More

Joseph A. Palermo

Joseph A. Palermo

Posted: August 10, 2009 09:59 AM

Bill O'Reilly-Keith Olbermann Feud Ends with a Corporate Handshake?


According to Brian Stelter, writing in the New York Times business section, it was FOX News director Roger Ailes who cooked up the original scheme to blunt Keith Olbermann's withering criticism of Bill O'Reilly. The plan entailed O'Reilly and Glenn Beck aiming their barbs, not at Olbermann or his show Countdown on MSNBC, but at Olbermann's boss at General Electric (MSNBC's parent company) and its CEO Jeffrey Immelt. It turned out Immelt had no stomach for the bad publicity O'Reilly and Beck were heaping on his corporation so he cut a deal with Rupert Murdoch agreeing to end the O'Reilly-Olbermann feud. The Murdoch-Immelt handshake agreement that enacted a "cease and desist" order to their two star anchors looks more like a corporate merger than anything having to do with journalism.

It was Murdoch of the media conglomerate News Corporation who chose the Republican strategist Ailes to head his FOX News division. When Murdoch hired him, the single most important achievement on Ailes's resume was his co-authorship of the racist Willie Horton ad of the 1988 George H. W. Bush campaign. Since that fateful day in 1996 Ailes's right-wing "news" outfit has become one of the most important sources of disseminating Republican talking points in American political discourse.

General Electric is responsible for catapulting Ronald Reagan's early political career (GE even gave Reagan his own designer kitchen to show off the "fully electric home"). Later, when Reagan became president, GE paid ZERO taxes for several years. GE is also known for dumping carcinogenic PCBs in the Hudson River and lying about it, and receiving billions of dollars in no-bid military contracts (including contracts for the Iraq war). And it was GE that forced MSNBC to cancel Phil Donahue's show because he was one of the only people on cable television who had the temerity to question George W. Bush's bogus claims that Iraq possessed an arsenal of "weapons of mass destruction." Both practically and ideologically there isn't a dime's worth of difference between Rupert Murdoch's News Corporation and Jeffrey Immelt's General Electric .

Corporate honchos making back-room editorial decisions for the "news" subsidiaries they control? I'm not a professional reporter but I cannot help but think that that practice might not be the best thing for the integrity of journalism.

From the time the O'Reilly-Olbermann rivalry began the media frame from CNN, NPR, the New York Times and even The Daily Show has constructed a false equivalency between O'Reilly (the Republican partisan) and Olbermann (the Democratic partisan). But that is an inaccurate narrative. Olbermann differs from O'Reilly in that he cares about truth and falsehood, and he understands the distinction between journalism and propaganda. Bill O'Reilly is a liar and a demagogue and a right-wing propagandist. Just do a quick Media Matters search under "Bill O'Reilly" and you won't believe what you'll find.

Keith Olbermann is one of the only cable television personalities who uses his allotted time on Countdown each night to trying to keep the record straight. Jeffrey Immelt, Rupert Murdoch, and Bill O'Reilly were the big winners in this corrupt bargain. The only thing Olbermann got from the episode was his integrity questioned by accusations he was a party to this tawdry "deal" struck between Wall Street titans and orchestrated by a Republican strategist.

 
 
  • Comments
  • 14
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
allenosuno
Just me being myself
03:01 PM on 08/11/2009
Why have the FCC broadcast licenses been allowed to be hijacked by for-profit corporations. It is my understanding that the FCC leases the airwaves to the various broadcast media. So WHY did the Fairness Doctrine and the Public Service requirement get revoked under Ronald Reagan and the FCC watered down by being infiltrated by GW Bush corporate cronies? The American public, not the corporations, own the airwaves, at least technically. The fact that the corporations and the oligarchy have hijacked the public trust in so many areas: banking, healthcare, broadcast media: all of these should exist as more or less public domain and be operated as utilities for the common good, not as cash cows for the elites. Can anyone tell me why Barack Obama and the Democratic leaders in Congress haven't re-visited the Fairness Doctrine, diversification of media ownership (trust busting the corpies lockhold) and the old requirement for the networks to give back in the form of public service and equal time provisions that used to exist before Ronald Reagan and the corporate oligarchy party (GOP) stripped away protections that were in place for decades since the advent of television at least. So now, as with everything, the profit motive for a few has supplanted the good of the many as our national ethos in every area of life. Why is our public so easily brainwashed by the obviously self-serving greedheads and so easily turn into their willing shills against their own best interests? .
01:00 PM on 08/11/2009
Seeing how Keith Olbermann always tries to make sure to keep his integrity and dignity, I expect him to disregard the cease fire order and keep firing shots to expose the blatant falsehoods of Fox News. Jeffrey Immelt, in my opinion, should have expanded the war to target Alias and all the major commentators and use the same underhanded and dirty tricks that Alias consistently uses seeing as, as Palermo wrote, this is a devil's bargain where the real loser is Americas interest for clean news. (Okay, you didn't say that Mr. Palermo, but was it at least close?)
01:52 PM on 08/12/2009
All Keith Olbermann does is rant and rave. I can't watch him for more than 10 minutes His whole show is devoted to Fox News and it really gets boring. Throwing stuff at the camera at the end of the show is pretty stupid.
02:05 AM on 08/11/2009
You absolutely nailed it when you said, “Both practically and ideologically there isn't a dime's worth of difference between Rupert Murdoch's News Corporation and Jeffrey Immelt's General Electric.” I cannot bear to watch most “news” programs. MSNBC does have Keith Olbermann and Rachel Maddow, thank God.

Your posts are the reason that HP is the first and last site I visit every day on my computer. Since I consider you to be a reliable and trustworthy source, would you please research something that is bothering me? Do you know how much the co-pay will be for euthanasia?

Keep up the good work.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Joseph A. Palermo
Author/Historian
11:08 AM on 08/11/2009
Thank you Francsesca for your kind comments -- I hope you keep reading my stuff. The corporate media filter is as strong as ever.
02:02 AM on 08/11/2009
Imagine the hypocrisy of O'Reilly. He does ambush interviews at the homes of obscure newspaper columnists who have dared to criticize O'Reilly in print. He trots Bernard Goldberg out every day to trash the "liberal elite media" (everyone but Fox). He has an "internet cop" from the Town Hall website to criticize left wing web sites. O'Reilly gets to sit in judgment from his bully pulpit, but no one is allowed to attack O'Reilly. If he can't bully you personally than he will bully your boss instead.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Joseph A. Palermo
Author/Historian
11:10 AM on 08/11/2009
Chalkeater, yes, I always cringe when I hear them talking about the "liberal" media or how "liberal" the NY Times is -- everything is framed in 7 minute segments so they can ram commercials down your throat -- media corporations selling audiences to other corporations -- wow! Liberal indeed!
12:03 AM on 08/11/2009
I watched Keith's commentary tonight regarding Sarah Palin's very irresponsible comments. We all need to "grow a pair" and rebel against the vicious lies that are being spread about our president.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Joseph A. Palermo
Author/Historian
10:26 PM on 08/10/2009
I watched Olbermann's Special Comment tonight and was just amazed that there is such a voice at all in the corporate media -- he was eloquent, ending with Lincoln's famous peroration -- now compare Olbermann's Special Comments to anything O'Reilly has ever done, ugh.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
den1953
The best politicians are for free!
06:50 PM on 08/10/2009
"CUT that's a wrap" watch the ratings drop for both FOX & MSNBC hurry up CNN get someone for the 8PM slot!!!!
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Joseph A. Palermo
Author/Historian
02:46 PM on 08/10/2009
Thanks for the comments -- I agree that the Anti-Trust Division of the D o J must finally do something to bring some real competition to these synergistic media behemoths -- I live in a Democratic district in a Democratic state and all we have on our local AM radio dial is right-wing drivel -- Limbaugh, Medved, and the rest (including local jocks who promote Tea Bagging protests, etc. -- local radio ain't controlled here by the locals -- so what gives?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
allenosuno
Just me being myself
01:32 PM on 08/10/2009
The media needs to have trust busting done. When GE, parent company of MSNBC and NBC makes deals with Rupert Murdoch to 'shut up' its political pundits (respectively Keith Olbermann and Bill O'Reilly), then we have media collusion, and monopolistic practices. You can see the collusion and concentration of power all around you. All the networks run similar stories and tap identical news feeds. They create and hobbyhorse the same NON-issues which they themselves trump up. The tv news media effectively are calling the shots and running the country. They tell people what is important to think and what is not important.
We need to have hearings and re-institute the old Fairness Doctrine that we used to have and FORCE the over-consolidated right-leaning corpies who own all the networks....FORCE them to be fair.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lgillooly
11:52 AM on 08/10/2009
Since the 4th Estate has been hi jacked by a handful of corporations and talk radio running 91 percent right wing talking points our Democracy has disappeared. We all like to think it is still alive and well, but it is hard to explain having the Democrats in the WH and majorities in both houses of Congress unable to implement desperatly needed reforms when a big majority voted for them.
Whoever owns the message, will control the Country. Sadly, the Democrats don't seem to realize this simple fact and are decades behind in building a message infrastructure.
Any American that does not want consumer choices and protection implemented for their Health care is a fool. Yet, they have been hoodwinked by talk radio and Fox and are fighting against their own intersts at town halls. like sheep to slaughter.
11:37 AM on 08/10/2009
A good piece, Mr. Palermo, especially after the brouhaha on whether or not Keith is deluding the public about what happened.

How much ink, or how many pixels, can that story possibly be worth?