More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
HuffPost Social Reading
Katie Goodman

GET UPDATES FROM Katie Goodman
 

Facebook Blocked Me From Friending: That is Soooo 7th Grade...

Posted: 02/17/2012 1:33 pm

A male friend of mine said his worst middle school memory is when he called a girl to ask her out and her mom grabbed the phone and said to stop calling her.

That's what happened to me on Facebook this week. I swear I was trying to friend real live people I know -- people I met at Occupy Wall Street and in New York at my comedy show who don't have any friends in common with me on Facebook but who I had actual human exchanges with that involved the use of mouths, vocal chords, brain synapses, and shared political camaraderie, a borrowing of pens, signs, witticisms, hand warmers, and probably a sharing of beers though I don't remember due to the sheer enthusiasm of being present with real live people! But Facebook deemed me a stalker and cut me off from friending anyone for seven days. And once you're on that community watch list, you're flagged for life. It's the NSA of relationships -- the crotch-frisking TSA who is thrilled to have finally caught someone doing something even if it's just sneaking Chapstick through security. The algorithm of supposed stalkers has led to my being virtually alone (pun intended).

And more to the point, why is it only okay to friend your friend's friends?!?! Is this 7th grade?!?!

"Why are you talking to them?" the popular girl demands.

"Um, cuz they were nice?" I sheepishly answer. I flip my hair, just to look innocent and fit in. Then I reluctantly ignore the new friend, suddenly aware that my standing with the popular girls is in jeopardy.

Seven days. I thought that was bad. But today when my seven days were up, like the curious or perhaps more accurately masochistic person that I am, I decided to experiment and test my precarious situation. I friended people who were - ready for this? -- suggested to me as people I might want to friend by Facebook! And like a recovered crack addict who leaves jail only to celebrate freedom that night with, why not?, a little crack, I just couldn't help it. I friended them. The result? Another 14 days back in the half-way house. Agh! Is this what my adult life has come to? Is Facebook really in a position to take away my car keys and TV privileges? This is like the best Firm Parenting Class for teens ever. Facebook does not get tired or annoyed and cave in, and there's no way for me to contest it. What's an anti-authority political satirist to do?

When I Googled "Facebook blocked me from friending people they suggested" I got three million results. And isn't that really the beauty of Facebook? To know you're not alone? Ah... I feel better already. But if only I had any real skills, I could start a new social networking site for these millions of potential friends! Like the Island of Misfit Toys: We would be rejected but we'd be together. Which is all I wanted in the first place!

Facebook is now standing in the way of my making friends in the real world because we agreed to friend each other on Facebook. All those great people I was looking forward to getting to know, seeing what their work is, sharing links with, they are dead to me since I am dead to Facebook. So. Feel free to friend me. I can confirm your friendship. I just cannot initiate the offering of the candy to you small innocent children from my unmarked van... Just be careful you don't friend my friends... until I'm your friend. And even then...

Or, um, call me?


Katie Goodman is a musical comic who's show, "I Didn't F*ck It Up," is running in New York City. www.katiegoodman.com

 
 
 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 194
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (7 total)
04:45 PM on 04/13/2012
The real problem here is that nobody can get in touch with facebook. No phone number, no real people to talk to in order to address a legitimate complaint.

I have a similar problem and I am just really annoyed that I cannot find anybody to review the issues.
This seems to be the customer complaint I see all over. So now we have facebook, Amazon, Apple - all cool companies with cool products. But there is nobody on the other side.

Where is the customer service in this? There is not even an outsourced company in "wherever" to call.

We need a new social media company that can use what we're used to and turn it into a "customer friendly" company. The first one that comes along with these features will get my business and loyalty.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
xianred
wo bu zhidao
09:30 AM on 02/21/2012
Moderator, can you tell me why my post about being blocked from Facebook is not showing up? My post was on topic, contained no obscene or profane language, and was in no way abusive or contrary to any of the rules for posting that I could see. Thank you.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
xianred
wo bu zhidao
08:44 AM on 02/21/2012
Facebook blocked me as well - but not for 'friending.' Someone unknown to us, not a family member but merely a friend of a friend of a friend, reported the account as being one of a deceased person and without notice or verification our access was shut down.

My daughter committed suicide last year. Before she left us she gave us access to her Facebook account where she wrote her final goodbyes to us. Her entries detailed the inner turmoil she endured. She wanted us to know, maybe we could find some peace in her solution.

I read as much as I could bear but I left most to come back to when I was stronger.

Through her Facebook account I passed the sad news on to her many friends. And over this past year I have received great love and support from them as we have helped each other grieve her loss. Then, the day after her birthday, after receiving an overwhelming number of messages from her friends who knew I would be in great pain on this day - Facebook blocked access to the account.

I learned anyone can have anybody' account blocked by reporting them deceased. YOU DON'T HAVE TO BE A FAMILY MEMBER! You don't need to know them or be a 'friend.' Her words were a treasure to us - Facebook stole them from us. Now Facebook has broken heart my anew.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:23 PM on 02/21/2012
I, and many others I am sure, sympathize about your deep loss, and wish you endless wonderful memories of your darling daughter through the eternity to come.

Most people don’t know to print out or save electronic copies of their online social networking account contents. Every single word and picture posted on Facebook or any such website are as perishable as the classified ads we used to post in local newspapers. People should hold absolute no illusion that these website operators have the will, ability, or interest in saving all the content for you. In fact, these contents are more a burden to them than treasure. All they care to get out of holding these contents for people is the traffic and ad dollars they generate.

Ironically though, every such website do have archive copies of all such content kept indefinitely into the future. But they hold these archives purely for legal and internal “just-in-case” purposes only, but they will never let you near it unless you get a court to order them to release it.
12:11 AM on 02/21/2012
Have you tried... I don't know... sending a message? This would be an easy work around.... but wouldn't make a good article.
orthobobsuruncle
Insurance is not the same as welfare
10:55 AM on 02/20/2012
Is it not just a glitch?
01:47 AM on 02/20/2012
Wow. Are we really complaining about "imaginary friends"? Its Facebook people. How many friends gave you a physical present or card for your birthday???? How many called you on the day and didnt need a reminder? Those five, six, or two people (not including family members), are your friends. Grow up and connect with tangible life that is going on around you. Facebook is probably telling you to get a grip and back away from your electronic devices...oh wait...some "body" is at my door. Probably one of my "friends".
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
05:00 AM on 02/21/2012
She said these were people she'd met in real life, at Occupy Wall Street and at her own show, and who had wanted to be in touch with her via Facebook, not "imaginary" friends. I'm the first one to criticize people who think that Facebook is a place for genuine connection, but if you've met a whole bunch of people in, you know, 3-D, and then want to keep in touch without having to email or phone each one individually, it seems reasonable that doing so through FB should be allowed, despite their algorithm. I'm not sure you quite got her point.
05:11 AM on 02/21/2012
Oh I'm quite sure I understood her point. I'm not quite as sure that you've understood mine, but thanks for playing anyway.
11:06 PM on 02/19/2012
Haha yeah..I only ever sent 'Friend requests to People I ACTUALLY KNOW and to 'Facebook Suggested people..' AND I GOT A WARNING!!! FaceBook, the Syphilis of Social Websties..warned me!!
11:05 PM on 02/19/2012
Facebook did the same thing to me. Seven days. I felt as if I'd been smacked. I started an author fan page and when asked if I wanted to notify my "friends" I said "okay" thinking they'd notify my FB friends. Apparently, FB contacted everyone I've ever had on my computer or close to it and FB then received "multiple complaints" that I had tried to befriend people I didn't know. Now, my landlord and former lawyer think I want them to promote my novel. I'd like to give Mark Zuckerberg the finger. He and the rest of the FB team can kiss my brass tacks. Google+ here I come!
08:39 AM on 02/20/2012
I had the same thing happen to me it was a friend of a friend and face book sent me her name and she turned me in and well we know what happened. But bless facebooks little heart i keep getting names from people i have never heard of not even friends of friends of friends of friends so on son you get the point, but if you have problem they can not be found,
09:43 AM on 02/20/2012
Well apparently when others try to profit from Facebook (author fan page) Facebook doesn't take kindly to it as you've discovered.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
GingersCorner
10:04 PM on 02/19/2012
Katie, the exact thing happened to me. First, I was put on probation for 7 days and then less than 24 hours after my release--bam, I was then on probation for 14 days. And you're right, I befriended friends that Facebook suggested I befriend. I mean, what are "friends" for? What is the criteria for FB friendship? To be-friend or not to be-friend, that is the question. They want to know if one's friends are close friends or acquaintances. Are we talking "know" in the Biblical way; or "Hi, how's it hangin?"; perhaps "Hey, don't I know you? Oh, yeah, you're Katie's friend, we met a her Xmas party.", or there's "Haven't we met before?" (wink wink). It's just a puzzlement; what's a FB newbie to do???
08:04 PM on 02/19/2012
I am on 7 day watch as well. Last night at a real life event sitting next to a woman who wanted me to FB add her - I was denied. 7 days of detention for me too.. wanna braid eachother's hair and put on temporary tattoos while we wait?
07:49 PM on 02/19/2012
Join Google+, problem solved.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bikelady1
Believe 1/2 of what u see, nothing of what u hear
09:51 AM on 02/20/2012
I did joint G+. Very happy now. cancelled my fb acct and I am even happier. But, thats me...
05:47 PM on 02/19/2012
I have no use for facebook. Have enough friends. Cannot understand the fascination with it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
signgrrl
typeface geek
10:06 AM on 02/20/2012
when you live 1400 miles away from most of your family, you will understand.
10:24 AM on 02/20/2012
I have no family -- could never rely on them when I did. Pretty much a loner with friends locally, in other states, in Paris. We talk on SKYPE and I write endless letters on my computer.
orthobobsuruncle
Insurance is not the same as welfare
10:55 AM on 02/20/2012
It's a boon, I can't believe I ever did without it from that point of view.
04:53 PM on 02/19/2012
Maybe someone will figure out that Facebook it not all it's really cracked up to be. Also that being a good friend is picking up the phone and calling your friend, and actually talking to them (if not getting together). Studies have shown the more time you spend on Facebook, the more likely you are to be sad because others' lives are more "Facebook fun" than your own. http://www.lvrj.com/news/facebook-may-cause-depression-in-teens-118772449.html
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
04:02 PM on 02/19/2012
I'm in seventh grade. The whole "Popular girls" thing, is actually not true. It probably was years before, but not all kids are concerned what others think about them. I understand you may have different experiences, but at my school we are above labels and such.
I deleted my facebook account. I had it for one week, and it became too self-absorbing. I'd like it better if Facebook anly allows you online for a certain amount of time a day.
10:38 PM on 02/19/2012
It's probably a before-the-internet thing. When I was in highschool 7 years ago, the "popular" kids were often mocked for being so full of themselves.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:37 PM on 02/21/2012
Those who think school was made for them to put social standings between friends will be the ones working at McDonalds at 45.
01:35 PM on 02/19/2012
I had the same experience. At the top of my homepage facebook recommends people that I may know and want to be friends with. So I click on the face and link facebook provides (not me searching for any) and they shut me out for ten days and said I violated their policy by asking too many people I didn't know to be friends. I wonder if some of the people complain or maybe it is all computerized. Don't take it personal, it is a malfunction in facebooks programming - created by some programmer that doesn't have a clue.