iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Leo W. Gerard

GET UPDATES FROM Leo W. Gerard
 

Romney Loves American Cars; Obama Loves American Car Workers

Posted: 09/24/2012 8:28 am

GOP presidential nominee Mitt Romney, son of an American Motors CEO, naturally says he loves American cars. His wife, as he put it, "drives a couple of Cadillacs." He's installing an elevator in his beach mansion just for his cars. Though a millionaire, he rejected flying his five sons to a vacation destination, instead packing them into a car, then strapping their dog Seamus' carrier to the car roof for a ride that, shall we say, challenged the canine's intestinal fortitude.

President Barack Obama, by contrast, has given some love to American car companies and American car workers. He rescued Chrysler and General Motors, preserving the American icon companies and hundreds of thousands of American car manufacturing jobs. He imposed sanctions on Chinese tires that received improper export subsidies, a move that saved thousands of U.S. tire-building jobs. And now he's challenging illegally-subsidized Chinese auto parts to sustain American companies and workers.

Romney has blasted Obama every auto-manufacturing-job-preserving step of the way. On the auto bailout, Romney admonished, "Let Detroit go bankrupt." He condemned the tariffs on Chinese tires. Romney claims he loves American cars. But the actions of his private equity firm, Bain Capital, in buying companies that were "pioneers" in offshoring American jobs, suggest he's fine with American firms making cars and car parts overseas. Obama, by contrast, took the action necessary to ensure American cars are made in America by American companies employing American workers.

Here's what Romney actually said about his adoration for cars:
I love cars. I love American cars. And long may they rule the world.
When it came to helping them continue to rule the world, however, Romney dissed Detroit.

President Obama embraced Detroit. He took money from the Wall Street bailout fund and used it to help GM and Chrysler continue to rule the world. GM regained the title of world's largest car company in January and hundreds of thousands of auto and auto part manufacturing workers retained their jobs.

Similarly, in September of 2009, President Obama imposed duties on unfairly traded Chinese tires. My union, the United Steelworkers (USW), filed the trade case that led to those duties. The sanctions saved thousands of tire-making jobs in the United States and contributed to creation of 1,000 more.

Earlier this year, the USW, the Alliance for American Manufacturing and 189 members of Congress urged Obama to take yet another trade action, this one to protect American auto parts manufacturers and their workers. The request followed publication of four reports detailing China's illegal export subsidies to its auto parts sector. Nations may subsidize manufacturing for internal consumption, but international law prohibits subsidizing products to be exported because it distorts the market, causing the bankruptcy of manufacturers in countries where the artificially cheap products are sold.

The auto parts complaint says that forbidden export subsidies, including cash grants, preferential tax treatment and other perks valued at $1 billion over the past three years enabled China to jump from 16th largest producer of auto parts in 2002, when it exported $7 billion in parts, to 5th largest last year when it exported $70 billion.

The upshot is that imports of auto parts from China increased seven-fold, contributing to the loss of nearly half of all U.S. auto parts jobs -- 400,000 -- since 2000. An example is Olymco, Inc. a Canton, Ohio, metal-plating company where 100 workers, members of the USW, once made auto parts. Now, mainly as a result of subsidized Chinese competition, only 11 workers remain.

The predatory Chinese practices encourage U.S. auto parts makers to offshore manufacturing, and now some of the largest U.S. auto parts companies produce in China.

Sensata, a car parts manufacturer in Freeport, Ill. is among those on the way to China. The 145 workers in Freeport, who make sensors and controls, are training their Chinese replacements.

These workers may return to China to join many there who are packed into dormitories that rival turn of the 20th century U.S. tenements for slum conditions. Romney described workers in a Chinese appliance factory he visited:

Working, working, working as hard as they could, at rates of roughly 50 cents an hour. They cared about their jobs; they wouldn't even look up as we walked by.

That's right. These exploited workers kept their heads down. These 50-cent-an-hour laborers feared they'd be fired for the audacity of looking at a quarter billionaire American visitor.

Sensata is owned by Bain Capital, the company Romney founded in 1984, the private equity firm that Romney claims he left in 1999, even though it continued to pay him millions for a decade afterward. The workers at Sensata have publically begged Romney to intervene with Bain on their behalf to keep the factory in the United States. They've collected 35,000 signatures supporting their cause. They've got the backing of the Freeport City Council, U.S. Rep. Jan Schakowsky and Illinois Gov. Pat Quinn. They're camping outside the factory in a tent city called Bainport. But Romney hasn't responded. No word from the candidate who claims to love American cars.

He loves owning 'em. He relishes riding them up and down on elevators. But when it comes to showing a little love for car businesses and car workers, Romney's frigid. Just ask the workers cooling their heels at Bainport.

The auto parts case is Obama's ninth trade action against China. The Washington Post wrote:

The Obama administration has steadily amped up its enforcement actions against China at the WTO.

Obama has repeatedly confronted countries whose illegal trade practices threaten American companies and workers, filing twice as many cases in one term as Bush did in two. He has tangibly demonstrated his love for American cars and American car workers.

 

Follow Leo W. Gerard on Twitter: www.twitter.com/uswblogger

FOLLOW BUSINESS
GOP presidential nominee Mitt Romney, son of an American Motors CEO, naturally says he loves American cars. His wife, as he put it, "drives a couple of Cadillacs." He's installing an elevator in his b...
GOP presidential nominee Mitt Romney, son of an American Motors CEO, naturally says he loves American cars. His wife, as he put it, "drives a couple of Cadillacs." He's installing an elevator in his b...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 232
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (5 total)
11:55 PM on 09/27/2012
Regardless of which one of these guys gets elected in November, if we, as a Nation do not restore our manufacturing base, we are doomed.
photo
portfolio
money is the barometer of a society's virtue
10:18 AM on 09/25/2012
Romney claims to love American cars, but I doubt he could tell a 57 Chevy from a 59 Ford Edsel.

The only thing Moneybags Mitt cares about is himself and his 1% contributors.
09:32 AM on 09/25/2012
Obama loves American UNION car workers. Those workers not involved in his union payoff scheme were not taken care of. All of this foolish spending has only paused the inevitable bankruptcy of GM. By paying off the unions, they were allowed to get away with zero concessions, and therefore the carrying costs for every vehicle remain in place. I would say it was criminal what he did, but his lack of business experience indicate ignorance more than theft.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gbrond23
04:15 AM on 09/25/2012
Obama likes votes, not people. When is the great bailout going to be over? 79% of GM auto sales are going to the federal government. Taxpayers are the gift that just keeps on giving...
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
stack
USW Blogger
09:58 AM on 09/25/2012
Uh, bailout over. Fund closed. Money being paid back.
Faux news is bad for mental health.
Faux news is the only place that would give you that laughable, hilarious, silly 79% figure. So cute!
photo
portfolio
money is the barometer of a society's virtue
10:22 AM on 09/25/2012
" 79% of GM auto sales are going to the federal government"

FALSE that number refers to the increase in govt. sales for month over month.

Here is the fact; http://www.snopes.com/politics/business/gmsales.asp
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gbrond23
08:48 PM on 09/25/2012
So in your mind a 79% increase is insignificant?
01:07 AM on 09/25/2012
The title is interesting and is well reflected in this election. One likes the materials and money symboled as Romney and the other one care about the people as Obama does.......
09:49 PM on 09/24/2012
Regardless of which one of these guys gets elected in November, if we, as a Nation do not restore our manufacturing base, we are doomed.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jd2020
Bill the Cat for President
09:41 PM on 09/24/2012
Do you trust your CEO to do what is best for the employees? Of course not. They do what is best for the shareholders and for the executive class. So, why should we trust their son to run an entire country? What has Romney learned from his father that qualifies him to be a leader of American Democracy?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
crownjamesp
09:24 PM on 09/24/2012
Three Dog Night "Just an Old Fashioned Love Song, Coming Down in Three Part RMoney"
07:19 PM on 09/25/2012
#37
09:12 PM on 09/24/2012
Don't put to much into leo's concerns for American workers. If it wasn't for him and his buddy Dave's incompetence, when three steel plants were sold 2 years ago, there might be 4000 steelworkers still working today instead of being on unemployment and having no benefits.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
stack
USW Blogger
09:59 AM on 09/25/2012
Alternatively, they would have been unemployed two years ago when no one wanted those plants.
11:21 AM on 09/25/2012
Wrong but nice try stack. There were people who wanted the plants, they just didn't want all of them together. The union decided to use thier rights under successorship to force one possible ownership group to buy all the plants, because they didn't want a anti union company buying any of them. What would have been better for the majority of the workers and would have at least gave us another day to fight? They wanted Ira and he put it to them, (and us).
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
RandomJ
GOP — (G)reedy (O)ne (P)ercenters
09:01 PM on 09/24/2012
"I'll take a lot of credit for the fact that this industry's come back." –Mitt Romney, on the American auto industry, despite having written a New York Times op-ed in 2008 titled "Let Detroit Go Bankrupt," in which he said if GM, Ford and Chrysler got a government bailout "you can kiss the American automotive industry goodbye"

"[My wife] drives a couple of Cadillacs." –Mitt Romney, campaigning for president in Michigan (February 2012)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Human1984
Old Angry Liberal Patriot
08:23 PM on 09/24/2012
"Romney admonished, "Let Detroit go bankrupt." He condemned the tariffs on Chinese tires." -- These are prime examples of how the global elitists sell us out, and justify it by their own profits.
It is this elitist viewpoint that is destroying American industries, and the good jobs we used to have in America. We have been sold out by greedy selfish elitsts, and we need to recover and repair the damages done!
08:02 PM on 09/24/2012
Gave the bond holders nothing for the sake of the unions. Unions are all he cares about
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
stack
USW Blogger
09:59 PM on 09/24/2012
He who?
If you are talking Obama, why were the auto workers forced to renegotiate their contract and give concessions?
I mean, if what you say about Obama is true, why didn't he totally protect the auto workers?
Why did auto workers who held GM and Chrysler stock lose out the same way other stock holders did?
07:19 PM on 09/24/2012
"The workers at Sensata have publically begged Romney to intervene with Bain on their behalf to keep the factory in the United States." MR left Bain in '99 or '02, but who's counting?
Jeesh, it's 165 jobs.
Can't the damn president and powerful senator Dick Durbin save this place?
If BHO "saved" the auto industry(except Ford, Honda, Toyota, VW, MB, etc. who all have US factories), surely he can save this little parts company.
But, it's better to serve them up as political fodder.....Isn't GM opening plants and dealerships in China?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rob Devitt
I like intelligent debate and slapping down trolls
09:27 PM on 09/24/2012
Is it opening dealerships in china? How else would they sell their cars there, via ebay?
11:30 AM on 09/28/2012
My point is that they(Govt.) stood by and watched US dealerships close...I see them empty all around, hundreds of lost jobs, but it is more politically advantageous to hammer on Bain/ read Romney.  lol.  sheeple, wake up.  GM is expanding into China....and so are other companies....Bain, or no Bain.  
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
stack
USW Blogger
10:01 PM on 09/24/2012
So exactly what would you have the President do to prevent this privately-held company from moving to China when this privately-held company has not asked the President for anything - unlike Chrysler and GM, which BEGGED for help from the government?
11:25 AM on 09/28/2012
Well, he and Biden are running around saying they "created" 4 million jobs; if you believe and think they, as in BHO and Joe, can create (private) jobs, then sure as heck they can save these 165 workers and their plant and support jobs.  Taxincentives?tarriffs? Ask them how to save these jobs.  
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jwl3ss
07:00 PM on 09/24/2012
General Motors's joint ventures sold more vehicles in China last year than in the U.S. and the car maker has ambitions growth plans there.

To be exact: GM’s December 31, 2011 annual report shows General Motors of North America accounting for 98,000 of the 207,000 GM jobs worldwide. But 12,000 of these jobs are in Canada and 11,500 are in Mexico. Accordingly, GM has 74,500 jobs in the United States and 122,500 abroad, even after Obama’s touted surge in Detroit jobs. Almost two thirds of GM’s jobs are in other countries.

GM Mexico employs 11,500 direct and about 90,000 indirect employees.”

GM outsourcing is explained, among other things, by $85 per hour UAW wages and benefits, inefficient work rules, controls on corporate compensation, and government dictates of the product mix.

Let’s remember Obama’s words at his Colorado rally: “Let’s give tax breaks to companies that are investing here. It’s the right thing to do.”
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rob Devitt
I like intelligent debate and slapping down trolls
09:37 PM on 09/24/2012
There are economies of scale here. these are not staplers they are making. It is more cost efficient and logical to make some cars in other parts of the world if you sell products there to offset transport costs. these are completely different to outsourcing office or telephone jobs to another country because they are cheaper. If i manufactured cars that sold all over the world i would have plants and offices all over the world. As you just indicated the US is no longer the biggest market yet it accounts for 40% of the staff and that's not including Canada and Mexico.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
stack
USW Blogger
10:06 AM on 09/25/2012
If GM doesn't make cars in China, it's not going to sell cars in China. That's the rule China enforces. No way to get around it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
J T K
Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?
06:49 PM on 09/24/2012
So nice to know that while thousands of other companies went bankrupt across the US and tens if not hundreds of thousands of workers got laid off the workers at the auto companies were so special that they got special treatment not afforded to the other taxpaying Americans who were being laid off.

If President Obama wants to find a moral hazard he should be looking in a mirror because while the government picks winners and losers every day, this was blatant and abusive even by government standards.