Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Leah Busque

GET UPDATES FROM Leah Busque
 

Why Independent Employment Is Killing the Nine to Five Job

Posted: 03/28/2012 9:33 am

The term "nine-to-five" has long symbolized a kind of drudgery that sucks up our lives and eclipses our identities, but it wasn't until the Great Recession that the pejorative phrase was crowned with an entirely new distinction: old-fashioned. Even as the jobless rate continues its slow decline, the still-anemic U.S. employment market is prompting more and more people to do the math: There are 12.8 million workers looking for jobs -- that means multiple candidates for every open position. Summation? The paths of least friction and risk are increasingly leading away from traditional employment.

Back in the days of the Industrial Revolution, companies hoping to crank out as many widgets as possible booked shift workers around the clock. Collective bargaining led to the labor laws that eventually replaced 12- to 16-hour shifts with a new-fangled concept -- the eight-hour workday. That worked then, but with technology streamlining efficiency in every industry imaginable, you'd think we would have moved away from the nine-to-five standard long ago.

But it wasn't until the economy slid off the rails in 2008 that freshly downsized workers were forced to confront the reality that the nine-to-five jobs they knew didn't offer the kind of financial security promised to them. Layoffs sent scores of people to the unemployment line and hiring freezes kept them there until, one-by-one, entrepreneurial-minded folks began a sidestep around the status quo by becoming independently employed.

By 2010, the Kauffman Index of Entrepreneurial Activity revealed the highest startup rate in 15 years, attributing the growth to necessary entrepreneurship as a result of joblessness. Kauffman's 2011 data shows a slight dip from 2010, but one thing is clear: Americans are still busy building new, mostly solo, businesses. The unemployed, along with their underemployed counterparts, nearly one in five U.S. workers according to Gallup, swiftly began sliding into a society of contingent talent (freelancers, self-employed, entrepreneurs, and contract workers) that some experts believe will comprise a majority of the workforce by 2020.

This new class of micro-entrepreneurs is doing the same thing MBAs have been shouting about in boardrooms for years -- diversifying their revenue streams. Instead of one company cutting a check twice a month, multiple sources contribute to a pipeline of income. Proceeds from Etsy shops and Ebay stores co-mingle with ad revenue from blogs and consultant fees from freelance gig work. A new crop of peer-to-peer marketplaces transforms those idling things leftover from an age of excessive consumption -- cars, power tools, DVDs, and even spare bedrooms -- into income-generating resources. With these intuitive systems imminently accessible -- and without 40 hours of each week committed to someone else's bottom line -- a micro-entrepreneur can hedge her bets and fill in the price tag on her skills, talents, and time.

Micro-entrepreneurship also translates directly to freedom of schedule. It means not having to use a sick day to attend a parent-teacher conference or missing that Tuesday afternoon yoga class. Those in charge of their own working schedules are able to seamlessly integrate work with life instead of trying to strike a balance between two conflicting sets of responsibility.

Swapping out the nine-to-five for a more agile, independent working life brings with it one other huge benefit -- a channel for self-actualization. Abraham Maslow and his psychoanalyst cohorts agreed that the drive to realize our potential and activate our capabilities is paramount, and we can only deal with it after basic physical and mental needs are squared away. Traditional models of work only let us cross out the needs on the very bottom of the pyramid -- basic sustenance. On the flipside, independent employment within the network of the new sharing economy addresses our needs for a sense of community and belonging, autonomy and respect, creativity and problem solving. Within the old models, these were flights of fancy resigned to vacation days, wee hours, and golden years. The new model casts them as foundational elements and lets us work our way up the pyramid to unlock the good stuff.

Nine-to-five never stood a chance.

 

Follow Leah Busque on Twitter: www.twitter.com/labusque

The term "nine-to-five" has long symbolized a kind of drudgery that sucks up our lives and eclipses our identities, but it wasn't until the Great Recession that the pejorative phrase was crowned with ...
The term "nine-to-five" has long symbolized a kind of drudgery that sucks up our lives and eclipses our identities, but it wasn't until the Great Recession that the pejorative phrase was crowned with ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 127
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4  Next ›  Last »  (4 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Barbara Saunders
Writer, SF Bay Area transplant from NY
04:53 PM on 05/17/2012
I think the term entrepreneurship has been misused to lump together this kind of work scenario and the creation of an enterprise. They are very, very different animals. Also, leaving aside those people forced into this scenario by a layoff, there are many individuals who would prefer a job, but cannot make it work in a job structured for a person with an at-home spouse. If you are single, a single parent, or a member of a dual-income couple, everything from care of your pet to exercising becomes a logistical nightmare if your schedule is inflexible.
06:46 PM on 04/01/2012
In the work force for nearly forty years and never less than 50 hr a week
09:12 PM on 03/31/2012
You're forgeting a large factor in the problems with direct employment. Such an arrangement is heavily taxed, both on you and your employer. The net effect is that you receive less and less of the benefit that your employer pays as an expense. A larger and larger percentage goes to someone else, via the government. As this 'payment to others' grows, both you and the employer see little reason to continue such an arrangement. Hence, you want to become a consultant to use a Schedule C to manage your tax burden and avoid taxes. And your employer also benefits tremendously by using you as an independent contractor without the burden of payroll taxes.
12:02 PM on 03/30/2012
What "9 to 5" jobs? I never had such hours in my 6 decades or so. 9 to 5 occured only in generally lower paying jobs. 40 hours/wk became sort of standard in the post-WW2 years and has continued. But it is considered to have started under Henry Ford in automobile manufacturing I believe.
When studying personal finance, it is often stated something like: "If you can't make enough to meet expenses, cut your expenses or get a part time job besides. The 40 hour week is a pagan construct while the biblical mandate is "six days you shall work and rest on the seventh day."
01:57 PM on 03/29/2012
This is all well and good, that is, unless you need health care. Without something akin to a single payer system being self employed is costly for a family.
01:12 PM on 03/29/2012
The dissolution of job security and the reduction of millions of people to rudderless, transient workers have been a boon to temp-runners. The latter rightly view the current conditions as a business utopia populated by shiny happy people. It is statistically possible that a few of the free floating cogs will make it to the shore, but the majority will be at the mercy of the turbulent flows and the constant danger of drowning.
11:36 AM on 03/29/2012
I've lived this since 1998 after 16 years in Corporate America and agree completely with the benefits of Independent employment. I must caution anyone who is considering becoming a freelancer or contractor that they will now have to become a salesperson on top of what they do. The business will not just fall into their hands, they will need to go out and make it happen and juggle this with the delivery of their service. If they are unable or unwilling to learn to sell, they may want to consider the tradeoffs of the 9-5 (which was never 9-5 in my world), maybe we call it Dependent employment instead. And don't forget what health insurance costs when you pay 100% yourself.

Sue Madden Moore
Executive Consulting Services
10:44 AM on 03/29/2012
Yeah, "entrepreneurship" is so great - and hobos and homeless peopleenjoy so much freedom too, don't they?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jabailo
(Participant) Texeme.Construct()
10:24 AM on 03/29/2012
A bunch of laid off people are living off their 401ks, starting boutique businesses to keep their resume alive and waiting for the rebound.
llwlknsn
Adequate words fail me.
09:48 AM on 03/29/2012
Let's get something straight here deary. The nine to five job is being actively murdered in favor of near slave labor. People are not going to free lance unless they have no other choice. Independent Employment is being pursued because there are no other options. Ask anyone in an independent job if they would rather have the stability of a nine to five and you will discover that like corporations we like the idea of knowing how much we are going to make and where it is coming from. This is not a 'logical' transition. It is a forced one.

Well you've done your job, now go get your blood money.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
AshleyMott
...Lemming lie catcher.
08:48 AM on 03/30/2012
Amen! I'm actually self-employed by choice as I started an e-commerce business right after high school that led to my then writing about e-commerce and then about other things, but I am getting an Bachelor's Degree in Business Administration with a focus on Accounting and Financial Services as we speak and am sincerly hoping CPAs aren't dead in the water by 2015 when I will have my masters in accounting and can actually test. Why? Stability.

With no certainity in the healthcare market and my having a pre-existing condition that will likely begin to dominate my life within the next 10-25 years (I'm 26 and have OI, commonly known as brittle bone disorder), I need to make all the green I can and hopefully at a payroll job with benefits that I can supplement with really aggressive savings and a part-time continuation of my freelance work for even greater savings.

The past two years have shown me exactly how whacked out so many of the people in our government are and while I don't trust the fact that even a healthy savings account and the funds for high dollar insurance will protect any of us from them, I think the odds are better.
02:32 PM on 04/04/2012
I strongly disagree. I went freelance 10 months ago and left a stable well paying job to do so. I make more now than I ever could have hoped to in my industry and have the flexibility to do my job when I want to AND choose the projects I want to work on.

Health insurance is a burden, there's no getting around that but, frankly, it is a systemic problem that if we didn't have such a ridiculous amount of government corruption would be fixed by now.
dpaustex
Sometimes people actually get it right.
08:42 AM on 03/29/2012
I always wonder where people get this information, for the articles. To wit: I have owned my own companies for over 20 years. My work day is more like 7 to 6 M-F, and whatever it takes on weekends. A 60 hour workweek is common. Where do I get one of those 9 to 5 jobs?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rich08533
I guess the word job sounds nasty to a lot of peop
10:33 AM on 04/01/2012
my neighbor recently said "it should be against the law for someome to work more than 32 hours a week. That will give you some idea of the mentality of many Americans.
The American spirit and work ethic is gone. In its place................tax the rich to pay for the programs.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
becky bradshaw
"In a time of universal deceit, telling the truth
08:09 AM on 03/29/2012
The great thing about hiring a small contractor is they completely lack leverage.. They cannot afford a lawyer, so they can be paid, or not paid, it is of little concern. They are usually borderline desperate, so they can be exploited in any number of ways. If one gets to uppity, there are a million more where they came from, and more are added to the pool every month. Highly Recommended!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
j main
Reality is just a collective hunch, anyways.
02:27 AM on 03/29/2012
"Micro-entrepreneurship also translates directly to freedom of schedule."

I have to have to point out the obvious. If you have that much time available to you during the day, chances are you aren't making any money and living hand to mouth. I never met a contract worker who had the opportunity to enjoy self actualization as defined by Mazlow.
06:55 AM on 03/29/2012
I think the idea is you are working at different times, nights, weekends, but not M-F 9-5. You
're doing the same amount of work or more, but not within the specified time that most offices operate.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
j main
Reality is just a collective hunch, anyways.
05:08 PM on 03/29/2012
An idealistic thought. I would bet that most self employed people put in a greater amount of hours than 9 - 5 office hours. In the age of cell phones and internet, there is no such thing as after work.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Barbara Saunders
Writer, SF Bay Area transplant from NY
04:57 PM on 05/17/2012
It's not about "free time during the day." If I spend an eight-hour day at my computer at home: I do not have to pay someone $400 per month to walk my dog. I have an extra two hours in the day that would have been spent sitting in traffic. I can cycle before work without having to worry about where to shower. A doctor's appointment doesn't require me asking permission like a child. And if I want to take a college class on Thursday at 2pm, again, I can simply rearrange the day without having to ask permission like a child.

The unspoken silliness is that there is no reason 9-5 jobs can't also be like this now that many of us work on computer networks.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
j main
Reality is just a collective hunch, anyways.
02:16 AM on 03/29/2012
Many self styled independent, entrepreneurial types I know in the media business have a simple mode of operation. Get a regular type job and convince the old guys that their work can be done from the end of a wifi connection. Then, while collecting wages from the old guys, look around for contracts from the contacts they made while working for the old guys. You know the type, the ones who design websites on behalf of media companies, but they can always make a "special deal" if you want to hire their cousin instead who works out of the house.
photo
BigBearcatBill
This is the real Bearcat - a Binturong
01:39 AM on 03/29/2012
Shrinking 40 hour work week to less, 35, 30, etc. and requiring more paid vacation like Europeans get, will put millions back to work if companies hire to fill in the reduced work week hours/person. Share the work better American, learn from Europe, not China and the other countries that work their people 60 hour work weeks.
01:21 PM on 03/29/2012
Europe had a good idea... unfortunately, unrealistic expectations and demands has pretty much bankrupt their model.

Speaking with some friends in Sweden, it seems like the programs were working well, as long as every body was "industrious" and doing the most they could within their working hours... But over the last few decades, productivity is down... and people have learned to play the system.
photo
BigBearcatBill
This is the real Bearcat - a Binturong
03:59 PM on 03/29/2012
I am not too surprised to hear that, so I would recommend learning from them as we should on health care socialized med options and find some approach between ours on these issues and theirs to end up in between combining best of both. In general, I think my USA politicians/leaders do not try to learn from others who for various reasons like in Europe being lack of natural resources since they have been using theirs for thousands more years know better how to use what they have. We Americans are very lucky to have "inherited" by taking from native Indians a super resource rich and moderate very nice agricultural productive continent chunk a few hundred years ago and we are not learning from other countries who are like what we will be like in near future running out of resources, space, good soil, etc. Back to the employment point, with robots/mechanization/productivity designs we just don't need as many bodies working as we used to for our needs of consumer and food products. So the best approach is to share the work hours better and fairer.