iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Kathy Guillermo

GET UPDATES FROM Kathy Guillermo
 

How Not to Save Lives

Posted: 09/15/11 12:59 PM ET

When the U.S. Army turns into Zombieland for monkeys, it makes sense that Woody Harrelson would take action. He couldn't supply the primates with sawed-off shotguns and souped-up SUVs, but this week he did speak out for them to the man in charge: new Army Chief of Staff Raymond Odierno.

I hope by now General Odierno has clicked on the link that Harrelson included in his letter to him. He would see what happens to vervet monkeys every single month at Aberdeen Proving Ground in Maryland: in a crude simulation of a nerve agent attack, the monkeys are given a massive overdose of a drug called physostigmine. The small, dark-faced monkeys, who never made war on anybody, twitch uncontrollably, convulse, vomit and lose bowel control while medical trainees watch.

Aberdeen Proving Ground appears to be the only Army facility where watching a monkey twitch and vomit passes for medical training. Other military bases use sophisticated human patient simulators that can be programmed to mimic the human response to a nerve agent attack. These simulators, unlike vervet monkeys, can be placed in outdoor areas to recreate conditions in which such an attack might actually occur. The Navy trains medics for chemical, biological and radiological casualty preparedness using immersive hospital drills with manikins and scenarios with human actors.

Why are Army medics at Aberdeen being short-changed? Observing the twitching of a tail and the perspiration on the paws of monkeys is so irrelevant to humans that the Army might as well prepare medics for chemical warfare by screening Invasion of the Body Snatchers. Seizures, vomiting and diarrhea aren't difficult to recognize. The antidote is standard. What makes treatment difficult is the chaos and danger of an attack -- conditions that can be simulated in moulage drills with actors. Military medics deserve the best, most relevant training because our men and women in war zones deserve medics who got the best, most relevant training.

When I was in college, I paid my tuition and expenses by working in an emergency veterinary clinic. It's a far cry from Afghanistan, but I remember late nights when the critical cases rolled in one after the other. I remember the rising panic when everything needed to be done at once -- a catheter inserted into a Beagle's vein, oxygen given to a cat in shock, a surgery suite prepped for a Great Dane with internal bleeding. Running over a borzoi with my Volkswagen would not have prepared me for helping a veterinarian treat a dog who ran into traffic. I learned that on the job, just as the veterinarian did, without deliberately harming anyone. The training I needed was similar to what the Navy provides: the role-playing and drills, repeated again and again, until working under stressful, life-threatening conditions becomes second nature. That's how lives are saved.

Why the Army insists on poisoning monkeys is a mystery. It appears to violate Department of Defense regulations prohibiting weapons training on primates and the use of animals when alternatives are available. Army spokespeople claim that it's a vital part of chemical casualty training. But if it's so crucial, then why then is it optional? That's right -- watching a monkey suffer the terrible effects of a nerve agent attack isn't required. It's simply offered as an option, like butter flavor on your popcorn at the movies.

PETA often takes calls from men and women in the military who are forced to watch animals endure unspeakable things in medical training and are upset about it. Many of these young soldiers know they will soon be deployed. They know the risks that lie ahead. They know they may not see their loved ones for many, many months. The last thing they want to do is harm an animal who never posed a threat to anyone. But they are soldiers, so they can't object. As the parents, sisters, brothers, friends and relatives of these men and women, and as citizens who object to gratuitous cruelty, we can speak out as Woody Harrelson has just done. We can remind military leaders that in America, we must give our soldiers the very best and most modern training, and that in America, we don't harm the weakest among us simply because we're bigger and stronger.

 
 
 

Follow Kathy Guillermo on Twitter: www.twitter.com/kathygfrompeta

 
 
  • Comments
  • 18
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
10:10 PM on 09/19/2011
As a lab tech based in the USA and who spends a good deal of time working throughout Asia working for this cause, I can report that these experiments are completely cruel and unnecessary. There are several digital computer solutions to replace this insanity. Please write to me if you are interested in knowing about this. msimmons
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
viper1ex19
IF IT’S FUN…….IT’S PROBABLY ILLEGAL….
08:39 PM on 09/16/2011
Disturbing…

A perfect example of wasteful spending on behalf of our government…
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Charles Queen
I am a disabled nam vet
10:11 PM on 09/16/2011
Very true my friend,very true.This has bee going on since they cracked the atom way back when.Monkeys especially seeemed to have been the ones most often picked to be used to see what happens when exposed to these chemical agents that somebody up in the hgiher archy decided to go ahead with.Yeppers,monkey's do see to be the mian ones that are used and discarded afterwards to the biohazordous waste company's of which surprisingly eneough there is not shortage of i this country
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Charles Queen
I am a disabled nam vet
10:24 PM on 09/16/2011
yes,as well as dogs too
07:56 AM on 09/16/2011
This is an outrage. Tormenting monkeys will not "save" soldiers. Spending our tax money for these cruel, useless experiments is something we should all be contacting our representatives about.
06:08 PM on 09/15/2011
We are better than this. Archaic, cruel experiments on animals is inhumane and unnecessary. The military must do right not only by animals, but by the men and women in uniform. The technology is there to make the military stronger and safer -- for everyone. Thank you, Ms. Guillermo, and PETA.
06:06 PM on 09/15/2011
This is terrible. Torturing animals is wrong no matter what. And doing it with tax dollars while we're broke is just rubbing salt in the wounds.
04:24 PM on 09/15/2011
Great article -- as a veteran, these people disgust me. Keep fighting the good fight!
03:20 PM on 09/15/2011
This is just terrible, I'm outraged. What does the US Army have to say for itself? WHY is this a vital part of training? When there are alternatives there really are NO excuses. I will forward this article to all my friends and family and encourage them to jump on with their reactions. We have only our voices, and I hope they will be heard by our country!
02:22 PM on 09/15/2011
Very Informative article! I knew that great apes and other animals are abused in cruel experiments, but the tests at Aberdeen Proving Ground are beyond shocking. I hope we have a real life a Rise of the Planet of the Apes. What are people thinking? Animal experimens are inhumane and ineffective.
01:52 PM on 09/15/2011
Thank you, Ms. Guillermo, for this eye-opening piece on the military's use of cruel and outdated methods to train military medics. In addition to being horribly abusive to the monkeys involved (how absolutely archaic!), the use of such methods seems to do a great disservice of our service personnel in the military. It is my earnest hope--for the animals and for our men and women in uniform--that General Odierno does the right thing and retires the use of animals in military training.
01:47 PM on 09/15/2011
How absolutely cruel and unnecessary. The army should be ashamed. Not only are they torturing animals for inconclusive and needless "tests," they are not properly preparing soldiers for battle. There is no excuse to not take advantage of the more up to date and reliable testing methods. Torturing animals in the name of science has got to stop. The army should be a leading example for the rest of "science" and stop this painful and terrifying violence against primates.
01:30 PM on 09/15/2011
Thanks to Woody Harrelson and PETA for calling the Army out on this needless cruelty. Let's hope the Army soon realizes that relying on outdated, useless animal experiments puts both monkeys and soldiers in danger.
01:07 PM on 09/15/2011
It is truly shameful that the Army would subject these monkeys to this cruel and crude training exercise, most especially when better and more sophisticated training methods are available and widely used elsewhere. Primates are highly intelligent, sensitive beings that experience the world much the way we do. The pain and terror they experience when they are poisoned in this horrific exercise is indistinguishable from the pain and terror any of us would feel. If this violence weren't being carried out in a laboratory behind closed doors, the perpetrators would likely face criminal prosecution for animal cruelty.
12:56 PM on 09/15/2011
I really hope the U.S. army listens to the public on this one. Monkeys are not ours (or the government's) to experiment on!
12:45 PM on 09/15/2011
You'd think the military has a moral obligation to use the most advanced training out there. Hurting monkeys in crude experiments is NOT cutting-edge technology. It's tragic, and WE--the taxpayers who don't voice our opinions--are ultimately to blame.
12:22 PM on 09/15/2011
This is horrible :( The Army needs to stop these cruel trainings and use non-animal options now! Thanks Kathy, Woody, and PETA for speaking out for monkeys. I will do the same