If you want to save your marriage, for the love of God, don't go to marriage counseling.
Eighteen years ago my marriage was in tatters. My husband and I went to counseling for years thinking there was something wrong with us, but we finally realized that the counseling was the problem. That set me on a path to discovering the principles of intimacy, which I describe in The Surrendered Wife, a New York Times best-selling book printed in 26 countries and 15 languages.
Hundreds of thousands of women have used these principles to transform their shredded marriages into intimate, passionate relationships, but too many are still stuck in ineffective marriage counseling. Here are some of the reasons that marriage counseling is a big, fat lie.
1. It starts with calling your spouse a loser
When a wife says to her husband, "We should go to counseling," what she really means is, "You're a loser."
Since a key ingredient for intimacy is emotional safety, this approach puts the connection she craves further out of reach. The last time your husband criticized you, did it make you want to hug him?
A woman who doesn't realize she just criticized her husband by suggesting marriage counseling might think his snarky response is coming out of nowhere -- which proves he needs marriage counseling.
No relationship ever got happier from one person criticizing the other. What takes more courage -- but always results in much greater connection -- is being vulnerable by admitting you feel hurt, rejected or lonely.
2. Some marriage counselors are failures
Some marriage counselors aren't married. Others are divorced twice or unhappily married. Is this who you want to pay for advice? Would you take fitness tips from a 350-pound personal trainer who just had bypass surgery?
If your marriage counselor doesn't have the kind of relationship you want, she simply can't tell you how to get it. When I think about the lousy advice that we got during our marriage counseling, I'm amazed that we survived it.
Instead of someone with an impressive diploma, consider seeking the advice of a wife with a happy, healthy, intimate relationship.
3. Any fool can complain and most do during marriage counseling
The fastest way to destroy your relationship is to focus on what's wrong with your partner. Dwelling on his faults is the opposite of what you did when you fell in love. If you admired his ambition and now you think he works too much, guess what changed? Only the way you're looking at him.
Couples typically argue after a marriage counseling session because focusing on each other's faults makes you feel more resentful and hopeless.
If you want to restore your relationship, here's a great remedy: Make a habit of giving your partner three expressions of gratitude daily. Focusing on the things you appreciate about your mate is a powerful way to remind yourself why you chose him in the first place.
4. It's a hideout for hypocrites
Lots of us go to marriage counseling secretly believing we're just there to be supportive while the counselor fixes the other person's shortcomings. Marriage counselors will tell you that the only thing you have to do to change your spouse is get him to come in for a hundred sessions. But marriage counseling will never work because it focuses on someone you can't change: Your spouse.
Trying to control someone else not only wears you out, it gives you the illusion that you're working really hard on your relationship while the other person isn't doing anything. It also steals energy away from improving the only person you can: Yourself.
It's only when you accept and celebrate your spouse as the quirky individual he is that you can both relax into being yourselves -- just like you did when you were dating.
5. Men are not big, hairy women
Many women believe that if their man would just share his feelings, they would finally have the connection they crave. But asking a man how he feels in counseling is like asking a woman in a bathing suit who's eating a piece of cake how much she weighs.
Trying and failing to get a man to talk about his feelings in marriage counseling may confirm a wife's worst fears that her husband is defective. But the real failure here is her lack of respect for the man he is -- the one she picked to marry.
Chances are good that you married an imperfect man who's perfect for you. Instead of trying to pry his feelings out of him, consider bringing respect back into the relationship by honoring your husband's masculinity and his choices for himself. If you want more passion in your marriage, there's no stronger aphrodisiac than respect.
6. It's the most expensive way to try to control your spouse
Marriage counseling may seem like an important purchase, but it's actually a tragic waste because it diverts funds from something that really would help your marriage: Self-care.
Self-care means not only getting enough rest and nourishment, it means that you make it a priority to do three pleasurable things every single day. Relationships naturally take a little energy and if you're depleted, you give your relationship no chance to thrive. Showing up delighted instead of depleted is indispensable for a gratifying and intimate partnership.
You may have thought it was your husband's job to make you happy, but it's actually yours. Your husband would like to make you happy, but if he can't he may stop trying. Once you make yourself feel good, he sees that you are pleasable, which opens the door for him to delight you too. Men love making their women happy. "Happy wife, happy life" is not just an adage. Ask any guy.
To have the relationship you crave, fire your marriage counselor and discover the principles of intimacy. To find out which skills you need to work on to experience love and connection that lasts a lifetime, take the quiz at lauradoyle.org.
All principles are absolutely true...
Conciliating works for some, for others it doesn't. Shocker I know.
I will say this though, the article has some valid points. It's just written in too many absolute terms. The real world is just not that black and white. Every relationship is different.
You will have to figure it out for yourself and decide if you want the relationship and if it has a change. (actually, do the work and think)
Just my two cents.
http://www.spiegelschrank-bad.eu
"Furthermore, no specific modality of psychotherapy did better than any other for any disorder; psychologists, psychiatrists, and social workers did not differ in their effectiveness as treaters; and all did better than marriage counselors and long-term family doctoring. "
Martin E. P. Seligman, "The Effectiveness of Psychotherapy",1995
Some of us see a social order that still has these barbaric and antiquated practices as the centre of their culture as backward and un-evolved. "lovers" still get all emotional and spend tons and brig everyone together in a consumption orgy to "commit to each other in front of our loved ones" in spite of the fact that over 50% of these puffed up consumerist/religious ceremonies and romances are all lies and no one today is going to chain themselves to one person forever. Failure in a realistic world would mean you get yourself into one of these endless power struggles in the first place.
Our second counselor after 9 months has made it clear that he does not think we should stay together.. my husband took that as permission to abuse more.. and force me out with nothing. I am 5'3 110 pounds... my husband is 6'2" 200pounds.. My husband uses the police department as his own guard dogs. calling them on me if I want to leave or if I refused to go into a store because of his behavior. He learned more in marriage counseling on how to "report" it so I look like the bad guy then anytime before.
He made sure that I have been cut off from all family and friends.. I have no income of my own and of course he controls the bank account.
Now the big question everyone ask.. why did I stay as long as I have (20 years), because he has made sure I am trapped.. unless I want to live on the streets I have no option... and right now that is what I chose...Yes there are crisis shelters but they are full right now for women with small children.. so until then I sleep in my van. sit outside a coffee shop so I can have internet, and try to put my life together enough so I can handle the divorce.. because I know that as hard as the marriage was divorce is 100X worse
I hope you find a way to extricate yourself from the mess created by the unholy union of feminist dogma, government bureaucracy and the legal industry's overwhelming greed.
I have to agree.. I am on day 2 of living in my van right now.. because I could not take my abusive husband anymore.we have been to 2 different marriage counselor.. the first one moved, and was not very good.. listened but gave no advice.. so we found a second one. at first my husband listened to what he had to say and tried to work on it. I too listened.. but my husband is a physical and emotional bully.. who must control everything. when we were discussing what i bring to the marriage he would pounce on it use it as a weapon against me any chance he got. he used the term "personal responsibility" as a weapon... he truly thinks that his behavior does not matter. that he can push and push until he finally gets a reaction..weather it is me shouting back after being screamed at all day.. or finally leaving, he claims I abandoned the family. then he sits back and says.. you chose to act like that.. it was you... he has learned how to manipulative the system to justify anything he does.