iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
GET UPDATES FROM Ken Blackwell
 
GET UPDATES FROM Bob Morrison
 

Hillary: Playing Roulette With the Russians

Posted: 04/23/2012 9:26 am

Secretary Hillary Clinton was at the Naval Academy recently. She went there to deliver a prestigious Forrestal Lecture. And she was well received by the 4,000 Midshipmen and hundreds of students attending the Naval Academy Foreign Affairs Conference.

One Midshipman asked Sec. Clinton about the killing of Osama bin Laden. Hillary responded with poised professionalism. She crisply outlined all the steps that were taken and the vast, complex operations that had to come together in time and space to bring success. She tells the story well. And, interestingly, she gives no hint of envy that it was Barack Obama who got to make that critical call, not Hillary herself.

Well, good for Hillary! It would be unchivalrous of us to deny Madame Secretary credit for the most praiseworthy act of the Obama administration. Even better, she did not tell Pakistan. Recall the invertebrate Sec. of State Cyrus Vance. He reigned in protest from Jimmy Carter's Cabinet in 1980 -- not because Carter failed to rescue our hostages in Iran, but because he tried!

Sec. Clinton was also asked about Russia's unhelpfulness and Syria. She replied:

Part of the difficulty is the change in leadership that is occurring in Russia. Vladimir Putin will assume the presidency very soon, but he's not president yet. It appears that Medvedev will be appointed prime minister. He's putting together a government, but it's not put together yet. So the Russians have a long-term relationship with the Assad family. They sell a lot of arms, continuing to do so, to the Assad regime. They use a port in Syria that has been made available to them for a number of years. So there are a lot of deep connections between Russia that go beyond whoever the leader is and Syria. So I think there will be a very rough couple of days in trying to determine whether we go to the Security Council seeking action knowing that Russia is still not on board but continuing to require them to have to either veto or abstain, and see what we can try to bring about because we're not going to give up. We're going to keep pushing for both humanitarian and strategic reasons.

It would be hard to imagine more errors in a single answer. Russia's change of leadership? What change? Putin has been in charge since New Year's Eve 2000. That has never been in doubt. The Obama administration made much -- too much -- of its closeness to Medvedev, even giving the appearance of disrespect to Putin in the process. That's like cozying up to the monkey in the hopes of showing up the organ grinder.

This is the same Russia whose foreign minister, Sergei Lavrov, Hillary famously gifted with a red "Re-set" button on their first meeting. That was to signal the new administration in Washington wouldn't fuss about Russia's 2008 aggression against the Republic of Georgia. Except that the Russian word for "Re-set" was spelled wrong. And the writing didn't even use the Russian Cyrillic alphabet!

Worse, the Obama administration abandoned missile defense for Poland, the Czech Republic and Hungary. This was, we were told, to make Russia more amenable on such matters at the Iranian nuclear program. Since then, the Russians pocketed Mr. Obama's concessions and have given us no help on Iran's nukes. And on Syria, Iran's puppet? Don't even ask.

When the FBI collared 10 Russian spies just days before an Obama-Medvedev "hamburger summit" in the U.S., the spies were all kicked out. They were allowed to go home to Russia with no harsh interrogation. They didn't even get a TSA pat-down. No wonder President Obama seemed not to notice that Dmitri Medvedev was eating his French fries.

Then, there was the quickie ratification of the deeply flawed START treaty. Sec. Clinton and Vice President Biden helped push that one-sided measure through a lame-duck U.S. Senate in December, 2010.

In every way imaginable, this administration has telegraphed -- no, tweeted -- its weakness to the Russians. Whatever else we know about Russians, we know they respect the vozhd. That's the Russian word for "boss." Based on our experience dealing with Russians -- at the top and the bottom levels -- they respect strength -- constancy and firmness. Let's see some of it.
# # #


Former Ambassador Ken Blackwell negotiated on human rights in Moscow with the Russians. He worked with Ronald Reagan's top arms negotiator, Max Kampelman. Bob Morrison served as a Russian interpreter aboard a Coast Guard cutter. He dealt with the Soviets about fish.

 
 
 
FOLLOW POLITICS
Secretary Hillary Clinton was at the Naval Academy recently. She went there to deliver a prestigious Forrestal Lecture. And she was well received by the 4,000 Midshipmen and hundreds of students atten...
Secretary Hillary Clinton was at the Naval Academy recently. She went there to deliver a prestigious Forrestal Lecture. And she was well received by the 4,000 Midshipmen and hundreds of students atten...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 6
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bi-partizan
citizen with integrity
10:12 AM on 04/24/2012
With all due respect to the former ambassador, our Madame Secretary is doing a great job balancing this totally unbalanced world of ours. In the view of this type of unbalanced and financially distressed world and totally disfunctional US congress.. (congress did not approve US ambassador appointees to Turkmenistan for 5 years, similar game is played for Turkey, Azerbaijan, Russia,and on and on) does not provide powerful hand to play.

Just as a reminder: Euro crisis, global financial crisis, real bad image of USA created by many different factors and so called friendly countries including the ones their existense depends on USA, global natural resource war, quite but real power war within Russia, Russia's desire to re-build the Soviet Empire which are contrary to US - Afghan and other FSU countries benefits( except Belarus) preparation to changes in central asia and Caspian regions.

Really....you have a problem with this secretary of state ....Make sure that you have all the solutions in your hand that can fix these SIMPLE problems without waking -up the bear or the Dragon or began loosing more friends around the world. .....Our Secretary of State Mrs. Clinton is doing a GREAT job within the parameters of the global politics and restraints and the games played by US congress.
02:27 AM on 04/24/2012
Here is a very interesting fact.

The red Reset button actually did have a cyrillic translation of the word above the button it self. And it didnt actually have the "reset" misspelled, but instead another word was used with a similar spelling. Ironically the word translated to "overload" (Russian: "Перегруз-ка") which can also be interpreted as "overcharge". I hope you get the irony.
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
realitytrumpsbull
Two 'alves of coconut!
10:58 PM on 04/23/2012
I disagree, I think if the Cold War really IS over, the RISK board going back in the box and back on the game shelf, then we need to start acting like it, and ixnay the Muscle Beach stuff, and focus on REAL 'strength', which is doing things like partnerships and import/export. Right now, we hitch-hike with the Russians to get to the ISS. Russia built the other half of Apollo-Soyuz. So, show of strength, force etc.? Or, respect borne out of good, well-efforted international relations. Maybe start by learning a few words of a language NOT English? That might actually impress a LOT of countries, not just Russia. Now, repeat after me: Adin, dva, tree, chtiri, pyacht, sheyst, syem, vocyet, dyevet, dyeset. Adinitzit, dvenatzit, treenatzit, chtirnatzit...maybe even a Russian edition of HuffPost so we don't just exclusively get bombarded with Ameri-ganda? Indeed, honesty IS a sign of true strength...? The gentleness, is the strength...
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:17 AM on 04/23/2012
"Russians ... respect strength -- constancy and firmness."

Russians also respect non-belligerence, intelligence, diplomatic ability and capacity for long-term strategic thinking, often an impossibility for American presidents most of the time preoccupied with the next election and collecting um... sponsors to get re-elected.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
gutenmorgen
a.k.a. crowsnest
11:06 AM on 04/23/2012
To understand the shallowness of this analysis you must find the answer to the question "how many military bases and where does Russia have outside her national borders?"
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
tacevad
American SS Card Carrying Socialist
10:01 AM on 04/23/2012
I'll take the Diplomatic solutions of The Obama Administration over the old Bully on the Block ideals purported by Mr Blackwell everyday of the week.