American dead worth the cost of war? By what math?

Posted March 19, 2008 | 10:36 AM (EST)



stumble digg reddit del.ico.us news trust mixx.com

It used to be - until this recent age - that a leader of a nation would ride out to war with his men as both a symbol of that which his military was fighting for and also as a show of his own commitment to the cause for which he was sending others to die. Even Queen Elizabeth I rode out with her small army as the Spanish Armada approached, instead of capitulating to her advisers that she should retreat to safety.

In the recent age the closest we have come to the bravery of a leader willing to die along side his men has been through the military service of our leaders before they put on the mantle of power. Although not as honorable as going to war alongside your men and women, it was still a lesson in the selflessness of those who serve their country and the true ugly of war. A lesson for a man much needed for when  - as leader - he has the power to send many to their deaths on his say-so. 

Now we are led by cowards who have never served in war and who only visit the front lines by cover of night, safely insulated from threats by the  highest security and guarded by all sorts of humans and machinery so that no scratch can befall them. The leaders we have now do not now stand with their men and women at the horror of it all. Worse still, the men who have now become our leaders have never risked themselves or defended to the death any notion of democracy that they now so eagerly order others to die for.

It is bad enough that these charlatans are willing to declare war as easily as they declare what the entree will be for their three course dinner. It is bad enough that these dilettantes will hold up a moral cause that must be won as easily as they would use that very cause for a punchline during a political fund-raiser. It is bad enough that these sciolists will lecture those who are their superiors in such things as war while never ever having themselves seen the barrel of a gun. All of this and much more is bad enough, disgraceful enough, unpardonable enough, contemptible enough. But there is a whole new category of despicable that has yet to be defined when a pretender to honor, a coward boy-king will stand in his air-conditioned palace far away from the front-lines and opine that the lives lost for his war of choice were worth it.

Ladies and gentleman, I give you the disgrace known as the leader of the free world:

"In speech excerpts released Tuesday by the White House, the president will acknowledge Wednesday, the U.S. has paid a "high cost in lives and treasure" and that there is a debate over whether the war was worth fighting."

He goes on to explain that yes, this cost in lives and treasure was indeed worth it and that really, the cost was not all that high, merely exaggerated:

"But Mr. Bush will say the war has been a success, especially since the deployment of an additional 30,000 U.S. troops last year to quell sectarian violence. He says the surge has led to "a major strategic victory" where Arabs are turning against the "grim ideology" of Osama bin Laden.

The president says critics have exaggerated the war's costs because they can no longer argue the U.S. is losing the conflict."

Aside from the blatant lie in which Osama bin Laden is cast with any role in Iraq, what this morally vacant nightmare of a man is really saying is that the death of your loved ones - America - was worth it. The death of your loved ones - America - was a cost he was willing to pay for a lie he was willing to tell for a profit he was willing to make on behalf of his friends. Your sacrifice - America - was well worth it for him and his, even if not for  you and yours.

Here is a man who stands for nothing, believes in nothing, sacrifices nothing, and yet has the audacity to tell you that you must stand for everything, believe everything, and sacrifice everything for him - not for democracy, which he himself does not believe in - but for him. Is this tolerable to any decent person?

My dear friend often cites Robert Penn Warren's classic All the King's Men to me in our constant debate over humanity's ultimate goodness (or lack there of). In particular, he cites this well-known line:

"Man is conceived in sin and born in corruption and he passeth from the stink of the didie to the stench of the shroud."

I am not cynic enough to believe this of humanity in general, but in the case of George W. Bush, it is a most apropos description. In Bush's case,  however, it is even more horrid when one considers that his passing from the "stink of the didie to the stench of the shroud" takes with him countless others, men women and children, whose value he so eagerly determined to be worth the cost.


 
 

Comments
13
Pending Comments
0

Want to reply to a comment? Hint: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to

View Comments:
- DLSteinhardt See Profile I'm a Fan of DLSteinhardt permalink

Thanks for the reminder to read Robert Penn Warren. He would have had a lot to say about today's news.

Dick Cavett, who's now blogging for the NY Times, did the best interviews with Warren I've seen. He'd been his student at Yale. I'll post in his comments section and request some reflections on his old teacher.

Comments seem a bit constipated or buggy tonight. My page says there are 12 comments and 4 pending (at 11:40 pm EDT March 19), but only one is visible, from Oldchef.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:41 PM on 03/19/2008
- ScooterLiddy See Profile I'm a Fan of ScooterLiddy permalink

GWB carries a stench that will last for the rest of his life. And he will one day abandon his mortal coil just as the rest of us, but his legacy will be one of death and destruction--this "President of Good and Evil" (see Peter Singer: The President of Good and Evil)

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:47 PM on 03/19/2008
- deminmo See Profile I'm a Fan of deminmo permalink

My mother is outspoken about her feelings about the President,
and because she was taught things by a Cherokee grandmother,
she holds fast to the idea that Bush has souless black eyes.
Which attests to the fact he cannot be trusted or believed. She
refers to him as "snake eyes". And since she is 73, most people
just roll their eyes. But she has been called a communist and
it was suggested on a local call in radio show, that something
should be done to change her mind. Great country we live in.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 09:40 PM on 03/19/2008
- winoohno See Profile I'm a Fan of winoohno permalink

Bush, Cheney, Rice, Rumsfeld, Tenet, Wolfowitz, Pearle -- all never served in the military. Don't even think about bringing up Bush's national guard service.

Those who beat the drum for war the loudest are the most coward of them all. We now know that all the reasons given for war were proven to be untrue. Every single foundation on which this criminal Administration built the rationale for war was fabricated and parsed in such a way there is now -- 5 years later -- no doubt they intentionally misled our country and should be IMPEACHED!

If Bush really respected the military, it wouldn't treat veterans like second-class citizens by not caring for their medical, educational, social and political needs. Instead, our Adminstration and those right-wing chicken hawks (Rush & Hannity) never had to serve and don't understand what its like to low crawl through sand and mud with bullets flying over your head.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 07:43 PM on 03/19/2008
- DLSteinhardt See Profile I'm a Fan of DLSteinhardt permalink

The stink of the didie is especially apropos in this case, as this president never could have been taken seriously as a low-level assistant, let alone the chief, without the accident of his privileged birth.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:21 PM on 03/19/2008
- TScheisskopf See Profile I'm a Fan of TScheisskopf permalink

Jeebus, Lala. Great ending. You nail the sociopath-in-chief completely.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:14 PM on 03/19/2008
- JohnFromCensornati See Profile I'm a Fan of JohnFromCensornati permalink

King George W is as spineless as it gets (even worse than Nancy & Harry).
He won't even face the people of this country much less ride out into battle.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:07 PM on 03/19/2008
- Ohjin See Profile I'm a Fan of Ohjin permalink

Thank you Larisa,

The world knows it, & every American knows it.

Shameful that we need to be reminded of all the atrocities being committed in the name of our ounce proud nation.

Unfortunately the media and politicians tell us there is no thing we can do to remedy it, and we are presently too fat and happy to lift a finger to change it.

The end result of Bush's treason is about to hit every American right in the fat and happy spot.

With 300 million Americans hungry and really pissed off things will change.

Hold on tight.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 12:00 PM on 03/19/2008
- RavagesOfTime See Profile I'm a Fan of RavagesOfTime permalink

And they publicly, frequently, and proudly denounce the will of the people that they are telling to sacrifice if they dare to consider the numbers of dead Americans in the name of their war.

Absolutely fantastic writing, Larisa. Thank you very much.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:44 AM on 03/19/2008
- Durango See Profile I'm a Fan of Durango permalink

Agreed. 100%

I am becoming a religious person because I have come to realize that there is no punishment sufficient for the lying criminal fools of Bush, Cheney, Rumsfeld, Rice etc etc.

I want to believe in an afterlife with a just God. Because burning in Hell for eternity is what these people deserve.

But I have to disagree with the premise. The issue is not whether it was worth the American lives, as important as that might be. But was it worth the Iraqi lives?

Bush went in and tore their society to pieces. In a war based on ignorance and pursued with incompetence.

Jefferson said "I tremble for my country when I reflect that God is just; that his justice cannot sleep forever. " about slavery.

Many people believed, like John Brown ,that the Civil War was divine retribution for the evils of slavery. That the sin had to be washed away in blood.

I fear for my country as well.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:31 AM on 03/19/2008
- hopeless277 See Profile I'm a Fan of hopeless277 permalink

Brilliant. I truly makes me ashamed to be a citizen of this nation knowing that 50% of 'us' could vote for McBush to continue the disasterous, planet killing, policies of our Coward-In-Chief.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:09 AM on 03/19/2008
- Nommo See Profile I'm a Fan of Nommo permalink

Or more ashamed that we followed said "leader". As if common sense were a commodity.

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 11:05 AM on 03/19/2008
- Oldchef See Profile I'm a Fan of Oldchef permalink

We should all be truly ashamed that this person is called our "leader".

    Favorite    Flag as abusive Posted 10:53 AM on 03/19/2008
Comments are closed for this entry

You must be logged in to reply to this comment. Log in

 
 

Bloggers Index›
Read All Posts by
Larisa Alexandrovna›
 

 Site  Web ask.com