iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Kristen Mark

GET UPDATES FROM Kristen Mark
 

Is It Better To Have Loved And Lost Than To Never Have Loved At All?

Posted: 07/17/2012 4:00 pm

Regret -- the negative emotion associated with realizing a different past decision may have brought a better outcome than what actually transpired -- accompanies a lot of failed marriages. And with a divorce rate of around 50 percent (although, this stat is a little misleading once you break it down into subgroups), there may be a lot of romantic regret going on in America.

According to a study published in 2011, the biggest regret on America's mind is actually a romantic one. University of Illinois' Mike Morrison and Northwestern University's Neal Roese led a nationally representative phone survey of 370 adults who were asked to detail their biggest regret. Almost 20 percent of those surveyed cited romantic regret as their primary regret, the largest of all categories.

Women cited a romantic regret more than twice as often as men (44 percent versus 19 percent, respectively), and men cited more work-oriented regret than women (34 percent versus 27 percent, respectively). The most interesting finding in this study to me, was that those who regretted inactions (they didn't do something but they wish they would have) held on to the regret longer than those who felt the regret was based on action (they did something but wish they wouldn't have).

When women were asked to submit their biggest romantic regrets to HuffPost Women via Twitter, themes of holding on to a relationship for too long, choosing the wrong type of partner, and not taking certain advice were big ones. Similarly, the descriptions of the romantic regrets in Morrison and Roese's study focused around lost chances at potential romance and relationships that didn't live up to their potential.

As noted above, taking action is better than sitting back and not doing anything about it. Although romantic regret is difficult, it lingers more when we regret not doing something than it does when we regret doing something.

In the Morrison and Roese study, the participants who were the most likely to have romantic regrets were the ones who were not currently in a relationship. The famous quote from Alfred Lord Tennyson, "'tis better to have loved and lost than never to have loved at all" is particularly relevant.

Although romantic regret can be difficult to handle, it also serves an important purpose: it shapes the way you handle future relationships. Learning from the regret and using it for a positive course of action (e.g., learning what qualities you should avoid or approach in a romantic partner, avoiding situations that may have led to infidelity in the past, etc.) can help to make the mistakes you've made in the past worth it. It's how we learn our life lessons.

Tell the truth. Express your feelings. If you like someone, tell them. If you don't, leave or at least be upfront with them about. Life should be that simple. This research on romantic regret sheds light on the importance of taking chances, especially when it comes to love.

Is it better to have loved and lost than to never have loved at all? My answer is an absolute yes.

 
 
 

Follow Kristen Mark on Twitter: www.twitter.com/Kristen_Mark

FOLLOW DIVORCE
 
 
  • Comments
  • 17
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
10:06 PM on 08/11/2012
My biggest regret was getting married. I did manage to have a beautiful divorce in spite of living with a violent wife.
Domestic violence committed by wives is severely under-reported.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:34 PM on 08/10/2012
"Tell the truth. Express your feelings. If you like someone, tell them. If you don't, leave or at least be upfront with them about. Life should be that simple. This research on romantic regret sheds light on the importance of taking chances, especially when it comes to love."
Would be nice if everyone operated that way. But doing any of the above is no protection from regret in my experience.
07:00 PM on 08/08/2012
Well I've seen already two women on this very thread say they divorced due to a spouse who was cheating or addicted to something...out of how many comments? So let me add yet another tic mark to the 'small minority' tally of women forced to file for divorce because the cheating spouse, wasn't adult enough to say they were unhappy and having an affair. Like poster 'Mommy' I regret that I didn't get out when I should have 3 years into it. I stayed 21 years trying to make that fiasco work. I lost everything I'd worked for over 21 years. I'm not financially better off, teetering somewhere between low middle class to upper poverty. But I'm I glad I got out, I'm happy not to have to deal with the alcoholism, the lies, and the mental anguish. Now the person my ex had the final affair with can and already does deal with the philandering and lies. Something in me just doesn't believe women leave because they are just feeling in the mood to do so. Perhaps because I took my vows so seriously, it's hard for me to imagine others don't, I guess that makes me naïve.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dancerctry
I love Gardening and Decorating
11:24 AM on 08/05/2012
50% might be the true divorce rate but that includes drunken elopements that wouldn't have occured if you weren't allowed to get married drunk and had to be tested first (of course that would ruin Vegas). It also includes serial marriers who have been married and divorced 3 or more times. The serial marriers haven't figured out how marriage works yet. When we think of divorce we think of a first divorce usually with a child involved between two people who were together a long time before the wedding. I don't know what the divorce rate would be if we only counted marriages were the couple has been together a long time before the wedding, soberly planned to get married (even if they elope) and are on either their first or second marriage but I assume it would be closer to 30%. HP: Article idea - what's the divorce rate if you remove serial marriers and drunken elopements? Don't forget to include the success rate for the different types of marriages too.
08:11 PM on 07/22/2012
"Tell the truth. Express your feelings. If you like someone, tell them. If you don't, leave or at least be upfront with them about. Life should be that simple. "

Agreed!! Yes it should.

Shame that truth, trust and failure to communicate in a clear understandable manner seem for most to be the hardest paths to follow.
05:50 AM on 07/25/2012
Certainly. It is really best to just tell the truth than to regret the opportunity you had. It is not easy but at least you tried.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Zalkreb
11:14 AM on 07/19/2012
To me the most striking thing about women and romance isn't what they regret, but that they don't seem to know what commitment is. For instance, they seem to interpret "until death do you part" to mean "until I think I'd be happier without him."

Women initiate the overwhelming majority of divorces, and the usual reasons are not violence, abuse, infidelity, drunkenness or serious breach of the marital vows. The most commonly cited reason for initiating divorce is, essentially, that the other partner failed to make her feel happy enough.

Recently I spent the day at a water park where I observed many thousands of people attired for swimming. I saw many tattoos of many types on both women and men, including many men with women's names tattooed on them. I saw no men's names tattooed on women. They talk a good game of commitment, but when it comes down to it, they get a rose on a hip, not their husband's name on their forearm.

This is fine, of course. It’s not up to me to tell women what to do, or what they should mean when they say they are committing. But guys need to have an accurate view of the situation, and know that commitment, to a woman, tends to mean something different than what it does to a man.
photo
bert1016
Can I get a microbio??
07:04 PM on 07/28/2012
I loved my husband more than anything. We were together 22 years (19 married) and I thought we had a good strong marriage. That was until I learned he was carrying on an affair with his married boss. Despite my better judgement I would have done a lot to salvage my marriage but he told me he loved her and while he wouldn't divorce me he made it very clear the marriage was over.

I filed for divorce and left. My vows were important to me but I could not remain married to a man who didn't want a marriage only a meal ticket and maid. Please don't assume all women file for divorce on a whim. It was the hardest, most painful thing I have ever done.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Zalkreb
03:08 PM on 07/29/2012
I'm sorry about your experience, bert1016. Clearly, all women don't divorce on a whim. However, infidelity is cited as a cause in a small minority. The usual reasons are feeling unloved, feeling unappreciated, lacking communication and lacking a feeling of closeness. Serious breaches of the marital compact such as abuse and drunkenness are also cited in a minority.

Research supports the view that women drive divorce in the pursuit of their personal happiness and to the profound and lasting detriment of children, partners, grandparents, in-laws and society at large. Children of divorce have more than twice the risk of suicide, depression, drug abuse, teen pregnancy -- and divorce -- than children from intact families. Divorced men kill themselves twice as often as married men. Divorce has no effect on women’s suicide rates.

I do not hate women. I hate a gender-biased system that enables and incentivizes one sex to perform actions that hurt others while benefiting themselves.

We need to stop automatically awarding mothers primary custody of children. Mothers not in jail, drug rehab, a mental hospital or otherwise AWOL are virtually guaranteed to be primary custodians, meaning in most cases they have custody 80 percent or more of the time, continue to receive a third or so their former partners’ income (tax-free and with no strings attached; he pays it or faces jail) and have a very good chance of remaining in the family home.

Women like the status quo; nobody else does.
02:37 PM on 07/30/2012
That was horrible. Many people thought that when a woman file a divorce, she's only after the money or the wealth it can give her. But most women, experience such things that is really unforgivable just like what had happened to you.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dancerctry
I love Gardening and Decorating
11:33 AM on 08/05/2012
For some that may be the case but not me. My husband and I are 32 and have been married for 8 years, together for 14 engaged all through college married at 24. We talk all the time about what commitment means to us as well as show each other with our actions. I'm not a tatoo person (although I no longer judge those with tatoos). The people I am close with who have tatoos with names only have their children's names, the men are the only ones with the names. It's an interesting observation you make (although some of those men might have that same "kids only" rule). Maybe it's easier for us since I'm a SAHM and have spent my life dedicated to me family (since I was 4 and my younger brother was born and I got to hold him, he just turned 28). My parents are married for 42 years and my in-laws for 46 (all married young). I think we had a good example of what commitment is so we just do it out of reflex. If you think living together is the same as marriage, then you don't know what commitment is.

I think the women's commitment thing is a mixed message of femanism. "Don't rely on a man for anything" means keep him at arms length and commitment requires more then that. That's part of what causes divorces (and cheating).
photo
jf12
When I saw her I marveled greatly.
07:53 AM on 07/19/2012
Is it better to live and die than never to have lived at all? I suppose so. But that doesn't condone murder.
photo
capt hastings
exercise the little grey cells
11:56 PM on 07/18/2012
My biggest regret is not being able to see into the future.
photo
jf12
When I saw her I marveled greatly.
10:06 PM on 07/17/2012
Women who initiated divorce in low conflict relationships tend to have the biggest regret, and yet cannot admit it even in anonymous surveys.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mommytomany
06:03 PM on 07/17/2012
My one regret is I didn't get out of the bad marriage earlier. I wasted so many years trying to make things work, when in reality it was past that stage.