As my wife and I were driving home one night on the highway from Merida, Mexico, the capital city of the Yucatan where we work, to our home in Cholul, the small pueblo right outside of the city, we somehow stumbled onto the topic of how many continents there are in the world. I mentioned seven and she indignantly replied:
"Seven! What do you mean seven: there are only five!"
"Five!" I responded. "What are you talking about? What are the five?"
"América. Asia. Europe. África. Oceanía," she said naming the five continents she learned in her elementary school in Merida.
After asking what Oceanía is in English (Australia), I listed the seven continents as I learned them in elementary school in the United States. After futilely arguing for a bit about who was right and who was wrong (luckily we were close to home so the argument didn't have much of a chance to escalate), we promptly looked up the "answer" on Wikipedia.
Wikipedia in English immediately identifies the seven continents. I'm right! But -- wait a minute -- Wikipedia in Spanish presents us with a chart of different possibilities ranging from four to seven with the explanation roughly translated, "In reality there isn't one fixed way to determine the number of continents. It depends on each cultural area to decide if two large masses of earth joined together form one or two continents, and if specifically Asia and Europe or North and South America are one or two continents."
So in fact, neither of us is either right or wrong. The "correct" answer depends on where in the world you were educated and taught to memorize the "right" answer of four, five, six, or seven. Asking our guests how many continents there are has become a fun dinner party game when we have visitors from different parts of the world. If they aren't aware of the varied definitions of what constitutes a continent, a hearty argument always ensues.
In school we are taught to memorize many facts -- seven continents, fifty states in the United States, 1 + 1 = 2 -- but rarely are we encouraged to question these supposed facts. What would happen if we posed each of these as questions? First, we would teach students that the skill of questioning is of equal or perhaps even more importance than providing the correct answers. Students would also learn that having a flexible stance on a particular issue, reconsidering our own assumptions, being able to see something from another person's perspective, and moving beyond who is right and who is wrong, are vital dispositions to have not only for dinner conversations, but for everything from working on a project together, to effectively communicating with your partner, to succeeding in international diplomacy.
Learning that 1 + 1 = 2 is important, and certainly an engineer designing a bridge would argue there are times when finding the right answer is critical. But it's quite fun to think of instances where we might question this equation, even if this moves us from the field of mathematics into linguistics (1 pair of shoes + 1 pair of shoes = 4 shoes or 1 ball of clay + 1 ball of clay = 1 large ball of clay). George Cantor, the inventor of set theory in mathematics during the nineteenth century felt that "in mathematics the art of asking questions is more valuable than solving problems." Teaching students to investigate deeply, to ask many questions, to consider multiple points of view, and to imagine numerous possible answers is perhaps much more important than teaching students to memorize and recite the fifty states. "Why is Puerto Rico not a state? Should it be? Who decides what is a state? What were the territories before they were states?"
Yet we have about 45 million students taking standardized tests across the United States. With this many tests, how can states possibly evaluate complex and creative answers to interesting questions? Open-ended questions must be graded by an actual person which costs significantly more than a multiple-choice answer checked by a computer. As a result of the NCLB act, we as a nation have moved increasingly towards multiple choice exams and, as we hold teachers and schools accountable for the results, classrooms have become places where the right answer rules. This is most apparent in New York City where the Department of Education has publicly released ratings of its 12,700 teachers. Teachers are listed by name and rated solely according to how well their students performed on standardized tests.
Such emphasis on the right answer is a far cry from the legacy of education reformer Ted Sizer who stressed the importance of an inquiry-based education: "Questions are usually more interesting than assertions or answers, and the most appealing questions are those which are genuine -- dealing with matters of manifest importance to the world--and have no easy or total resolution." Perhaps along with asking students to list the four-seven continents, we might also ask, "How and why are continents defined differently in various areas of the world? Based on the multiple definitions of the word continent how many do you think there are?" Such questions will help our students to think deeply and flexibly, which will also help them to negotiate different cultures and ways of knowing. Asking questions places us in the stance of the listener rather than the speaker. And no matter our profession -- teacher, doctor, mechanic, lawyer, politician -- isn't asking the right question usually more productive than immediately offering an answer?
Follow Kurt Wootton on Twitter: www.twitter.com/kurtwootton
DC schools chief asks for national standards to probe claims of cheating on ...
Ga. teachers would lose pay for test cheating
Validity Of Field Sobriety Tests Questioned
Bryon Barrington column: Get the facts on standardized tests
My Turn: Truckee Elementary draws academic strength through diversity
My Very Educated Mother Just Served Us Nine Pizza-Pies.
Mercury, Venus, Earth, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, Neptune and Pluto.
Then scientists redefined the term planet, and we were left with eight. Pluto is still Pluto, whether we call it a planet or a planetoid or that dog in the Disney cartoons. Time that we stop worrying about how many states or continents or planets, and start worrying about the one world we all live in.
I have other questions: how big could an island grow before we called it a continent? How narrow must an isthmus be to qualify as the border between two continents?
And why would we ever think Europe and Asia are two separate things?
For that matter, how many oceans are there in the world? (One, in my opinion.)
Some folks think in black and white in a multi-hued world.
To look at the standardized testing epidemic through the eyes of an inner-city high school student please visit http://solutions-for-schools.com/2012/02/lynda-and-the-standardized-test-zombie-apocalypse/
http://www.nationalgeographic.com/faq/geography.html
Also here's a great video showing the complexity of the issue:
http://blog.cgpgrey.com/what-are-continents/