iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Kathy Kemper

GET UPDATES FROM Kathy Kemper
 

Stop Demonizing the Wealthy

Posted: 07/19/2012 12:19 pm

The other day, at our local fresh fruit and veggie stand, I noticed that a young woman working there was requesting tips for her "college fund." I put $5.00 in the jar that she had and asked her where she was studying. Her mom, who runs the stand, said wearily: "I'm not so sure college is the right idea anymore. A college degree doesn't necessarily mean a job when you have so much debt." John Zogby, the noted pollster, calls such people CEWCGJ: "College Educated Who Cannot Get Jobs."

That experience was a wake-up call: a hardworking mom with few dreams for her daughter's future. Consider this statistic: "About 1.5 million, or 53.6 percent, of bachelor's degree-holders under the age of 25 last year were jobless or underemployed, the highest share in at least 11 years."

Since when did America become a land of no opportunity? Nobel Laureate Joseph Stiglitz recently declared that "the U.S. worked hard to create the American dream of opportunity. But today, that dream is a myth." Like many others, he focuses on the growing concentration of income in America. While I worry about it, too, I also fear that we've become obsessed with income inequality, to the point that our leadership beats up on hardworking people who chase their dreams and become successful as a result.

The America I'm proud of rewards education, ambition, and work. Why should someone be embarrassed about making a seven-figure salary? According to a GlobeScan poll, 58 percent of Americans "strongly agree" or "somewhat agree" that the rich deserve their wealth. And according to a recent Gallup poll, "three-quarters of registered voters say the fact that Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney is worth more than $200 million makes no difference to their likelihood of voting for him."

It has become too common to think that anyone who makes a lot of money must be greedy. In fact, some of the biggest philanthropists are some of the biggest business titans: think Bill Gates and Warren Buffett. Indeed, the wealthy have played an indispensable role in making America into what it is today: think Andrew Carnegie, Henry Ford, and John Rockefeller.

Rather than demonizing them and their success, we should be encouraging innovation and getting out of the way of entrepreneurs. It's thanks to the private sector that we've been able to tap huge reserves of tight oil and shale gas, discoveries that many people think will lead to American energy independence. It's also thanks to the private sector that we're tapping the potential of nanotechnology, big data, three-dimensional printing, and online education, among other things, all of which could reap huge economic dividends down the road.

Stoking class warfare may be good election-year politics, but it isn't the way to restore the American Dream. If it was, unemployment wouldn't be stuck at 8.2 percent, and young women like the one I met would be on their feet and hopeful for the future.

 
FOLLOW POLITICS
The other day, at our local fresh fruit and veggie stand, I noticed that a young woman working there was requesting tips for her "college fund." I put $5.00 in the jar that she had and asked her wher...
The other day, at our local fresh fruit and veggie stand, I noticed that a young woman working there was requesting tips for her "college fund." I put $5.00 in the jar that she had and asked her wher...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 121
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (5 total)
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Paul Robertson
07:22 PM on 07/23/2012
Let me get this straight. You start off by describing a system that has left a young girl with few hopes of a better future but a man who had produced nothing with over $200 million and you conclude that we shouldn't be critical of this?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Eno
More of the same ol same ... A change has to come.
02:21 PM on 07/23/2012
My original comment was not posted for being too truthful. Something the media has a hard problem with.

I do not know a single person that demonizes the wealthy. No one I know hates people for being rich. What people do have a problem with is the rich who have continued to rig the game by buying the office’s of our political leaders. It wasn’t the poor or mid class who wanted bank deregulation, it wasn’t the poor or mid class that created and invested in asset backed securities, it wasn’t at the request of the poor and middle class that we are in the place we are now.

No one hates Bill Gates because he is too rich. But they do hate Madoff because he stole. And this is what many of the rich are doing. Buying laws, changing the rules and moving the country backwards.

What does it say today on HP – The rich are hoarding 32 Billion in offshore tax havens? How many poor or middle class have money to hide from the tax man? None.

Give me a break. Can't wait to hear more from out of touch insiders.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
street fightin man
07:04 AM on 07/22/2012
It's a fixed game. Upward mobility is a myth. The wealthy have already won the "class" war.
12:49 PM on 07/21/2012
Corporations are not magic unicorns of opportunity. They do not create opportunity. They exploit existing market conditions. Only a communist would believe corporations create opportunity. A free marketer would say that markets are self organizing and not dependent on any one entity.
12:03 AM on 07/21/2012
I don't know any worker who has limited liability. Only corporations get that. As for unions, unions are a response to corporate power. If we got rid of corporations (just had private businesses) then I'd be fine with ending unions.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:04 PM on 07/20/2012
Y'know, when I object (as I do) to rich sh*theads wanting to run the world for their own benefit, it usually ain't the "rich" part that bothers me. It's the rest of it.
schatsie
Wall Street is Worse than Vegas
08:59 PM on 07/20/2012
And you believe in the Tooth Fairy and the Easter Bunny also, don't you....READ FREE LUNCH and the Big Con and wake up and smell the coffee....Reality sucks for the bottom 50% who have as much wealth as ONE FAMILY at to top....This is A DIRECT AND PLANNED ASSAULT on the MIDDLE CLASS and has been perpetrated over the last 30 years.....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ken Maddox
This time abolish the GOP WealthCare programs!
07:46 PM on 07/20/2012
Making a 7 figure, or even 8 or more, isn't a bad thing. The bad thing is 7 and 7+ figure earners claiming that 6 and 6- figure earners are making too much money and are causing economic troubles. It is storing this money in tax haven accounts in other nations to avoid doing your fair share to support this nation. It is making things in off shore factories, and hiring workers for sub poverty wages in order to add one more figure to your salary, that is the bad thing.
There is an old adage that states "Don't bite the hand that feeds you." If the wealthy don't stop biting the hands of the workers that feed their greed, we will stop buying your products.
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
maxfax
Taa - dah!
07:43 PM on 07/20/2012
Have them stop destroying the working class.
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
maxfax
Taa - dah!
06:58 PM on 07/20/2012
"...Rather than demonizing them and their success, we should be encouraging innovation and getting out of the way of entrepreneurs. It's thanks to the private sector...." It's okay to continue outsourcing millions of American jobs? Dismantle thousands of American businesses, destroying those decent wage paying jobs, all for the sake of obscene profits, sent to offshore accounts, out of America, to avoid paying little to mostly no taxes, all on the backs of working or trying to work Americans? Americans who 9to5 it,mor try to are not the villains, they're angry what the privileged have "gamed" for themselves and scared where it leaves them. You are plain wrong.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
paulhunterjones
A new age Republican
06:52 PM on 07/20/2012
The theme of this post is easy to comprehend; it is not in our national interest to attack the American Dream. The desire to accumulate wealth and to be successful has fueled the national entrepreneurial spirit since the birth of the country. Competition to produce the best products or rendered superior services has led to innovation and a general rise in nation’s standard of living. In the past we refused to settle for meritocracy in any of our endeavors, especially in education. Foreigner’s plan their arrival in this country by learning English, saving money, investigating higher educational opportunities, and developing strategies for starting a business. They understand that they will have to work hard to obtain their dreams. American baby boomers were firm believers in hard work and rarely criticized wealth. I have not met a person including Liberal-Democrats that didn’t want to take every take tax deduction that they could. The tax laws at every level of government are designed to raise revenue and to encourage investments. By all accounts the complexion of America is changing at an exponential rate. This new generation of highly motivated and culturally different Americans is less likely to forego its collective dreams just to satisfy the politics of those who disapprove of success.
06:46 PM on 07/20/2012
This is a disappointingly vapid piece. No one is out there hating rich people for being successful. Many people are identifying and discussing the factors that have contributed to our rigid lack of social mobility and how dead the 'American Dream' is...does that count as demonizing the successful?

As a nation, I'd say we hold more contempt for the person that cleans toilets than for rich people. I mean the system is just set up for one at the expense of the other. Maybe you consider taxation a form of assault on character?
06:39 PM on 07/20/2012
I just want the wealthy to stop lobbying to suppress my wages. H-1b work visas were created by the rich to drive down the pay of skilled workers. They started this. I don't have a lobby. The rich are the one's who have lobbyist in DC constantly asking for special deals for themselves. The real welfare queens have lobbyist.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
05:46 PM on 07/20/2012
And thanks to Obama, there are more wealthy than ever before. Stock market is at the top again with corp's earnings and cash on hand well in the black. However, capitalism has failed to transfer this success to that 3 or 4 % that haven't recovered. US corp's either off-shored these jobs or decided not to re-fill these positions. POTUS has basically 2 options-----#1 FDR jobs program #2 making corp environment strong for the private sector to hire. Fact is capitalism has failed us.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
inorbit
03:20 PM on 07/20/2012
Making a seven figure salary is fine. Trying to squirm out of every single tax you can to the determent of the rest of the country is not.
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
maxfax
Taa - dah!
07:44 PM on 07/20/2012
You can that again, emphatically.
schatsie
Wall Street is Worse than Vegas
09:01 PM on 07/20/2012
And EXPECTING the middle 60% to pick up the 50 billion dollars in avoided taxes that are a direct result of the So Called Business Expenditures of the Fat and Famous is blankety blank INSANE.....