Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Karen Dionne

GET UPDATES FROM Karen Dionne
 

Readers: Are You Buying Fewer Books Now That Borders Is Gone?

Posted: 01/31/2012 11:51 am

I miss my Borders. The Borders bookstore on Hall Road in Utica, Mich. was my hangout. I'd drop in whenever I was in the mood to browse for books, and inevitably, I'd leave with great armfuls.

There's a Barnes & Noble a few miles away from my still-empty Borders. I've tried shopping there, but it's not the same. The store looks different. Feels different. It doesn't feel like home.

Recently I realized something that, for an author who makes her living writing novels, is somewhat horrifying: Since Borders went out of business, I'm buying fewer books.

I asked a few writer friends if the same was true for them. Turns out, I'm not the only one.

"My buying habits have definitely changed," says Deborah Klaus. "We still have a Barnes & Noble, but it feels like an apples and oranges situation. Borders had a beating heart. And I miss it. It sucks that Borders is gone."

"No, I don't buy as many books as I'm an impulse buyer," Brenda Birch agrees. "There's a big empty store in Northlake Mall in Charlotte. I hope another indy or chain moves in and soon. Sadly, there are no other bookstores close by. I used to go in just to browse and ended up spending at least $50.00 each visit."

"Borders in my small city of Danbury, Conn., was less than 10 minutes from my home," says multi-published author Lauren Baratz-Logsted. "Most weekends, my whole family would go there. Almost all birthday presents for the gazillion birthday parties my daughter goes to were bought there. Most Christmas and Hanukkah presents were bought there. Danbury doesn't have any general independents and the Barnes & Noble is on the other side of the city, about 20-25 minutes away with traffic. It's not close enough to just drop in for no reason. I'll go there for specific things or if I'm already in the area, but I think it's obvious that without Borders, my purchases of books has drastically decreased."

"The closing of the two Borders nearest to me is what finally pushed me into buying an ereader," Lynette Eklund says. "I'm still really hoping an indy store will replace at least one of them."

Fortunately, not every author I surveyed admits to buying fewer books in a world without Borders.

"I think that I might actually buy more ebooks and more tree books now because I can't go to Borders," says Amy Sue Nathan. "I get an itchy clicking finger and just buy, buy, buy. There's no heft when loading a virtual shopping basket, no coffee and cake distractions, no wind-up toys or chocolates. I miss the browsing though, that's for sure."

Pamela Toler agrees:

My first stop for books is my neighborhood independent bookstore (Go Seminary Coop Books!). That said, I was at Borders a lot. There was one a five minute walk from my house and two in downtown Chicago. I always stopped at them when I had time to kill. Sometimes I walked down to the local store just to take a break. I always bought books when I was there.

Do I buy fewer books with Borders gone? Having just paid my monthly bookstore tab, I'm pretty sure the answer is no. But I miss them.

As do I. Now if you'll excuse me, I think I'm going to go visit a bookstore.

 
 
 

Follow Karen Dionne on Twitter: www.twitter.com/KarenDionne

I miss my Borders. The Borders bookstore on Hall Road in Utica, Mich. was my hangout. I'd drop in whenever I was in the mood to browse for books, and inevitably, I'd leave with great armfuls. There's...
I miss my Borders. The Borders bookstore on Hall Road in Utica, Mich. was my hangout. I'd drop in whenever I was in the mood to browse for books, and inevitably, I'd leave with great armfuls. There's...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 10
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
09:35 PM on 02/24/2012
"Sadly, there are no other bookstores close by." There are tons in Charlotte, a simple Google maps search will show that. If you're spending $50 on books, you can drive 10 extra miles to do so.

Try Book Buyers on Central Avenue. And don't discount thrift stores, as they offer an incredible amount of used books.

Lastly, whether you're in Charlotte or not, check out http://www.listia.com/?r=40548 , as you can get an endless supply of free books shipped to you from there.
03:14 AM on 02/03/2012
Borders refused to include Native American in their religion section.

They argued it was their right as a 'Christian' bookstore to discriminate against us based on religion.

I argued it was a place of public accommodation and therefore it was illegal to treat us differently. I had been complaining about it for years, and had damages, so at that point they quit. I don't think they wanted to face a lawsuit for religious discrimination against Native Americans since I was also talking class action and collecting friends. At the very least it was going to be a public relations nightmare.

I modeled my act of protest against Borders on the story of White Buffalo Woman. She always let them know she was coming.
photo
BrotherRog
author, Kissing Fish: christianity for people who
01:27 AM on 02/03/2012
Heck NO I'm not purchasing fewer books because Borders has closed! I didn't buy at Borders to begin with. I buy books from my local independent book store, and if they don't have one I'm wanting, I have them order it for me. hint, hint y'all...
photo
Justine Musk
I live and write in Los Angeles.
11:30 AM on 02/02/2012
When my favorite local indie bookstores shut down (especially Dutton's in Brentwood -- please, a moment of silence for Dutton's...) I was upset. Borders? Not so much. The big box bookstores ate up the indies because the indies couldn't compete on selection and pricing; Amazon will eat up the big box bookstores for the same reason. I was an obsessive reader to begin with, but since converting to ereaders -- with astonishing speed, considering my initial resistance -- I read even more deeply and widely and buy even more books. I'm waiting for indie bookstores to rise again, once they figure out how to cater to the print crowd in a way that cultivates the very things that Amazon can't -- great atmosphere, knowledgeable friendly sales people who are also BOOK people, readings + workshops that cultivate a strong sense of local community, etc. Stocking shelves with toys and whatever, like Barnes + Noble is doing, won't cut it. But once B + N is gone as well, maybe book people will be forced to come together and rebirth or re/vision what a physical bookstore can and should be -- the way Ann Patchett is doing, for example. http://www.salon.com/2011/11/19/ann_patchett_bookstores_matter_so_ill_pay_to_open_one/ In the meantime, I've got my Kindle and Book Soup on Sunset (may it live long).
08:11 PM on 02/01/2012
So, Borders is gone. Now we need to determine how to replace their stores. How avid readers will satiate their hunger. That is the looming issue.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Candi Cj Dubord Jensen
Caution: I will most likey offend you. Often.
03:40 PM on 02/01/2012
Borders was where I used to do all my holiday and birthday shopping for people. Ours had the best people working there. I could easily drop 50 bucks whenever I went in there. Always had a great selection of books. Our Barnes and Nobles just don't compare, plus they it seems they have snotty people working for them. The store is not organized at all, which is very annoying. At Borders, you got your member card for free, an extra member discount, plus the occasional coupons, the coffee card program, every now and then they did something different...at B&N they want $25 for the card and the discount isn't as good. Plus, Borders had tons of clearance that changed often, at B&N it is always the same books sitting there.

I want my Borders BACK!!! Now I buy ebooks as cheap as I can find them. Or I go to goodwill or this really huge used book store we found.
photo
BlackJAC
It's better to be a black king than a white knight
01:16 PM on 02/01/2012
Not really.  Barnes & Noble tended to be my primary vendor due to their adoption of the 10%-across-the-board discount program, whereas Borders was a place to check out when I had one of their coupons.
thebigbike
ran away to be a cowboy
10:37 PM on 01/31/2012
Our local Borders closed and I noticed virtually no change in my full price retail book buying habits. Bore-ders never seemed to have any of the books I was looking for, even when I'd get a 40% off any one item coupon, I could only rarely find something I wanted. Even when they had their HUGE closing sale I couldn't find anything I was interested in. Barnes & Noble always had a larger MUCH more interesting remainders section, and their current affairs section was always better stocked and easier to search.

But our local Goodwill Industries Thrift stores opened a Goodwill store dedicated to BOOKS!!! I end up picking up about 10-12 books a week there ( Hardbounds nearly all $1.25. PB $.95) Ones that disappoint me on reading or that I simply don't want to keep after reading go to SPCA for their annual book sale. WIN/WIN/WIN Of course the GW doesn't generally see much very current stuff, though Twilight type stuff and pop novels do show up fairly quickly .
06:32 PM on 01/31/2012
Borders was over-priced, with rude employees, and sorry coffee --however, I was there at least three times a week until it closed down. Borders was a place where I can browse and read for a couple of hours and not feel as if I was in anyone's way. And yes, I bought more often than not.
02:02 PM on 01/31/2012
Great article,Karen!! I just received an e-reader as a gift so I think I'll be spending even more money on books! You know what they say, "so many books, so little time."