More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
John Bridgeland

John Bridgeland

Posted: March 9, 2011 05:22 PM

The Civility of David Broder


When I received the news of David Broder's death, I was in the middle of writing a case statement on why we needed more civility in our public discourse. David exemplified that civility and was able to bridge ideology, party, and national tensions to spark action on issues about which he and the nation cared.

My first experience with David occurred when I was a Chief of Staff on Capitol Hill in my early 30s and heard him talk about the power of communities to effect change. I promptly wrote him a letter about how our congressional office was envisioning a "new model of governance" in which Members of Congress organized leaders in local communities to tackle tough problems. He immediately wrote me back and wanted to learn more. We had organized the Coalition for a Drug-Free Cincinnati and David was excited to come see it. He reported on it at the Republican National Convention in a column entitled, Jump-Starting New Models of Governance. It prompted more national attention and helped result in the development and passage of the Drug-Free Communities Act, which provided support to hundreds of community anti-drug coalitions across the country.

When I served as Director of the White House Domestic Policy Council and then USA Freedom Corps after 9/11, David was there, covering our issues in a balanced manner and quietly forging bipartisan consensus. He loved America and consistently wrote about national and community service opportunities for citizens to give something back to their country. After 9/11, he wrote numerous columns that helped galvanize more Americans to serve through USA Freedom Corps programs. Many Republicans did not like federal support for national service -- David took them head on.

I went to see David in 2005 about a forthcoming report on the high school dropout epidemic. He welcomed me into his office at the Washington Post, where I found him in a small office with mounds of papers and reports surrounding him, and he listened to my story. I told him that almost no one in America knew that one-third of all public high school students -- and one-half of minorities -- were dropping out of high school; that we had just completed a survey, working with the Gates Foundation and Hart Research, of dropouts that gave the nation hope that most could have graduated; and that we were outlining a 10-point plan of action to mobilize all sectors to respond. He told me of a recent visit to the Gateway to College program in Portland, Oregon, where he saw former dropouts reading Plato and Malcolm X and engaging in their learning. He said, "Sunday or Thursday for the column?" Sunday it was.

David wrote a column called The Dropout Challenge that ignited a national movement to address it. Millions of people were instantly educated about this "silent epidemic" and the country awakened to do something about it. Just last year, we reported with Johns Hopkins and America's Promise Alliance increases in high school graduation rates across 29 states and were able to showcase states, districts and schools that had boosted their graduation rates significantly. David Broder played a significant part in helping to engage every sector in America to help stem the dropout tide.

But what I loved about him the most was that he was such a fine human being who valued civility in public discourse and had a rare ability to clarify issues and marshal relevant facts in an unemotional manner to support his judgments. Even though he was on many TV programs, and this Pulitzer-Prize winning journalist was syndicated all over the country and picked up in markets around the world, the fame never took hold of him and he was humble and respectful and patriotic to the end.

We will miss you, David Broder. My hope for the country is that we will honor you in many ways, but perhaps most of all by finding more room for civility in our public discourse. God knows our country needs it.

John M. Bridgeland was former Director of the White House Domestic Policy Council and USA Freedom Corps. He is currently CEO of Civic Enterprises in Washington, DC.

 

Follow John Bridgeland on Twitter: www.twitter.com/@civicenterpris

 
 
  • Comments
  • 14
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
07:22 PM on 03/13/2011
HUGE loss for policy analysis, not to mention his family and friends. I'm an avid MTP fan and was wondering where Mr. Broder has been the past few months. Although I didn't know him personally, I feel a loss myself. He was a very kind, generous person who was respectful in his interactions with others on television and always had a great perspective that didn't appear tainted with politics. RIP, David Broder
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:30 PM on 03/10/2011
John, you're right. Broder was civil! But, he couldn't appreciate the violence, death, immorality and mayhem of the U.S. wars that he had endorsed, including, especially the Iraq War. This, sadly, is a huge part of Broder's legacy as a journalist of "civility."
09:26 AM on 03/10/2011
I always admired Mr. Broder as a panelist on "Washington Week", but in recent years found his editorials very unenlightening, as they almost exclusively focused on Beltway political strategy - which politician and party will it help and which will it hurt? And always, who "won"? Rarely any larger observations about whether the country would benefit or be hurt by such political wranglings. Mr. Broder also tended to view ongoing and highly disputed policy agguments as haveing already been decided, and as having become universally agreed upon conventional wisdom. For example, he recently penned that "everyone knows" the Social Security retirement age needs to be raised, and benefits reduced. Hardly a settled argument.

chaslf
Lincoln, NE
12:42 AM on 03/10/2011
Someone who writes an opinion column must be principally judged by whether they get things right or wrong. There is an entire subset of wrongness named Broderism. Look it up. In 2003, he said this for Harpers: "Let me disclose my own bias in this matter. I like Karl Rove." Truly, a man with his finger on the pulse of the nation. No, that's his pulse.
11:23 PM on 03/09/2011
May he rest in peace. I agree that he " valued civility in public discourse and had a rare ability to clarify issues and marshal relevant facts in an unemotional manner to support his judgments." But I also think time passed him by and that his work in later years was rather out of touch with the tempo and the mood of the times. He was a good writer who became less relevant to me over time. Happens to all of us I guess.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:46 PM on 03/09/2011
I agree. Always enjoyed Broder. He will be missed.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
hipocampelofantocame
retired pediatrician
09:32 PM on 03/09/2011
I'm sorry that he's gone. We have lost yet another good man.
photo
StillIRise
The past, present and future are one
08:54 PM on 03/09/2011
David Broder was indeed the embodiment of civility, something that is very rare in today's political discourse. 
 
I am very sorry to hear of his death.  He was widely and well respected, and he will be missed.
08:02 PM on 03/09/2011
I don't know-the impression I got from reading David Broder's columns in the WaPo was that he was willfully blind to the basic nature and political strategy of the modern republican party.

Bipartisan compromise is only possible when both sides are willing to bargain in good faith and are actually interested in coming to an agreement.

The republican party's only goal is the total political destruction of President Obama and the Democratic Party. David Broder in spite of his unique position and his infinite political wisdom was never able to see or admit that such a situation even exists.

May be rest in peace. It's time for a new generation to become the "Deans of Washington journalism."
09:05 PM on 03/09/2011
He sold the hatred and mean-spirited GOP very short! He actually trusted them! Why....I'll never know!
07:05 PM on 03/09/2011
Civil, yes, but to what end? Has he ever conducted a revealing interview? If so, please provide a link.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tulka2
Solidarity. Courage. Humor.
09:19 PM on 03/09/2011
Pithy and true.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
eden4barack08
Watch out! He carries a big stick!
06:31 PM on 03/09/2011
I will always remember David Broder for the most insightful and farsighted article I've ever read, written by someone who wasn't exactly a fan of this President, as David wasn't.
To quote a few of the memorable paragraphs:

"We are beginning to learn that the Obama presidency will be an era of substantial but deferred accomplishments -- His vaunted "cool" allows him to wait without impatience and to endure without visible despair. It asks the same of his constituents."

"It is likely that if and when Congress responds to other challenges Obama has given it -- to restructure financial regulation; to rationalize energy, education and environmental policies; and to slow the ruinous growth of entitlement programs -- the pattern will be the same: incremental steps leading to possible future breakthroughs.

For a nation whose culture has produced a psychology demanding instant gratification, this politics of deferred satisfaction is something not easily learned. In his political career, Obama has been a perfect embodiment of an impatient generation. He rocketed through his few years in Springfield to capture a Senate seat from Illinois, then quickly became impatient with the Senate's ways and set his cap for the presidency.

But somewhere, he has learned the virtues of patience when it comes to governing."

"But a president who is not driven by a compulsion to provide instant gratification for his constituents must also cultivate adult patience in them."

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/04/14/AR2010041402991.html?wpisrc=nl_opinions
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
08:07 PM on 03/09/2011
I've always thought that the public has for more capacity for patience and the willingness to defer reward than they are given credit for.

What is missing are leaders willing to treat the public like adults, and who can lay out a logical argument in a compelling fashion. And a media willing to give them the means to do so, instead of bombarding us with sound bites.