More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
HuffPost Social Reading
Katrina Lantos Swett

GET UPDATES FROM Katrina Lantos Swett
 

Can Enlightenment Come to Russia?

Posted: 02/16/2012 5:11 pm

History is replete with tales of those whose enlightened view of the world became their ultimate undoing. It happened in the early 1400s to John Wycliffe who disregarded papal opposition and translated the Bible into the language of ordinary Englishmen. Wycliffe died of a stroke before he could be charged with heresy and burned at the stake, but that did not prevent a trial and conviction years later that resulted in his unearthed bones being cast into the River Swift. Unfortunately, two similar tales are playing out today in modern Russia, and we can only hope that the endings will be vastly different.

The first tale resurrected just last week when we learned that the Russian Ministry of Interior intends to put on trial the "bones" of Sergei Magnitsky, who suspiciously died in custody two years ago after he testified that Ministry officials embezzled $230 million dollars. This bizarre saga will break new ground as the first posthumous prosecution in Russian legal history. For those interested in rule of law, this is a particularly outrageous example of the "legal nihilism" that President Medvedev at first decried but has since accepted.

The second tale began in 2003 with the arrest of Mikhail Khodorkovsky and continues today as the most high profile example of Russian judicial corruption. Khodorkovsky took advantage of the chaotic "wild, wild east" period following the collapse of communism to build Yukos Oil Company into one of the most profitable businesses in Russia. Yet in the inverted world of Russian justice, adherence to such unorthodox standards was not his undoing.

The Kremlin began targeting Khodorkovsky when he applied Western standards to his business practices: bringing in outside Directors, conducting bona fide audits, and paying more taxes than any other private entity in Russia. More worrisome was that Khodorkovsky promoted genuine political opposition and sought to strengthen independent civil society groups. Recognizing the need for Russia to become truly modern, open, and democratic and believing that he could help usher in those changes, Khodorkovsky used his resources to attempt to reform the country he loved. For that lofty ambition, Putin's henchmen set out to destroy him.

Khodorkovsky has since been subjected to two show trials and spent nearly a decade in the Gulag with a sentence of 14 years still ahead. His prosecution has been denounced as politically motivated and a violation of human rights by the Parliamentary Council of Europe and the European Court of Human Rights, while Amnesty International has declared him a Prisoner of Conscience.

It is my greatest hope that the people of Russia see these two tales come to an honorable end. Compared to Sergei Magnitsky, who paid with his life for daring to expose corruption in Russia, Mikhail is a lucky man. As the refreshing spring winds of reform blow across Red Square, there is renewed hope that this courageous man may one day breathe the air of freedom outside prison walls. And yet, the bizarre announcement of the posthumous trial of Sergei Magnitsky, serves as a chilling reminder that the Russian winter is by no means over.

WATCH: Mikhail Khodorkovsky -- The Man Who Believed He Could Change Russia

 
History is replete with tales of those whose enlightened view of the world became their ultimate undoing. It happened in the early 1400s to John Wycliffe who disregarded papal opposition and translat...
History is replete with tales of those whose enlightened view of the world became their ultimate undoing. It happened in the early 1400s to John Wycliffe who disregarded papal opposition and translat...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 29
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
12:51 PM on 02/20/2012
That just amazing how many KGB agents in the USA. They are paid fore.
Khodorkovsky does not have any property in Russia, neither abroad. His business was lowful and apsolutely transperent. But Putin's propaganda is working.
12:43 PM on 02/20/2012
Dear Katrina:
We are so thankful for your artical about Khodorkovsky. It is very importent to support Prisoners of Conscience: Khodorkovsky, Lebedev and Pichugin. When people of the Word rises their voices for Political Prisoners in Russia- there are more chance for them to be alive.
Anfortunately, translation of you fraze "Khodorkovsky has since been subjected to two show trials and spent nearly a decade in the Gulag with a sentence of 14 years still ahead. His prosecution has been denounced as politically motivated and a violation of human rights by the Parliamentary Council of Europe and the European Court of Human Rights, while Amnesty International has declared him a Prisoner of Conscience" was incorrect: 14 years being in prison more, above 9 yeasr already been in prison.
Deeply appreciate.
Joseph and Rita,
Detroit, MI
04:09 AM on 02/18/2012
Great article. And the "Russian winter" will not end until Russia has a legal system capable of functioning without dictates from other branches of government or easily influenced by corruption.
According to Transparency International, Russia is ranked 143 out of 182, and us the mist corrupt industrial country in the world.
http://en.rian.ru/crime/20111201/169195312.html
What else can one say? "Clean up your act, Putin?"
From the protests in the streets, it is clear Russians themselves are sick of being played the fools.
AllegroTroppo
Appeaser feeds crocodile hopes to be eaten last
07:31 PM on 02/17/2012
Khodorkovsky was one of the oligarchs who made a commitment to keep his billions out of politics, and leave the rebuilding of the federation to professionals.
In exchange Russian government made a commitment to turn the blind eye to the methods oligarchs used to get and keep their billions.

Khodorkovsky violated his pledge and lost everything because of it.
To the lasting benefit of the Russian people.
AllegroTroppo
Appeaser feeds crocodile hopes to be eaten last
07:27 PM on 02/17/2012
When Russians try to copy Western liberalism during Yeltsin, going as far important a whole troops of Ivy League economists and other limo-liberals, the country was pushed to the brink of cultural, economic and military collapse.
Putin brought Russia back from the chasm.
Let's face it Russia will never be Denmark. But that's a good thing.
12:58 PM on 02/20/2012
For Allegro Troppo: Putin bring Russia to the dictatorship and to the most corrupted country and I do not wish you to get to the Russian court for any reason. Think about.
10:50 AM on 02/17/2012
I think the Russian leaders mixed up the D words... they have a dictatorship and not a democracy. I've read that many who tried to expose their corruption or to change the way they control and manipulate their country have paid dearly for it. There seems to be no fair and impartial judicial system nor is journalism free. Huff Post has written several articles in the past weeks on Russian political control over child adoption as well as child abduction.

This one on fostering child abduction is shocking ...
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/harris-silver/russian-democracy-has-a-p_b_1228575.html
03:35 AM on 02/18/2012
Very true. If the independence of the judiciary, or the lack of it, can be seen in small cases, it's a given the courts can't be trusted to be fair in the big, high profile cases.
09:50 AM on 02/17/2012
"Khodorkovsky took advantage of the chaotic "wild, wild east" period following the collapse of communism to build Yukos Oil Company into one of the most profitable businesses in Russia. Yet in the inverted world of Russian justice, adherence to such unorthodox standards was not his undoing."

Are you being paid to write this? He is partly responsible for all the loopholes in the constitution, because it had been forced through after a coup. Its validity today is still in question.

"More worrisome was that Khodorkovsky promoted genuine political opposition and sought to strengthen independent civil society groups."

He bought two-thirds of the Duma because he did not want to pay taxes. The richest can do whatever the they please, and this is "enlightenment" to you? It does not matter if you like what he did (which probably includes the murder of the the mayor of Nefteyugansk), this is the farthest thing from democracy.

"His prosecution has been denounced as politically motivated and a violation of human rights by the Parliamentary Council of Europe and the European Court of Human Rights,"

WRONG. The ECHR has said that the trial is not politically motivated.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/russia/8547862/Mikhail-Khodorkovsky-not-a-political-prisoner-Human-Rights-court-rules.html

This man has millions (billions?) hidden away that were stolen from the Russian people so he can continue paying for the finest publicity campaign. Are you receiving any of this?
03:40 AM on 02/18/2012
"he bought two thirds of the Duma..."
And on those grounds, the reason he is in jail and not Putin would be what?
02:50 PM on 02/18/2012
He was using the Duma to benefit himself, whereas Putin used the Duma to benefit Russia. Do you think he should get tax breaks while the government cannot pay teachers, conscripts, doctors, scientists, and other employees?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Paperless Tiger
07:50 AM on 02/17/2012
Khodorkovsky = Wall Street mole
07:04 AM on 02/17/2012
Actually, Khordorkovsky's crime was cavorting with American neocons who openly called for the destruction of Russian power. Allowing this resource, that was obtained criminally by the way, "Wild Wild East" rationalisation notwithstanding, to stay in the hands of someone out to destroy Russia, was not what a reasonable government would allow. Boris Yeltsin by the way was one of the all-time worst leaders of any country at any time, ever, and Russia will be more enlightened only when the vestiges of that horror are totally swept away. Putin has not done this.
TomMartin
Freedom and equality.
05:45 AM on 02/17/2012
Pope Formosus was similarly unearthed and sentenced by Pope Stephen VII. So absurd.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:14 PM on 02/16/2012
The Russian bureaucratic elite is quite well integrated with the West; Russian oligarchs own mansions, yachts and sports teams all over Europe and America. This hasn't prevented Russia from drifting once again into autocracy. Only Russians can decide whether they want to have a Western model state, or to pursue their "special path."
07:32 PM on 02/16/2012
I would not recommend that anyone from Russia move to the United States. The reason is because as that country is moving out of communism, Obama is rapidly moving this country into it.
11:34 PM on 02/16/2012
I'll bet you know a lot about it.
TomMartin
Freedom and equality.
05:46 AM on 02/17/2012
Russia is moving back into a form of communism. Obama will never allow this here.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
doriath22
Born-again Jacobin. Robespierre had the right idea
06:31 PM on 02/16/2012
They've been working on that one for over 300 years, now.
photo
Dredd
Our government is a wartocracy.
06:11 PM on 02/16/2012
After passing similar laws in the U.S.eh? recently, lets hope this interesting post does not apply here. Remember "It Can't Happen Here" by Sinclair Lewis?

http://blogdredd.blogspot.com/2012/02/momcoms-mass-suicide-murder-pact.html
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Arion
05:44 PM on 02/16/2012
Russia has never known anything like true democracy of the rule of law. The nation went from Tsarism to neo-Tsarism (or communism). Putin seems to occupy a kind of middle ground.
TomMartin
Freedom and equality.
05:50 AM on 02/17/2012
Kerensky tried it, and recently Yeltsin tried it. Unfortunately both failed.
02:51 PM on 02/18/2012
Yeltsin slaughtered about 2000 protesters, so he never cared to try democracy.