More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Keli Goff

Keli Goff

Posted: April 14, 2010 08:45 AM

Why Michael Steele Still Matters (Even If You Wish That He Didn't)

What's Your Reaction:

At this point Michael Steele's tenure as RNC Chair has become such a joke, that it's hard not to wonder if he's intentionally writing the punch lines himself.

As everyone who doesn't live under a rock now knows, a recent report revealed that on Steele's watch the RNC billed thousands of dollars on luxury hotels and travel, and most embarrassingly, a bondage themed nightclub. (Try to read that sentence without giggling. It's virtually impossible.) Despite his early run-ins with (and subsequent retreat from) Rush Limbaugh, his multiple verbal gaffes, (including musing on the record that the GOP was not likely to reclaim the House this year) it is Bondage-gate that appears to have finally turned Steele from laughingstock to the political equivalent of Dead Man Walking.

GOP Consultant Alex Castellanos, a former Steele confidante, was recently joined by North Carolina's GOP Chair in calling for Steele's resignation. Anyone seeking further proof that Steele's tenure as Chair is on the political equivalent of life support, need look no further than the recent "letter of support" signed by thirty other state GOP chairs. That seems like the political equivalent of a Hollywood couple issuing a press release to announce how happily married they are.

Steele recently admitted that he believes that Blacks in high profile positions -- from himself to the President -- are judged more harshly than their White counterparts. This statement is one of the few things that he (someone I have interviewed in the past and on a personal level happen to like) has said in recent months that I actually agree with. But since he ceased being taken seriously a while ago, now everything he says is either dismissed altogether or greeted with outright ridicule, even when it actually makes some sense. The irony of course, is that if he believes this axiom to be true, that he would be held to a higher standard, shouldn't he have tried harder all along to avoid so many unnecessary yet costly mistakes?

I thought things couldn't get worse for him when someone created a video mocking Steele's financial scandal by depicting him as a blinged-out rapper, complete with gyrating video vixens and all. Then The Root.com included him on a list that could have been called "Fellow Blacks we Wish we Could Give Back." (I know Steele hasn't had the greatest year but to put him on a list with O.J. Simpson still seems pretty harsh.)

But as funny as taking potshots at Steele may seem at the moment, the possible failure of his tenure is ultimately no laughing matter for Black Americans of all political stripes.

When Steele acknowledged that he believes he has a slimmer margin of error as a Black man, he hinted at a largely unspoken, yet widely perceived racial reality in the eyes of many minorities: that when a minority trailblazer fails they make it that much harder for those who come after them.

A friend of mine once shared that there were young women working in entertainment who privately shed tears when Jamie Tarses, the first female head of ABC's entertainment division, resigned, after her gift for picking hits like Friends for NBC did not translate into success as an executive. Their tears could have been for a variety of reasons, but it's likely that some of them knew that fairly or not, she was carrying their own hopes and futures on her shoulders, and that her failure had just made their own climbs up the ladder a little tougher.

The same goes for President Obama. I often get criticized, particularly among some older Americans, for being too "Pollyanna-ish" (read: naĂ¯ve) about my perspective on race relations, so it came as a surprise to some when I said at one speaking engagement that President Obama has zero room for outright failure, simply because he's the first. And if he fails -- and I'm talking impeachment level embarrassment -- it will make it that much harder for another Black person to be granted the same opportunity anytime in the near future.

Which brings me back to Michael Steele. Some of you may be thinking that nothing would make you happier that to see Steele fail, because you see him as a token, or political turncoat or simply don't like him.

But let's not forget that former Secretary of State Colin Powell, a Black conservative, arguably did just as much to make some white conservatives and swing voters comfortable with the idea of seeing a Black man serve in a leadership capacity at the highest levels of government as any Black Democrat has. My point is that effectively combating racism and prejudice has historically required a combination of government intervention, along with individuals encountering those who defy the negative stereotypes that they possess. So far, Steele does not appear to be doing that. Which does not help any of us -- particularly among some of the extremists within his party who are looking to validate their prejudice.

So even though I don't agree with Steele on everything, I for one am rooting for him to salvage both his reputation and his leadership role.

Because if Steele fails, it simply makes it that much harder for those who have refused to accept the President in a leadership role, to accept any Black man in one, and in the end that doesn't help any of us.

This piece is republished courtesy of TheLoop21.com for which Goff is a political writer.

www.keligoff.com


 
 
 

Follow Keli Goff on Twitter: www.twitter.com/keligoff

 
 
  • Comments
  • 72
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4  Next ›  Last »  (4 total)
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Natalie Bridgewater
08:07 AM on 04/23/2010
Ms. Goff, you got it wrong on this one. Incompetence comes in all stripes. Black folk need not have special sympathy when it comes in black skin. We can call it as we see it.
07:27 PM on 04/22/2010
Keli, your thnking regarding Steele is so ridiculously flawed. First of all, you must not compare Obama with Michael Steele, who by all evidence is simply a token in Republican leadership circle. Secondly, it is insulting to mention Obama and Steele in the same breadth when it comes to leadership. I think Steele's leadership skills are shabby and second-rate at best.
ThinkCreeps
Seriously, it's time.
02:26 PM on 04/15/2010
Steele is at the vanguard of the campaign to end discrimination on the grounds of ability.

The problem he faces in his bid to be the Rosa Parks of dumb, is that he can't work out which end of the bus is which.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
BoyInBOYCOTT
09:10 PM on 04/14/2010
Not every Black in a leadership role, makes it easier for the Blacks or (other minority people) to follow.
Steele made himself a JOKE, no one encouraged his LAME hip hop wannabe schtick, he did that all on his own. It rivaled Blacksploitation flicks of the 70's. If you want to mention the trailblazers for Blacks...... they are Democrats, Barbara Jordan, Shirley Chisolm, John Lewis, Andrew Young.
They took the reins of power, and kept their DIGNITY.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
Wallysmom
What Washington needs is adult supervision.
03:31 PM on 04/22/2010
Excellent post. I totally am not in agreement with the article. It is almost a statement that says "better an incompetent Black man making it, than no Black man". With his continued inept handling of the RNC, Steele gives ammunition to the racists in the GOP to never trust another minority in a position of leadership. Democrats know how to treat those of diversity and color -- your list is admirable. His flag tie pin. His cross pen set. His letterhead. He's gonna keep it all. I think DIGNITY is the last thing Steele is keeping.
12:58 AM on 04/23/2010
Fanned! I agree that Democrats are a Party of Diversity as well! The GOP know they want to get rid of Steele but cannot afford the talk that will come out of the Democratic Party as well as America, so for right now they are keeping him until they are SAFE! Steele will soon learn he was used by the GOP. Steele, I believe knows how valuable he is to the GOP right now, but the GOP's leopard spots changed quickly to the venomous snake of the Tea Party!! So my advice to Steele...watch your back!!!!
05:12 PM on 04/14/2010
Why wasn't the democrats treatment of Clarence Thomas during his hearings called racism? Democrats were just brutal to him and pretty much treated him like a hound dog. I don't think Republicans yelled "Racism" as the reason for the treatment of Clarence Thomas by the left. Does the left have some sort of mystical monopoly over the use of the term Racism with any meaning? No, but the left sure does "Go there" when it comes to demonizing anyone that is considered conservative. Use of cheapshots is a calling card of the left and it speaks to the inability to maintain a cooler head during a debate, it requires an appeal to emotion to make a point rather than intellect. Classic example of the dangers of emotional appeal, Why don't we parents just spoil our children rotten with gifts or cookies or whatever they want when they start to cry? Because we know that in the long run, that would actually be harmful to both them and those around them when they come of age. We have to teach the children to behave and be happy with the things they already have, and if they want something, they need to earn it through chores or good grades or some other beneficial behavior. That is the difference between appeals to emotion vs. logic.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
BoyInBOYCOTT
09:04 PM on 04/14/2010
Because the charges against Thomas were from a Black Woman, Anita Hill...who had her reputation dragged through the mud being a whistle blower.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
Wallysmom
What Washington needs is adult supervision.
03:31 PM on 04/22/2010
Fanning you. I especially liked your last post.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
05:06 PM on 04/14/2010
You say that as if Michael Steele hadn't already failed.
04:49 PM on 04/14/2010
Somebody please give me a list of racist Republican or conservative policies.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
07:54 PM on 04/14/2010
How about that whole "Let's Celebrate the Confederacy" thing? Or their opposition to reasonable affirmative action? Or their opposition to anything Obama proposes-- even when it is IDENTICAL to their own past positions?

Puh-leeze.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
BoyInBOYCOTT
09:16 PM on 04/14/2010
Repeatedly refusing to honor Dr. King with a National Holiday.
Tony Perkins buying the klan mailing list from David Duke for $ 83,000
Haley Barbour attending a klan affiliated BBQ with CCC, and his photo was on their website.
04:44 PM on 04/14/2010
Minority status is more of a political asset than a liability in today's political atmosphere. But if you are a bone-head while you hold these esteemed positions, your gonna get raked over the coals. That has never changed in the history of our country. Continuously reminding people that "THE PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES" and the "LEADER OF THE RNC" are black and that any criticism of them is due to racism is extremely dangerous and short-sighted. You have to admit, Obama is very.....how do you say "Progressive". And has us on a path never breached before in our history (Healthcare takeover, Auto industry take over, Financial Takeover, Bailouts around 1 trillion and and deficit spending that is not been seen since WWII and the Civil War). We got "change", but some who voted for him expected a differnent kind of "change", and those that did not want "change" in the first place are even more ticked off. Criticism for both Obama and Steele has nothing to do with race. Criticism is based on the content of their character.
photo
TXDeb
optimistic
03:51 PM on 04/14/2010
I call "bunk" on this article. Mr. Steele, along with so many other republicans, made a conscience decision to obstruct any initiatives put forth by the Obama administration. Now that the bright light of modern technology is being shinned on the republican party, their true nature is being exposed. And the so called 'family values' party is being revealed as fraud.

Sometimes it's about the man (not his race), and this is one of those times.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
madinirose
03:43 PM on 04/14/2010
Look, Steele's gonna fail anyway! So, we've gotta just deal with it.
photo
BBackSoon
Hello, I must be going.
02:30 PM on 04/14/2010
Nope he is a tool, I don't care if he was green, I would still think of him as a tool.

He was hired to add a 'splash of color' to the pasty white GOP. But instead of actually trying to find a qualified candidate they pulled a Sarah Palin and just picked someone.

I do think it is funny that GWB was the last moronic figurehead that didn't completely implode. Well we can argue that one. You would think that someone that is given a national position then immediately thinks they earned it and that they know everything.
02:25 PM on 04/14/2010
I have to disagree with the premise of this piece. I understand why someone would want Michael Steele to succeed, as it might pave the way for more inclusiveness in the future.

However, if the point is just to prove that African Americans can lead major political organizations, the late Ron Brown (Chairman of the DNC) decisively proved that point 20 years ago.

If the Republican Party will be reluctant to reach out to minorities for the foreseeable future due to Michael Steele’s incompetence, that says more about what is wrong with Republicans – and why many of us here choose not to join them – than it does about African Americans.

I certain would not want the Republican agenda to succeed just to assuage Republican racism.
02:20 PM on 04/14/2010
If Michael Steele was chosen because he was the most qualified person, then I would agree with some of your assessment. However, he was chosen because the GOP planned an all out assault on Obama and they wanted cover on the racial front. "Look, it's not about race, our chair is a black guy... We're not racists...look at Steele" Secondly, he has gone along with all of the racist nonsense that HIS party has thrown at Obama and has offered no criticism to the most vitriolic and racist assaults launched. So, don't expect people to rally around a man based on race when he is one of those black people who conveniently denies the existence of racism unless he is the victim. Ms. Goff, giving Michael Steele support just because he's black is as wrong as the racists giving Obama flack just because he's black. And I'm going along with the rhetoric that black conservatives have been spouting for years, I'm going to judge him on HIS accomplishments, abilities and on the content of his character, and not expect less of him because he's black.
01:15 AM on 04/21/2010
Excellent post.hlhicks

Steele reminds me of those blacks who hate affirmative action NOW after they have benefited from it. I am black and I don't care if Michael Steele fails. He is not good at his job. Period! So therefore if racism does not exist and Michael Steele has on many occasions talked about the color free society now all of a sudden Steele is a victim? Please.

He like Sarah Palin was chosen by the establishment as a foil against Obama. Palin because Obama did not pick Hilary as VP and therefore McCain just picked a woman (despite the fact that she was not vetted properly) to go up against Obama. It did not work because Palin is clueless.

Steele because any black man coming up against Pres. Obama will be strictly about politics and they could assault the Pres in any way that they choose and look to Steele as the point man. The joke is on the "Repugs" now - all men are not created equal and a dimwit like Steele could never hold a candle to the President. Fire him and put someone in there who can do the job whatever the color.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Friction57
full grown and still a microbio
01:30 PM on 04/14/2010
I'm sorry but I am going to have to disagree with your article. I liked your writing style, it was the content that was discordant for me. Generally speaking I'd say that the inverse was true about the standard Mr. Steele is held too. I read something the other day "the only thing harder for the Republican party to do than hire a person of color is to fire one". Mr. Steel was picked because of his race, not because his spectacular abilities or resume. The republican's know they have a huge issue with racism in their ranks and they needed a face of color with the election of a black president to give them some political cover. If he were white he would have been fired long ago. His playing the race card now is a cop out that actually is more damning than his behavior.

For most people Mr. Steel isn't doing harm to African Americans, he is doing harm to himself and his party. Granted there is an element of society that will feel the way you describe, but they are a minority that will always look at people different than themselves with suspicion and fear, they are called racist..
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
HarmNone
Censorship: Reaction of the ignorant to freedom
01:30 PM on 04/14/2010
I didn't vote for Pres. Obama because he was black, I voted for him because I believed in his ability and that he was the best man for the job. To make a decision on any situation just because someone is or isn't of a color is discriminatory. For a change, let's be human beings and judge people by their actions toward community and not their packaging. Whatever happens to Steele should reflect on him as a person, not on any racial platform.