More

John V. Santore

John V. Santore

Posted: January 26, 2009 12:17 PM

Michelle Obama Is Not Just a Black Woman


A long time ago, I had a fascinating conversation with one of then candidate-Obama's staffers who just happened to be visiting a home I was staying at while on the campaign. I asked him about criticisms Obama had faced from Cornel West and other African-American commentators for his failure to attend the State of the Black Union forum hosted every year by Tavis Smiley. The aide explained to me that what some black intellectual leaders hadn't yet realized was that this time, it wasn't just a case of a black candidate running to represent black America. This was a black candidate who could actually win, and who had the opportunity to be president of all of America, not just a portion of it. As such, he didn't need to make all of the rounds that African-American candidates make when they are just trying to appeal to black voters.

I thought of this when I read the below story, especially this quote: "Why wasn't she wearing the clothes of a black designer? That was our moment." I'm not for a second going to dispute the fact that the election of Obama was massively significant for African-Americans in America, for nothing less than the fact that for once, I believe, blacks in the country felt as though they too were truly Americans, and could potentially be viewed as individuals -- as human beings -- by everyone. But if that is the case, then Michelle Obama shouldn't have to wear clothes by a black designer just because she is black. She should wear anything she wants. And the point of Obama's election is not that African-Americans had a singular moment on January 20th. The hope is that now, every day is their moment, because in Obama's America, everyone has a chance to succeed. Dismissing such a basic principal -- albeit one that has never been realized -- as nothing more than "Kumbaya" thinking reveals a mindset in which this election was just a fluke, and wasn't really representative of a fundamental shift in the thinking of the American electorate regarding race. We'll have to see how true this turns out to be, but for the time being, why not at least consider it to be a possibility?

Here's the related story:

FIRST LADY UNDER FIRE: Amid all the praise of First Lady Michelle Obama's fashion choices for the inaugural festivities, the Black Artists Association is taking her to task for not wearing anything by an African American designer. Cofounder Amnau Eele said Wednesday she will make a formal appeal to the First Lady's office on behalf of the BAA. "It's fine and good if you want to be all 'Kumbaya' and 'We Are the World' by representing all different countries. But if you are going to have Isabel Toledo do the inauguration dress, and Jason Wu do the evening gown, why not have Kevan Hall, B Michael, Stephen Burrows or any of the other black designers do something too?" Eele said. The BAA leader was a runway model in her own right for Yves Saint Laurent, Giorgio Armani, Bill Blass and others.

Asked if perhaps the First Lady isn't looking at the world colorlessly, Eele said, "It's one thing to look at the world without color but she had seven slots to wear designer clothes. Why wasn't she wearing the clothes of a black designer? That was our moment."

 
 
  • Comments
  • 31
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
08:56 AM on 02/14/2009
Hmmm, well that Kumbaya commentary is fatuous and misleading. I think the change here should be that we recognize designers, novelists, actors, politicians for their talents rather than ethnicity, gender, physical attributes, sexual identity. It would probably be fair to say that the 1st Lady passed over many outfits, her criterion based more on how the designs looked on her rather than the looks of the designer.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
december30
03:02 PM on 01/27/2009
Brilliant. Thank you, Thank you.
02:21 PM on 01/27/2009
Good article. Thanks.
10:10 AM on 01/27/2009
Thank you, what a well-written and to the point article. I'm an African-American woman, but I've been raised to believe that foremost, I am unique individual. Choosing a designer or anyone simply because of their race diminishes the perception of their actual talent and ability. As the first family, the Obamas bring the possibility of showing that African-Americans are articulate and distinct people who choose styles based on a wonderful concept-personal preferences.
02:31 PM on 01/27/2009
Love you!lolll! Great and Truthful comment EL04!

A lot of people thought that America was racist...NOW there is a president of African descent (and by the way NOT a "black president"), thoughless minds still need to find scape goats for their own racism. It's no wonder a wise person once said that we only externalise our own fears and doubts.

I am not implying that racism doesn't exist, what I am saying is this :

the more you look after it, the more you are bound to witness it galore...

America (as a whole) is not stupid to choose somebody just because of the colour of their skins. It wouldn't be a superpower in the Whole World if it did accept such a puny mindframe.

As "propitiousmoment" below mentioned delightfully, America voted for Obama because of his ideals and positive ideas.....and I forgot to mention, he happened to be black :) .That's it!

Stay Blessed and keep Growing thoughless minds!
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
propitiousmoment
the journey is the destination....
02:02 AM on 01/27/2009
I voted for Obama because of who he is, his authenticity, his leadership, his ability to inspire, and because of the promise of what I perceive to be his progressive ideals. Part of who he is, is black. He would have been awesome in any skin, but part of what makes him special is that he's black, how that shaped him and what it represents for this country. We celebrated all of that with his inauguration, and he is the president of all of us. And his wife is the first lady of all of us. She is beautiful, smart, warm, direct, and deep. Part of her depth is the result of having lived the black experience, part of her outward beauty is owing to her blackness, and part of our celebration of the inauguration had to do with what her ancestry and her ascension to the role of first lady represents to the country. Let her be the one to decide how she connects with and represents us, in fashion or in anything else.
10:15 AM on 02/01/2009
propitiousmoment >"He would have been awesome in any skin, but part of what makes him special is that he's black, how that shaped him and what it represents for this country."

I'll give you the benefit of the doubt in what you stated, but there are ALOT of people who voted for BHO simply because of his skin color. I wished I had a quarter for everytime I've heard, mostly blacks say, "I voted for him because he's black, it is so wonderful to finally have a black President." And that was their reasoning for voting for him.

I could care less whether a President's skin color is black, white, green, or polka dot. The thing that is botherersome is the reverse racism of voting for BHO just because of his skin color. For those who did vote for him mainly because of his skin color, it lessens the "specialness" of a black man being our President.

Racism is foolish to begin with, and reverse racism is no different. If BHO was fully white, not as many black people would have voted for him.
12:20 AM on 01/27/2009
This is where things get silly. Let Michelle Obama wear whatever the h*ll she wants. She is the First Lady of all Americans.

It is very ignorant and stupid of Amnau Eele to judge Michelle Obama because of the skin color of the designer. They have learned nothing from the election. This is the chance for Barack Obama to put this country back on the right track for ALL people. The fact that Obama won the election is amazing in itself. And all these people can say is they don't like the skin color of Michelle's designers? Seriously?!
11:31 PM on 01/26/2009
Never heard of the BAA. Is it a real organization? If nobody knows, why's everybody talking about them this evening?
11:31 PM on 01/26/2009
This could be an over simplification on my part but is it possible she couldn't find anything she liked by a black designer. She is the one wearing the clothes. Was she supposed to just show up wearing something, anything just to say it's by a black designer.

Then there is the possible influence of the Retailer/Stylist Ikram Goldman, who she alledgely worked with very closely to choose her attire for the inauguration events. What possible options was she shown by the stylist? Were any by black designers included?

My moneys on option one.
11:27 PM on 01/26/2009
Michelle Obama is NOT JUST a Black Woman??? Was that a compliment?
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
propitiousmoment
the journey is the destination....
01:49 AM on 01/27/2009
"just" meaning "only"
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
montecarlo408
01:25 PM on 01/27/2009
I think it is. She is more than just a walking billboard for black people and our causes. She is a human being, with a conscience, feelings, accomplishments, faults, and, yes, her own tastes. For them to say this is "our" moment like black people are the only people who voted for Obama is ridiculous. Just because we have had white Presidents who only thought about their rich, white friends doesn't mean that we as black people should do likewise.
09:26 PM on 01/26/2009
Man. As a black woman, I am so over this. Come on people, Michelle is not the BLACK First Lady. She is the First Lady period. She can well whatever the hell she damn well pleases whenever the hell she damn well please. Get over yourselves. If she wants to wear a gown by a black designer it will be one that fits into her ethos, the spirit of her being, not because some organization whines about it. Let's remember this was not just a moment for black people, it was a moment for all Americans and for the world. How else do we move beyond this instinct to marginalize each other? I'm so proud of her and Barack. They are the essence of style and grace and compassion and hard work. Their beautiful daughters reflect that. I pray for them both each day. And to all the haters out there -- go do your job and design a beautiful dress; only that will catch her eye not your whining.
07:47 AM on 01/27/2009
As an Black American woman, 'THANK YOU' for this comment.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
montecarlo408
01:25 PM on 01/27/2009
I second that.
02:01 PM on 01/27/2009
Ditto, my sistah.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
psychmaj323
06:05 PM on 01/27/2009
Thank you! I'm like I love my people, but uhhh...this is a little too much. Hell I wouldn't wear something just because someone Black made it; it'd FIRST have to be something that actually looks nice.
09:24 PM on 01/26/2009
Man. As a black woman, I am so over this. Come on people, Michelle is not the BLACK First Lady. She is the First Lady period. She can well whatever the hell she damn well pleases whenever the hell she damn well please. Get over yourselves. If she wants to wear a gown by a black designer it will be one that fits into her ethos, the spirit of her being, not because some organization whines about it. Let's remember this was not just a moment for black people, it was a moment for all Americans and for the world. How else do we move beyond this instinct to marginalize each other? I'm so proud of her and Barack. They are the essence of style and grace and compassion and hard work. Their beautiful daughters reflect that. I pray for them both each day. And to all the haters out there -- go do your job and design a beautiful dress; only that will catch her eye not your whining.
09:24 PM on 01/26/2009
This is crazy for them to Criticize the first lady for being a Global First Lady. She is not a Black First Lady, She is the First Lady period. She choose designs that reflect her particular style and also gave them exposure that perhaps a more established Black designer like Kevan Hall. I love his stuff since his was a student at Fashion Institute of Design and Merchandising, but the First Lady is not required to only choose a Black Artist overtime she wears something.

Also, the Black Artist are whining like victims...Why don't they submit some designs to the White House and be proactive in lieu of complaining after the fact. They should share in the excitement in "Firsts." I don't remember this organization complaining when previous First Ladies choose European designers all the time. At least She is keeping the $$$ in USA and promoting People of Color who live the American Dream when they arrived here from their foreign lands.

Give me a break...
07:48 PM on 01/26/2009
I had never even heard of the Black Artists Association before today. If it's a bonafide organization, they're an embarrassment. The only way Obama won the presidency was by convincing the American people that he would be EVERYONE'S president -- all races, creeds and colors. BAA's views are divisive, backward and ridiculous. For the first time in my life, I feel so positve about race relations in this country and I don't feel like being yanked backward in time by the BAA.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Solja
05:54 PM on 01/26/2009
That article about the Assoc. of Black Artists was some B.S. that shouldn't have even been typed, let alone published. Who cares what this unknown person in some unknown association thinks of what someone should be wearing? It was a waste of space and my time.

As for Tavis Smiley and Cornel West, somewhere along the line, someone told them that they represented black America. THEY DON'T. Tavis is an opportunist and he doesn't represent me as a black woman, and Cornel West is an embarassment to black America. We don't look THAT raggedy. Both of these people, who happen to be black, only served to piss off the black community to the point that Tavis was getting death threats and thousands of hate mail. He deserved the community whooping he got because he doesn't speak for the masses. Nobody voted him into office. He's on PBS where the average viewer, black or otherwise, isn't turning to for their "news" or "current events".

He lost a lot of viewers and respect in the black community, and he will never be forgotten for what he did while we were all working, volunteering, hoping and praying that we'd elect our first black President. To the basement with BOTH he and West. They can't get any of my attention ever again.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
psychmaj323
06:08 PM on 01/27/2009
GEEZ, death threats? WOW, Tavis kept his mouth shut and I'm glad.
05:54 PM on 01/26/2009
NO Amnau Eele. That was not "our" moment as black Americans...it was a moment that belonged to all the Americans who elected Barack Obama and did their part to help put this nation back on the right track. That Inauguration was Michelles's day to shine and exhibit her individual flare as our next First Lady. How dare you take that away from her with your self-centered crap. I think you owe Ms. Obama anapology.