iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Josh Silver

GET UPDATES FROM Josh Silver
 

Wall Street Protests: A Right-Left Movement Must Emerge

Posted: 10/02/2011 1:53 pm

The Wall Street protests represent the most potentially transforming political movement in generations: finally a revolt against the root problem that corrupts and paralyzes U.S. government. And the nascent movement might actually succeed if we stop turning ordinary Americans against each other along the tired and destructive battle lines of left vs. right.

For the past forty years, the expansion of unchecked corporate power has taken over Washington and state capitals. Armies of industry funded lobbyists, PR firms, think tanks, fake "Astroturf" groups and billions in campaign contributions have quietly corrupted a vulnerable system of government and seized control.

This juggernaut has decimated basic consumer protections and created the biggest gap between rich and poor since the Great Depression. It created the financial meltdown and the Great Recession. It is why nearly 50 million Americans lack health insurance. It has created a political system that is more like a heroin addict: dependent on billions of dollars that determine who gets elected, which laws get passed, and which don't. Both major political parties are addicted and beholden.

While the protests are proudly decentralized and leaderless, the unifying theme is "revoking corporate personhood" and "campaign finance reform" that would reverse the January 2010 Citizens United Supreme Court decision that lifted the flood gates to unlimited corporate money in elections.

Some call the protests a progressive response to the Tea Party movement, and play right into the hands of the corporate juggernaut, whose proxies -- along with a compliant media -- have mastered the art of turning ordinary Americans against each other instead of the real problem.

This is a right-left issue if there ever was one, and the potential to build an unstoppable movement is unprecedented. Just last weekend, liberal and Tea Party activists joined together for an unusual conference about the feasibility of a constitutional amendment to check undue corporate power in elections and government.

The right-leaning Daily Caller wrote, "Tea party activists made common cause with anti-corporate liberals this weekend at a venue quite unlike the firebrand populist movement: Harvard Law School. The improbable allies met to discuss the possibility of a new constitutional convention to address what they see as fundamental failures in the American system of government."

Grassroots liberals and conservatives agree on this issue. But many argue that there are too many differences between them to allow a unified movement. To them I say, find common ground or fail. Fixing this problem will require getting the fox to put a lock on the henhouse. That requires the kind of heat Congress felt after Watergate, when they last implemented sweeping reforms. A unified movement is not the same as seeking compromise between sold out Democratic and Republican politicians; it's about finding common ground between real people across the nation who are all suffering.

76% of Republicans and 85% of Democrats opposed the Citizens United decision. A long-running Gallup poll shows that Americans politically self-identify 40% conservative, 35% moderate and just 21% progressive.

Just look at the numbers. The way we win is by rallying around a democracy reform agenda, being thoughtful about how we talk about it, and building the kind of broad-based political movement that cannot be stopped.

What does a democracy reform agenda look like? Concrete answers are notably absent at the Wall Street rallies, so let me suggest this starting point: we must support an omnibus democracy agenda that both reduces the role of money in elections and politics, and enfranchises and protects voters so that our democracy enjoys full participation.

The actual policies that will save our democracy are wonky, and the list is long -- I will save that for a subsequent post. In the meantime, remember: before any lasting structural reform will advance, we must build a diverse movement of millions that cannot be ignored. Americans from the right and left must abandon the polarizing rhetoric from our leaders and our TV screens, and join hands in support of a 21st century democracy reform agenda that reclaims our government from moneyed special interests.

The future of our nation depends on it. The time has come. The beginning of a much larger uprising is at hand. The journey begins at the Occupy Wall Street website or Rootstrikers.org.

 

Follow Josh Silver on Twitter: www.twitter.com/unitedrep

FOLLOW POLITICS
 
 
  • Comments
  • 559
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (15 total)
12:12 AM on 10/19/2011
This is exactly what I've been thinking, good ole divide and conquer techniques at work. In fact I just started a Facebook page to try to get people to discuss this. It's called "Occupy the middle." Look for it if you are on Facebook.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Frank Smith
03:39 PM on 10/11/2011
Americans just have to get out and vote and vote for anyone other than Republicans and Democrats. Third parties, write-ins, whatever it takes. Create the demand for a quality alternative and it will develop. It's the best vote you'll ever cast.
07:54 PM on 10/08/2011
The lack of true responses from elected officials in order to show any deserved recognition for the gathering of the American People across the nation speaks volumes. It is this same disregard for the relevant truths of layer upon layer of bought poltical favortism that will continue to fuel the voices and resolve of many people ignored the rights of due process of law. It looks as history may have to repeat itself as cycles of historic movements have proven so in history books. There was a king long ago who viewed the cries of colonists as " Rabble." It may take a period of careful and systematic resolution of minds united in the pursuit of due course of action, but the seeds of change have gone beyond germination and are now sprouting and growing to utilize democracy in the manner designed by our forefathers.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Jeff Norman
01:34 PM on 10/08/2011
Josh Silver: “...the unifying theme is ‘revoking corporate personhood’ and ‘campaign finance reform’ that would reverse the January 2010 Citizens United Supreme Court decision that lifted the flood gates to unlimited corporate money in elections.”

That’s obviously not true, Josh. Actually, the unifying theme is economic justice. The misguided obsession you and others have with the Citizens United decision has barely been mentioned. Which is a good thing, because y’all don’t deserve to be taken seriously. You can’t even identify any restrictions that would fairly and effectively level the playing field, nor can you explain who is/isn’t entitled to freedom of the press rights. Instead, you hide behind meaningless rhetoric like “corporations aren’t people” and “money isn’t speech.” Will any of you guys EVER get around to addressing the Court’s reasoning, or to specifying exactly who should be deprived of which rights and why? Among those of you who want to amend the Constitution, will there EVER be any consensus on a proposed amendment?

Not only would it conflict with the First Amendment to give some speakers more rights than others, it just isn’t doable to level the playing field.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
prrrrrr
Out of many, we are one!
02:37 PM on 10/07/2011
Here, Here! Excellent post!
photo
Rockwell
Recovering Reagan republican. 26 years sober.
12:29 PM on 10/07/2011
I'm convinced that step one is a Constitutional Ammendment to publicly fund all elections and eliminate private money. Money is not free speech. Its a bribe. A vote is free speech and everyone gets one, whether you are homeles or the CEO of BoA.

Until that cancer is purged from the body politic, nothing else can get done.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
08:01 PM on 10/05/2011
So was there not a problem with campaign financing before 2010? Any campaign contribution coming from a corporation or industry is bribery. The entire system is broken and self serving politicians have no interest in addressing it. It's not wall street thats the problem, it's washington taking legal bribes to protect them. Only politicians can correct this
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SUSOGAPADROMA
Stand Up Speak Out G A P & Do Right Or Move Aside
03:59 PM on 10/05/2011
Funny that the media keeps demanding to "know" the "demands" of the OWS movement. They wonder if it's "real" because of "homemade signs" instead of slick, just off the presses signs like those carried by the Freedom Works TPers.

They talk about it being "mostly young" people, as if those "young people"( many deep in student loan debt w/no prospects for a decent job to pay back those loans)..have no right to be actively engaged in discussions of this country's direction or how this "bought" government affects their futures.

But..then.. picture persons...gasp.. in their 30's, 40's, 50's, 60's....oops. Displaced workers....and workers who have seen their wages not only stagnate...but decline.

They talk about how so many are "dressed funny"...So if you're not in 1776 garb...or draped in a flag....the US...or Gadsden Flag..are best...or wearing a Lady Liberty foam visor ...or have a six-shooter strapped on your hip...your semi-automatic slung over your shoulder....you.. my friend.. just MUST NOT be bright, serious, or cognizant enough of the issues, policies...and SCOTUS decisions to participate in this Nation's Future. Well guess what....These young people are our future.

Being an "older" American, myself.....It warms my heart and my soul to see these "young people" in the streets....I hope to join you soon.
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
noaxe397
02:30 PM on 10/05/2011
The problem with Mr. Silver's belief as stated here is that, while the right and left agree on some things the further you move to the relative extremes, the fundamental difference between left and right-the role of government-is insurmountable and cannot be compromised on. As for the 40%-35%-21% political identification, the thing Mr. Silver also fails to realize is that those numbers in reality are 40% conservative and 56% liberal because self identified moderates almost always support the same government policies as liberals do; that's why the are called moderate.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Carmen Slade
5150 Or Fight!
12:18 PM on 10/04/2011
Here is a highly relevant essay I hope #OWS people pay attention to: how the Libertarian Tea Party got co-opted by the more rabid edge of the GOP:

http://www.reddit.com/r/occupywallstreet/comments/kyjo2/an_open_letter_and_warning_from_a_former_tea/
02:24 AM on 10/05/2011
Interesting, although tea party groups are independent in their messaging.
But the bizarre and malicious media ploy to re-brand the TP ra.c.ist and rad,ical is so so far out of their character that its unimaginable any one could believe the false accusation as anything other than vicious campaign slander.

I mean the media was speaking with tea party members and coming away from interviews seeing nothing but integrity and respect, when suddenly one day after the tea party candidates were announced the DNC blurts out they're "ra.c.I.st" and "ha.t.e.ful."

But the point of the article is that as far fetched as media blackballing seemed to TP, expect the same attempt to target your group.
The links on Rosa Parks were good too, didn't kmow Rosa was their third try.
photo
Rockwell
Recovering Reagan republican. 26 years sober.
12:26 PM on 10/07/2011
Not sure what you were watching but the TP was clearly racists and filled with hate from day one. It didn't take the DNC to convince me of that. In fact I think they were late in the game in calling the TP movement what it was - a backlash against the election of an African American president.
06:45 PM on 10/11/2011
I think all controversial movements will be branded with every manner of insult and misrepresentation. The Democrats saw the Tea Party as a treat, so they call them a lot of names. Now (some) Republicans see the Occupy Movement as a threat, so a bunch more nasty insults are being spewed at Americans patriotic enough to get off the couch and protest injustice. People just need to stop tuning into hatefulmedia and form their own opinions.
11:43 AM on 10/04/2011
A SHELL GAME… this ‘protest’ is just a distraction from the real problem- politicians who put their own interests, and their party’s interests ahead of the country’s.

1) HOW COME this administration has NOT PROSECUTED ANYONE for wrong doing leading to the financial meltdown? NOT ONE!!!
2) DON’T GIVE POLITICIANS A FREE PASS. They created the conditions for the meltdown by pushing banks into lending money to people the banks knew were unqualified. They did this because, in their elite opinions, “more people should own their own homes”. When the government strays from its constitutional mandate, we all suffer.
3) IF the problem is government corruption (because politicians can and do write special laws for their corporate donors), then the ONLY solution is to REDUCE THE SIZE OF GOVERNMENT. A flat tax with no loopholes or subsidies eliminates the main corrupting influence on our system. Why lobby if the politician can't give your company what you want?
4) ‘Attack the Rich’ may appeal to the envious (and yes, I’ve been there too!), BUT it’s just a DISTRACTION. “Bad economy? Don’t blame me, your congressman (senator, president). It’s those greedy RICH people”. YOU WANT A LIST OF THE GREEDIEST MOST CORRUPT RICH PEOPLE? The one who hardly work and when they do always ask ‘what’s in it for them’? Look up a list of congressmen, senators, the president and his cabinet postings. Rich, greedy, self-serving. Nearly all attorneys. THAT’s who you should be protesting.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
den1953
The National Inquire of Politics the GOP!
09:19 AM on 10/04/2011
I agree when you can't find a job politics shouldn't have anything to do with it, but what will hurt is the buy out of the nations political leaders,it is truly time to put a huge break on the Corporate freight train that is threatening the American peoples government..........We are becoming a off shoot of Communist China and are being run by the wealthy Corporate masters with a overtone of Greed Before Country!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
wikwox
So there I was, playing the piano....
09:01 AM on 10/04/2011
It will take a generation to remove the scourge of the Citizens United decision, a plague visited on us by unelected life term "justices" with a far right agenda. As has been shown a thousand times in the past what the American people want, hate or love matters little to the political elite. Also as noted corporations are masters of turning us against each other, we fall for it like clock work. But the protest matters, it's the start of something that should have began years ago.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
juna
Golden Rule is my religion
06:54 AM on 10/04/2011
An agenda with specific reforms outlined is needed. This is a good start, but seems amorphous. I see the beginnings of a new political party, possibly. Repealing corporate personhood so beloved by the stacked Supreme Court is a good beginning. But how to actually do that?
05:57 AM on 10/04/2011
The author states as a lead to this story: "The Wall Street protests represent the most potentially transforming political movement in generations: finally a revolt against the root problem that corrupts and paralyzes U.S. government"

What absolute bombast and cr*p that statement is.

How many protest posters over the "Citizen's United" ruling were there?? The entire "Citizen's United" rants are bogus and fake arguments made by liberals intentionally blind to the unseemingly amounts of money procured by unionists before Citizens United.

There's no broad alliance to be made here between a couple of idle whining college kids and hardworking Americans. And there is no larger story other than these are self-indulgent brats. They dont have a coherent message, in the least, and they dont represent any fraction of a segment of America that is meaningful.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ultrawiz
Holding the Middle Ground
03:28 PM on 10/04/2011
There are none so blind as those that will not see. Just keep your head buried in the sand while the rest of the world moves on without you. I'm quite sure no one will miss your presence.