More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Judith J. Wurtman, PhD

GET UPDATES FROM Judith J. Wurtman, PhD

Weight Loss Cleanse: A Better Kind

Posted: 01/14/11 09:29 AM ET

Everyone seems to be talking about cleansing diets. Celebrities and self-appointed diet gurus gush over the joy of a clean intestinal tract. The Internet, drug stores and publishers promote colon cleansers as essential to our well being. Lurid, unbelievably detailed descriptions of the horrors lurking in our guts are available to anyone with the courage to read about them.

According to all the experts, if you don't heed the advice, don't bother trying to lose weight. Apparently the toxins and the nasty bacteria that have snuck into your body are huddling together in the dark recesses of your gut to make fat cells fatter and the mid-section flabbier. Going on a diet is pointless until and unless you rid yourself of these forces for fat.

The simplest and cheapest way of doing so is to drink a homemade concoction of lemon juice, maple syrup, cayenne pepper, an herbal laxative and lots of water. However, if mixing such a brew does not appeal to you, there are countless commercial versions available that activate bowel motility and supply some electrolytes. They also tell you to drink copious amounts of water. Naturally the combination of fasting and laxative-use is an effective way of losing weight (anyone who has eaten contaminated food can attest to that).

Whether cleansing has any real effect on dieting, bowel health, or longevity is for the experts and epidemiologists to determine. But if a diet is to succeed, removing the supposed environmental toxins from our bodies is not what is important. Instead, what we should be doing is cleansing ourselves of the psychological toxins that have been making us overeat and gain weight.

We rarely overeat in a vacuum. Almost every bout of overeating is caused by something. It could be something acute like finding out that your road assistance plan expired the day before you had a flat tire in a blizzard. Or it may be something chronic, such as being the caretaker for a parent with Alzheimer's disease or being forced to do the work of three recently laid-off coworkers. The reasons may be embedded in your psychological self, such as resenting having someone tell you what you can and cannot eat because that is what your mother did all the time. Or the overeating may be habitual. You always ate while doing your homework when in high school and now you always eat when writing reports for your job.

The "cleanse yourself" people claim that we are bombarded with countless toxins that make us fat. Whether that is true or not, what is true is we may feel unable to control our overeating because of our toxic memories, habits or life situations. Some toxic triggers to overeating can be "cleansed" easily. If skipping breakfast and lunch leads to excessive eating from supper to bedtime, following a structured meal and snack plan will eliminate this. Eating your way through a lonely Sunday can be avoided by finding others with whom you can share those empty afternoons. But other triggers may require help and intervention that can range from a life coach to a lawyer to a dating service. In the meantime, here is what you can do:

1. Use the lemon juice/cayenne pepper concoction to kill the bugs on your house plants and spend the time thinking and writing down the many reasons you overeat.

2. Be gentle with yourself. You are not judging yourself; rather you are trying to understand what has been going on when you cannot resist overeating.

3. Ask yourself if this is even the right time to go on a diet or whether it is better to wait until you are better able to control the stresses that are causing you to overeat.

4. Be honest about why you are thinking of going on a particular diet. Sometimes rigorous diets are selected as a way of avoiding thinking about the problems that caused the weight gain. If you focus on the diet, then you don't have to focus on your problems. It never works.

5. Do you need help and support? Find someone who is as interested in your problems as the number of calories you just consumed for lunch.

6. Find a weight-loss plan that allows you to lose weight slowly, and occasionally not at all, when life starts to interfere with dieting.

7. Avoid diets that mess with your brain chemistry by decreasing serotonin, the chemical which keeps you calm and allows you to cope. Weight loss itself may reveal more reasons why you gained weight and coping with these reasons could be difficult. If you avoid eating carbohydrates, your brain won't be able to make serotonin and coping will become very difficult.

And when you have successfully lost your weight, devote your energy to cleansing your closet of all your over-sized clothes. It is much more fun than drinking lemon juice and pepper.

 

Follow Judith J. Wurtman, PhD on Twitter: www.twitter.com/@stopmed_wt_gai

Everyone seems to be talking about cleansing diets. Celebrities and self-appointed diet gurus gush over the joy of a clean intestinal tract. The Internet, drug stores and publishers promote colon cl...
Everyone seems to be talking about cleansing diets. Celebrities and self-appointed diet gurus gush over the joy of a clean intestinal tract. The Internet, drug stores and publishers promote colon cl...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 142
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4  Next ›  Last »  (4 total)
03:07 PM on 01/21/2011
I totally agree that fasting cleanses are miserable and not necessarily the best thing for your body. Our bodies need food, especially protein to detoxify. We have a natural detoxification system built in. The healthiest way to detox is to remove toxic foods that are hard on our livers and body and to consume lots of fruits, veggies and lean protein. My favorite detox diet is a 4 week cleanse by www.cleanseorganic.com. I've never felt more energy than when I was on this diet, it got me back in touch with my body's need for real food and allowed me to let go of my sugar cravings.
11:31 PM on 01/19/2011
I agree, great article! Emotional eating is something that certainly plagues so many people. I have a bit of a snippet on what triggers the emotional eating,and how we can address it.
Eat Less, Feel Full And Drop Weight!
05:10 PM on 01/18/2011
The person on the scale weights only 50 lbs. Isn't this a problem?
03:25 PM on 01/18/2011
Excellent article on emotional eating. Many people skip breakfast b/c they think they don't have time in the morning to eat well and then they are sooooo hungry later they'll eat anything, this later sets the tone for the rest of the day. I start the day w/ a super healthy shake and since I've already done something good for me in the morning, it helps me stay focused to continue making healthy eating choices throughout the day.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Erinaleks
Architectural Artisan, Free Thinker
03:27 PM on 01/16/2011
Diets do not work over the long term.
Dietary life style does. Exersize is as
Important as how you eat. There are
Plenty of good authors on the subject.
The tried and tested such as Jack Lalanne,
Bill Pearl, Paul Bragg and Andrew Weil
To name a few. Fads come and go. Life
Style change is always formost to the real
Experts on weight, health, and fitness.
I am a vegetarian. If I did not Exersize I
Would have a gut and be puny and flabby.
Getting started and seeing results will be the
Best encouragement. It takes about 8 weeks
To see transformation on a healthy life style.
03:32 AM on 01/16/2011
Losing weight without the right mindset is the reason so many people are frustrated with the result they get. you must first control your mind before you can control your diet, it is as simple as that. so many people want to lose weight within weeks and stay that way, but it is impossible, they need to understand that losing weight takes time. http://bit.ly/eo5A84 there is an ebook that talks about this in detail
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
realitytrumpsbull
two 'alves of coconut!
12:00 AM on 01/16/2011
I think there's a lot to be said for hitting the carrots and apples and fresh raw spinach and copious amounts of water to wash it down with. Fresh fruits and vegetables really hit the mark, can make you feel 1,000% better, especially if coupled with some regular walking. So, next time you're at the grocery store, get ye a bag of lettuce, and resolve to eat the whole thing in the next couple days. Get a bowl full of apples on the counter, citrus? You betcha. But, still count the calories, and don't serve your 'veg in a moat of your favorite dressing, or you're sort of defeating the purpose. And, if you're doing right otherwise in your diet, I recommend a Reese's or equivalent snack, whatever you can tolerate, there. 

Don't be a diet nazi, but do largely what's right, so you don't become larger. Water isn't poison, get 2 quarts a day in you for general good health so your kidneys can do their 'thing'. Soda? Nyet. A can, that is, ONE can per day, maximum, and if you can knock it down to one can per week, so much the better, same with alcoholic beverages. Lots of people have fallen into the trap of staying home, being homebodies, and loading up on food, and they end up looking like butterballs and wondering why.
Genders
Love, Tolerance, Enlightenment
10:02 PM on 01/15/2011
Try to get used to and comfortable feeling hunger, and not eating or drinking.
08:44 PM on 01/16/2011
That's ridiculous. If you're eating healthy food there's absolutely no reason you should feel hungry.
Genders
Love, Tolerance, Enlightenment
09:55 PM on 01/16/2011
why do people overeat?
06:50 AM on 01/17/2011
It is important to recognize hunger/satiety cues in order to identify when your body needs food and when it is ready to stop eating. Allowing the body to feel these hunger signals until it is to the point of ravenous is how many people end up eating too many calories because it drives the brain to the point that it thinks food is becoming scarce. This is how many people fail at restrictive diets and why those of us in the nutrition field advocate learning to honor your body's signals and not ignore them.
04:49 PM on 01/15/2011
Really, this whole "losing weight" thing is so easy. Eat less calories, eat more green stuff, 30 min of moderate excercise and you are on the right track. It is all about balance in life. Never deprive yourself of anything just be conscious of what you are putting inot your body. Of course, this is easy to say when you aren't at work and don't have a break room is filled with goodies. It is also hard to take care of your physical self when your emotional self is not in shape.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
steve12
02:24 AM on 01/17/2011
If it were so easy, why are over two-thirds of the American adult population overweight? There is nothing easy about it, but it is very necessary. Good health habits should be encouraged by all sectors of society, including work, places of worship, schools, and the community.
12:52 PM on 01/20/2011
The concept is easy. The actual "doing" is the hard part. I am not saying I have it all down. Sometimes it is easier to just drive through Burger King and get a burger than go home and make a healthy meal after work.

Americans are typically lazy too..this doesn't help...
03:41 PM on 01/15/2011
Great article. A lot of information I can use with my clients. Thanks
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
katmeyster
Proud practical progressive atheist
02:22 PM on 01/15/2011
Be very afraid -- of your own body.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
HeadAches
I'm here, getting into your head giving you...
02:16 PM on 01/15/2011
There is only one way to lose weight - consume less calories then what your body burns per day.

I personally did it without any exorcize or special diet or any fancy high priced cures - simply by eating a lot less. Months of going to bed hungry is not fun but neither is being overweight. Best thing about it is you will not have a fall back as over time your body has adjusted itself to consume less food and you have a much harder time overeating.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dazzle59
04:38 PM on 01/15/2011
As a lifetime member of Weight Watchers, I agree that eating less is important, but going to bed hungry is not going to work for most people. A trick I learned years ago is to eat very slowly. It takes 20 minutes for your brain to realize that your stomach is full. If you're a fast eater (like me), you can gulp down 2 to 3 portions in 20 minutes. Instead, train yourself to eat slowly and mindfully. Put your fork down between bites. Chew each mouthful 20 to 30 times. This technique works so well for me that I rarely crave a second helping.
photo
iRock
and that's all that needs to be said...
01:35 PM on 01/15/2011
i love this article.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Lollie Com
Habit kicks willpower's rear seven days a week!! ~
12:11 PM on 01/15/2011
I was a stress eater. I made a habit of playing ping pong every time I stressed out. It worked so much better than eating that it killed the stress eating in under a month. That's one of many small changes I've made and so far I've eliminated (not lost, but absolutely eliminated) 124 pounds of excess fat. I've got around 30 or 40 more to go. I love my diet. I love my workouts. I love my ping pong. I've done no cleansing drinks or fasts, but I do eat red pepper every day. I never skip breakfast. In fact my friends say I eat a lot of food, all the time. But hey, when you eat nothing but highly nutritious foods, it takes a lot of food to meet your calorie requirements.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:26 AM on 01/16/2011
Congratulations!
01:17 AM on 01/16/2011
congrats on your success!

bell peppers of all colors are great.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
millebocca
veni, vidi, clicki
12:06 PM on 01/15/2011
any "cleanse" is just another laxative.
any laxative creates a body's dependancy on it to be able to "go," which is a bad thing all around.