social media (especially Twitter) have become some of my closest confidants, biggest cheerleaders, and most instrumental mentors. Yes, I'm talking about people I've met in real life; but those in real life meetings would never had happened, if not for connecting first online.
11:10 PM on 02/01/2011
And two little notes, and then I'll stop... :)

1. Paukku and I first "met" via Twitter. He and his wife and their amazing daughter shared their breakfast table with me during my last trip through New Mexico. His daughter's drawing is hanging on my refrigerator. Now that's social.

2. Joe (the author) and I would never have connected were it not for my involvement in social media. :)
07:53 PM on 02/01/2011
Social Networking is already done as much damage as all that the media has done in the past 30. Only historians will recognize this -- because our culture has been deeply brain-washed to unshakeably believe....

...... "If I like it, it's good for me!"

(Which is the fundamental cause for everything from Addiction to Obesity.)
07:23 PM on 02/01/2011
Social media is launching my social life. This month I met face-to-face 2 college friends not seen for 20 years. Would never have happened without social media forces of FB and LinkedIn.
http://www.returntoworkmom.com/
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sensimilla
Lead with your heart, and your mind will follow...
06:18 PM on 02/01/2011
short answer: no

long answer: no, not really.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Widespread Panic
To the bang bang boogie, say up jump the boogie
05:08 PM on 02/01/2011
Easier said than done for us shy folks. I've tried joining groups, but I just don't click with anyone cause no matter what folks are always in a clique. And like high school, it's just tough to break into those cliques. I find that I have more things in common with folks online cause they seem to be more diverse.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sensimilla
Lead with your heart, and your mind will follow...
06:18 PM on 02/01/2011
you definitely have something there..
10:56 PM on 02/01/2011
I find that too. I'm shy, but you'd never guess it from my online chatter and honesty; I've had to learn to be "unshy" in person, because that's what society expects of us. Sometimes I can pull it off in person; others, I wind up making a "french exit."

I meet a lot of great people in real life; I've met a couple of people who are like my #wondertwins through friendships that started online. I know there are people of all stripes who participate in online communities, but I've seen what you have, too -- that it can be easier to find more people "like me" socially, that I connect with more easily and with less social anxiety, online than in the real world.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Widespread Panic
To the bang bang boogie, say up jump the boogie
11:09 PM on 02/01/2011
Exactly. I was trying to say this but even online I sometimes can not find the right words. Thank you - fanned and faved. :)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Oregonian76
Just a guy from the PacNW
01:59 PM on 02/01/2011
I like the sentiment about "participant recreation". Something my wife & I make it a point to do: not have conversation via email or text. We only use those methods to send little reminders when necessary (ie groceries, errands, etc). We actually talk to each other when we're at home together.

I have a friend that is constantly waffling about how he wants (or doesn't want) social media in his life. He hasn't learned yet that it's merely an enhancer; it as never meant as a substitute for the real thing. But he goes to the extreme in his thoughts about it, much like many younger people are going to the extreme in how they use social media and technology.

It's all about balance... and knowing that things have their place and their purpose, so use them as such...