iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
LearnVest

GET UPDATES FROM LearnVest
 

I'm A Slave To My Health Care

Posted: 06/14/2012 9:36 am

By Kimberly Dawn Neumann

"What am I going to do? COBRA costs almost half my rent," I wept to a friend of mine. "I can't afford health insurance anymore, but we all know I'm one of those people who has to have it."

All my friends laugh, but they agree there is no way I can risk being uninsured. I have a tendency to live life at full tilt and with that kind of energy comes a higher propensity for bizarre ailments and injuries.

There was the time I split my chin open in yoga (jumping from chatturanga to crow's pose--I overshot) three days before a dear friend's wedding in which I was a bridesmaid (ten stitches--the bride was not pleased with me). Once, a full length mirror fell near me and shattered, with a shard slicing open my leg before a callback for a national commercial (ended up in the ER instead of the callback--15 stitches).

I broke my hand on a guy's face when I accidentally connected with him during a stage fight (major surgery with a rod inserted in my hand). Then there were the two knee surgeries (a function of years as a professional dancer). Oh, and I actually got swine flu. Seriously.

My hospital record is thick. I actually had a nurse comment once, "Oh, you've been here before." Yes, ma'am. A few times too many.

For years, I never had to worry about coverage. I was very fortunate to work as a professional dancer/singer/actress and I managed to qualify for very decent health insurance through the Actors Equity Association. But about six years ago, everything changed.

The First Time I Lost My Health Insurance
To begin, the health fund through my union started to suffer (read: go bankrupt), so they began upping the number of weeks a performer had to work in order to qualify for insurance benefits. It went from ten weeks per year to 12 weeks to qualify for six months of insurance, and 20-24 weeks to get a year (virtually impossible for most performers unless they are in a long-running Broadway show or national tour).

Though I had been blessed with consistent work, I lost my health insurance for the first time when I found myself undergoing my first major knee surgery five years ago. I needed about three more weeks of work in the yearly period to qualify. But oh, right ... I was on crutches!!! No one was going to hire me to perform in a show if I crutched my way in to an audition.

I appealed to the Union, asking them to freeze the weeks I had accrued until I was healthy again, but they pretty much ignored me. I lost all those qualifying weeks, because if you don't use them within a year, they take them away.

I went on COBRA for the first time. And holy what? It was like $650 per month. How on earth was I supposed to pay for that and a Manhattan apartment? I was in sticker shock.

But I paid, knowing that at any moment something horrible might happen (like the swine flu episode, for example ... I was really sick). For part of the year I managed to qualify for a government subsidy for artists, which cut my COBRA payment in half and made it almost doable. But as soon as that was done, I watched the money I had once thought would be a down payment on my own place someday dwindle, owing to the additional expense of health insurance.

Something Had to Give
After I recovered from my first knee surgery, I landed a Broadway show and during that run qualified for another six months of coverage through the Union. I was feeling good ... until I reinjured my knee in that show and had to have a second knee surgery. And after another long stint on crutches and rehab, I lost my insurance again.

Back to the COBRA payments, which were insult to injury ... literally. This time, they'd gone up to almost $750 per month, with a $500 yearly deductible. I kept paying, and kept watching my savings disappear. As my financial stress levels skyrocketed because I wasn't in a show anymore and didn't have coverage as a freelance writer, I began to panic. Something had to give.

I switched to "disaster insurance" through a freelancer's union type of program. But even that was $300 a month, with a $6,000 deductible. I felt like I couldn't even go to the doctor.

I called it my "I've been hit by a bus while rollerblading in NYC and I don't want my parents to go broke trying to cover my bills" insurance, because that was the only possible scenario when paying that deductible would be rational. I could no longer see my neurologist (migraines), my orthopedist (knees), my therapist (which I needed because of this insurance stress!), my chiropractor or even my regular gynecologist (I had to go on their "Healthy Woman" plan; they still ended up charging me $60 for lab fees because I didn't know to ask my doctor to send my lab work somewhere in my health plan's network).

With a $1,000+ deductible for pharmaceuticals, I had no choice but to recruit one of my best friends from Mexico as my "drug mule." When she would go home to visit family, I would have her bring me back a couple of Z-pacs in case I got a bronchial infection and some muscle relaxers for my migraine headaches. It was the only way I could afford it in case I got really sick.

My Quest for Other Options
I realized that this disaster insurance/drug mule plan wasn't healthy, either ... so I started looking for other options. I found that one of the gyms in New York City offers insurance if you teach a certain number of classes per week. So, though I hadn't taught in years, I immediately started teaching again ... a lot! But it took me a year to get enough permanent classes to qualify for their employee plan.

Even that insurance (for which I'm insanely grateful; I've been on the program for a few months now), still requires I deduct $120 to $240 per month from my paycheck depending on how many classes I teach a week, usually eight to ten. With that much physical activity, I am going to need the insurance because my body is breaking! It's an HMO, so I have to go to the doctors on their plan. And, of course, none of the doctors I've gone to for years seem to be "on" that insurance ... sigh.

How Health Insurance Is Stifling My Dreams
I've found myself turning down certain performing auditions because, if I got the job and had to stop teaching, I would lose my hard-earned health insurance at the gym. I feel like I am working for health insurance and stifling my dreams on the off-chance I end up with a sprained ankle or some other bizarre virus (or worse).

The only other viable option I've seen for getting health insurance is to marry into it. But since my love life has been less than stellar as of late, I guess it's all up to me ... or Obamacare.

Please, Mr. President. Please, Congress. Please, America.

I'm exhausted and broke from my efforts to get and pay for health insurance. I'm a hard worker. I'm not taking advantage of any system. But I don't work in corporate America. I'm an artist and a writer. And I'm struggling.

We need a national health care plan. It's time. Unless Mr. Right With the Awesome Medical Plan sweeps into my world (and if he's on his way, his GPS seems to be seriously messed up), it's just me ... and I need help.

Imagine what I could accomplish creatively if I didn't have to spend so much time just trying to stay insured?

The world could be my oyster, but right now I'm just trying to make sure I don't step on one and need more stitches.

Maybe you can relate--and hopefully you haven't even had as many mishaps as I have. What do you think we should do?

More From LearnVest
How I Went Bankrupt at 23

The Surprising Health Costs of Being a Woman

Learn More About the Insurance You Need in Take Control Bootcamp!

LearnVest is the leading personal finance site for women. Need help managing your money? Our free Money Center will help you create a budget. Our free bootcamps will help you take control of your money, cut your costs or get out of debt. And our premium financial plans--managed by LearnVest Certified Financial Planners--can help you chart a course for the future you want.

 

Follow LearnVest on Twitter: www.twitter.com/LearnVest

FOLLOW MONEY
By Kimberly Dawn Neumann "What am I going to do? COBRA costs almost half my rent," I wept to a friend of mine. "I can't afford health insurance anymore, but we all know I'm one of those people who ha...
By Kimberly Dawn Neumann "What am I going to do? COBRA costs almost half my rent," I wept to a friend of mine. "I can't afford health insurance anymore, but we all know I'm one of those people who ha...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 61
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:39 AM on 06/17/2012
From a European perspective it's kind of unfathomable why there's so much resistance against universal healthcare in the US. Universal healthcare works! I can assure you of that, it's even cheaper per head and it really makes life more enjoyable and relaxed for everyone. Don't believe the horror stories of people having to stand in lines over here. We pay less and we get more. Universal healthcare is a pretty good deal!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:30 PM on 06/16/2012
If we get universal health care (and I hope we will), you either keep your insurance you have and pay for your policy or you sign up under the universal health care plan and pay a tax. It does not matter what you call it, a policy or taxes, same thing. Health care is not free, but regulated by the government will limit the greed of insurance companies and their loop holes to make us pay more.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
maurage
03:43 PM on 06/15/2012
Hate to repeat myself. North of Blaine, WA (BC, Canada for the geographically challenged), full monthly premium for MSP i.e medicare for a single person is $64 per month; premium assistance is available to anyone having an annual adjusted net income of less than $30,000. And then again, no deductible, no copay, no lifetime cap and no preexisting conditions. That is their way to promote personal freedom and choice of occupation, I suppose.
10:24 AM on 06/15/2012
I definitely want to see universal healthcare, but i don't want my taxes raised for it. It isn't that i don't want to pay for it. But our taxes are already high, and i have no idea what i am getting for the money i pay now. I do not support the wars we've waged, so i do not feel responsible for that tab. Our infrastructure is crap, so i know my money isn't going there. Close inspection of the quality of our public schools shows no sign of my tax dollars. I am tired of spending money for regulators who refuse to regulate. Besides massive corruption, i have absolutely no idea where the taxes i pay go now. So please give us universal healthcare, but i don't want my taxes raised until someone explains to me where the taxes i am currently paying are going.
10:16 AM on 06/15/2012
Can I make a suggestion? Apply to become a Canadian citizen.
photo
KarmaPatrol
Riverboat Gambler, satellite whisperer. Independe
10:13 AM on 06/15/2012
I've known employees of both sexes stay on a job way past their "useful" date due to pre-existing conditions. These employees eventually turned toxic but couldn't be easily replaced due to their skill set and a corporate culture of seniority. A national health plan may have allowed them to find better work.
04:24 AM on 06/15/2012
If this lady wanted stable income and insurance, she should have gotten a real job. Everyone knows the life of an artist is feast-or-famine. And if she's so accident-prone, it is really unwise of her to keep working in a field with such lousy insurance prospects. It sounds like her actors' union is a con-job, but she's not blaming them for screwing her. She's blaming The System for not tossing sacks of money at her.

As others have said here, her poor career choices are the reason she is underinsured. I'd love to be an artist and a writer, too. But art doesn't pay the bills! This lady can either be a starving artist or she can pay her medical bills. She can't have both...and I'm sure as heck not going to subsidize her fantasy work life.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
chris hatala
06:27 AM on 06/15/2012
With what we are being charged in premiums and co pays, even we with company jobs are paying a good bit of income on health insurance. This is he war on the middle class that is being waged b the tpubs.
10:14 AM on 06/15/2012
You completely missed the point. And I do mean COMPLETELY.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
SageFire
Research Vote by Mail
07:42 PM on 06/14/2012
Completely agreed. We are already paying more than we would if we had it, and there is so much suffering with out it. I am lucky, I am alive because I have insurance and a good salary. I am so sad for others not in my position.
07:36 PM on 06/14/2012
Maybe you should get an office job. Can you do manual labor, I think it's time to realize you lack the talent to be a big league performer. I always wanted to be a game show host, but came to realize I probably wasn't going to be the next Bob Barker. So, I studied business. Isn't there anything you can do beside third-rate entertaining?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Frank-Landfield
05:36 PM on 06/14/2012
Bravo
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
celticmaiden7475
05:35 PM on 06/14/2012
I don't think health care has to be government paid however some of the insurance plans are worthless cost a ton and don't pay out when you need it. I have a friend on her husbands insurance they have to each pay $12,000 before insurance even pays for medications. Well she might just save her money the insurance never pays obviously. It's things like that that need to stop. What other business in the US do you pay for services you are never able to use.
photo
The Corporate Champion
Conservative, because someone's got to do the work
04:44 PM on 06/14/2012
The reality: you a slave to your poor career choice.

Stop asking the government to raise everyone elses' taxes because you don't have a good job.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Anne Rutherford
07:12 PM on 06/14/2012
I have a decent job but I can never retire, or stop driving the 106 miles a day that I do because my husband is chronically ill - and I have to have the insurance. It's not always a poor career choice - insurance decisions change lives in many ways. How many new businesses that might provide jobs don't get started because the person with the idea is stuck because of insurance?
07:38 PM on 06/14/2012
So, do you think everyone should pay more taxes some can try out fantasy jobs? How many of those businesses do you think would actually be a success?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
chris hatala
06:29 AM on 06/15/2012
The companies are forcing their employees to pay more and more and this is justified by the tpubs who want to destroy the middle class.
02:42 PM on 06/14/2012
We need an overhaul of the medical insurance norms in our country. The current changes are good if and when they become law. Then no person can be turned down for insurance. There has to be a balance though. The current changes in law made by Obama achieves a sort of the balance. It's not perfect but it's better than before. But we have to be careful so that we don't go the at of Europe where getting treatment means standing in a line and waiting. That's why it is important to maintain a balance.
foubabou
Mean People Suck
04:51 PM on 06/14/2012
"But we have to be careful so that we don't go the at of Europe" Go the at? Huh?

.....where getting treatment means standing in line and waiting. You people crack me up. When was the last time you were in Europe and got healthcare? The only standing in line and waiting I do is sitting in the waiting room of the Dr until my name is called.

Now you might wait if you go to an emergency room. My friends tell me horror stories trying to get seen quickly in an American Emergency Room.

Read a story last week of a man from northern Europe that got bit by a rattlesnake and the hospital bill was $100K. He was saying how it would have cost nothing in his home country. Fortunately he had purchased travel health insurance for the trip.

I got a feeling that if Obamacare gets spooled up in its present form Americans are in for a rude awakening.
04:57 PM on 06/14/2012
Took me three weeks to see a podiatrist - sounds a lot like waiting.
Mom had to wait 6 weeks to see a hand specialist - sounds a lot like waiting.
My friend had to wait 3 weeks for his son to get ear surgery - again, sounds a lot like waiting.

Gee, I'm glad I'm not in a 'European' system where I have to wait!
07:39 PM on 06/14/2012
That is not so bad. I know a friend in the UK whose mom had to wait three months for a sore shoulder. Another person's dad was told cancer therapy would begin in a "couple of months".
02:23 PM on 06/14/2012
Ok, seriously, we should feel bad?

You took a career where you can rarely get more than 20-24 works of week out of 52. So, you are effectively part time at best and you wonder why you are broke? You went into a field, the arts, which is notoriously poorly paid but now you want those of us who made responsible decisions to subsidize you? Puhlease.

You think your healthcare is overpriced and unfair, at the very same time you talk about the number of serious injuries you have incurred (largely by your own choices). Do you think those remedies would be cheap? You were paying 7k a year in premiums for a $500 deductible, a good deal in most worlds. In exchange you had 2 minor surgeries (knees) and one moderate surgery (ORIF) over a short period of time. Do you think the insurance company made any money off you?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Anne Rutherford
07:06 PM on 06/14/2012
Why are you willing to accept that this is right, or even cost-efficient? Why should we pay for useless plans? I'd much rather pay a tax (couldn't be much higher than my costs now) - and be able to choose a plan from a pool that suits my family.
07:40 PM on 06/14/2012
How do you know the tax won't be much higher? Are you speaking for everyone?
02:13 PM on 06/14/2012
Getting health care, and dealing with health insurance, is like dealing with a do nothing congress. We don't even have a system, just a hodge podge of pay as you go services with various or none guaranteeors with no transparent billing. And the right wants to keep that going on. Health care is already so overpriced and our government can't get a focus on what needs to be done even with the first stab at health reform, now likely to be overturned by the supreme court. Its a failure of government really if its job is to solve problems for the people.