iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Kathy Freston

GET UPDATES FROM Kathy Freston
 

3 Reasons Your Diet Isn't Working

Posted: 06/14/2012 7:16 am

Not losing weight? Or worse, you worked like hell to lose it and now the pounds are back, and then some? If you're on a diet, or if you've spent much of your life dieting, you've undoubtedly worked very, very hard to achieve results. And quite probably you've experienced the devastating shame or disappointment of having the weight creep back on. Whether you've been working against 10 pounds or 200, losing weight and keeping it off can be one of the toughest challenges, and I bow to you for the efforts you've made. Losing weight may have been hard thus far, but it doesn't have to be. Let's look at three of the reasons your diet has probably not been working, and then I'll show you how to change things up.

The Three Reasons Your Diet Isn't Working:

  1. You are miserable while dieting. Most diets would have you cutting things out from your diet; they are about denial and discipline. You love pizza? No more of that. Pasta? Forget it. Dessert? Erase the word from your vocabulary. So you white-knuckle your way through some crazy diet of deprivation, and you're miserable. If you are fed up with too many restrictions and you are missing the simple joys of your old life, you simply won't keep up the effort. And why should you? Life is meant to be lived and enjoyed -- and that includes enjoying your food.
  2. You are doing the high-protein thing. You are most likely doing a high-protein, low-carb (HPLC) diet, which has been the popular diet since the last century. Yes, you do lose weight on a HPLC diet. But the weight loss comes partly from losing a lot of water in the beginning of the diet. When you stop eating carbohydrates, your body rapidly loses water. In the first few days of a low-carb diet, you'll be in the bathroom surprisingly often, and the first few pounds of "weight loss" are not fat loss at all. They are temporary water loss. This happens because the body, starving for glucose normally found in carbs, is using up stored glycogen which holds a lot of water -- one pound of glycogen holds three pounds of water; the first bit of weight loss you see on the low-carb diet is just water loss from losing your natural glycogen, and as soon as you allow a little bit of carbs back in, your water weight comes right back.

    The weight loss from a HPLC diet also comes from eating fewer calories, because you are knocking out so much of what you normally would consume -- because these days, eliminating carbs means doing away with calorie-dense, highly processed foods, most of which contain high-fructose corn sweetener. Of course you lose weight when you give up cookies and cakes and doughnuts, which erroneously get lumped together with good carbs like those from brown rice and quinoa.

    But eating a HPLC doesn't work long-term. Your body needs GOOD carbs, and will crave them voraciously if you don't pony up a steady, healthy supply of them. Whole grains like brown rice and quinoa, and beans like lentils, chickpeas, and black beans supply the body with the much-needed slow and steady supply of glucose. Glucose is not a bad thing; it's the source of fuel for the brain and body and it's not negotiable that we get it. Which is why the cravings for carbs become so irresistible that you end up caving: it's your brilliant body telling you to stop starving yourself of what you need!

    The trick, of course, is to stick with the good carbs (whole grains, beans), not the bad, refined, junky carbs (white bread, chips, cakes, cookies).

    Whole foods like grains and beans release their sugar very, very slowly because of the fiber in them, and they don't give you a sugar rush. They feed your cells as needed, and as a result, you have loads of stable energy that powers you through the day. Not so with meat, dairy and eggs (they have no fiber in them, but more on that soon), which are the centerpiece of the HPLC diet.

    And why else is your HPLC diet not working? Let's not forget the obvious: Meat and dairy are concentrated sources of fat and calories. Fat and calories make you fat. Period. Even a lean breast of skinless chicken -- certainly the leanest of all the meats -- has 20 percent of its calories in fat, 29 percent of which is saturated. So, that's a problem when it comes to weight loss and health.

  3. You aren't getting enough fiber. In medical literature, the one dietary component that has been most highly and consistently associated with long-term weight loss is fiber consumption. It controls your weight because it adds volume to foods without a lot of calories, so it fills you up and makes you feel satiated, thus turning off the hunger signals. It helps to slow down the release of glucose, therefore stabilizing your blood sugar -- which means the rollercoaster of cravings is finally brought to a halt. Fiber also acts like an internal scrub brush, too, cleaning out the fat and gunk. Animal-based foods have no fiber -- zero, zilch. Plant-based foods are chock full of fiber.

So now you know why your diet probably wasn't working. Now here's what you do to change things:

Upgrade

You can still have that beloved burger or pizza or pasta; just make them healthier by opting for a veggie burger, or pizza with nondairy cheese and soy sausage, or pasta that's made from brown rice rather than white flour. Have all the foods you grew up loving, but just have better versions of them. Eventually, lean even further toward simple nutrient-dense plant-based foods like whole grains, legumes, nuts, veggies and fruits.

Add in Good Stuff

Fill up on some good stuff by incorporating new little habits into your daily routine. Things like adding two tablespoons of ground flaxseeds to a soup or smoothie, or adding in an apple a day to pump up your fiber intake will go far in changing your body's chemistry. You can do something as simple as drinking two cups of water before a meal to fill your belly a bit so that you don't overeat, or change up your cheese from dairy to nondairy.

When you ADD things in to your daily routine rather than parsing out calories and counting grams of protein, you don't feel deprived or hungry. It's called "crowding out," and it's a whole different approach to the old "cutting out" method of dieting. You won't be white-knuckling your way through some crazy deprivation diet that makes you miserable. You don't need to stick to tough rules or overnight changes; you need not rely on hardcore discipline that makes you hate your life. You need only focus on progress, not perfection. Lean in to the process of losing weight, and it will happen easily. And it will last. At last!

For more tips and a simple 30 day plan for losing weight and keeping it off, please check out The Lean!

For more by Kathy Freston, click here.

For more on weight loss, click here.

 
 
 

Follow Kathy Freston on Twitter: www.twitter.com/kathyfreston

FOLLOW HEALTHY LIVING
Not losing weight? Or worse, you worked like hell to lose it and now the pounds are back, and then some? If you're on a diet, or if you've spent much of your life dieting, you've undoubtedly worked ...
Not losing weight? Or worse, you worked like hell to lose it and now the pounds are back, and then some? If you're on a diet, or if you've spent much of your life dieting, you've undoubtedly worked ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 1,006
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (11 total)
12:06 PM on 06/21/2012
People need adopt a lifestyle change, not the next fad diet. Diets don't work because diets ask that you to cut out things you enjoy eating. Your body craves salty, fatty and sweet foods for a reason. Moderation is key along with lots of veggies. People make losing weight so difficult. Just eat less calories than your daily RMR, fast once or twice a week, and throw in some exercise.
10:53 PM on 06/20/2012
i was absolutely miserable while on the high protein diet, eww.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jimboy71
Hen Diapheron Heautoi
01:06 PM on 06/20/2012
Oh good grief...it really is simple. Eat lots of whole foods, colourful ones especially, with an emphasis on fruits, vegetables, grains, and legumes, and eat high quality, low fat proteins...eschew processed foods and modified fats.

Exercise.

That's it.
11:42 PM on 06/19/2012
I definitely disagree with # 2 - I have been living LCHP for 10 years and... I feel PHENOMENAL!!! Don't miss carbs AT ALL.
04:23 PM on 06/19/2012
As soon as she (wrongly) identified quinoa as a grain, I stopped reading.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jimboy71
Hen Diapheron Heautoi
01:06 PM on 06/20/2012
It is classified nutritionally as a grain replacement, even though it is not technically a grain.
01:58 PM on 06/21/2012
According to whom? I could classify lettuce as a grain replacement, still doesn't make it a grain.
12:06 PM on 06/28/2012
Good catch. I missed that. I remember arguing with someone about a year and a half ago, insisting that Quinoa was a grain. Of course, now I know it is a seed. Thanks for mentioning this mistake.
mothergrace
If they knock you down, bite 'em on the ankle.
02:34 PM on 06/18/2012
Eating a soy burger or more soy in the form of non-dairy cheese or even more soy with soy sausage is NOT the answer if you crave a burger or pizza.

How this author can, in one and the same article, tell us that our diets will fail if we eliminate carbs because our body is craving them and then to tell us to substitute soy for meat and dairy when we crave them is illogical.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jimboy71
Hen Diapheron Heautoi
01:07 PM on 06/20/2012
Because she is on the vegan bandwagon.
04:59 PM on 06/21/2012
I hope everyone jumps on the GD "bandwagon"! Good for the GD Bandwagon, it can carry the entire world!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:14 PM on 06/18/2012
#2...yet even more anti-Atkins propaganda protecting the massive carbohydrate industry.

The Atkins diet is CONTROLLED CARB, not low carb. The Atkins diet is not high protein.

You lose FAT from KETOSIS on the Atkins diet, not water weight.

ATKINS WORKS. PERIOD.
09:21 PM on 06/19/2012
Yep, it works. Until you go off it, then it all comes back and often a bit more.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DrP
09:42 PM on 06/19/2012
The point is that you don't "go off it." It is a lifestyle plan.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
elcerritan
My bio is not micro
12:20 PM on 06/20/2012
Not true, actually. First, because as DrP said, eating low carb isn't a "diet," in the popular sense; it's a permanent change in eating habits. And second, because the boomerang effect of "dieting" generally occurs when people do calorie restriction plus fat reduction, not when people reduce carbohydrates, keep calorie levels appropriate for their gender, age, and level of physical activity for someone of their "target" weight, eat the appropriate grams of protein in light of the same factors, and get most of their calories from fats rather than carbohydrates. The endocrinology and biochemistry of human metabolism supports this. Read up on the "A to Z Study" conducted at Stanford University, which found that as compared with other popular "diet" programs, including low-fat and "veganish" Ornish, those who followed Atkins had better weight loss and better health markers for CVD risk even after two years.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
AuGlove5
01:35 PM on 06/18/2012
So what this article is saying is that the most optimum fuel for the body is glucose - something that becomes toxic in amounts slightly higher than a teaspoon and will make you pass in amounts slightly under? Sounds like science believed by a population of diabetics... Oh wait.

In reality, the body first burns glycogen because it is most readily available (already in the blood stream). However a body that is well adapted, with steady blood sugar levels, will switch to fat quickly for long term, more efficient energy because less glucose is stored.

Glycogen regulates blood sugar levels and is produced by the liver in adequate supply for those few parts of the body that require it for fuel.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DrP
01:07 PM on 06/19/2012
Thanks. Real science is appreciated!
As someone who is completely keto-adapted, I can vouch for the validity of your statement - I get by quite well on under 20 grams of carbohydrate a day in the form of non-starchy veggies and a few high-fat nuts, such as macadamias.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
AuGlove5
01:25 PM on 06/19/2012
I'm glad to hear my understanding of it is fairly accurate. Let's just consider all of the bad information out there as thinning the herd a bit.

My apologies, that was of poor taste. ;)
photo
undrgrndgirl
what's so funny 'bout peace, love & understanding?
10:58 PM on 06/17/2012
mmm...fake cheese and soy based (gmo) fud. thanks but i'll pass.
mountainmama
then they crawl across the beds teasing the alliga
08:37 PM on 06/17/2012
I almost never read any article that uses the term "change up." Sure clue it is claptrap. And it was.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Relentless rik
08:13 PM on 06/17/2012
What diet? [belch]
07:38 PM on 06/17/2012
Wow, there is so much bad information in this article. Study after study proves that high protein low carb diets work. All of the nonsense regarding water weight, etc has long been debunked. Please tell me what carbs your body "needs". All of the essential amino acids - there's a reason they're called essential- are found in proteins. Studies also support that fat intake has no relation to weight or cholesterol levels. As for the cravings comment, who do you know that craves brown rice and beans? The reason diets fail is that people eat junk food, go on a diet to lose weight then go right back to the eating habits that made them fat. Permanent weight loss requires a permanent lifestyle change.
06:42 PM on 06/17/2012
It took me years to realize that I should never "diet." If you diet, once you reach your ideal weight, you think you can resume eating the way you used to - and of course the pounds return.

Instead of dieting, eat what you need to maintain the weight you want to be - and once you get there, keep it up.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DrP
01:08 PM on 06/19/2012
Or stop worrying about weight. Eat a proper diet (low in carbohydrates, moderate in protein, and high in fats with the exception of transfats) and weight will normalize.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jimboy71
Hen Diapheron Heautoi
01:10 PM on 06/20/2012
It's not about going on a diet, it's about what goes into your diet. We need to look long and hard at what we like to eat, find non-processed, whole food alternatives, and yes, exercise a little more.
05:21 PM on 06/17/2012
Hey Kelly? Starch is starch. Not all vegan options are healthy. Why can't you accept that? I won't eat processed meat. I enjoy a diet that doesn't generate excessive insulin after a lifetime of eating too darned much grain in refined and whole forms. I cut out that stuff and am at a normal weight. I can even eat some of them in moderation now. I don't see much difference in the whole wheat vs refined wheat. They both drive the release of insulin I don't actually need, or want. How is this good for my health? Glucose and glycogen are things my body can make from protein if it needs it, so why would I want to keep stoking the fire with newspaper when I can use a nice hardwood log that keeps me going all day? If you don't want to eat animals, don't eat them, but don't tell me it would be better if I didn't eat them when science and empirical evidence indicate the opposite.
11:26 PM on 06/20/2012
Okay, but she's a busy "Health Activist and Author," so she's got legislation to write, appearances to make, books to sell, people to influence, and all that stuff -- no time for sciencey things. From what I understand, she is working feverishly against the very powerful "meat industry." It's really unfortunate that there isn't a "veg or carb lobby" to help her cause along...
07:36 AM on 06/21/2012
Quite so! I mean imagine the influence a body of non-customers can have on the "meat industry"! They could so shame them into doing things differently! Or maybe if she can get meat outlawed completely, she can make us even more dependent on foreign oil/fertilizer of which the run off destroys our lakes and rivers! Too bad there isn't an alternative! Our hands are completely tied!
04:39 PM on 06/17/2012
I recently read that the French do not eat between meals as a normal thing. And in America, 'coffee' breaks are written into contracts. Even the diet companies make it so that, overall, one is supposed to be losing weight while snacking and eating most of the day and into the evening.

If you want to lose weight, perhaps eating 3 small reasonable meals a day should be sufficient. If not, they losing weight is a losing proposition IMO.
05:16 PM on 06/19/2012
This is correct. We, French, are slim by eating everything in moderation, however sufficient quantities. We do not drink wine outside meals or hot beverages like some commercial coffeesalon brands offer and even less soft drinks. Our coffee is just coffee, small and unsweetened most often.
By digressing, the newer generations are getting fat. We had a regular mid afternoon snack as kids, usually French bread (no fat or sugar involved), sometimes buttered, sometimes with jam (often homemade) or sometimes a few chocolate squares (not candy bars). Dessert is a piece of fruit or yogurt, the natural kind, pastries are a (not regular) treat.
This said, the acceptable weight is extremely low in the US (we do not go by size as there is too much vanity sizing in US brands) and we are not trying to reach that absolute skinniness that some think is the norm. Our acceptable body weight range from thin to sturdy, within the medical guidelines. Start dieting and each time you gain everything plus a lb or 2 back.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jimboy71
Hen Diapheron Heautoi
01:11 PM on 06/20/2012
Pastries are not regular?

Don't tell the folks at Laduree...